All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Alterac Valley Achievements

    Quote From meisterz39

    The Chillwind Yeti bug makes it pretty clear that little to no manual testing goes into these achievements. I can imagine some poorly written unit tests that might exist and make it look like the code works as intended, but clearly no one ever bothered to try and do this achievement in Standard because you literally can't get the right version of Yeti in Standard.

    Regarding Bless, I've got a new wrinkle to add here. After reading all of this I thought I might test a hypothesis, so I played my first Bless Priest game (which happened to be in Wild). I thought maybe there was some bug resulting in bad integer division (e.g. if it were dividing by 5, let's say, then any buff lower than 5 Attack would count as 0, anything between 5 and 9 would count as 1, etc.). That sort of thing might account for why a huge buff was only counted as 6 points.

    However, my achievement worked exactly as it should have with the following plays: Kabal Talonpriest buff applied to a Northshire Cleric (both played in the same turn), then 2x Divine Spirit into Bless on the subsequent turn for a 26/26 Cleric. My achievement is now at 25/200.

    EDIT: My second attempt with the same deck resulted in a gain of 0 despite buffing a Kabal Talonpriest to 11/11. I don't recall exactly what buffs I put on him when, but he got at least one Talonpriest buff and the Bless buff (and maybe a Focused Will buff?), and was not at full health when I cast Bless on him. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    EDIT: Third attempt, buffed Reliquary of Souls (at full HP) with Divine Spirit and Bless, made no progress...

    I genuinely think it has something to do with breaking after the first game. My first game went just fine too, progress counted perfectly, but afterwards no game counted properly

  • Alterac Valley Achievements

    Okay, so the implication here is that the Gesundheit! achievement is currently only tracking the max value you've ever granted (in my case, 25 attack). Certainly seems like a bug (since the achievement text clearly reads "Give 200 Attack to minions with Bless."), but it's something that we can test further. Of course, it would be incredibly hard to get a minion up to 200+ health for this.

  • Every meta. Why?

    I agree with you that the two biggest issues Hearthstone has is card draw and mana cheating. Time and again those are the things that end up warping metagames. But I also think that's kind of tangential to desire expressed by the OP to see new archetypes buffed to have a chance. Central to that is the question of whether or not all archetypes should be equally viable in competitive environments, and the Mark Rosewater articles are still hugely relevant to that.

    Quick aside - you equate Timmy with Control and Spike with Aggro/OTK, but that's not really correct. Quoting from the Timmy article: "I should stress that Timmies don't like cards because they're expensive. They like cards that are impressive, and many of the most impressive cards are big (in size or effect) and thus are expensive. In addition, let me point out that a card doesn't have to be expensive to appeal to Timmy. If a card has a fun effect or creates interesting gameplay, Timmy can get quite excited even for cards that cost one or two mana."

    Timmies care about big, impressive plays (which often requires a slower metagame), but they don't need to be playing a strict control deck to get that. Burgle Rogue is a great example of this - Contraband Stash is absolutely a Timmy card, but the deck is really more of a midrange/tempo deck than a control deck. Many versions happen to run disruption cards because that's the only way to stay alive in a warped OTK metagame. Similarly, Spike cares about efficient plays that rack up wins, so while Spikes tends to gravitate toward aggro decks for their efficiency they're not strictly aggro players. (Hearthstone has had some degenerate Control metas - e.g. Bomb Warrior meta - and you can bet Spike was playing optimized control decks in those metas.)

    So, why can't fun and competitive be the same thing? For some people they are the same thing, and some archetypes exist to support them. For some people they're not, and other archetypes exist to support them (e.g. Burgle Rogue). They can't all be buffed to equal competitive levels just because some part of the player base likes them. Now, should those "fun" decks like Burgle Rogue be more competitive than they are? Probably, but that reflects problems like excess draw and mana cheating, and buffing weaker decks will only serve to power creep the whole game rather than reign in the actual problems.

  • Celestalon Shares the Hearthstone Team's Thoughts on Drek'Thar and Vanndar Stormpike as Free Golden Card Rewards

    I just think the whole "choose one" idea was dumb. Yes, I get that they want "Horde vs. Alliance" to be a flavorful aspect of Hearthstone. However, I don't think that aspect of the game is top of mind for the majority of players.

    Most players care a lot more about owning Legendaries so they can build the decks they want to build. This gameplay issue trumps any lore or atmosphere reason you could give for doing anything.

