I imagine the Ultra Rare pool exist to add more unpredictability to the runs. It's probably a similar logic to critical hits in RPGs. Whether they have a place in a competitive environment is another discussion (they probably don't)
Huh, the duels nerf feels odd. I can't remember where the discussion was occurring (maybe here?) but obviously the big issue with treasures in duels is that if they are so strong that they need to be put in the "Pool 2 Ultra Rare" pool, then they probably should be balanced instead. Some builds are gonna have strong "non-rare" treasures, and others are going to effectively rely on those treasures. And it still takes the agency out of the players hands. You could have a mirror match where both players are playing something like....Duels Ping Mage, but the player who gets ultra lucky with Battle Totem is going to most likely have a way easier time than the person who doesn't.
Ultimately this is going to make the person who doesn't find that treasure feel bad when they go up against someone with that treasure. And this leads back to my initial through which is: why not just get rid of Pool 2 Ultra Rare, and just balance the treasures, or split them out so they aren't a problem. Instead of "Your battlecries trigger twice" maybe make it so "Your Battlecries with a cost <4 trigger twice" or something like that.
Noticed your new versions too late. The Storm's Wrath one is probably fine as a 3-Cost. Getting extra stats shouldn't be a problem considering you won't be able to get the effect on-curve.
I do like both of them, but I like the second one better, because it also buffs the Elementals you get from Invoking and combos well with the Neutral Invoke minions.
I like the first version better. It fits the lightning sword flavor well. I think the second version's effect is a bit odd to put on a weapon.
Demonxc95
I hadn't noticed there was already a Herald here. What are the odds?
Wailor does have a point about its value. I don't think it's too crazy, because there weren't many spell Shaman decks, but maybe just reduce the Attack gain to 1. Although we do already have Squallhunter in the same expansion, which is why I think you should go with your second idea.
I definitely think "For each time you've Invoked this game," is going to do well in this comp. Not sure if it has enough flair, but it'll definitely do well playability-wise.
Wailor
I really like Redscale Armorsmith. Particularly how its Battlecry interacts with the Invoke effect. That's two for two with your ideas inspiring people.
I'm less of a fan of Dragonblight Ritualist. Mainly because I just like your other idea better, but also because I think its value scales too slowly.
BloodMefist
I like both of these, but I think you should go with Gronn Taskmaster. Sure, Storming Invocation has some great art, but it'd be the only "If you've played an Elemental last turn," card in the format, which I think is quite problematic. Also, it should be a Nature spell.
SkeithDE
Welcome! It's been a while since a new creator showed up, because that's how long I've been here! I look forward to seeing your ideas.
I really like how its effect casts an Overload spell, so you still have to sort of pay for the extra effect. However, I do feel it's a bit too difficult to get the effect, compared to its value. There aren't a lot of Invoke cards, which is why the "Invoked twice"-cards have quite strong effects. Your card only requires one Invoke, but getting it on the same turn can be difficult.
Also, a 4/4 3-Cost is kind of unusual. For minions of 2 Mana or higher you should probably stick to a stat total of (Cost * 2 + 1) max, unless they have some sort of negative effect.
I resonate with the last point made; the buckets are the worst part of Duels (and Dungeon Runs). Rather than picking what seems best, you're usually picking what seems least worst. As mentioned, I often find myself playing Pirate Warrior because that's the only deck which somewhat reliably gets buckets.
Frankly, the bucket system should be replaced with something else. It's not fun. It biases players towards meta decks. It's impossible to properly balance.
Out of every class, Priest is currently tied with Hunter for fewest winning cards (they both have 4). If there's a comp here that can get Priest out of that spot, it's this one. I'm honestly a bit surprised to not see any Rogue cards yet. There's a lot of Shaman here.
Feedback
Linkblade91
Did someone say…
Jokes aside, you may get some meme points for using Thunderfury. The first version is very Reaper's Scythe-esque, though it's a lot easier to use in my opinion making it a stronger card. The second one I would avoid because giving a lot of stuff Windfury will always be problematic. We all know how [Hearthstone Card (Battlegrounds Battlemaster) Not Found] turned out.
Wailor
Redscale Armorsmith is a very solid card all around and I can see it doing well.
Dragonblight Ritualist is a cool design (and one that I may or may not have taken some inspiration from, so I hope I didn't step on your toes too much) though the reward is definitely too weak. Compared to Scion of Ruin which gives you some addition 3/2s with Rush or Veiled Worshipper which draws 3 cards, your reward for Invoking twice is summoning a random 2-Cost Demon. If you can bump that up, I think it'll be a pretty good card.
