All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    Its amazing to me how much these third party software are doing - for free to the consumer - whilst a company like blizz sit on their hands on a simple request like this.

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    Quote From sinti

    Maybe it wasnt exciting overall, but it did bring some good cards and Rush was one of the biggest stepping stones in the future design since that point and allowed to make some more exciting cards since :)

    It has been argued that the overuse of Rush is when the decline of the board-centric meta began. When immediate removal is so easy and commonplace, you look for ways to win without needing to stick a board.

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    WW wasn't just "low excitement" to me; it was actively discouraging. I hated Genn and Baku enough that I took a year-long break from HS.

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    Why would you think a streamer's habits or opinions are representative of the greater player base?

    They may have a broader perspective on gameplay issues (because they play a lot more than the average player), but this is a quality-of-life issue. Enough people have asked for this with such consistent frequency that there's really no excuse for ignoring the request.

  • Worth Every Penny - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Pro

    Feedback at last, sorry for being late! 

    DestroyerR
    I like your general idea but this is too weak by far to be worth the draw back. I'm also not sure if Mage is the right class, there's not much flavor in any direction so you might as well make it a Neutral.

    BloodMefist
    My favorite card so far. Very cool!

    Wailor
    Interesting flavor though I have to admit I'm not a big fan of the pizza art piece. You managed to find a very fitting effect for it and the foreshadowing of Honorable Kill is a really nice addition that you should definitely mention in your description box. I'd go with the rare version that increases the cost of one card.

    R
    Plus 1 point for creativity since you are the only one in this thread who went down the Hero Power road. Other than that, judging the balance is pretty hard since there's a delay, but it lacks Baku's deck building restriction. I tend to vote OP though.

    BasilAnguis
    This is genius and at the brink of being too complicated at the same time. I can guarantee 4 stars from me but will have to think some more about adding the fifth as well. Great work! (The name is a bit bulky as well)

    Demonxz95
    The Golem would have been fine a few years ago but doesn't make the cut for me these days. Clock Tower Guard is okay but too niche to be really interesting. The Hunter card has a lot of combo potential without necessarily encouraging OTK builds too much. I definitely like that one the most out of the three.

  • The Scariest Mobalytics Decks

    if people actually stop playing ionia just because God-Willow Seedling is less op now and Kinkou Wayfinder is less abusive then that's clearly an overreaction/mistake

    Ionia got great new cards if people don't find ways to use them then that's on them

    could it be that the actual reason why people stoped playing ionia decks is that streamers haven't come up with new decks to copy paste and/or people just want to take their chance to play old decks before new decks roll around?

    Like if your deck was pushed into tier 2-3 by the decks that now got nerfed and now you got a realistic chance to do your thing then you would take this chance wouldn't you?

     

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    If it weren't for HS Tracker's auto-squelch plugin, I probably would have left Hearthstone many years ago. Can't play without it.

  • The Final Nozdormu Day of 2021 in the Hearthstone Tavern - Speedy Dragon Joins Our Decks to Fight for Honor

    Staff Pro

    Played the (filthy, disgusting) Facedormu Hunter deck. Never procced Noz in any game, won once, and did not have fun :/ I feel dirty just touching an Aggro deck; yuck.

    I will say that using Aimed Shot on my own face to bypass Cloak of Shadows for lethal was the high moment, but the rest was dumb.

  • The Final Nozdormu Day of 2021 in the Hearthstone Tavern - Speedy Dragon Joins Our Decks to Fight for Honor

    Great games to end the year. All played in ranked standard.

    Playing N'Zoth, God of the Deep Commencement Warrior with Noz.

    1st Game Vs Questline Priest w/ Nozdormu. I got to them too fast with Clockwork Giant. Put up a great fight but had to use alot of removal early as I cheated them out. Finished off with Troll Centurion honorable kill.

    2nd Game Vs Hand Lock. Fast Giant again set them off balance. By the time they had Tickatus corrupted they were dead.

