All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Expensive Tastes - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    Congratulations to Jhamel!

  • New Warrior Minion - Captain Galvangar

    Pro

    6 mana 9/9 with Charge. I don't know: I don't like those stats for that cost, and Charge is basically a Tier 3 keyword (it's certainly no Taunt). I think the powercreep of Hearthstone is such that a 9/9 on Turn 6 that can attack immediately isn't good enough. It's not like before turn 6 you can play a minion that gains you 3 Armor at the end of the turn, or a 4 mana AoE that gains you Armor, or any cheap spells that gain you, say, 10 or 8 Armor, or use a Hero Power that gains Armor. I mean, Warrior isn't really an Armor class, at the end of the day, and that's really what bothers me about this card: it forces Warrior to play completely outside its identity to gain Armor just to activate what is, in my opinion, a worse King Krush. I mean, it doesn't even have a minion tribe. What, am I supposed to play this 9/9 on turn 6 and eat my opponent's largest minion while still putting pressure on their life total? Do I just send 9 damage face? That's not even one third of their life total! Where am I getting the rest of that damage? From other minions? Why have I allowed this bit to go on for so long? Probably the only people still reading this are the ones who think that I'm being completely serious, and let's be completely honest: no one really reads these comments, do they? Everyone just scrolls immediately to the bottom of the thread so they can post their thoughts on the card and don't even take a second to look at someone else's thoughts, and those that do are mainly doing so because they want to find people that disagree with them. That's all the internet is, isn't it? Just people looking for something to disagree with. Certainly this long block of text is so uninviting that no one is going to bother to read it; it might even get marked as spam, at this point I honestly don't care. I'll even throw in a couple of random cards Dr. Boom to give this a little Recurring Villain color because there's not a chance anyone has the patience to actually read the words, they'll just think I've made a couple of card comparisons Vanndar Stormpike or synergy ideas Larry, Cashier of Women's Clothing, because no one is going to read this and there's a man in a cloak standing behind you. There's not, but you looked, didn't you? I'm exhausted.

  • Blizzard Changes Hearthstone's Alterac Valley Card Reveal Season Plans, No Final Stream, More Creators Being Given Reveals

    We still have 4 hero cards left to be revealed, i think that we will see more strong cards

  • Blizzard Changes Hearthstone's Alterac Valley Card Reveal Season Plans, No Final Stream, More Creators Being Given Reveals

    Staff Pro

    I'm going to assume whatever dumps on Nov 24 will be the "pack filler" and the cool cards we'd normally see during a stream, like a few remaining legendaries and epics, will end up in creator hands.

    The only question I still have is when do the reveals start. Not likely to be the weekend because Blizzard has mostly stopped doing weekend reveals (bless) and Thursday+Friday is probably out of the equation due to American Thanksgiving at the Hearthstone team being on vacation for the week. So, early Monday is possible.

  • Blizzard Changes Hearthstone's Alterac Valley Card Reveal Season Plans, No Final Stream, More Creators Being Given Reveals

    Marks card reveal had better be a Snow Ogre with good stats or I will personally riot.

  • Sigil of Reckoning is a New Demon Hunter Card Revealed by Orange for Fractured in Alterac Valley

    Amazing Big Demon card. This is Skull of the Man'ari that only lasts 1 turn, but can't be destroyed. Demon Hunters also have significantly better Big Demons than Warlock. 

  • Blizzard Changes Hearthstone's Alterac Valley Card Reveal Season Plans, No Final Stream, More Creators Being Given Reveals

    Hmm... So we have some meme/combo cards leftover?

  • New Mage Spell - Iceblood Tower

    Pro

    Although it costs 10, I'm counting this as more Big Spell support and not a Big Spell in itself (mainly because it doesn't do anything on its own). My initial thought is that this goes into C'Thun Mage, since it can pull out as many as three of the pieces of C'Thun over the course of three turns. Could be a nice combo with Clumsy Courier or Balinda Stonehearth to be played quickly and actually start working towards C'Thun. I say they could be a nice combo, but I legitimately don't see this in a deck that doesn't run either of those minions, it's too expensive otherwise.

  • Scholomance's Transfer Student Gets an Upgrade in Alterac Valley With the New Honorable Kill Keyword

    Nah unfortunately starting next year it will be just "get Random card from Expansion X"

  • New Mage Minion - Balinda Stonehearth

    Pro

    Big Spell support, and it's pretty good. I feel like there still aren't enough Big Spells in Standard to make a really good deck (in fact, it feels like there are more cards that care about Big Spells than there are Big Spells), but drawing two spells is a good deal especially if you're only running Big'uns (for to make her stats bigger). I assume if she draws double Hot Streak she dies?

