Its amazing how underwhelming Edwin, Defias Kingpin looks compared to Mr. Smite, who might as well be a thinly disguised Leeroy, and will be in just about any aggro deck simply because its a 6 mana deal 6, which in standard currently is about as good as it gets. On top of this, if the juggernaunt ever spawns him for free, that's basically an instant win out of rng's bum.
Sneed is interesting. But a tad expensive, and is existing in a meta where people dont play much minions. Still, its at least an interesting take, considering the words "you choose the targets". Might be revolutionary in terms of UI for hearthstone.
Cookie is just fine. A good murloc for any occassion.
Ben Brode's vision was "lol, nerfs are dumb, let the players deal with it".
As much as the new devs get flak for their questionable decisions, at least they're actively trying to innovate and aren't afraid to make mistakes along the way.
You're missing a couple of things on Smite. First, you can roll him from the Juggernaut. That's already huge, getting a 6/4 body for free that gives everything you drop from your hand charge.
Secondly, he affects cards that get rolled from Juggernaut, so worst case scenario you get 8 charge damage on board, best case you get 11
Smite might be a nerf target, so you'd be getting your investment back. All the other legendaries are playable at the very least (and might be a lot stronger in the future). In order to get all the commons and rares you'd still have to spend a decent amount of gold on packs so it's better to buy (with gold) than to try and get it from packs (at least not unless you commit to never crafting any of the legendaries)
So first of all: Tech has evolved. This proves that multi-target is now a possibility without RNG which opens up a lot of design space (I smell a future keyword).
Second: This is actually good. Slow, but good. This is a fantastic Control board swing that allows you to deal with a lot of board states without having to rely on RNG, which is massive. Sure, control might have a hard time at the moment, but that could always be subject to change (and will change by next year)
Competes with Kazakus, which makes it really questionable as of now (might change if Rogue keeps getting good 4-drops). Consistency is also an issue, since you probably can't build your deck to guarantee this effect proccing multiple times.
That being said, a self-containted Auctioneer that comes with fat stacks if you get the train rolling is nothing to be laughed at. Hell, in certain matchups you can probably get away with Shadowstepping him on turn 4 and then popping off on the next one.
I really like that this clearly isn't meant to be some degenerate combo tool but just a classic mid-game powerplay. I could see him in Quest Rogue if the deck was able to run a lower curve (which would require more SI:7 cards). I feel like he'd be really sick with Scabbs if you can somehow set it up.
If he didn't give himself charge he would be a worse Tundra Rhino (a notoriously awful card despite a technically insane effect).
The only problem (if there even is one) is that his stats are too big, specifically his attack. That being said, if he does become a problem they'll probably just shave 2-3 attack off him and he'll be fine. 6-mana is no joke, especially when games can end on turn 7.
Who thought that printing Leeroy Jenkins and Tundra Rhino in 1 as a 6 cost minion was okay?!? Also this directly contradicts blizzards "Moving away from Charge" thing they did by rotating all the charge cards during the previous rotation.
Lets look at what decks can abuse him in standard:
Oh and in wild every aggro deck will use him, but most importantly Pirate warrior will probably become a rank S+ deck. And of course Handbuff paladin will also use him i bet. The one thing we can be thankfull of, is that Mr. Smite is EVEN costed, so ODD decks such as ODD DH and ODD Paladin can't use him. (Which is probably the only reason Leeroy Jenkins might still see play.)
Honestly why did they decide to print a card that turns Pirate warrior, which is a tier 1 deck in both standard and wild into a tier S deck instead of supporting archetypes that need help? Do they REALLY want everyone to stop playing HS and play Mercenaries or BGs instead THAT badly?
The only "good" thing about Mr. Smite is that the board is finally going to matter... somewhat. So uh.. when are they raising your health from 30 to like 40? Cuz i feel like thats going to be important if the powercreep keeps going up like this.
Blizzard: "Let's get rid of charge and replace it with rush. Charge is such a hard mechanic to balance and creates uninteractive mechanics"
Also Blizzard: "jUsT kIdDinG! wE bRoUgHt BaCk ChArGe!"