    3rd Game vs Elemental Shaman with a Nozdormu. I had a bad starting hand and they were very aggressive. Got me down to 1hp despite my clearing as much as possible. Lucky Commencement into Mo'arg Forgefiend almost wasn't even. Heavy Plate andLokholar the Ice Lord won me the game.

    2 out of 3 games with Nozdormu the Eternal in ranked. So fun!  Forgot it even was the 15th, thanks for the reminder.

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    I think Dean was talking about how weak Witchwood's theme was overall. It was originally going to be a murder mystery set that took place on a train and all the promotional images reflected that. The issue was that the actual set did not so there was this weird disconnected between the promotional theme and the vibes given from the cards. This was also during a time when Dungeon runs were still new and did not contain a lot of the story. I also believe Blizzard startedto invest less in Hearthstone during this time as it was the first set in a while that did not come with a comic book (which could have made the murder mystery part make sense).

  • The Scariest Mobalytics Decks

    If you look at my most recent meta stats Ionia is completely absent from what's being played post hotfix nerfs.

    I wish it wasn't Ionia is super easy to play and tech against.

  • Cloneball!

    They should "randomly" make it that Nozdormu is in every deck for Nozdormu Day

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    I don't care what streamers request. This feature for me would be the single most important QoL feature they could implement and I know I'm not the only one. Half of the comments under this article are about auto-squelch while that's only a fraction of the article. This is what people want.

  • Brand New Meta Stats - Post Hotfix

    https://lor.mobalytics.gg/stats/decks

    Honestly, I consider everything about these new stats to be absolutely terrifying.

    All the decks are extremely strong and versatile and their winrates have gone through the roof.

    1. Dragons already called that one plus 55%

    2. Lisandra plus 55% 

    3. Midrange plunder plus 55%

    4. Pantheon plus 55%

    I guess ezreal was keeping these decks in cheque and now that he's gone they are absolutely dominating

    So no longer do you need to tech against aggro and combo now it's how the hell do you deal with all these midrange powerhouses?

    Honestly, I don't know it's very possible something like a Lee Sin combo deck will ultimately be the tournament answer, but that lineup is scary and difficult to play against.

    Maybe a new king of aggro will emerge and start pressuring from the other end as well, and that's usually when midrange starts to take a hit, but right now it's open season.

  • Worth Every Penny - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro
    Quote From DestroyerR
    Quote From linkblade91

    If the opinion of the theme-suggester matters, I’d be inclined to say it doesn’t count unfortunately. I pictured the card as actually raising the cost of cards and turning them red, not having the option to spend additional mana. By the way, I also didn’t mean for cards that raise costs in both sides to count, a lá Mana Wraith

    Well...damn. I kinda figured, as Demon had already told me No on Discord. I will come up with something else.

    Feedback:

    Show Spoiler

    DestroyerR - As Sinti noted, I don't think anyone would ever play it as a Mage minion. The stats aren't worth it at all, and the Mage cares about the cost of cards in its hand; your opponent would simply kill and rekill this over and over until your hand is worthless.

    BloodMefist - I like that it switches around; that's a neat feature. I'm concerned that someone would find a way to abuse the fact that it starts as Shadow, like with Mind Blast and Void Shard: play this during an OTK turn (after reducing its cost with Insight?) and just utilize the Shadow cost reduction without any care for the switching part.

    Wailor - I would very much not have it increase the cost of all cards in-hand, like the Epic version: that's just awful. The Rare version seems good-to-go.

    anchorm4n - I honestly don't think you'll be able to fit the "up to 10" part without sacrificing something else to make room, so I say screw it. You're good-to-go otherwise :)

    R - With the existence of Tour Guide I just don't think this should be a Start of Game effect. Battlecry, sure, but Tour Guide just blows the requirement out of the water and defeats the point.

    BasilAnguis - I like that it promotes decision-making: the more productive your turn, the more expensive it becomes (and thus harder to refill). That being said I don't think others will appreciate that as much, and it just kind of feels wrong to have a Rogue card that becomes harder to use.

