Well, the stealth makes the card more consistent, and if you really want the honorable kill effect, you just wait till the opponent plays a 3 health minion, or setup your trades to get the effect. It's just 2 mana cheat though, and Sneaky Scout won't be surviving long on 2 health anyway.
Quite a powerful Honorable Kill effect. This is basically a paladin only card but would allow for great value in arena for any class. I'd definitely recommend playing Corporal with a rush effect to instantly get the divine shield off. One this to also note, seeing as the honorable kill mechanic can activate it's effect multiple times, you'd need to kill this minion or risk your opponent getting another round of divine shields. Least Corporal doesn't get a shield.
You mean Zeddy who can't even read the card before evaluation and instead of HP refresh on minion attack he evaluates it as HP refresh on minion death?
On paper it looks inconsistent at best. But I'm not writing this one off until the meta settles because the pay off is so great its not impossible for this to see some play, even if its only in aggro decks. Being able to give your board divine shield is about as good as it can get.
Drop this out on 2. Your opponent will scramble to kill it or play no minions, because of this work, it'll give you such a massive advantage.
Probably never used. Not only does this require an honor kill to be relevant at all, its much more consistent predecessor, Tour Guide, is still here. And your opponent will likely play around this hard, if they think your hp is worth it.
Its only ever going to see play in either mage or hunter. Nothing else.
I assume that after one turn, whenever you thaw this it'll be able to attack immediately. But likely it wouldn't or otherwise it'll be way too strong.
Will it ever be a core meta card? Too inconsistent for it to ever be. But sometimes when it does work, your opponent will be covering his face like he's just scored an own goal.
Its a good card even with that condition. There are ways to gain armor while still playing something. You get 3 armor for each Cargo Guard, 5 from Shieldmaiden and another 5 from rokara. And you've got your trusty hp to help out too.
So this will never really be a play on curve, unless you're playing something like Frozen Buckler, but as a end game win condition, it doesn't need to be. Its like Leeroy, it'll never be played on curve but simply by being cheaper than alternatives, its immediately a go to card.
Even if its not meta now, it'll be at some point. Because being able to dish out 9 damage earlier than turn 8 is worth it.
Man, I hope Deathrattle Hunter becomes a thing. I'm so sick of the face-face-face archetypes that the class has had for almost two years now.
Mountain Bear is a good revival target for Jewel of N'Zoth and Revive Pet. But this looks like an Arena card for now, I don't see it being played as much in Standard and Wild.
This has almost always have to be a no in Arena. 6/6s for 6 are bad( maybe you can get the dream picks but not likely ). In constructed.... It's very slow but a hard maybe if the meta isn't its usual ridiculous fast or you can really hit something that saves your ass that turn..
Missing the 'Good old days' of Inner Fire priest decks, I've come to two designs to fit that style of play.
The Mythsinger is reminiscent of Questing Adventurer and would likely fill a central role in a board-centric combo deck (considering making it Holy spells only), while Reverberating Hymn pushes a more, "go wide" strategy aiming to make as many minions as possible good targets for Inner Fire or similar cards.
Interested to know thoughts on the balance of these and which is generally more interesting.
Feedback:
Show Spoiler
Wailor - Both of these look good and seem balanced. As for the 'flashiness' of the effects - these seem like good archetype support cards. I tend to appreciate that style of design, and I think Thunderbass does it best. It might be worth outlining some synergy cards you had in mind in the description.
Demonxz95 - A cool way to bring the ETC tokens back! I wonder if it could be tied to rush minions / attacks instead to thematically fit with E.T.C., God of Metal. I think this could reasonably be 2 mana as those tokens are not very strong by todays standards.
AeroJulwin - Your new pied piper may be slightly too strong as is, its basically Drek'Thar without a condition. I'd suggest making it hit 1-cost minions/Beasts as hunter has had 1-cost minion synergies in the past and it could more easily target specific beasts (like the Sunscale Raptor)
linkblade91 - I like the "Frenzy as Encore" idea. I think this is a fun and versatile card. It might be worth clarifying if these options are discovered, randomly generated or cast by the minion as the text on the card is a bit unclear.
anchorm4n - I really like this. Seems well balanced and creates an interesting twist on the murloc paladin archetype. Good stuff!
