I second the comments above, please keep this series going! I love reading the deck analysis and game plans and feel like it helps me be a better player. There’s still plenty of Wild players out there trying to be creative and try out ridiculous things
I'd like to make a Xavius Prime, but I'm too busy now to come up with good 'Prime' effect.
Sorry, I'll try to leave feedback tomorrow.
EDIT: no, I'll make feedback now. From last to first.
FEEDBACK
linkblade91
About new version. .. So nightmare Ysera still summon treans? IDK. Previous version which destroy all minions was better imo. But leave new hero power.
AeroJulwin
Card is nice and clear. One thing - maybe it is not so flavorful in terms of the emerald nightmare.
Wailor
While you can Silence or just trade Xavius with minions and evade damage from its ability, you can do nothing with this spell. And what if it was played twice? Double damage when spend mana? I think minion is better. I'm right, isn't it?
BasilAnguis
Two turns Immune minion is OP imo.
TheHoax91
Its not clear. Dormnant hero can play cards or use hero power? If not, then this is too OP. If yes, then … never mind.
I missed the update where you are being forced to play exclusively Rogue after you aquire Legendary rank. Seriously, is there anyone in Standard Legendary NOT playing rogue?
I play decks that take actual thinking like Thief Rogue, Handlock, and Menagerie DR DH. You play decks that take simple computing like Pirate Warrior, Elemental Shaman, and Face Hunter.
I am a human. You are a robot.
What piques my interest when a new set comes out are cards that look enjoyable and can lead to different paths each game. What you care about is which are over-tuned and will lead to 100''s of repetitive games.
I am a human. You are a robot.
When I net-deck something that looks good I'm happy to throw in a few cards I find fun, and I still win. You among millions shudder at the thought of deviating from the list.
I am a human. You are a robot.
When I win with my deck I know that I had a lot to do with it. When you win with yours, trust me it was more the deck.
I am a human. You are a robot.
I play Arena because it's fresh every time and takes some skill to get far in. You play Duels with the same 15 cards every time in every class; playing against other robots and whoever gets the more busted treasures and passives wins.
I am a human. You are a robot.
I put enjoying myself playing a video game above winning while you are a sad android that can't stand to lose.
I'm not sure that's what's going on here. I encourage you to keep the original Battlecry. It turned a strong summon into a perhaps even more powerful destruction. It fits the prompt perfectly, turning the effect around in a evil and (often) profitable way, similar to Circus Medic. I should have mentioned this in my original feedback, but my feedback tends to get pretty long, so I often focus on improvements.
I enjoy cards that are a bit more out there and have unique effects. Those cards do make it to the finals, but in my experience, it tends to be the saver (whatever that means) cards that win. But I don't think you should let that limit your creativity. And most certainly don't mistake your own creativity for ego.
Thank you for your encouragement! I'm doing my best for the time being even if I can't live up to Swizard's standards in creativity. Right now I'm searching the web each week for something interesting that isn't a complete meme to begin with and features a class that hasn't been on the series so far. Maybe someone more apt at deckbuilding might pick up the torch in a more interesting way, we'll see what the future holds.
I wouldn't say the deck as it is is tier 1, but it's definitely working. If you think you can't afford playing the rod just do the alternative combo with Vol'jin or Phylactery. Usually you'll find a moment to sneak it out though, like on a Plague of Flames turn later in the game. There's also an argument to be made that QL Hunter and QL Pirate Warrior play 5 mana do nothings on a regular basis ;-)
Wow, I really have nothing for this one so far. I've submitted a card for every comp so far, and I'm not going to let this one be the first one that I don't enter. For the Christmas comp, I ended up having to submit a card I made in less than a minute without any feedback and I surprisingly made it to the finals with it, so I guess that may happen here as well.
But here's a follow-up to my original feedback.
