All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • I am a human. You are a robot.

    I don't get offended by it. I've been incarcerated before and grew up in a dicey neighborhood so the written word of some gamer I've never met doesn't make me bat one eye.

     

    However on the ethics of etiquette I will point out that I was calling out a general group of players while you are singling out one. So which of us is the rude one?

     

    Also someone has to make threads here! These forums are barren. I'm just trying to start conversation and, hey, it's working....

  • I am a human. You are a robot.

    I hope you stop making threads one day.

    If you get offended by this, that speaks volumes about you. I'm using a few literary techniques to annunciate a point. Satire, repetition, avant garde. Please take with a grain of salt.

  • Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    No, its like after Nightmare Lord Xavius's death Emerald Dream is freed from the corruption. (:

    Updated my Prime version!

  • Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    Here's my feedback, a day late and a dollar short. Meant to get it up yesterday but I was having too much fun playing Gunfire Reborn lel:

    Show Spoiler

    Demonxz95 - You really like resetting the game to the start lol :P I am not a fan, to be honest, because as AeroJulwin alluded to there isn't much advantage to be had here. Celestial Alignment's positives can be exploited; this is just a hard reset that drags out the game and/or forces you to double-down on the ramp to get back up to speed.

    R - Going the Prime route is a great idea; kind of upset I didn't think of it first. That said Xavius Prime should not produce Dream cards, unless it is explicitly Nightmare. It's a major disconnect to the whole flavor. I would not be against something as simple as "Add three copies of Nightmare to your hand", to try and extend for lethal, although I imagine there are more creative things to do with it.

    AeroJulwin - I think the card is neat, but I wonder if I would ever use it. Theoretically the Druid wouldn't be as punished because ramp can mitigate the cost, but I wonder if such a thing would make more sense in the Warlock. That or some other class that can burn through its deck faster; lets you screw with your opponent without hurting yourself as much. If your deck is slower, you have more to lose from this.

    Wailor - My concern with this effect is that you would just use it to guarantee someone's death: if they're low on Health they literally can't do anything but skip their turn and await your lethal hit. Fever Dream is especially bad because you can cast it twice in a round for double the trouble. Xavius might be fine, given it's an expensive Legendary, but it's definitely not a fun card to be around IMO.

    BasilAnguis - Immune is dangerous; always makes me nervous. Two turns is a lot, as well. I don't know, it just seems like a small downside when you can turn off like a token or something small for what could be a major play.

    TheHoax91 - It's certainly an interesting idea: you would naturally play this last in a turn, after doing what damage you can. I think it might seem unintuitive for some, and that could cost you points.

  • The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays

    https://www.hearthstonetopdecks.com/decks/mechathun-warlock-118-legend-合纵连横-wild-s83/

     

    For the record, thanks. Might be viable still, who knows. Only much linear, with no plans B and C and loses hard to Rat

  • The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays

    Could be talking about the Dollmaster Dorian + Plot Twist, Bloodbloom + Cataclysm combo.  I think the Bloom nerf killed that.

    At launch of Barrens a list similar to this one that ran Hemet could win by turn 8 if you had the Coin and got lucky draws.  Same idea: 0 mana minion, Shadow Hunter to swap with the only other minion in your hand, Mecha’thun, and then Cataclysm.  9 mana total for the combo turn.  Just had to make sure you didn’t play Hemet until after you draw a 0 mana minion.

  • Shudder Freeze Shaman

    Played a deck like this with a few alterations and absolutely breezed Diamond to Legend this month, went 22-3 with it. Deck felt incredibly OP if im being honest. Heals/Armour to keep you alive, decks that want the board you can freeze over and over again and rats to help you with combo decks

  • Does each region have enough of an identity?

    For what it's worth, I think you're right about how the Riot design philosophy works here - Champions are about fulfilling a particular fantasy regardless of their region. I guess it's a big part of why I got frustrated with the game, but for folks that have no issue with that, the game is probably totally reasonable.

    As far as I'm concerned, if it were just Champions in isolation that broke the regional identites, it might be fine. But Champions often need Followers that directly support their unique game plan in order to work (e.g. the Diana and Nocturne need a lot of Nightfall units to work, and Rek'Sai's payoff is worthless if your deck isn't full of Lurkers). The result is that huge chunks of expansions are dedicated not to the core regional identities of regions, but to the Champions' identities.

  • Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    R
    I think creating a Prime is a great idea. Similar to linkblade's 7-cost Corrupt, it requires some setting up. That allows you to go a little nuts with the effect, which is exactly what a lot of the cards for this prompt need. 

    That being said, the Prime effect isn't very interesting to me. It already exists on Ysera the Dreamer and why Dream cards? Isn't Xavius suppose to be on the opposite side?

    Demonxc95
    The effect fits Druid and although it may look similar at first, in practice it works quite different from Celestial Alignment.

    However, I just don't think it's very appealing. It's effectively a hard reset, which makes the match progress very slowly and will remove the advantage of any extra mana crystals Druid is so fond of getting.

  • I am a human. You are a robot.

    I think how offended people get by my posts really speaks volumes. I'm using a few literary techniques to annunciate a point. Satire, repetition, avant garde. Please take with a grain of salt.

    Yes, fun IS subjective but when my sort of fun is being oppressed I feel I have all rights coming out swinging like this. 

     

    let's try an example as you would rather me state it:

    "Oh jeez man I rly don't like how these easy to play decks are everywhere. It'd make the game better if ppl played more interesting decks like burgle rogue"

     

    Do you see how ineffective and tired that paragraph is? Why not just enjoy the show? Are you really that easily offended? My point is valid if insulting but should be worth thinking about.

     

    Or maybe Trump, Kibler, Regis and many more are wrong too...

     

  • Card Design Conversation - Zero Regrets

    Pro

    You fell right into my trap!

    It might be unnecessaryly complicated, but I phrased that sentence like this on purpose: If 2023 finds Shadows happy and healthy, that means that 2022 has been a good year for them ;-) 

  • I am a human. You are a robot.

    Pro

    Honestly, you should really stop starting threads like these. I'm not even sure if this is a serious attempt to start a discussion anymore or one of those opportunities to point someone to the Salt Thread. I give you the benefit of the doubt and take it as an invitation to debate netdecking, but as several people have told you before: check your manners mate. You can't expect us to happily exchange opinions with you when you start the discussion with such a haughty tone that borders on insult. And don't come back at me again with that freedom of speech stuff, it's not like your threads get locked (yet?). I for one won't reply to your rants anymore if you don't improve your choice of words.

  • Card Design Conversation - Zero Regrets

    Staff Pro

    That's quite some foresight you got there. But don't forget about 2022, the year that we're about to get into. *insert tongue out emoticon*

  • Nightmare On Emerald Street - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    What's really difficult is trying to come up with something that makes sense for the competition, but at the same time, not going against the core philosophies of how Druid cards are designed. Some designs I can think of in my mind that make sense are like "oh, that's kinda cool, but... it I can't break that weakness of Druid."

    Nonetheless, I did manage to get something out that doesn't fall into that trap.

  • Card Design Conversation - Zero Regrets

    Pro

    Thank you for all your work and dedication Shadows. May 2023 find you happy and healthy! 

  • Does each region have enough of an identity?

    You are not wrong on that, you can translate a champions ability in way that stay true to region identity,  it's exactly what they did with LeBlanc.

    In league Leblanc is a squishy burst mage who either one shot you or die so her LOR equivalent has high power with quick attack and low health, they also made her a combat oriented to fit within Noxus play style. The thing is most of the player base hated that design even dubbing her Lebland, because the majority of the player base care more about the champion fulfilling a certain power fantasy than how honest they are to a region identity. 

    That's why region identity for me at very least is tied more to the generic tool that a region have rather than the champions themselves. So if they release a champion like Urgot for example and made him a very good combat centric unit which is something that P&Z isn't supposed to be good at, that wouldn't bother me but if they start releasing a bunch a good generic combat centric cards that any P&Z deck could use then that would a problem.

    Anyway that my personal view on the subject.

  • The Era of Flesh Has Ended - A Full Guide to Mecha'thun Warlock on the Wildest of Wednesdays

    There were versions of Mecha’Thun Lock with Hemet that won pretty consistently at T7-8. I wonder why they suddenly disappeared..