    I really, really hated having to choose one of two legendaries before I opened any packs, knowing I might not get the other one for many weeks. I really, really hated that my Horde/Alliance decision was tied to a card that I might not care for on a mechanical level. And most of all, I really, really hate that we are only getting one diamond version out of all this, even though you know they have both cards prepared as diamond. Everything about this implementation has felt bad from start to finish.

    Ultimately, the whole idea of golden cards is really dumb. It's an attempt to replicate the foil premium cards of physical TCGs. However, Hearthstone is NOT a physical TCG, and every time they try to make it seem like one, it causes problems, starting with the random-pack business model and ending with this.

  • Celestalon Shares the Hearthstone Team's Thoughts on Drek'Thar and Vanndar Stormpike as Free Golden Card Rewards

    Understandable, but not excusable. They need to have someone on staff who looks at every decision from the player's perspective.

  • What is the Alterac Valley Meta going to be?

    Quote From FortyDust
    Quote From meisterz39
    Quote From FortyDust

    It's because Warlock has too much healing. I've been saying this since Barrens.

    One of the main points of Warlock is that it uses Health as a resource. That's all well and good, and makes for interesting decisions ... until you give the class so much healing that there are no more decisions. Just go ahead and spend that Health willy-nilly in full confidence that you'll have no trouble getting it back.

    When you're trying to draw through your entire deck, life tapping and cards like Backfire are not the least bit scary because you are guaranteed to get 12 points of healing from quilboars and two 1-mana 6/6 taunts, not to mention all the lifesteal removal you'll draw along the way, some of which may be doubled by Tamsin.

    Warlock may not technically have more healing than Priest, but it definitely has far more efficient healing, and a lot of it.

    The problems go hand-in-hand, but I do think the latest "OwlTK" Warlock decks shows that card draw is the biggest issue. It's true that decks that care about self-harm (i.e. Questline Handlock) use Barrens Scavenger and Blood Shard Bristleback to recover, but they're only enabled by drawing your whole deck really fast. Meanwhile the "OwlTK" Warlock doesn't use either of those cards to stabalize, instead getting by with cheap AOE like Grimoire of Sacrifice along with extra card draw like Bloodmage Thalnos and the Tour Guide/Manafeeder Panthara combo.

    I see what you're saying, but accelerated card draw is supposed to be part of the Warlock class identity. It wouldn't make sense to take that away from them. Healing, on the other hand, should be present but minimal.

    OwlTK does make use of the worst offender, Touch of the Nathrezim, along with Drain Soul, exacerbated by Mo'arg Artificer and Tamsin Roame (in a pinch). So the amount of healing generated by even OwlTK is way too much.

    I agree card draw is their identity. (hell it's built into their hero power) but they have so much also besides that.  In fact I'd argue that the warlock class itself should have almost NO card draw in their class cards simply because their hero power is so central to it. 

    For the last year, if not two years, warlock has continually proven to be a problem because of it's core design (hero power, self-damage, and now lifesteal).   I think this is a clear indication the class needs to be reworked from the ground up, similar to how Priest was.  I know we are coming up on another core rotation next year so maybe that will help tone down the class.  But I have to agree.  Warlock has TOO much lifesteal/life gain.  It has TOO much card draw.  

  • Celestalon Shares the Hearthstone Team's Thoughts on Drek'Thar and Vanndar Stormpike as Free Golden Card Rewards

    That destroys any prestige of owning golden/diamond reward cards that cannot be crafted.

    I don't care about such things, but apparently some people do, and it seems Blizzard definitely does.

  • What is the Alterac Valley Meta going to be?

    Quote From meisterz39
    Quote From FortyDust

    It's because Warlock has too much healing. I've been saying this since Barrens.

    One of the main points of Warlock is that it uses Health as a resource. That's all well and good, and makes for interesting decisions ... until you give the class so much healing that there are no more decisions. Just go ahead and spend that Health willy-nilly in full confidence that you'll have no trouble getting it back.

    When you're trying to draw through your entire deck, life tapping and cards like Backfire are not the least bit scary because you are guaranteed to get 12 points of healing from quilboars and two 1-mana 6/6 taunts, not to mention all the lifesteal removal you'll draw along the way, some of which may be doubled by Tamsin.

    Warlock may not technically have more healing than Priest, but it definitely has far more efficient healing, and a lot of it.