Nirast - An interesting idea. Hard to judge its balance as it would highly depend on the card pool available. I think its probably balanced, compared to Moonlit Guidance, if anything is pushing it over the line it'll be the Twinspell. As Linkblade pointed out, an infinite loop is possible, easily fixed by using the wording "Discover another spell…"
6 mana 9/9 with Charge. I don't know: I don't like those stats for that cost, and Charge is basically a Tier 3 keyword (it's certainly no Taunt). I think the powercreep of Hearthstone is such that a 9/9 on Turn 6 that can attack immediately isn't good enough. It's not like before turn 6 you can play a minion that gains you 3 Armor at the end of the turn, or a 4 mana AoE that gains you Armor, or any cheap spells that gain you, say, 10 or 8 Armor, or use a Hero Power that gains Armor. I mean, Warrior isn't really an Armor class, at the end of the day, and that's really what bothers me about this card: it forces Warrior to play completely outside its identity to gain Armor just to activate what is, in my opinion, a worse King Krush. I mean, it doesn't even have a minion tribe. What, am I supposed to play this 9/9 on turn 6 and eat my opponent's largest minion while still putting pressure on their life total? Do I just send 9 damage face? That's not even one third of their life total! Where am I getting the rest of that damage? From other minions? Why have I allowed this bit to go on for so long? Probably the only people still reading this are the ones who think that I'm being completely serious, and let's be completely honest: no one really reads these comments, do they? Everyone just scrolls immediately to the bottom of the thread so they can post their thoughts on the card and don't even take a second to look at someone else's thoughts, and those that do are mainly doing so because they want to find people that disagree with them. That's all the internet is, isn't it? Just people looking for something to disagree with. Certainly this long block of text is so uninviting that no one is going to bother to read it; it might even get marked as spam, at this point I honestly don't care. I'll even throw in a couple of random cards Dr. Boom to give this a little Recurring Villain color because there's not a chance anyone has the patience to actually read the words, they'll just think I've made a couple of card comparisons Vanndar Stormpike or synergy ideas Larry, Cashier of Women's Clothing, because no one is going to read this and there's a man in a cloak standing behind you. There's not, but you looked, didn't you? I'm exhausted.
You're really an evil genius in the making. Purposefully writing such a wonderfully long prose that I have no choice but to read it to the end. Only to get a payoff equal to what is a monty python's holy grail ending.
Did it occur to you as you're writing, or was this the genius plan all along? :)
Really bad. 5 mana, draw a card and deal 2 (3) dmg to enemies. Mostly 2 dmg, because most of Warlock's spells are shadow and fire and exisiting fel spells aren't that good, ex. Shadow Council, Fiendish Circle, The Dark Portal etc. The only small advantage it doesn't affect your board unlike Hellfire or Soul Rend. But for 5 mana you can play School Spirits and use Hero Power.
I guess that's as close as I'll ever get to predicting a Hearthstone card and seeing your reactions to Mountain Bear's flavor, I even might have done a better job :D
Its not as value oriented as the other hero cards, but this one delivers well in terms of just winning. Basically unless you've played this card your opponent will constantly be looking over his shoulder whenever he starts playing big minions because this can easily just scam a win out of nowhere. Against paladin its particularly insane, making sure that handbuff pally will never sleep well at night.
But at the end without that its still just a weapon that deals 5 damage twice, which means its technically too expensive for its value, because the hero power is simply deal 2 damage, with only occasionally gaining 4 armor. But honestly, it'll never realistically gain much in armor because you'd much rather hit face with hp anyway.
Gaining 5 armor also puts you that close to Captain Galvangar, which is a massive plus.
So we've waited long for a deathrattle card in rogue to be introduced so the earlier deathrattle support aren't completely shit. And we duly got rewarded by a card that basically fits any and all roles as a deathrattle target.
The only way this card backfires spectacularly is if you get offered up the pre-prime cards like Lady Vashj for example, which doesn't really do much tempo wise. On the other hand you can easily highroll Najak Hexxen and just have a 4 mana Mind Control in a class with Shadowstep.
In Arena this is one of those very fun gambling cards you can add to your deck. No one alive can blame you for picking it because it can easily pay off well.
3 mana deal 3 summon a (hopefully) good 3/3 is superb. Just be ready that this just ain't gonna happen a lotta times. I'll still draft it cuz it's fast and fun!
Good arena card. But is so mundane that its practically combo filler in ranked. I cannot for the life of me understand why'd anyone would want to play this unironically in a standard ranked deck, because we're coming close to the point where even a 4/5 on 3 is no longer good enough, and this one needs to be combo-ed out to even start dreaming of being viable.
Oh well, filler is filler. There's no much else to say
If this unconditionally gets a copy, then its great. But unfortunately, it needs to honor kill for 2 in order to trigger, which drastically reduces its consistency.
The irony is that this will likely consistently work against most decks that play for tempo, which would probably give you a card you won't be using, only rarely will this ever turn out to be a winner.
The genius level play is to play out Spy-o-matic, honor kill something and simulate a discover a card from your opponent's topdecks. But that's stretching it so far I wouldn't think that's a winning play.
How does it work with Professor Slate? Not sure how Honorable Kill and Poisounous interact with each other. Poisoning someone doesn’t seem very honorable but maybe it still activates?
