I don't think this makes Whiteflame decks much better. Wounded Whiteflame already grows fast enough and outgrows pretty much anything. The deck needs help against recalls, stuns, and wide boards - attach doesn't help with that at all, and in fact is weak to the same things!
Attach however feels too forgiving/ hard to counter.
Like the way it works attach can't be countered by any mechanic in the game.
It might very well be too slow and fail because of that but this design is kinda bad aswell (because mechanics like these are supposed to have clear counters)
I mean this card doesn't have to see play in Targon BC specifically. Afaik this is probably the only card that grants quick attack onto a unit and costs less than 3 Mana and it returns to hand if the unit does die? It's also 2 mana and goes to 0 Mana from Gleaming Lantern so then Gleaming Lantern is now a 3 Mana 4/4 with Quick Attack. Pretty strong if you do get that start. It also allows Zoe to get a +1/+1 buff permanently on Focus-speed which is hard to do on turn 2. Otherwise, this card is going to allow Fiora to branch towards BC. Card has a lot of potential imo.
I hope in the next miniset this control meta will finally end!
About 3/4 what I meet on ladder is Control Warrior, Control Priest, Control Druid or other infinitive heal and removal decks. x_X
Do you want to trade dimensions with me? I'd love to go to the universe where people are playing control decks and not pirate warrior, token druid, and face hunter endlessly.
Continuing the trend of Bandle City having infinite value, their unit buffs get returned back to their hand when the buffed unit dies, gets captured, etc. Yuumi in particular looks incredibly obnoxious: She's cheap, she's strong, and from what I can tell it's literally impossible to get rid of her for good.
I think Unchained Soultaker is your most interesting card here, but it's probably too weak. I don't know if making it a 2 Mana that steals the stats of a 3-Cost minion would be too broken, but I'd say it would be fine, because many 3-Costs have weak bodies with strong effects, so I guess this card would be very dependant on the meta.
About your other cards, Spellsmithis the runner up for me.
linkblade91
I agree with everyone else, this is very dangerous. I like Aerojulwin's suggestions about affecting only the Attack or shuffling it at the end of your turn, but I'd only apply one of them because both at the same time feels unnatural. I'd go with the shuffle effect while rising the Cost to 3 (both to make it legal for the comp and to make it less dangerous).
AeroJulwin
It's indeed a bit on the nose, but I like it a lot. The art is very cute, which is something weird considering it depicts snakes lol
About the inconsitency with the "Draw 1 card" thing, I don't mind it too much in this very specific case: wording it with "Draw a card" would break both the aesthetic of the text AND the parallel to Ultimate Infestation. If Blizzard ever printed this card (which they might do at some point), I wouldn't be surprised if they too broke the convention.
Demonxz95
I didn't know if negative numbers would increase or decrease the count, I guess this answers my question heh
About the card, it's very weird. I don't like that minions with two or less Health die instantly nor the fact that it enables combos way too easily, but I find it very funny how this issues counter each other (you can't pull an Archmage Antonidas OTK because Sorcerer's Apprentices would die as soon as they hit the battlefield). I don't know if I like the card or not; as I said, it's very weird.
Finally, I think it shouldn't be a Beast, as it seems in the same category as Worgens or Pandaren, even if rat-people don't exist so far.
With the new Attach cards and the confirmation that its effect works the turn you play it, I think Gleaming Lantern is going to skyrocket as the top must-nerf card in the new expansion. You just play this card in swarm decks like Bandle City Mayor. It has 3/3 statline which makes it hard to kill compared to Mayor as well. Idk card just seems ridiculous, I hope I'm the one that's wrong but I can't just see it NOT being good.
Both of its effects are worse than those of cards we already have: Prismatic Barrier gives Barrier for less mana, Spirit's Refuge gives Barrier AND Lifesteal for the same mana, and Bastion's buff lasts longer and grants permanent stat buffs. In this card's favor is its versatility: It can give Barrier OR Spellshield, whichever one you need. And we've seen the value of versatility: It's why Three Sisters is the single most played card from Freljord, and Twin Disciplines is the most played card from Ionia.
This card's versatility is helpful, but it's not as good as Twin Disciplines or even Three Sisters. Three Sisters gives you three options, this one only gives you two and both are purely defensive. It's an alright card, maybe it sees play or maybe not, it's a meta call. Verdict: 3/5
Yuumi: New Bandle City & Targon Champion Reveal - 9 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
I don't think this makes Whiteflame decks much better. Wounded Whiteflame already grows fast enough and outgrows pretty much anything. The deck needs help against recalls, stuns, and wide boards - attach doesn't help with that at all, and in fact is weak to the same things!
Make Your Own Luck - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
From what I gather from the feedback, Dr. Smalls is basically DOA so here's a new card instead without negative numbers.
Yuumi: New Bandle City & Targon Champion Reveal - 9 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
Attach however feels too forgiving/ hard to counter.
Like the way it works attach can't be countered by any mechanic in the game.
It might very well be too slow and fail because of that but this design is kinda bad aswell (because mechanics like these are supposed to have clear counters)
New Bandle City Card - Quick Quill
I mean this card doesn't have to see play in Targon BC specifically. Afaik this is probably the only card that grants quick attack onto a unit and costs less than 3 Mana and it returns to hand if the unit does die? It's also 2 mana and goes to 0 Mana from Gleaming Lantern so then Gleaming Lantern is now a 3 Mana 4/4 with Quick Attack. Pretty strong if you do get that start. It also allows Zoe to get a +1/+1 buff permanently on Focus-speed which is hard to do on turn 2. Otherwise, this card is going to allow Fiora to branch towards BC. Card has a lot of potential imo.