I actually disagree. At some point in the past they made a lot of very questionable decisions of "this is not happening" which have lead to...confusing balancing choices.
Remember when they said Shadow Priest wouldn't be a thing because they couldn't figure out how to make damage in Priest work without enabling OTKs? Well, if they hadn't gone back on that we wouldn't have Shadow Priest now, which is arguably the most interesting direction the class has gone in. The game evolves and stuff that was busted 2 years ago might barely be relevant nowadays. I see no problem in occasionally testing the waters and just throwing out crazy shit like this. Sure, it might backfire and be horribly overpowered, but at this point they nerf stuff within a week so I don't see the issue. As much as powercreep is frustrating to experience, I'd still prefer it over total stagnation or a constant stream of unplayably weak gimmick archetypes.
Looks massively overrated outside of the fact that it has Charge itself (which is most likely the first thing they'll nerf, if it does turn out OP). In an aggro deck this is at best a minor Leeroy replacement (arguably worse because +1 mana which is very relevant). Honestly, a lot of problems in the current meta stem from the fact that direct damage is surprisingly hard to come by if you have to build your deck around minions,, which is part of the reason why the degenerate OTK decks are allowed to get away with all their shit. I'm actually interested in what a more late-game bursty minion meta would look like.
Not to mention that minion aggro making a bigger return (as opposed to just burn damage) could actually enable dedicated control decks to return, since the only reason those aren't around is because the playerbase insists that Quest Mage is a viable deck despite statistics proving the opposite.
The only problem with this is how bonkers it is off of The Juggernaut. It evokes flashbacks of Dr. Boom randomly discovering the perfect hero power every turn.
If only Captain Hooktusk wwas around to see it. Could have been glorious...and really broken.
So, uh...we're just printing stat sticks for Shaman now? Sure, I'll play it, but it seems excessively boring. Also it has anti synergy with all the currently used weapons. Wouldn't want to override a Doomhammer.
Probably better after next year's rotation when Cagematch Custodian goes away.
Maybe there's some weird heal Shaman coming in the future and we just don't understand the significance of this yet.
If Mr. Smite didn't give himself Charge, he wouldn't be a big deal. You would need a lot more mana to get any benefit from the aura. But he does have Charge which makes him a viable finisher with an upside. I'm not particularly impressed by any of the other cards. The Murloc is okay. It can provide a bit of healing for a Murloc deck but it isn't all that special. The mech is okay for removing stuff and leaving a big body behind but doesn't look like the kind of card that is going to have any impact on the meta. And the new Edwin seems interesting for a miracle style deck with a lot of cheap cards but he doesn't look as capable of winning games early as old Edwin. This miniset doesn't look interesting or strong enough to put a stop to the dominance of Quest decks so i don't really see anything changing (other than Quest Warrior becoming a much bigger player).
Legends of Runeterra Will Participate in the Upcoming Riot x Arcane Event - Free Stuff & Jayce Coming!
There are additional information on Riot website.
New Neutral Minion - Mr. Smite
This guy may be the reason I craft Hooktusk! LtEddy is going to have to get back to some Even Pirate Rogue for a future “Mishaps” episode!
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
I was referring more to the design side of things and less on the balance side of things...
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
Its amazing how underwhelming Edwin, Defias Kingpin looks compared to Mr. Smite, who might as well be a thinly disguised Leeroy, and will be in just about any aggro deck simply because its a 6 mana deal 6, which in standard currently is about as good as it gets. On top of this, if the juggernaunt ever spawns him for free, that's basically an instant win out of rng's bum.
Sneed is interesting. But a tad expensive, and is existing in a meta where people dont play much minions. Still, its at least an interesting take, considering the words "you choose the targets". Might be revolutionary in terms of UI for hearthstone.
Cookie is just fine. A good murloc for any occassion.
Blizzard is Finalizing Details on Hearthstone Esports in 2022, Information Coming Soon
Sounds foreboding....
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
I mean it was already good, no reason not to.