    The problems go hand-in-hand, but I do think the latest "OwlTK" Warlock decks shows that card draw is the biggest issue. It's true that decks that care about self-harm (i.e. Questline Handlock) use Barrens Scavenger and Blood Shard Bristleback to recover, but they're only enabled by drawing your whole deck really fast. Meanwhile the "OwlTK" Warlock doesn't use either of those cards to stabalize, instead getting by with cheap AOE like Grimoire of Sacrifice along with extra card draw like Bloodmage Thalnos and the Tour Guide/Manafeeder Panthara combo.

    I see what you're saying, but accelerated card draw is supposed to be part of the Warlock class identity. It wouldn't make sense to take that away from them. Healing, on the other hand, should be present but minimal.

    OwlTK does make use of the worst offender, Touch of the Nathrezim, along with Drain Soul, exacerbated by Mo'arg Artificer and Tamsin Roame (in a pinch). So the amount of healing generated by even OwlTK is way too much.

  • 3 Off Meta Decks To Beat Kenin

    Yeah bro for sure. Vengeance is probably the cut, doesn't have a lot of great targets these days.

  • Last Call for Hearthstone Battleground's Pirate-themed Shop Skins - Buccaneer's Booty Leaves Soon!

    I’m totally with you there. And yes, spending a little money to support your favorite game is nowhere a crime. And I have no problem with the fact that you inform people about deals, that’s actually pretty helpful. My problem is the fomo created by remembering everyone that this will leave soon. That’s exactly what blizzard wants and what I and a lot of other people are not okay with. 
    My statement was not meant to be rude against you or the website itself. I always appreciated your efforts since the hearthpwn era and will continue so in the future 

  • 3 Off Meta Decks To Beat Kenin

    Only 1 The Box in slay control?

    Given the frequency of turn 4 wayfinders i would run at least 2 copies to always "welcome" our Kennens

  • Last Call for Hearthstone Battleground's Pirate-themed Shop Skins - Buccaneer's Booty Leaves Soon!

    Staff Pro

    Yeah I'm very curious if we'll ever get to that point. Probably when there's a crazy number of skins for each of the heroes.

    Battlegrounds being monetized purely off cosmetics does put them in a bit of a weird spot to continue supporting the mode if they just give stuff out for "free".

  • Last Call for Hearthstone Battleground's Pirate-themed Shop Skins - Buccaneer's Booty Leaves Soon!

    Staff Pro

    If we were going to take a position and not post about deals because of the stuff going on with Blizzard's higher-ups, then we would just stop posting about Hearthstone completely. Though at our core we're a community site, news is a big part of that and we like to keep people informed. If we're going to not post about deals in the shop then maybe we shouldn't post about decks that use lots of the new cards either because we're just trying to push it into people's minds that they need to buy the cards to be successful.

    What's going on at Blizzard is disgusting on so many levels and I personally believe that Kotick should be removed from his position at the head of the company. But Kotick and other higher-ups aren't the only people at the company. In fact, if things don't change and all the Blizzard products stopped being profitable, I believe there is a decent chance hiring would stop and they might start letting some people go. You can still support the people that work on the games you love while thinking that the people at the top there are a bunch of assholes. Though its not like buying stuff is like a charity handout either, you are getting something in return. If you like or want something and you can afford it, buy it.

    The politics at the company will eventually sort themselves out and if anyone doesn't think so, I recommend they stop playing the games completely because everything Blizzard releases is a live service product so if the company shuts down, any money or time invested into the games goes away. Not to say that time investment is completely wasted though as long as you were having fun.

    And I agree, everyone is welcome to make their own opinions. Mine is that we're treating everything as business as usual because I'm not trying to create a cesspool - quite the opposite. We'll report on the biggest of the news items at Blizzard because I believe everyone should know what is happening, but we're not going to report on every single detail because at the end of the day, its mentally draining and there's days where our entire front page or Hearthstone portal would be nothing but "what did Blizzard management mess up today".

  • 3 Off Meta Decks To Beat Kenin

    Yeah so you're getting stunned, you're getting comboed out, and burst down and you can't do anything. I know it's frustrating, the meta decks just aren't cutting it right now, and you dont want to play the mirror.

    Well boys I've got you covered here are 3 deck concepts that all do well into Kenin, you could call them control lists but they play like midrange.