  • I am a human. You are a robot.

  • Group Therapy! Need to blow off some steam? Mega salty? Here's the place!

    Quote From WiseWolf

    I missed the update where you are being forced to play exclusively Rogue after you aquire Legendary rank. Seriously, is there anyone in Standard Legendary NOT playing rogue? 

    very weird, while in my case, it was like 7 out of 10 games with Pirates Warrior. And trust me when I say I had enough, so I went full Freeze Shaman to counter it. Maybe next season climb I get to face more Rogue then.

  • I am a human. You are a robot.

    Is this some kind of rants? Because I read this and felt something happened in your games, that you immediately tried to objectified everything here.

    I mean, it's a different kind of fun for everyone else. I'm having fun when I played a decisive match because some aggro can't no longer 'aggroing' their deck against my heavy taunts deck.

    So, if you think you're the only one having fun, I must say, you're probably wrong.

     

  • I am a human. You are a robot.

    Compared to all the filthy things meta decks are slinging right now they aren't that strong. Trust me they don't help a lot.. try it before you say it.

  • Group Therapy! Need to blow off some steam? Mega salty? Here's the place!

    Quote From WiseWolf

    I missed the update where you are being forced to play exclusively Rogue after you aquire Legendary rank. Seriously, is there anyone in Standard Legendary NOT playing rogue? 

    No, rank 3 and above is full of rogues too
    Got like 4 in a row

  • This Week's Top Hearthstone Twitch Clips Featuring Kripparrian, Thijs, & Rdu

    I had so much fun watching clips, my fav one is Thijs 🤣

  • I am a human. You are a robot.

    I mean, Thief Rogue is literally "play Wildpaw Gnoll and Double Agent as soon as possible", but sure.

  • Does each region have enough of an identity?

    Quote From minuano28
    Region identity is not based around a single mechanic but rather strength and weakness :
    ...

    Finally it's not a realistic expectation to think that every champion is going to fit withing the confine of region identity, Demacia for example is supposed to be a anti magical, combat oriented region but many of their remaining champions are mages ( Sona, Sylas, Morgana ) 

     

    This is exactly what I thought Riot believed, and is fundamentally the problem I tried to highlight in my original post. Regional identity takes a backseat to champion identity, which in turn leads to regional pair identities to ensure each Champion has enough support for their gameplan. It dilutes the unique feeling of any given region and weakens deck-building.

    I'd also like to challenge you a bit on this idea that these remaining champions can't fit their regions simply because there's some surface-level clashing of themes. Demacia is all about nullifying magic, the righteous pursuit and striking down of their enemies, and winning on board with challenge and smart trades. With that in mind, consider this design that I just threw together for Morgana:


    To be very clear, I didn't make much of an effort to think about balance here, I just wanted to flesh out how you might translate her LoL abilities to a Demacia card that's still honest to the region's identity.

    Her Black Shield power becomes a Support SpellShield. There's not much SpellShielding in Demacia, but it's thematically relevant and clearly splashes in a bit (Captain Arrika, and sort of Towering Stonehorn). It fits the anit-magic themes and pushes the player to enter combat. Her Soul Shackles ability becomes a Grant Vulnerable for champions at Level 2. Vulnerable is another keyword that doesn't show up in Demacia, but since it's the inverse of Challenge and focused exclusively on champions it's still suitable to fit what Demacia does (i.e. targeted trades), and it fits better with the behavior of the LoL ability. Finally, her Dark Binding causes an enemy to strike itself, fitting with the fantasy of the ability and Demacia's common keywords (on the LoL website, it's described as "forcing them to feel the pain they've caused").

    So, this is a mage/support card in Demacia that still highlights an anti-magic theme and pushes the player to engage in board-based combat, but is different enough to feel special/different from the more hardcore combat champions of Demacia without being so rooted in its own arbitrary abilities that it can't function without tons of specific card packages. It's not a perfect 1-to-1 translation of Morgana from LoL to LoR, but it does a good job without muddying Demacia's strengths and weaknesses, and it's a card that has broad enough application (by virtue of being a Champ killer) that it could see play in a variety of decks/archetypes.