BloodMefist
Storming Invocation should probably be a Nature spell, but otherwise it's a fine card.
I prefer Gronn Taskmaster. I think its designing is just a lot more interesting overall.
SkeithDE
Welcome aboard! I look forward to seeing more of you around these parts.
I am a fan of this "if you've Invoked this turn" idea as it's a cool spin on the usual Invoke effects not just in the real game, but also so far in this competition. It's a strong 3 mana 4/4 which isn't technically overpowered, but with a positive effect, will most likely rub people the wrong way. I do think the effect is also a bit weak. Forked Lightning is not exactly one of Shaman's stronger spells.
Forked Lightning also doesn't need the DoD watermark in my opinion.
AeroJulwin
Shaman seems to be the most popular choice for the comp so far.
I like this. I quite like that the Invoke plays into the Freeze effect with the 2/1 Elemental. I will say that maybe it should be a 2/5 because it seems quite pushed at the moment. Great job overall though.
There weren't really enough Elemental synergies to make a deck around them, but this should be fine since you can get more Elementals through Invoking and it strengthens Elementals that may have already been worth including in a deck.
EDIT: I did consider making it a 5-Cost 3/6. Thoughts?
Kinda surprised to see all cards are Shaman or Warrior.
Some early feedback:
linkblade91
The version that affects adjacent minions is way cooler and less problematic. To be honest, I could see it winning the comp. Maybe the effect would fit more in Warrior, but I get it could be a bit OP considering the effect of Galakrond's Might.
Demonxz95
I like the card, but I think you should probably drop the stat gain. +2 Spell Damage for 2 is very strong, and something you already wanna do later in the game (not a card to play on curve), so the requirement isn't too bad for it, especially considering Shaman was a very efficient Invoker.
BloodMefist
Both are solid, but I'd say I like Storming Invocation a bit better.
SkeithDE
Hey, it's always nice to see a new face. And if it's a fellow Pokémon fan, even better :)
About your card, I like the effect, but the statline should definetly be 3/4 or even 4/4. The effect is positive (even if it has Overload), so it shouldn't have above vanilla stats.
All I want right now is a new set to play with. It's so stale at the minute and I wouldn't be bothered if I didnt get Van/Drek if the Scholomance heroes had some new cards for deck building 😴😴
Sooooo, I screwed up! I said that Ranked Rewards would be offered at the start of the new season. They were offered as soon as you passed their respective tier, I just didn't notice. Sorry about that.
Very extensive and informative duels article, well done.
Side note: Shadow Word: Void by itself can win games when you drop a 7+ health minion and don't have access to board clears. Blizzard needs to redesign this card coz the nerf isn't fixing the actual problem with the treasure.
You know the card is a problem when a priest can AFK for the first 3 turns and just play this one card and win the game.
That unlocking treasures and hp in duels is really testing the limits of my patience. The second hp for drekthar requires the person to play 40 spells at 3 mana or more, which is frankly disgusting. Most of the time you'd just die by turn 6 whilst only permitted to play 1 card per turn, and the minute you try to build a deck that can actually win and features a few spells that do cost 3 or more, those spells feel more like a self-inflicted handicap, like trying a 100m race on one foot.
In other words, its simply more efficient to build a deck thats 100% unable to win games but ticking requirements. Hardly a fun time to be had. Even the bs stormwind meta seems less rage inducing.
Perhaps team5 thought that since Vanndar/Drekthar would be here to stay long term it'll eventually be done with some coaxing and nose holding, but I fear that all it does is discourage me from playing these heroes at all. I dont play duels just to grind up requirements, knowing full well that my opponent is hardly ever going to do me favors. At least let us choose the damn classes, so we can build decks that can actually stand a decent chance at all.
Finished all weeklies and jumped from lvl 99 to 107 yesterday. Also reached Diamond 5, a new personal best, with just a few hours left of the season. Now to decide what portrait to choose from the rewards...
Yu-Gi-Oh Master Duel Ranked Season 2 Just Started, but You Might Be Missing Out on Gems
the more you win the less you are rewarded....... no doubts, terrible design !
Great Battlegrounds Balance Changes Coming to Hearthstone in Patch 22.2.1 Today Including Tarecgosa Nerfs
I imagine the Ultra Rare pool exist to add more unpredictability to the runs. It's probably a similar logic to critical hits in RPGs. Whether they have a place in a competitive environment is another discussion (they probably don't)
Great Battlegrounds Balance Changes Coming to Hearthstone in Patch 22.2.1 Today Including Tarecgosa Nerfs
Huh, the duels nerf feels odd. I can't remember where the discussion was occurring (maybe here?) but obviously the big issue with treasures in duels is that if they are so strong that they need to be put in the "Pool 2 Ultra Rare" pool, then they probably should be balanced instead. Some builds are gonna have strong "non-rare" treasures, and others are going to effectively rely on those treasures. And it still takes the agency out of the players hands. You could have a mirror match where both players are playing something like....Duels Ping Mage, but the player who gets ultra lucky with Battle Totem is going to most likely have a way easier time than the person who doesn't.