BasilAnguis
I'm going to have to agree and say that two turns of immunity is quite strong. Druid can easily just choose a meaningless 1/1 token to make Dormant almost completely negating the downside and then buff the Immune minion. Immune in general is a touchy keyword to explore because it can easily become problematic. It also feels a bit weird in flavor as well.
R
I do realize that bending Druid's flavor and mechanical identity is a necessity for this comp, but this definitely steps over the line. I suppose it makes sense flavorfully, but having a card that is very heavily Demon-centric in a class without Demons (other than Imprisoned Satyr), even if it's not requiring you to actually use them in your deck, feels very strange.
Wailor
Solid idea, but I think the strength of these cards can be increased since they're both entirely reliant on your opponent's actions and board state. Sometimes your opponent may simply be able to play around either of these effects by just not spending mana. Both of these cards will require your opponent to spend roughly 7 or 8 mana on their next turn before they become "even", and Nightmare Lord Xavius can possibly be killed before it does anything if your opponent has the means to kill it without needing to spend mana effectively making it winmore-y.
AeroJulwin
I like this. It's a neat juxtaposition of traditional Druid mechanics that work for this competition, and the class can play into the effect perfectly with ramp.
Linkblade91
I do prefer this version. It's more in line with what Corrupt is supposed to do, which I think is beneficial both for consistency and for gameplay.
In the end, I think it's going to be either Mage or Shaman, given that both classes see competitive play and I am close to hitting the 1000 wins goal with both.
Lightforged Uther is another incredibly sick skin (despite that strange, robotic, tubular armguard in the bottom right corner), but 540 wins are a lot...
Now the Corrupt is blatantly better, summoning upgraded Treants. They also can feed into Nightmare's Embrace immediately (by trading), meaning Corrupted Ysera gets a head-start on her Hero Power usage. I kept regular-Ysera's Hero Power as Play instead of Summon mostly because it wouldn't fit without looking ugly.
Sadly can't show you the Treant token, 'cause I've run out of room *shrugs* It would just be an evil tree, functioning as a "vanilla" 4/4/4 with Rush.
I will say that I'm not personally as thrilled about this current iteration, because I wanted to keep the Twisting Nether/better Poison Seeds connection to the Nightmare, being a realm of death, but if people prefer this version than that's fine. I'd rather win than soothe my ego lol.
Thanks for the reminder, the invite and the encouragement - but I ended up losing on my final game ... In terms of game plans, any cheap spells packages will be put to good use, as well as spell/outcast discount, allowing you to cycle through your hand faster. Make sure to add extra card draw for quest completion purposes - a few treasures of that 0 mana spell, you and your opponent draw 2 cards sure won't hurt. Ideally, you want to set your self up for a TTK, swinging almost all you got in about 2 turns - 15 to 20 dmg each blow - aiming for a midrange win. Best of luck!
Predict is a Shurima identity technically, but because of the champion pairing system, it is only 1/8 of Shurima's identity. The problem is that "identity" becomes so wide and muddled and there's so much crossover between region identity that regions don't really feel different anymore. Like OP said, region pairings have more identity than the regions themselves. The Shurima+PnZ pairing has more identity than Shurima on its own. Zilean feels more like a PnZ champion than a Shurima champion, and Nasus feels more like a Shadow Isles champion than a Shurima champion.
And yes, Bandle's main identity is card generation, but so is that of Targon and PnZ. The extreme overlap is pretty clear.
Region identity is not based around a single mechanic but rather strength and weakness :
P&Z for example has access to lots of removal, burn damage and is good at maintaining card advantage ( either with draw effect or card generation ), on flip side the region has no healing and struggle in combat because it's unit's tend to have underwhelming stat line.
Some regions can overlap with another and still tweak the mechanic enough for it to be different for example Ionia, Noxus and Freljord all have spell removal as part of their identity but they are different from one another :
- Ionia cannot completely get rid of an enemy unit they can only temporarily recall it with cards like Will of Ionia or Homecoming.