Yuumi: New Bandle City & Targon Champion Reveal - 9 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
Never said it failed, hell, it's among my favorite mechanics in card games, up there with slivers/survivors. it just felt kinda vulnerable.
Major Battlegrounds Buddies Changes Coming in Today's 22.2.2 Hearthstone Patch, Archdruid Hamuul Removed
Now he has reason to be...Crabby
I hope you enjoy your big stuff control & wombo combo meta.
Do you want to trade dimensions with me? I'd love to go to the universe where people are playing control decks and not pirate warrior, token druid, and face hunter endlessly.
Yuumi: New Bandle City & Targon Champion Reveal - 9 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
I don't know but my magnetic paladin was good enough to make me not call it a failed mechanic tho
New Bandle City Card - Quick Quill
And you get quick attack and you get quick attack...
I don't see this making much sense in targon bc but maybe if the stars align a bc noxus repuation deck could make use of this card.
LeBlanc shows that a 5+ attack unit with quick attack makes for a great follower and this only being 2 mana is huuuge for reputation archetypes.
New Bandle City Card - Scholarly Climber
This costs 1 less mana so it's arguably better than Fused Firebrand in nondragon decks.
Should be great in limited I think
I hope you enjoy your big stuff control & wombo combo meta.
Looking at the latest vs meta report 3/10 top decks can be considered 'control' (at top 1k legend). Hand warlock, fel demon hunter and quest shaman.
'control meta' indeed...
New Bandle City Spell - Friendship!
I originally thought for 4 mana this spell would at least give both buffs but it doesn't even do that.
Given the cost and the very mediocre spell I would't run this ever unless your region combination only allows for this one.
Yuumi: New Bandle City & Targon Champion Reveal - 9 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
Continuing the trend of Bandle City having infinite value, their unit buffs get returned back to their hand when the buffed unit dies, gets captured, etc. Yuumi in particular looks incredibly obnoxious: She's cheap, she's strong, and from what I can tell it's literally impossible to get rid of her for good.
Hearthstone Mercenaries Sees Lowered Difficulty in Newer Bounty Content in Today's Patch
Alright, a few questions:
1). How often did this occur? (Follow up question, did this happen to any of you?)
2). How the fuck did this happen?
Major Battlegrounds Buddies Changes Coming in Today's 22.2.2 Hearthstone Patch, Archdruid Hamuul Removed
I personally would rework completely Tess and Scabbs' buddies. They are fun but feel so weak (unless you get a good buddy like Millificient's).
Make Your Own Luck - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
About your other cards, Spellsmith is the runner up for me.
About the inconsitency with the "Draw 1 card" thing, I don't mind it too much in this very specific case: wording it with "Draw a card" would break both the aesthetic of the text AND the parallel to Ultimate Infestation. If Blizzard ever printed this card (which they might do at some point), I wouldn't be surprised if they too broke the convention.
About the card, it's very weird. I don't like that minions with two or less Health die instantly nor the fact that it enables combos way too easily, but I find it very funny how this issues counter each other (you can't pull an Archmage Antonidas OTK because Sorcerer's Apprentices would die as soon as they hit the battlefield). I don't know if I like the card or not; as I said, it's very weird.
Finally, I think it shouldn't be a Beast, as it seems in the same category as Worgens or Pandaren, even if rat-people don't exist so far.
Yuumi: New Bandle City & Targon Champion Reveal - 9 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
Glorious news: Silence doesn't affect them!
Yuumi: New Bandle City & Targon Champion Reveal - 9 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
PRAISE TARGON! This is what Magnetic should've been in Hearthstone!
I hope you enjoy your big stuff control & wombo combo meta.
I hope in the next miniset this control meta will finally end!
About 3/4 what I meet on ladder is Control Warrior, Control Priest, Control Druid or other infinitive heal and removal decks. x_X
Major Battlegrounds Buddies Changes Coming in Today's 22.2.2 Hearthstone Patch, Archdruid Hamuul Removed
Maybe. Maybe not
Major Battlegrounds Buddies Changes Coming in Today's 22.2.2 Hearthstone Patch, Archdruid Hamuul Removed
I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish here, perhaps trying to summon changes, but there were no constructed balance changes this week.
New Bandle City Card - Gleaming Lantern
With the new Attach cards and the confirmation that its effect works the turn you play it, I think Gleaming Lantern is going to skyrocket as the top must-nerf card in the new expansion. You just play this card in swarm decks like Bandle City Mayor. It has 3/3 statline which makes it hard to kill compared to Mayor as well. Idk card just seems ridiculous, I hope I'm the one that's wrong but I can't just see it NOT being good.
New Bandle City Spell - Friendship!
Both of its effects are worse than those of cards we already have: Prismatic Barrier gives Barrier for less mana, Spirit's Refuge gives Barrier AND Lifesteal for the same mana, and Bastion's buff lasts longer and grants permanent stat buffs. In this card's favor is its versatility: It can give Barrier OR Spellshield, whichever one you need. And we've seen the value of versatility: It's why Three Sisters is the single most played card from Freljord, and Twin Disciplines is the most played card from Ionia.
This card's versatility is helpful, but it's not as good as Twin Disciplines or even Three Sisters. Three Sisters gives you three options, this one only gives you two and both are purely defensive. It's an alright card, maybe it sees play or maybe not, it's a meta call. Verdict: 3/5
Yuumi: New Bandle City & Targon Champion Reveal - 9 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
Yeah and when you think about it, it's also like the Libram of Wisdom and gives pretty much infinite value.
New Bandle City Card - Papercraft Dragon
wow slow speed grant and ally +2+2 and double attack? That's combined with any good overwhelm unit (like Ruin Runner) got to be nuts.
Sure you open yourself up to get removed but the potential of this buff is huge + its reusable.
I can't see this not making into at least some (maybe not all meme) decks