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
Ben Brode's vision was "lol, nerfs are dumb, let the players deal with it".
As much as the new devs get flak for their questionable decisions, at least they're actively trying to innovate and aren't afraid to make mistakes along the way.
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
You're missing a couple of things on Smite. First, you can roll him from the Juggernaut. That's already huge, getting a 6/4 body for free that gives everything you drop from your hand charge.
Secondly, he affects cards that get rolled from Juggernaut, so worst case scenario you get 8 charge damage on board, best case you get 11
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
Smite might be a nerf target, so you'd be getting your investment back. All the other legendaries are playable at the very least (and might be a lot stronger in the future). In order to get all the commons and rares you'd still have to spend a decent amount of gold on packs so it's better to buy (with gold) than to try and get it from packs (at least not unless you commit to never crafting any of the legendaries)
New Neutral Minion - Goliath, Sneed's Masterpiece
Weird card, the meta is too fast for a 8 mana board clear.
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
Not even the 1600 dust from Mr. Smite nerf?
New Neutral Minion - Goliath, Sneed's Masterpiece
So first of all: Tech has evolved. This proves that multi-target is now a possibility without RNG which opens up a lot of design space (I smell a future keyword).
Second: This is actually good. Slow, but good. This is a fantastic Control board swing that allows you to deal with a lot of board states without having to rely on RNG, which is massive. Sure, control might have a hard time at the moment, but that could always be subject to change (and will change by next year)
Also, sick with the Shaman Parrot.
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
Your opinion might change tho as soon as you get charged down by pirates in 8 out of 10 games.
New Rogue Minion - Edwin, Defias Kingpin
Competes with Kazakus, which makes it really questionable as of now (might change if Rogue keeps getting good 4-drops). Consistency is also an issue, since you probably can't build your deck to guarantee this effect proccing multiple times.
That being said, a self-containted Auctioneer that comes with fat stacks if you get the train rolling is nothing to be laughed at. Hell, in certain matchups you can probably get away with Shadowstepping him on turn 4 and then popping off on the next one.
I really like that this clearly isn't meant to be some degenerate combo tool but just a classic mid-game powerplay. I could see him in Quest Rogue if the deck was able to run a lower curve (which would require more SI:7 cards). I feel like he'd be really sick with Scabbs if you can somehow set it up.
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
I didn't see anything that made me want to buy the set.
New Neutral Minion - Mr. Smite
OTK Pirate Druid incoming with Celestial Alignment, mark my words!
New Shaman Minion - Cookie the Cook
6-8 heal with body+weapon is good at it's own.
Controlish shaman needs heals, and that one it's a good gift.
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
If he didn't give himself charge he would be a worse Tundra Rhino (a notoriously awful card despite a technically insane effect).
The only problem (if there even is one) is that his stats are too big, specifically his attack. That being said, if he does become a problem they'll probably just shave 2-3 attack off him and he'll be fine. 6-mana is no joke, especially when games can end on turn 7.
New Neutral Minion - Mr. Smite
Remember how everyone complained about Leeroy Jenkins so so long, and then complained about Alexstrasza the Life-Binder for being the "Leeroy Jenkins replacement". Well looks like we "finally" got an actual POWERCREEPED Leeroy Jenkins! WHY?
Who thought that printing Leeroy Jenkins and Tundra Rhino in 1 as a 6 cost minion was okay?!? Also this directly contradicts blizzards "Moving away from Charge" thing they did by rotating all the charge cards during the previous rotation.
Lets look at what decks can abuse him in standard:
Pirate warrior is going to become the most oppresive deck in the game, especially because The Juggernaut can randomly summon Mr. Smite. Also any Aggro deck will use him as a the new powercrept Leeroy Jenkins. Also Handbuff Paladin can cards such as Highlord Fordragon, Alliance Bannerman and Righteous Defense in order to buff up a HUGE Mr. Smite and kill your from in hand.