- With cards like Ravenous Flock or Scorched Earth Noxus is good at removing single high health unit's but don't have ways to deal with swarm.
- Freljord is good at dealing with swarm of low health unit with cards like Avalanche or Blighted Ravine but struggle at dealing with big ones.
Finally it's not a realistic expectation to think that every champion is going to fit withing the confine of region identity, Demacia for example is supposed to be a anti magical, combat oriented region but many of their remaining champions are mages ( Sona, Sylas, Morgana )
With Mondays Weeklies I´ve finally hit lvl 70 and got that 20% boost. Today I´ve also hit 1400 Honor for the High Warlord rank and got golden Vanndar Stormpike, so now I can try to do the Wing Commander Ichman achievement (which I "luckily" opened in my last pack). My XP achievement count is at 55% done, hope that they will fix the broken ones soon.
When the expansion launched and the OwlTK became a thing I used that package for some Maly Lock hijinks. I thought while playing my Malygos list, “This package could easily be used for some Mecha’thun BS!” I never tried it but obviously many others had the same thought as the Mecha’thun Warlocks started popping up quickly while the Owl was suddenly nowhere to found in Wild.
Probably not going to be addressed until at least a few weeks after Dec 2021. Its that time of the year after all, just try losing your internet line during a major holiday and face a week without it because everyone's taken a hike.
Perhaps this is the time we finally have a little talk about putting xp rewards for achievements and how unrealistic it is for the majority of the players to achieve it without going all out of their way to do so. And then for some reason they'd set it so it will only grant xp on the expansion itself, so you cant just let it be and complete it naturally as the game ages, forcing you to purposefully create decks out of cards no one in their right mind would insert into a competitive deck, just for the sake of the xp gain. To be honest, if there's an angry mob outside their offices demanding swift bug fixes to achievements, they have no one to blame but themselves.
Unfortunately yes, it appears that the first month of the expansion isn't the best period for a Master Duelist challenge. Not even I was able to have a shot at 1.5: between the (huge) content creation of these weeks and the fact that, you know, I wanted to try the new cards, I think I had just a couple Duels runs.
Thanks Calemnir for the submission and congratulations for your 12er: definitely an interesting take on the archetype, and I am glad it worked out in the end!
The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays
I second the comments above, please keep this series going! I love reading the deck analysis and game plans and feel like it helps me be a better player. There’s still plenty of Wild players out there trying to be creative and try out ridiculous things
Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I'd like to make a Xavius Prime, but I'm too busy now to come up with good 'Prime' effect.
Sorry, I'll try to leave feedback tomorrow.
EDIT: no, I'll make feedback now. From last to first.
Group Therapy! Need to blow off some steam? Mega salty? Here's the place!
I missed the update where you are being forced to play exclusively Rogue after you aquire Legendary rank. Seriously, is there anyone in Standard Legendary NOT playing rogue?
I am a human. You are a robot.
I play decks that take actual thinking like Thief Rogue, Handlock, and Menagerie DR DH. You play decks that take simple computing like Pirate Warrior, Elemental Shaman, and Face Hunter.
I am a human. You are a robot.
What piques my interest when a new set comes out are cards that look enjoyable and can lead to different paths each game. What you care about is which are over-tuned and will lead to 100''s of repetitive games.
I am a human. You are a robot.
When I net-deck something that looks good I'm happy to throw in a few cards I find fun, and I still win. You among millions shudder at the thought of deviating from the list.
I am a human. You are a robot.
When I win with my deck I know that I had a lot to do with it. When you win with yours, trust me it was more the deck.
I am a human. You are a robot.
I play Arena because it's fresh every time and takes some skill to get far in. You play Duels with the same 15 cards every time in every class; playing against other robots and whoever gets the more busted treasures and passives wins.
I am a human. You are a robot.
I put enjoying myself playing a video game above winning while you are a sad android that can't stand to lose.