  • New Warrior Minion - Captain Galvangar

    Seems good, 15 armor isn't terribly hard to get in a game. The problem is this is if a 9/9 with Charge that requires a setup will be worth playing, or if it can spawn a deck that overtakes Pirates.

  • New Mage Spell - Iceblood Tower

    Depends if this casts with random targets (I assume) or only targets enemies. Could be really good to auto cast some big spells, but not being able to target what you want means this can also waste good spells in your deck.

  • New Rogue Weapon - The Lobotomizer

    Pro

    I mean, it's a 2 mana 2/2 weapon that sometimes could draw you a card (albeit one that you didn't put in your deck). Good for Thief Rogue, and you don't necessarily need to hit minions with exactly 2 Health because of things like Deadly Poison. I don't think you runs this card in anything other than Thief Rogue.

  • Solving The Meta Again - Landmark Nasus

    The thing that makes me sceptical if nifty is the flawless LoR that he pretends to be is that his decks hardly every play 2/1 ofs.

    In aggro decks where synergy matters a lot less than raw card quality it often makes sense to build decks in that way but in control / combo decks that is most of the times not the right thing to do.

    Anyway: I absolutely agree with your  idea: we can't know how good eachother's deck is as long as we don't play against eachother.

    And I totaly would be into this if I currently had a deck ready for pvp.

    So sure gimme a week to find my cool niche in the meta and I will challenge whoever is into duels :)

     

     

  • Sigil of Reckoning is a New Demon Hunter Card Revealed by Orange for Fractured in Alterac Valley

    I see what you mean, as it isn't a very proactive turn to spend, but one could coin-out on T4, making this effective by the early T5

  • New Demon Hunter Spell - Sigil of Reckoning

    Cheating those Big Demons as early as T5-T6, this makes me happy

  • Wronchi Reveals Three New Cards for Fractured in Alterac Valley

    WTF that Warrior legendary is broken af. Someone at HS team really likes aggressive Warrior decks..

  • Sigil of Reckoning is a New Demon Hunter Card Revealed by Orange for Fractured in Alterac Valley

    Powerful as this seems, it's still a do-nothing turn 5, which is a bit precarious. In fact, you may easily be forced to put off casting it against aggro, and if you put it off too long, its value starts to plummet.

  • New Mage Minion - Balinda Stonehearth

    OK, I'm ready to see the new big spells now. Tower doesn't count.

  • Battle Of The Bards - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread


    Competition Theme: Battle Of The Bards

    We want you to feel the groove this week, so get into a good rhythm when creating!

    • You must create a card themed around Music
      • We're looking for musical references in the art or name - if you can squeeze one into the effect that's a bonus!

    Fittingly, this weeks theme comes to us from MrRhapsody - make sure you create something worthy of the name!

    As always, I can be reached through Discord or here on the site via PM if you have any issues to report.


    Competition Phases

    Here are the phases of this card design competition

    • Submission Phase: Starts on Mon, Nov 22 17:00 EST (GMT -0500). Runs until Sat, Nov 27 17:00 EST (GMT -0500)
    • Voting Phase: Starts on Sat, Nov 27 17:00 EST (GMT -0500). Runs until Sun, Nov 28 16:00 EST (GMT -0500)
    • Finalist Phase: Starts on Sun, Nov 28 17:00 EST (GMT -0500). Runs until Mon, Nov 29 17:00 EST (GMT -0500)
    • Winner Selected: After finalist voting concludes and we validate votes.

    Discussion Thread Rules

    No thread rules were added to this season. Please populate and manually edit this thread with them.

  • New Warrior Minion - Captain Galvangar

    you probably run both TBH

  • The Lobotomizer is a New Rogue Card Revealed by Blizzard for Fractured in Alterac Valley

    I like the name-action link and it's a decent weapon in itself, especially in Arena.

  • The Lobotomizer is a New Rogue Card Revealed by Blizzard for Fractured in Alterac Valley

  • New Mage Minion - Balinda Stonehearth

    Alright for Big Spell Mage, but seems incredibly slow. This does tutor spells, but Mage already has that with Deepwater Evoker. This might fit in if the deck still has an open spot, but might not make the cut.

  • New Rogue Weapon - The Lobotomizer

    Not very good. Requires the effect to trigger to be good, but even then you don't know if the card you're getting works for you. Fun meme card in Thief Rogue at best.