Ultimately this is going to make the person who doesn't find that treasure feel bad when they go up against someone with that treasure. And this leads back to my initial through which is: why not just get rid of Pool 2 Ultra Rare, and just balance the treasures, or split them out so they aren't a problem. Instead of "Your battlecries trigger twice" maybe make it so "Your Battlecries with a cost <4 trigger twice" or something like that.
Hearthstone’s Duels Recent Feedback Thread Summary and Opinions - How Do You Feel About the Big Duels Update?
so much for those problematic treasures
Goons Of Galakrond - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I do like both of them, but I like the second one better, because it also buffs the Elementals you get from Invoking and combos well with the Neutral Invoke minions.
Goons Of Galakrond - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Wailor does have a point about its value. I don't think it's too crazy, because there weren't many spell Shaman decks, but maybe just reduce the Attack gain to 1. Although we do already have Squallhunter in the same expansion, which is why I think you should go with your second idea.
I definitely think "For each time you've Invoked this game," is going to do well in this comp. Not sure if it has enough flair, but it'll definitely do well playability-wise.
I'm less of a fan of Dragonblight Ritualist. Mainly because I just like your other idea better, but also because I think its value scales too slowly.
I really like how its effect casts an Overload spell, so you still have to sort of pay for the extra effect. However, I do feel it's a bit too difficult to get the effect, compared to its value. There aren't a lot of Invoke cards, which is why the "Invoked twice"-cards have quite strong effects. Your card only requires one Invoke, but getting it on the same turn can be difficult.
Also, a 4/4 3-Cost is kind of unusual. For minions of 2 Mana or higher you should probably stick to a stat total of (Cost * 2 + 1) max, unless they have some sort of negative effect.
Hearthstone’s Duels Recent Feedback Thread Summary and Opinions - How Do You Feel About the Big Duels Update?
Glad you appreciated our summary - it may not seem, but it took quite some time to prepare!
Goons Of Galakrond - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Alright so Wailor and Demon, I created two possible new versions based on your respective pieces of feedback.
Hearthstone’s Duels Recent Feedback Thread Summary and Opinions - How Do You Feel About the Big Duels Update?
This is a great, comprehensive article.
I resonate with the last point made; the buckets are the worst part of Duels (and Dungeon Runs). Rather than picking what seems best, you're usually picking what seems least worst. As mentioned, I often find myself playing Pirate Warrior because that's the only deck which somewhat reliably gets buckets.
Frankly, the bucket system should be replaced with something else. It's not fun. It biases players towards meta decks. It's impossible to properly balance.
Goons Of Galakrond - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Managed to get another idea in here.
Out of every class, Priest is currently tied with Hunter for fewest winning cards (they both have 4). If there's a comp here that can get Priest out of that spot, it's this one. I'm honestly a bit surprised to not see any Rogue cards yet. There's a lot of Shaman here.
Feedback
Did someone say…
Jokes aside, you may get some meme points for using Thunderfury. The first version is very Reaper's Scythe-esque, though it's a lot easier to use in my opinion making it a stronger card. The second one I would avoid because giving a lot of stuff Windfury will always be problematic. We all know how [Hearthstone Card (Battlegrounds Battlemaster) Not Found] turned out.
Redscale Armorsmith is a very solid card all around and I can see it doing well.
Dragonblight Ritualist is a cool design (and one that I may or may not have taken some inspiration from, so I hope I didn't step on your toes too much) though the reward is definitely too weak. Compared to Scion of Ruin which gives you some addition 3/2s with Rush or Veiled Worshipper which draws 3 cards, your reward for Invoking twice is summoning a random 2-Cost Demon. If you can bump that up, I think it'll be a pretty good card.
Storming Invocation should probably be a Nature spell, but otherwise it's a fine card.
I prefer Gronn Taskmaster. I think its designing is just a lot more interesting overall.
Welcome aboard! I look forward to seeing more of you around these parts.
I am a fan of this "if you've Invoked this turn" idea as it's a cool spin on the usual Invoke effects not just in the real game, but also so far in this competition. It's a strong 3 mana 4/4 which isn't technically overpowered, but with a positive effect, will most likely rub people the wrong way. I do think the effect is also a bit weak. Forked Lightning is not exactly one of Shaman's stronger spells.