Oh and in wild every aggro deck will use him, but most importantly Pirate warrior will probably become a rank S+ deck. And of course Handbuff paladin will also use him i bet. The one thing we can be thankfull of, is that Mr. Smite is EVEN costed, so ODD decks such as ODD DH and ODD Paladin can't use him. (Which is probably the only reason Leeroy Jenkins might still see play.)
Honestly why did they decide to print a card that turns Pirate warrior, which is a tier 1 deck in both standard and wild into a tier S deck instead of supporting archetypes that need help? Do they REALLY want everyone to stop playing HS and play Mercenaries or BGs instead THAT badly?
The only "good" thing about Mr. Smite is that the board is finally going to matter... somewhat. So uh.. when are they raising your health from 30 to like 40? Cuz i feel like thats going to be important if the powercreep keeps going up like this.
New Neutral Minion - Mr. Smite
I actually disagree. At some point in the past they made a lot of very questionable decisions of "this is not happening" which have lead to...confusing balancing choices.
Remember when they said Shadow Priest wouldn't be a thing because they couldn't figure out how to make damage in Priest work without enabling OTKs? Well, if they hadn't gone back on that we wouldn't have Shadow Priest now, which is arguably the most interesting direction the class has gone in. The game evolves and stuff that was busted 2 years ago might barely be relevant nowadays. I see no problem in occasionally testing the waters and just throwing out crazy shit like this. Sure, it might backfire and be horribly overpowered, but at this point they nerf stuff within a week so I don't see the issue. As much as powercreep is frustrating to experience, I'd still prefer it over total stagnation or a constant stream of unplayably weak gimmick archetypes.
New Neutral Minion - Mr. Smite
The card doesn't say "other pirates" so that one will have charge.
We need to see how many cheap pirates can combo with that but looks scary...
New Neutral Minion - Mr. Smite
Looks massively overrated outside of the fact that it has Charge itself (which is most likely the first thing they'll nerf, if it does turn out OP). In an aggro deck this is at best a minor Leeroy replacement (arguably worse because +1 mana which is very relevant). Honestly, a lot of problems in the current meta stem from the fact that direct damage is surprisingly hard to come by if you have to build your deck around minions,, which is part of the reason why the degenerate OTK decks are allowed to get away with all their shit. I'm actually interested in what a more late-game bursty minion meta would look like.
Not to mention that minion aggro making a bigger return (as opposed to just burn damage) could actually enable dedicated control decks to return, since the only reason those aren't around is because the playerbase insists that Quest Mage is a viable deck despite statistics proving the opposite.
The only problem with this is how bonkers it is off of The Juggernaut. It evokes flashbacks of Dr. Boom randomly discovering the perfect hero power every turn.
If only Captain Hooktusk wwas around to see it. Could have been glorious...and really broken.
New Shaman Minion - Cookie the Cook
So, uh...we're just printing stat sticks for Shaman now? Sure, I'll play it, but it seems excessively boring. Also it has anti synergy with all the currently used weapons. Wouldn't want to override a Doomhammer.
Probably better after next year's rotation when Cagematch Custodian goes away.
Maybe there's some weird heal Shaman coming in the future and we just don't understand the significance of this yet.
New Shaman Minion - Cookie the Cook
It's seems like a decent card for deck that doesn't exist. Hopefully next expansion will improve it's existence
Blizzard Reveals the Remaining Deadmines Mini-Set Cards - 4 New Legendary Cards Revealed Including a New Edwin
If Mr. Smite didn't give himself Charge, he wouldn't be a big deal. You would need a lot more mana to get any benefit from the aura. But he does have Charge which makes him a viable finisher with an upside. I'm not particularly impressed by any of the other cards. The Murloc is okay. It can provide a bit of healing for a Murloc deck but it isn't all that special. The mech is okay for removing stuff and leaving a big body behind but doesn't look like the kind of card that is going to have any impact on the meta. And the new Edwin seems interesting for a miracle style deck with a lot of cheap cards but he doesn't look as capable of winning games early as old Edwin. This miniset doesn't look interesting or strong enough to put a stop to the dominance of Quest decks so i don't really see anything changing (other than Quest Warrior becoming a much bigger player).