    1. Just challenge everything

    Drag that little ****** with laurent protégé or bird as soon as he comes down, and then drag everything else over and over until you get the concede. Keep your singles and sharpsights for reactive plays.

    2. Nami TF control

    Pings all day long, and lots of attune and draw to keep things flexible. Probably the only "infinite" cycling deck I enjoy because there is some skill involved.

    Tf Nami Control
    A Runeterra Deck created by Nifty129. Last updated 4 years, 11 months ago
    -1

    3. Slay Control

    Vulnerable is almost as good as challenger, and we have things like vile feast and other sweepers to keep the party rolling. Has the addeded benefit of playing well into other midrange decks.

    So yeah if you don't like these lists just build your own, remembering that if you can't out control the combo deck you have to out aggro them consistently so that limits your deck building option to low curve threats like pirate aggro etc. and most people already know those lists so here are the more interesting options.

    ---Bonus--- 

    Swain decks are always strong in combo situations because youre essentially putting them on a clock to go off and they don't run a ton of non self bounces sometimes none. So yeah thats basically all the regions so you can counter Kenen with pretty much anything you want to greater or lesser effect as long as its built right.

  • Recent change to video ads?

    Good call 👍🏻

    I wanted to create a similar thread, but the topic starter beat me to it. I visit OoC quite often daily and I understand ads are a big part of income for keeping the site up and running. That is why I hesitated at first when I also experienced the same annoying video ads issue and now the issue is already addressed. Kudos!

  • Every meta. Why?

    Quote From meisterz39

    I opened Shadowcrafter Scabbs and Cera'thine Fleetrunner on the first day of the expansion, and was really excited to try out Burgle Rogue too. And it's certainly a cool deck that does some powerful stuff. The early tempo you can get from Double Agent and Wildpaw Gnoll thanks to how they interact with Maestra of the Masquerade is awesome, and Contraband Stash is a great payoff card that benefits from smart playing (e.g. by picking spells from Wand Thief that will always target enemies, picking high-value deathrattles from Reconnaissance, or maybe holding back a bit when playing Shadowjeweler Hanar to avoid losing out on the tempo value you might otherwise get from the Contraband Stash).

    It's a sweet deck, and when it goes off it's incredibly fun. I played a game where, between Reconnaissance and Contraband Stash, I generated a full board of Greyboughs and become untouchable. A part of me feels the same way you do about wanting to see it be more competitive so that I can win more and enjoy these sweet moments.

    The reality, though, is that cards and archetypes are intentionally not created equal. These articles by Mark Rosewater back in 2009 speak to how MTG goes about designing for different players. Together I think they paint a good picture of how cards and archetypes will naturally vary in strength because they're basically serving different constituencies. As I see it, Burgle Rogue is likely always going to occupy some Timmy/Johnny design space, and probably won't be terribly competitive. That's not to say that every individual player can't find success with it (e.g. Rogue has some nice disruption tools that can really mess with OwlTK Warlock), but it's naturally going to be weaker because it's built to serve a set of players who care more than the average player about the "how" of winning.

    To the broader point about issues with the metagame, I think you're right that it's in an unhealthy place right now. You need only tune in to one of Kibler's streams to see a player who is famous for winning with "Timmy decks" frustrated at every turn by the efficiency of the top tier decks.

    The efficiency of top tier decks continually seems to be born from "overwhelming" turns, usually due to some form of mana cheating.  I think the most restrictive thing is that the hearthstone team constantly seems to turn to mana cheating as their "wow this card is so cool" as some sort of design crutch instead of creating other interesting mechanics or ways to interact on the board.

    I've read the MTG articles before, and while I understand the premise, I also think it's highly outdated.  Why can't fun and competitive be the same thing? (yes I know that "fun" is subjective but the underlying point still stands)

    Timmy will play card "A" if its a powerful and aesthetic card,  Johnny will play card "A" if it's a way to get a complicated flashy win, Spike will play card "A" only if it improves the efficacy of his deck and makes him win % more games.

    Those are the fundamental (in a nutshell) differences between the players.  If we want to give them "real names".  Why does Timmy's control deck seem to never have the tools necessary to allow him a chance at reaching end game?  Why does Spike's aggro/otk deck always seem to have a plethora of ways to easily win?  People are fine with everyone having different playstyles.  What they aren't fine with is more tools being available to the Spike players.  Control players holistically have to "survive" an onslaught of cards and hope that they luck out.  Meanwhile aggro players (and in this meta OTK decks) simply just draw their their deck spamming minions, or tutors, until they get their win condition. 