Forked Lightning also doesn't need the DoD watermark in my opinion.
Shaman seems to be the most popular choice for the comp so far.
I like this. I quite like that the Invoke plays into the Freeze effect with the 2/1 Elemental. I will say that maybe it should be a 2/5 because it seems quite pushed at the moment. Great job overall though.
Goons Of Galakrond - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
My third Shaman card in a row.
There weren't really enough Elemental synergies to make a deck around them, but this should be fine since you can get more Elementals through Invoking and it strengthens Elementals that may have already been worth including in a deck.
EDIT: I did consider making it a 5-Cost 3/6. Thoughts?
Alterac Duels Meta Update #3 - Best 12-Win Hearthstone Duels Decks for January Week 4
I found myself in a good spot against Big Vanndar with Overload Drek'Thar - Natural Force is nutty.
Drek’Thar, Tax Collector
Righteous Inferno
For the Hoard!
Beat That Bounty Boss!
I successfully piloted a few builds from this streamer to beat heroic bosses. He really seems to know what he is talking about ^_^
By the way, except for the latest 5 added mercenaries I have all the other mercs fully maxed out, so that might also play a role in the success rate.
Alterac Duels Meta Update #3 - Best 12-Win Hearthstone Duels Decks for January Week 4
I went 10-0 only to loose 3 time a row to Battle Tactics
Goons Of Galakrond - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Kinda surprised to see all cards are Shaman or Warrior.
Some early feedback:
About your card, I like the effect, but the statline should definetly be 3/4 or even 4/4. The effect is positive (even if it has Overload), so it shouldn't have above vanilla stats.
BEST Control Priest Is With Shudderwock Is BROKEN | WILD | Fractured in Alterac Valley | Hearthstone
I am glad, I will be careful from now on! :D
[12 Wins] Humble Blessings Paladin
Sweet, just wanted to make sure you were the same person, so if I want to showcase your decks I don't have to create them.
Beat That Bounty Boss!
How did you beat heroic Lok'holar? I want that equipment but get badly beaten whenever I get to the boss..
Hearthstone’s Duels Recent Feedback Thread Summary and Opinions - How Do You Feel About the Big Duels Update?
All I want right now is a new set to play with. It's so stale at the minute and I wouldn't be bothered if I didnt get Van/Drek if the Scholomance heroes had some new cards for deck building 😴😴
Yu-Gi-Oh Master Duel's First Ranked Season Ends in A Couple of Days
Sooooo, I screwed up! I said that Ranked Rewards would be offered at the start of the new season. They were offered as soon as you passed their respective tier, I just didn't notice. Sorry about that.
Hearthstone’s Duels Recent Feedback Thread Summary and Opinions - How Do You Feel About the Big Duels Update?
Very extensive and informative duels article, well done.
Side note: Shadow Word: Void by itself can win games when you drop a 7+ health minion and don't have access to board clears. Blizzard needs to redesign this card coz the nerf isn't fixing the actual problem with the treasure.
You know the card is a problem when a priest can AFK for the first 3 turns and just play this one card and win the game.
Beat That Bounty Boss!
The design is fine and the heroic bosses are indeed beatable. As a matter of fact, I have completed them all in the meantime.
Hearthstone’s Duels Recent Feedback Thread Summary and Opinions - How Do You Feel About the Big Duels Update?
That unlocking treasures and hp in duels is really testing the limits of my patience. The second hp for drekthar requires the person to play 40 spells at 3 mana or more, which is frankly disgusting. Most of the time you'd just die by turn 6 whilst only permitted to play 1 card per turn, and the minute you try to build a deck that can actually win and features a few spells that do cost 3 or more, those spells feel more like a self-inflicted handicap, like trying a 100m race on one foot.
In other words, its simply more efficient to build a deck thats 100% unable to win games but ticking requirements. Hardly a fun time to be had. Even the bs stormwind meta seems less rage inducing.
Perhaps team5 thought that since Vanndar/Drekthar would be here to stay long term it'll eventually be done with some coaxing and nose holding, but I fear that all it does is discourage me from playing these heroes at all. I dont play duels just to grind up requirements, knowing full well that my opponent is hardly ever going to do me favors. At least let us choose the damn classes, so we can build decks that can actually stand a decent chance at all.
Rewards Track Progress: 4.0
Finished all weeklies and jumped from lvl 99 to 107 yesterday. Also reached Diamond 5, a new personal best, with just a few hours left of the season. Now to decide what portrait to choose from the rewards...