New Neutral Minion - Sneaky Scout
Well, the stealth makes the card more consistent, and if you really want the honorable kill effect, you just wait till the opponent plays a 3 health minion, or setup your trades to get the effect. It's just 2 mana cheat though, and Sneaky Scout won't be surviving long on 2 health anyway.
New Neutral Minion - Corporal
Quite a powerful Honorable Kill effect. This is basically a paladin only card but would allow for great value in arena for any class. I'd definitely recommend playing Corporal with a rush effect to instantly get the divine shield off. One this to also note, seeing as the honorable kill mechanic can activate it's effect multiple times, you'd need to kill this minion or risk your opponent getting another round of divine shields. Least Corporal doesn't get a shield.
Kurtrus, Demon-Render is a New Legendary Demon Hunter Hearthstone Card Revealed by Blizzard for Fractured in Alterac Valley
You mean Zeddy who can't even read the card before evaluation and instead of HP refresh on minion attack he evaluates it as HP refresh on minion death?
Fractured in Alterac Valley
We got our tavern crawl! https://outof.cards/hearthstone/expansions/fractured-in-alterac-valley/tavern-crawl-and-giveaway/
New Neutral Minion - Corporal
On paper it looks inconsistent at best. But I'm not writing this one off until the meta settles because the pay off is so great its not impossible for this to see some play, even if its only in aggro decks. Being able to give your board divine shield is about as good as it can get.
Drop this out on 2. Your opponent will scramble to kill it or play no minions, because of this work, it'll give you such a massive advantage.
New Neutral Minion - Sneaky Scout
Probably never used. Not only does this require an honor kill to be relevant at all, its much more consistent predecessor, Tour Guide, is still here. And your opponent will likely play around this hard, if they think your hp is worth it.
New Neutral Minion - Frozen Mammoth
Its only ever going to see play in either mage or hunter. Nothing else.
I assume that after one turn, whenever you thaw this it'll be able to attack immediately. But likely it wouldn't or otherwise it'll be way too strong.
Will it ever be a core meta card? Too inconsistent for it to ever be. But sometimes when it does work, your opponent will be covering his face like he's just scored an own goal.
New Warrior Minion - Scrapsmith
Straight from blizz. A small image mismatch. Just wanted to preserve this for later when they eventually reuse this portrait.
But the card? Yeah its good. If Bumper Car sees play, why wouldn't this?
Kurtrus, Demon-Render is a New Legendary Demon Hunter Hearthstone Card Revealed by Blizzard for Fractured in Alterac Valley
Can't wait for the eventual patch that nerfs Felfire Deadeye to read "Your Hero Power costs (1) less, but no less than (1)".
New Warrior Minion - Captain Galvangar
Its a good card even with that condition. There are ways to gain armor while still playing something. You get 3 armor for each Cargo Guard, 5 from Shieldmaiden and another 5 from rokara. And you've got your trusty hp to help out too.
So this will never really be a play on curve, unless you're playing something like Frozen Buckler, but as a end game win condition, it doesn't need to be. Its like Leeroy, it'll never be played on curve but simply by being cheaper than alternatives, its immediately a go to card.
Even if its not meta now, it'll be at some point. Because being able to dish out 9 damage earlier than turn 8 is worth it.
New Hunter Minion - Mountain Bear
Man, I hope Deathrattle Hunter becomes a thing. I'm so sick of the face-face-face archetypes that the class has had for almost two years now.
Mountain Bear is a good revival target for Jewel of N'Zoth and Revive Pet. But this looks like an Arena card for now, I don't see it being played as much in Standard and Wild.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Caria Felsoul
This has almost always have to be a no in Arena. 6/6s for 6 are bad( maybe you can get the dream picks but not likely ). In constructed.... It's very slow but a hard maybe if the meta isn't its usual ridiculous fast or you can really hit something that saves your ass that turn..
Battle Of The Bards - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Hey Everyone!,
Missing the 'Good old days' of Inner Fire priest decks, I've come to two designs to fit that style of play.
The Mythsinger is reminiscent of Questing Adventurer and would likely fill a central role in a board-centric combo deck (considering making it Holy spells only), while Reverberating Hymn pushes a more, "go wide" strategy aiming to make as many minions as possible good targets for Inner Fire or similar cards.
Interested to know thoughts on the balance of these and which is generally more interesting.
Feedback:
Wailor - Both of these look good and seem balanced. As for the 'flashiness' of the effects - these seem like good archetype support cards. I tend to appreciate that style of design, and I think Thunderbass does it best. It might be worth outlining some synergy cards you had in mind in the description.
Demonxz95 - A cool way to bring the ETC tokens back! I wonder if it could be tied to rush minions / attacks instead to thematically fit with E.T.C., God of Metal. I think this could reasonably be 2 mana as those tokens are not very strong by todays standards.
