All Comments

Trades into a minion, draws a card and is a pirate. Could work in a Frenzy Warrior deck or even in any deck really. It's very good and flexible.

I think there's potential in some miracle/tempo something, but will such a deck be good in the first place? Maybe.

Not a big fan of the handbuff mechanics on hunter but in can't be worse than gadgetzan

pretty strong in specific situations

Slower, but could be used to tutor specific stuff. I think we'll see this floating around a bunch. 

You know it's not a legitimate list if someone doesn't disagree with it! 

I will never forget my fellow human... But he won't be missed

Something about this just seems too slow for me. The buff is very powerful and you draw a the Beast too, but it just seems like a meme and nothing more. Eh, I wish I'm wrong.

Seems like a good frenzy card, and a solid pirate. Plus card draw, which is always good. 

Too weak, and too slow. 

If it were a Murloc, maybe there would be a chance to work out well. As is, nope.

an ok card, at least hyena has rush now

Seems pretty meh. I don't see myself playing this as a card in my deck. 

slow and too easy to remove

Seems fine. It deals some damage, heals some health, overall probably not a staple but certainly a good Discover.

I think it is a bit slow for aggro lock. I'm probably wrong here, but I don't see this one being as strong as people think. 

<Edit> Got caught up on not using Druid, didn't realize it was class specific challenge. Updated artwork that looks more Warlock.

flexible card with fine stats

I think this is solid. Decent for small boards or single minions. Bonus with lifesteal. I think we'll see this from time to time, but not powerful enough for an auto-include. 

the card looks good

Too slow for most decks, especially murlocs, and too weak to stay alive long enough to have an impact. 

I never understood the mage hate, cyclone mage is the deck I had the most fun with during these two years. Conjurer's calling and Evocation needed to be nerfed but playing against it didn't feel as bad to me since it requires flexibility of play with generated cards and ensures more varied games than consistent straightforward decks like soul DH, bomb warrior or libram paladin. Maybe that's just me, but the miracle part of hs is my favorite thing in the game. 

too slow card with arguable value 

With Warsong Commander giving rush, I guess the spirit of Patron warrior will return, even if the specific details mean it will have to play out differently. Still, it's a nice thing to be able to do, and well worth Gruntled Patron's place in the set.