All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Make Your Own Luck - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Pretty late to the party, but here are my initial ideas.

  • Nemsy’s Fine Dining

    Thank you so much for this! I haven’t even played it, but I know it’s gonna be good

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    Probably just a coincidence, but the gem in the center looks like a Red Mana Crystal, a scrapped mechanic from the Gadgetzan expansion for the Kabal. The Kabal are tied to Kazakus who will most likely play a significant role in the miniset.

    Interesting interview from 2017 stating they'd like to introduce Red Mana somewhere down the road. This would be the perfect opportunity if they ever do that.

    https://www.ign.com/articles/2017/01/13/hearthstone-blizzard-on-designing-jade-testing-red-mana-and-leaving-reno-behind

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    If that could bring us a flock of dragons ... 

                           ....  I'd be so happy

  • Hearthstone Dying?

    Honestly, I can't see Hearthstone dying. It makes the most money out of every digital card game (as far as I could find on google), has been going steady for 8 years. Why would it start to die if the year before was fine and the year before that fine?

    I think people don't see that it is competing monetarily with games like CoD and assume it is dead without understanding it is a card game and the average gamer does not want to wait and sit for their turn. HS has the card game demographic down and no other digital TCG competes with it. If HS dies, then I imagine so would every other digital card game.

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    Honestly, I have the exact opposite problem with the minisets... too many of the cards are cutesy.

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    Why even comment?

  • Make Your Own Luck - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    There's a lot of struggling going on for what sounded like a simple prompt. My card is definitely not the best either, but unless I end up thinking of something more original, I'll probably just submit it.

    More More Feedback

    linkblade91
    I really like the new idea, but it is VERY powerful for a 4-Cost. I'd advise you to rebalance its numbers. Otherwise, at least make it target three random minions (rather than being able to hit the same one multiple times), so it isn't strong against both single big minions AND wide boards.

    Demonxz95
    If Dr. Smalls is still on the table, I would prefer that one. It's far more unique. Although I still think it should only affect you deck.

    Swizard
    I totally forgot about [Hearthstone Card (Shadow Step) Not Found]. And all things considered, I think this idea is just too difficult to properly balance.

    SkeithDE
    I think you should stick to the first idea. I don't like how the second version backfires on Deathrattle minions with 3 or more Health. And otherwise you'd still lose the body. Something like an upgraded version of Animated Berserker would probably do the same job better. It could have extra stats in return for damaging other minions you play. But that's probably for a different competition.

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    Sorry for you man, because I do

  • Card Design Conversation - Number's Up

    Staff Pro

    Steal Fate another very cool winner! Liking what we are getting! CG! :)

  • How do Pot of Greed cards work?

    Staff Pro

    That's the neat part: They don't...

    Those cards were likely printed before Pot was banned, and Konami seems to not really care that a bunch of cards are unplayable. Also, there's Traditional format, where banned cards are only limited.

  • The Fury of Kael'Thas

    The old suggested decks are no longer applicable, because most of the cards have rotated out. Here's a version for the current Brawl (February 2022) -- Guardian Animals Druid:

    ### Brawl Deck
    # Class: Druid
    # Format: Standard
    # Year of the Gryphon
    #
    # 2x (0) Innervate
    # 2x (0) Lightning Bloom
    # 2x (0) Pounce
    # 2x (1) Guidance
    # 2x (1) Nature Studies
    # 2x (3) Frostwolf Kennels
    # 2x (5) Glowfly Swarm
    # 2x (5) Lake Thresher
    # 2x (5) Teacher's Pet
    # 2x (5) Twilight Runner
    # 2x (6) Best in Shell
    # 2x (6) Nourish
    # 2x (8) Cenarion Ward
    # 2x (8) Guardian Animals
    # 2x (10) Survival of the Fittest
    #
    AAECAaCtBAAP77oDks0Dm84DutADvNADk9ED3tED8NQDpOEDiuQDpPYDrp8E2p8EuaAEuL4EAA==
    #
    # To use this deck, copy it to your clipboard and create a new deck in Hearthstone

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    Funnily enough, I actually did look up pictures of Whitemane to compare the staff.