AeroJulwin - Your new pied piper may be slightly too strong as is, its basically Drek'Thar without a condition. I'd suggest making it hit 1-cost minions/Beasts as hunter has had 1-cost minion synergies in the past and it could more easily target specific beasts (like the Sunscale Raptor)
linkblade91 - I like the "Frenzy as Encore" idea. I think this is a fun and versatile card. It might be worth clarifying if these options are discovered, randomly generated or cast by the minion as the text on the card is a bit unclear.
anchorm4n - I really like this. Seems well balanced and creates an interesting twist on the murloc paladin archetype. Good stuff!
Nirast - An interesting idea. Hard to judge its balance as it would highly depend on the card pool available. I think its probably balanced, compared to Moonlit Guidance, if anything is pushing it over the line it'll be the Twinspell. As Linkblade pointed out, an infinite loop is possible, easily fixed by using the wording "Discover another spell…"
New Warrior Minion - Captain Galvangar
You're really an evil genius in the making. Purposefully writing such a wonderfully long prose that I have no choice but to read it to the end. Only to get a payoff equal to what is a monty python's holy grail ending.
Did it occur to you as you're writing, or was this the genius plan all along? :)
Felfire in the Hole! is a New Warlock Hearthstone Card Revealed by 驴鸽 for Fractured in Alterac Valley
Really bad. 5 mana, draw a card and deal 2 (3) dmg to enemies. Mostly 2 dmg, because most of Warlock's spells are shadow and fire and exisiting fel spells aren't that good, ex. Shadow Council, Fiendish Circle, The Dark Portal etc. The only small advantage it doesn't affect your board unlike Hellfire or Soul Rend. But for 5 mana you can play School Spirits and use Hero Power.
New Hunter Minion - Mountain Bear
I guess that's as close as I'll ever get to predicting a Hearthstone card and seeing your reactions to Mountain Bear's flavor, I even might have done a better job :D
(won Weekly Card Design Competition 3.07 with this)
New Warrior Hero - Rokara, the Valorous
Its not as value oriented as the other hero cards, but this one delivers well in terms of just winning. Basically unless you've played this card your opponent will constantly be looking over his shoulder whenever he starts playing big minions because this can easily just scam a win out of nowhere. Against paladin its particularly insane, making sure that handbuff pally will never sleep well at night.
But at the end without that its still just a weapon that deals 5 damage twice, which means its technically too expensive for its value, because the hero power is simply deal 2 damage, with only occasionally gaining 4 armor. But honestly, it'll never realistically gain much in armor because you'd much rather hit face with hp anyway.
Gaining 5 armor also puts you that close to Captain Galvangar, which is a massive plus.
Fractured in Alterac Valley
There is a date for the final reveal?
New Rogue Spell - Reconnaissance
So we've waited long for a deathrattle card in rogue to be introduced so the earlier deathrattle support aren't completely shit. And we duly got rewarded by a card that basically fits any and all roles as a deathrattle target.
The only way this card backfires spectacularly is if you get offered up the pre-prime cards like Lady Vashj for example, which doesn't really do much tempo wise. On the other hand you can easily highroll Najak Hexxen and just have a 4 mana Mind Control in a class with Shadowstep.
This is just what deathrattle rogue needs.
New Priest Spell - Deliverance
In Arena this is one of those very fun gambling cards you can add to your deck. No one alive can blame you for picking it because it can easily pay off well.
3 mana deal 3 summon a (hopefully) good 3/3 is superb. Just be ready that this just ain't gonna happen a lotta times. I'll still draft it cuz it's fast and fun!
Felfire in the Hole! is a New Warlock Hearthstone Card Revealed by 驴鸽 for Fractured in Alterac Valley
Keep in mind that the Rifts from Dreadlich Tamsin are also Fel spells.
New Rogue Minion - Coldtooth Yeti
Um yea no. .. even in Arena.
We don't like dependency!!!!!!
New Rogue Minion - Coldtooth Yeti
Good arena card. But is so mundane that its practically combo filler in ranked. I cannot for the life of me understand why'd anyone would want to play this unironically in a standard ranked deck, because we're coming close to the point where even a 4/5 on 3 is no longer good enough, and this one needs to be combo-ed out to even start dreaming of being viable.
Oh well, filler is filler. There's no much else to say
New Rogue Weapon - The Lobotomizer
If this unconditionally gets a copy, then its great. But unfortunately, it needs to honor kill for 2 in order to trigger, which drastically reduces its consistency.
The irony is that this will likely consistently work against most decks that play for tempo, which would probably give you a card you won't be using, only rarely will this ever turn out to be a winner.
The genius level play is to play out Spy-o-matic, honor kill something and simulate a discover a card from your opponent's topdecks. But that's stretching it so far I wouldn't think that's a winning play.
Spring the Trap
How does it work with Professor Slate? Not sure how Honorable Kill and Poisounous interact with each other. Poisoning someone doesn’t seem very honorable but maybe it still activates?