I am a human. You are a robot.
The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays
I hate mecha'thun warlock, but very informational article though. Now I know how to annoy their playstyle >:)
Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I'm not sure that's what's going on here. I encourage you to keep the original Battlecry. It turned a strong summon into a perhaps even more powerful destruction. It fits the prompt perfectly, turning the effect around in a evil and (often) profitable way, similar to Circus Medic. I should have mentioned this in my original feedback, but my feedback tends to get pretty long, so I often focus on improvements.
I enjoy cards that are a bit more out there and have unique effects. Those cards do make it to the finals, but in my experience, it tends to be the saver (whatever that means) cards that win. But I don't think you should let that limit your creativity. And most certainly don't mistake your own creativity for ego.
Card Design Conversation - Zero Regrets
Insane cards!! Well done :)
The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays
Thank you for your encouragement! I'm doing my best for the time being even if I can't live up to Swizard's standards in creativity. Right now I'm searching the web each week for something interesting that isn't a complete meme to begin with and features a class that hasn't been on the series so far. Maybe someone more apt at deckbuilding might pick up the torch in a more interesting way, we'll see what the future holds.
The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays
I wouldn't say the deck as it is is tier 1, but it's definitely working. If you think you can't afford playing the rod just do the alternative combo with Vol'jin or Phylactery. Usually you'll find a moment to sneak it out though, like on a Plague of Flames turn later in the game. There's also an argument to be made that QL Hunter and QL Pirate Warrior play 5 mana do nothings on a regular basis ;-)
Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Wow, I really have nothing for this one so far. I've submitted a card for every comp so far, and I'm not going to let this one be the first one that I don't enter. For the Christmas comp, I ended up having to submit a card I made in less than a minute without any feedback and I surprisingly made it to the finals with it, so I guess that may happen here as well.
But here's a follow-up to my original feedback.
I'm going to have to agree and say that two turns of immunity is quite strong. Druid can easily just choose a meaningless 1/1 token to make Dormant almost completely negating the downside and then buff the Immune minion. Immune in general is a touchy keyword to explore because it can easily become problematic. It also feels a bit weird in flavor as well.
The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays
Are you sure Mithril Rod is still playable in this format? 5 mana do nothing
The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays
PLEASE you all, just keep this series alive. Until the end of days. Thanks :-).
Can we get a Path of Champions section?
Thread title.
Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I also prefer the previous version.
Achievement Hunting: Alterac edition (featuring bugs from the smol indie company series & Knuckles)
Is there any info about Lightforged Cariel being still bugged?
Anyway, I wonder it could be done without the actual hero card, using Kobold Stickyfinger?...
Golden Hero Portrait - Completionist & Grind
Thanks Horus. And congrats: you just got yourself a Snowball Fight! worthy of that name!
NebuchadnezzarHS - So, the one you see below is my situation
Here are a couple notes about my personal tastes:
In the end, I think it's going to be either Mage or Shaman, given that both classes see competitive play and I am close to hitting the 1000 wins goal with both.
Lightforged Uther is another incredibly sick skin (despite that strange, robotic, tubular armguard in the bottom right corner), but 540 wins are a lot...
Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
How's this for an update on the Hero card?
Now the Corrupt is blatantly better, summoning upgraded Treants. They also can feed into Nightmare's Embrace immediately (by trading), meaning Corrupted Ysera gets a head-start on her Hero Power usage. I kept regular-Ysera's Hero Power as Play instead of Summon mostly because it wouldn't fit without looking ugly.
Sadly can't show you the Treant token, 'cause I've run out of room *shrugs* It would just be an evil tree, functioning as a "vanilla" 4/4/4 with Rush.
I will say that I'm not personally as thrilled about this current iteration, because I wanted to keep the Twisting Nether/better Poison Seeds connection to the Nightmare, being a realm of death, but if people prefer this version than that's fine. I'd rather win than soothe my ego lol.