    It seemed like a pretty clear match, but apparently the design was changed in Mists when Scarlet Monastery was revamped. Prestor makes a lot more sense.

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    I can't tell if you're joking, but you should probably Google some images of Lady Prestor and Whitemane.

  • Hearthstone Dying?

    Regis on the topic

  • Hearthstone Dying?

    Zeddy on the topic

  • Hearthstone Dying?

    The video makes a compelling argument. Basically the reason why traditional hearthstone is declining;

    - Its a very old game at this point. I dont need stats to show that traditional hearthstone is losing traction and that its esport scene is close to being dead. Youtube views have also substantially declined, followed by the loss of interest of popular youtubers like disguisedtoast. Most games that aren't csgo don't really sustain its audiences through the test of time. I remember that rainbow six siege was at some point hailed as a milestone, and I simply couldn't see it go down. Same goes with pubg. And yet here we are.

    - The controversies aren't a small thing. While I dont think current players can actually quit hearthstone for it, it makes it very difficult for new (young) players to want to start playing it. Given how most youngsters are given choice, and are usually more progressive than older players, why would they bother with a blizz game when there's thousands of others.

    - Hearthstone is expensive to collect, to have fun in. That's a point. I don't need to reiterate what most people would be well acquainted at this point, but to put simply I've opened somewhere around 130 packs this expansion and I still only have around 1/3 of the legendaries in the set. The reason why LoR can only get better (its still trailing behind hearthstone in my opinion) is because its just easier to get into by comparison.

     

    I kinda like bot mathematician's work to be honest. I feel that they measure their opinions well, and use whatever stats that is available to them to make a point. I don't necessarily think they are the apex in terms of statistical analysis, but they are one of very few, maybe none, that makes an attempt at a hearthstone viewpoint using stats. Besides, the presentation must take some work, and I can respect that. Youtubers like Kibler and zeddy may get more views, but its one thing to hold a camera and express your point, its quite another to make an somewhat animated show out of it.

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    I'm not excited

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    Don't forget Deathwing the hero portrait lol

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    There's another thing that in my mind speaks against this being Scarlet Monastery. We've seen our mercenaries level up, get mounts and ding 60 (hero cards), so taking on their first raid is a much better fit than going back and farming mid level dungeons. Scarlet Monastery would've been a great fit for United in Stormwind.

  • How do Pot of Greed cards work?

    It’s simply a case where those cards are not on the banlist so there isn’t really a reason why they should be excluded.  No cards treat themselves as Pot of Greed, save for Pot of Greed itself.  There is no use for their effects currently, but that doesn’t mean there never could be.  While Pot of Greed is highly unlikely to be unbanned in the competitive format anytime soon (if ever), there is always the possibility that some events allow for some banned cards to be played

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    Yeah, that probably makes more sense story-wise. I cannot for the life of me understand why we got Saidan, though.

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    I wonder if we'll get another Onyxia, otherwise probably Kazakus in dragon form. While highly unlikely, it would be cool with either of them as a first neutral hero card. 

    But we gotta get another Onyxia to rival Deathwing, three is a magic number! (Yes it is, it's a magic number).

     

    Edit: Oh, there are four five Deathwings. Deathwing, Deathwing, Dragonlord Deathwing the Destroyer, Deathwing, Mad Aspect and Deathwing.

     

  • New Demacia Card - Petricite Stag

    Without tough this unit is outright trash and even with tough it wouldn't be that good

    You better don't play this unless you have a very specific deck needing desperately protection for it's units

     

     

  • Hearthstone's Upcoming Mini-Set to be Announced Tomorrow, February 10 - New Cards Coming Soon!

    Staff Pro

    My bad, sorry. I killed a Deathwing, Dragonlord, and it dropped a lot of the stuff on board. :p