    It's a disparity in the way that cards are designed that fundamentally means that control players are always left feeling like they are on the back foot.  Never being able to do anything except clear/taunt/survive until something hopefully breaks their way.

    And to be honest, it's a problem with the way HS was designed.  Other games such as MTG and even LoR have far better systems designed to allow control opponents flexibility.  LoR allows control players to bank mana to use on later turns as "spell mana" which lets them access more expensive spells to summon stronger units or stronger board clears naturally because the aggro player isn't going to bank mana, they are going to spend their mana summoning a bunch of smaller units.  The only way HS allows this is through mana cheating.  Except mana cheating is universal.  It can be used by any archetype (see Incanters flow)

    What HS needs is either way more restrictive deck building decisions (similar to vandar or drek actually) that force players to build their decks in specific ways if they want some sort of bonus.  Or they need to fundamentally change how the game works (which let's be honest, will probably never happen).

    I'll also point out that with so much card draw, player hand management/resource management is next to nothing.  If card draw wasn't so universally available or at least as "easily" available to use without restrictions, you'd see more careful play and more mid-range decks pop up.  

    If I personally had to boil down the two biggest issues in Hearthstone it would be "too much card draw" and "too much easy/non-restrictive mana cheating".

  • Quest Rogue

    very strong deck, i will probably catch legend with it!

  • Mozaki Mage

    nice

  • Buff Paladin

    nice deck bro

  • Every meta. Why?

    I'm going to add to what @anchom4n said by pointing out you recently opted to make a troll post when prompted to give a genuine answer to the thread in question (about people's favourite Merc character). I know nothing about you personally, but knowing that you are more than happy to make troll posts hardly makes me want to take what you say seriously.  

    If you are genuinely annoyed with how people respond to your comments, then you have been shooting yourself in the foot for a while and would benefit from taking a more genuine and respectful tone in future. You reap what you sow, so to speak.

    If you don't actually care then fine, I guess. That's my baseline assumption anyway.

    --------------------

    FWIW, as a burgle rogue main, I actually think it has been the most consistently well-balanced archetypes in the game. It has never been prominent in the meta, but it is the sort of deck that we don't really want to be either lest things devolve into completely unpredictable RNG fiestas. They make some popular Tavern Brawls, but not constructed metas.

    Ultimately, burgle rogue is a meme deck that manages to retain a following pretty much regardless of what the Wild and Standard metas are doing, and generally does so without inviting calls for nerfs or buffs. That's a lot more than most archetypes can claim, and makes it one of the most successful archetypes they have ever designed.

  • Alterac Valley Achievements

    Quote From Ataturk

    with this deck you will do it the rogue one in 2 games also counts for the Spammy Arcanist one

     

    AAEBAd75AwLZ4wKljQQOzQO9BPW7At/jAvDmAsfOA+LdA+fdA6vrA/7uA6H0A5GfBPefBPylBAA=

    Add Knife Juggler and Deathspeaker and *Puff* hilarious OTK deck.

  • Last Call for Hearthstone Battleground's Pirate-themed Shop Skins - Buccaneer's Booty Leaves Soon!

    I mean it’s kind of you to say us that they will leave but with posts like this you only increase the Fomo in peoples minds. Blizzards price politics shouldn’t be advertised right now. But that’s just my opinion. Everyone else can feel free to have a different one

  • Every meta. Why?

    Pro

    You're very obviously perfectly free to do and say what you want, but so is everyone else and with that controversial ideas to begin with and the way you express them on top of that, you really shouldn't be surprised about getting so much negative feedback.

  • Celestalon Shares the Hearthstone Team's Thoughts on Drek'Thar and Vanndar Stormpike as Free Golden Card Rewards

    The choice is between undisenchantable cosmetics or nothing - they're not going to suddenly drop a big increase in the amount of dust on the Rewards Track. If they WERE going to do that, they wouldn't do it through making the Goldens dustable, because as they've said many many times they don't like incentivizing card destruction.

  • BG Skin - Arena of Champions - Is it worth it?

    As title says, has anyone here purchased the BG board skin and do you think it's worth it?  Is it neat?  Does it have interactables?  etc.  I haven't seen any videos reviewing it anywhere so wanted to see if I could get any feedback on if it makes the experience worth it or not.

    Thanks!