I'll provide feedback later.
Yugu's 12 Wins Outlander Demon Hunter
Thanks for the reminder, the invite and the encouragement - but I ended up losing on my final game ...
In terms of game plans, any cheap spells packages will be put to good use, as well as spell/outcast discount, allowing you to cycle through your hand faster. Make sure to add extra card draw for quest completion purposes - a few treasures of that 0 mana spell, you and your opponent draw 2 cards sure won't hurt. Ideally, you want to set your self up for a TTK, swinging almost all you got in about 2 turns - 15 to 20 dmg each blow - aiming for a midrange win. Best of luck!
Does each region have enough of an identity?
Region identity is not based around a single mechanic but rather strength and weakness :
P&Z for example has access to lots of removal, burn damage and is good at maintaining card advantage ( either with draw effect or card generation ), on flip side the region has no healing and struggle in combat because it's unit's tend to have underwhelming stat line.
Some regions can overlap with another and still tweak the mechanic enough for it to be different for example Ionia, Noxus and Freljord all have spell removal as part of their identity but they are different from one another :
- Ionia cannot completely get rid of an enemy unit they can only temporarily recall it with cards like Will of Ionia or Homecoming.
- With cards like Ravenous Flock or Scorched Earth Noxus is good at removing single high health unit's but don't have ways to deal with swarm.
- Freljord is good at dealing with swarm of low health unit with cards like Avalanche or Blighted Ravine but struggle at dealing with big ones.
Finally it's not a realistic expectation to think that every champion is going to fit withing the confine of region identity, Demacia for example is supposed to be a anti magical, combat oriented region but many of their remaining champions are mages ( Sona, Sylas, Morgana )
Rewards Track Progress: 4.0
With Mondays Weeklies I´ve finally hit lvl 70 and got that 20% boost. Today I´ve also hit 1400 Honor for the High Warlord rank and got golden Vanndar Stormpike, so now I can try to do the Wing Commander Ichman achievement (which I "luckily" opened in my last pack). My XP achievement count is at 55% done, hope that they will fix the broken ones soon.
Good luck all!
Golden Hero Portrait - Completionist & Grind
Well done Avalon! Here, have some snowballs to celebrate your achievement!
The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays
When the expansion launched and the OwlTK became a thing I used that package for some Maly Lock hijinks. I thought while playing my Malygos list, “This package could easily be used for some Mecha’thun BS!” I never tried it but obviously many others had the same thought as the Mecha’thun Warlocks started popping up quickly while the Owl was suddenly nowhere to found in Wild.
Any news on these damned bug fixes?
Probably not going to be addressed until at least a few weeks after Dec 2021. Its that time of the year after all, just try losing your internet line during a major holiday and face a week without it because everyone's taken a hike.
Perhaps this is the time we finally have a little talk about putting xp rewards for achievements and how unrealistic it is for the majority of the players to achieve it without going all out of their way to do so. And then for some reason they'd set it so it will only grant xp on the expansion itself, so you cant just let it be and complete it naturally as the game ages, forcing you to purposefully create decks out of cards no one in their right mind would insert into a competitive deck, just for the sake of the xp gain. To be honest, if there's an angry mob outside their offices demanding swift bug fixes to achievements, they have no one to blame but themselves.
Golden Hero Portrait - Completionist & Grind
Congratulations, Avalon!! Job's done!!
What is going to be the next challenge?
Master Duelist 1.5: The Battle For Alterac - Submission & Discussion Thread
Unfortunately yes, it appears that the first month of the expansion isn't the best period for a Master Duelist challenge. Not even I was able to have a shot at 1.5: between the (huge) content creation of these weeks and the fact that, you know, I wanted to try the new cards, I think I had just a couple Duels runs.
Thanks Calemnir for the submission and congratulations for your 12er: definitely an interesting take on the archetype, and I am glad it worked out in the end!