    Wailor (again) - The flavor of Mythmaker is awesome…it's just that the actual effect is suspect. Most 1-Cost minions are not impactful enough with their effects to warrant being 10/10/10s. I think maybe you could win off the idea alone, if people don't think about it too much, but it's hard to say. Desperate Shot annoys me because it would go right into a "dump my hand and win the game" Hunter deck to remove a Taunt.

  • Cloneball!

    It happened 7 times before... those 7 times were not this week though...

  • Cloneball!

    Returns this week, for the eighth time

  • Cloneball!

    What does the title mean by "The Eighth Time This Week"?

  • Cloneball!

    Your best strategy is to mulligan for multiple copies of the same minion, hopefully in the 4-7 mana range. Basically, you want to get on the board early with chunky minions and overwhelm your opponent.

    In my opinion, this is one of the worst Brawls, because there's very little space for player skill. One of the players usually ends up with a hand of garbage legendaries and promptly loses. On the good side, matches are short.

  • Worth Every Penny - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro
    Quote From DestroyerR

    How do you balance this?

     

    Why would you play this lol. Maybe if it was a 5/5 or something :D

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    Staff Pro

    Maybe it wasnt exciting overall, but it did bring some good cards and Rush was one of the biggest stepping stones in the future design since that point and allowed to make some more exciting cards since :)

  • The Final Nozdormu Day of 2021 in the Hearthstone Tavern - Speedy Dragon Joins Our Decks to Fight for Honor

    I wonder why I even bother with other decks. The Nozdormu Face Hunter that I haven’t changed since Forged in the Barrens just won me three ladder games for the second month in a row. One of them was against a Nozdormu opponent. Best of all, all three were 40 Honor kills. 

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #35 - New Card Type, Cosmetics Monetization, Future of Hearthstone, Internal Team Reorganization

    Quote From dapperdog

    Competitive games tend to bring the worse out of some. Its just a human emotion. But I dont like the idea of repercussions for meaningless words or actions of which any serious person would just easily ignore. Especially because we know very well that the report button would easily be abused, and it puts our accounts at the mercy of some community manager etc who would likely be monitoring these things. Sometimes when I get rng-ed to death I would use the 'wow' emote, of which some person might take offense at and report my arse. I wouldn't like the idea of getting a ban from that, and then losing days of productivity appealing it off.

    If there was a 30 min cooldown to invite someone you've just faced, its enough to cool heads or sometimes prompt some self-reflection. That's more positive to me than implementing punishments.

    Agreed.  If someone is still angry after 30 minutes or even remember the details of the game that's going to be surprising.  I think that if someone rage-adds someone and throws out explicitives or racial slurs, sure that should be a "warning: this community does not tolerate verbal harrasment" kind of thing.  Once someone gets a 12 hour ban from their behavior, they will do 1 of 2 things:  A) Change their behavior, because they realize their current behavior has consequences or B) leave the game because they don't want to change.)

    Either of those is a win-win for the community.

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    Quote From Tumbleweedovski

    Auto-squelch could happen. Just do it already, please! I know they've said the game feels more immersive without it, but to me it's only more immersive in a negative way.

    Not decrying your opinion, but I've never seen a single streamer (granted I don't watch a ton except for Regis/Kibler/Kripp/and a few others) request auto squelch.  Generally they don't care if the opponent emotes occassionally, and if they opponent becomes overly "vocal", they just squelch them.

    Not to mention but the game has a built in timer feature for emotes anyways.  After using like 3 or 4 emotes in a row, the game times out your use of emotes for something like 30-60 seconds.

    This just seems like low-hanging fruit.  I know there is no harm in adding this feature, but you gotta remember that time spent on a largely unnecessary feature (that technically already exists, you just have to manually click) is time not spent on other QoL features.

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Q&A #36 - Battlegrounds Streamer Reveals, Long-Term Plan for Tavern Brawl, Auto-squelch

    I agree, but I am just saying that even if this somehow (though not likely) became a paid for feature I will even consider paying for it (only for a reasonable price of course) which means it is very high on my list of things I really want (need) inside the game 😄