This event has been utterly disappointing so far. Apart from the Book of Heroes (which hopefully will not replace the solo content for this expansion) we pretty much only got a couple of new BG heroes. The rest was promotion of mostly overpriced packages and cosmetics. The Brawliseum is no different, average players will likely not make a profit here. I daresay the free pack would probably be better for most.
I'm ok with this if we will get an actual Scholomance event later, if this has been the main event of this expansion then I'm pissed.
I like Conjure Food because of the lore background you've provided. Maybe you can find better art for it?
FieselFitz
Show Spoiler
If it was my card I'd drop the Scholomance watermark and go for a custom one. The card doesn't relate to Scholomance and some people will punish you for this (including me). I'd also toy around with the text to see if you can manage to avoid the single word in the last line ("orphan").
Ok, always thought i should pick the Watermark for the most recent Expansion. How can i make a custom one?
Will try to mess with the text so i can get rid of the single word.
Thx
When you choose a watermark, there's a "Custom" option which will take you to a place where you can choose a variety of custom watermarks. This is also where you can force apply a watermark to a card without a rarity, which is good for tokens
I like Conjure Food because of the lore background you've provided. Maybe you can find better art for it?
FieselFitz
Show Spoiler
If it was my card I'd drop the Scholomance watermark and go for a custom one. The card doesn't relate to Scholomance and some people will punish you for this (including me). I'd also toy around with the text to see if you can manage to avoid the single word in the last line ("orphan").
Ok, always thought i should pick the Watermark for the most recent Expansion. How can i make a custom one?
Will try to mess with the text so i can get rid of the single word.
Thx
Edit:
Still not sure how i did it but i messed around a little and got a Costum Watermark - it didn't work at first but i still got it :)
Also messed with the Text so i do not have a Single Word in the last line.
Don't forget that they also usually do a pretty large event in October for Hallow's End. This was likely just a themed way to showcase the new single-player content as well as put some stuff in the store to test the waters for the class specific bundle (Needs work for my money).
My other idea wasn't going over well so decided to go back to the drawing board. Came up with the below:
You can think of it like a precursor to Zephrys the Great but this comes from your deck instead of a resource generation. Need that Brawl really bad? Play this with 5 remaining mana crystals to try and grab it (obviously still can whiff if you have multiple cards in your deck of that certain amount but that is to be expected).
I guess I didn't read that right when it was announced... I couldn't imagine, they would choose 1000-gold cost Tavern Brawl during so called "3-Week Event"...
I was so sure, we will just get Brawliseum, maybe because the Heroic version of it didn't appear for such a looong time. Now that's a disappointment right? Huge disappointment :(
Even tho I had a great results this month (66% winrate with Face Hunter), as a F2P player, I am not willing to risk 1000 gold for it... Peace, i'm out for this week :(((
I like Conjure Food because of the lore background you've provided. Maybe you can find better art for it?
FieselFitz
Show Spoiler
If it was my card I'd drop the Scholomance watermark and go for a custom one. The card doesn't relate to Scholomance and some people will punish you for this (including me). I'd also toy around with the text to see if you can manage to avoid the single word in the last line ("orphan").
Changed the effect because like anchorm4n mentioned - it didn't realy suit the theme that well :) and i also liked his idea and it is more suitable for the theme too.
Also made him 5 instead of 4 Mana and therefor changed his stats a little bit too.
Feedback Basil Anguis:
Show Spoiler
I like the Secret. Not Sure about the "Text Formation" - Maybe something like:
Secret: At the start of your turn, restore 4 Health to your Hero and gain 1 Mana Crystal this turn only.
I think that sounds better than "When your turn starts"
About the Recipe and the Pie:
Nice Idea and not much to add but i like the Secret better.
Thanks for the feedback! The text format is actually taken after Competitive Spirit. Not sure if i should use a more modern text like the one you gave, or stay in line with previous iterations of this sort of secret.
Ah ok, i personaly would prefer the modern text but i guess the other one is ok too. Just a personal reference.Quote From anchorm4n
Alright just forget about the Dragon (and the Squirrel I edited out because it was awful). I had to dig hard, but I've found some nice fitting art and I'm excited to hear what you think about this:
Do you think the balance is okay? I thought it important to restrict the damage dealt to minions. I could imagine making it cost 5, deal 3, buff +2/+2 or cost 3, deal 2, buff +1/+1. #makehunterwinawcdc
I like it. I think the Balance is good alltough 3 Damage can kill a lot of minions these days but i still think the card is fine.
Thanks for feedback! Unfortunately, my sin is to go hard on unique design and forget the story behind the card. That's why you may not exactly resonate with it, but tbh the theme around it's effect can be interrpretated by combining the damage from your hero power and the ominousity of the chandelier to also damage the other hero. They are merciless, and even dissapointed that there is no third hero to damage - I want to include that in the potential flavor text.
Hey look, Swim and Mobalytics edited their tier lists and multiple bilgewater decks got knocked down a tier. Is it time for you to change opinion again?
Swim actually put two targon decks in tier 1 now. Is Targon Actually Good After All?
This is exactly what needs to be done - as a wild main, I also want to play this in wild format, and I'm pretty sure a significant portion of the community rathers standard. This change alone will improve the experience significantly.
Changed the effect because like anchorm4n mentioned - it didn't realy suit the theme that well :) and i also liked his idea and it is more suitable for the theme too.
Also made him 5 instead of 4 Mana and therefor changed his stats a little bit too.
Feedback Basil Anguis:
Show Spoiler
I like the Secret. Not Sure about the "Text Formation" - Maybe something like:
Secret: At the start of your turn, restore 4 Health to your Hero and gain 1 Mana Crystal this turn only.
I think that sounds better than "When your turn starts"
About the Recipe and the Pie:
Nice Idea and not much to add but i like the Secret better.
Thanks for the feedback! The text format is actually taken after Competitive Spirit. Not sure if i should use a more modern text like the one you gave, or stay in line with previous iterations of this sort of secret.
I really wish the tavern brawl was toggleable Standard/Wild. As a Wild only player, I don't have a Standard collection. I could make a janky budget deck but then if I likely go 0-3 it's just a huge loss and I would have been better without entering. If I could play with a Wild deck I have experience with, my chances would be much better.
Really, if Blizz only makes it either Standard or Wild, then one half of the playerbase is bound to be unsatisfied.
Alright just forget about the Dragon (and the Squirrel I edited out because it was awful). I had to dig hard, but I've found some nice fitting art and I'm excited to hear what you think about this:
Do you think the balance is okay? I thought it important to restrict the damage dealt to minions. I could imagine making it cost 5, deal 3, buff +2/+2 or cost 3, deal 2, buff +1/+1. #makehunterwinawcdc
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
Uhh, this is the solo content for this expansion. Sorry to ruin your day.
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
Do we know if the MMR matchmaking will be active this tavern brawl
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
That is a ridiculous value. 50 packs, lots of dust, AND legendaries...
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
This event has been utterly disappointing so far. Apart from the Book of Heroes (which hopefully will not replace the solo content for this expansion) we pretty much only got a couple of new BG heroes. The rest was promotion of mostly overpriced packages and cosmetics. The Brawliseum is no different, average players will likely not make a profit here. I daresay the free pack would probably be better for most.
I'm ok with this if we will get an actual Scholomance event later, if this has been the main event of this expansion then I'm pissed.
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
Leatherclad Hogleader?
À La Card - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
When you choose a watermark, there's a "Custom" option which will take you to a place where you can choose a variety of custom watermarks. This is also where you can force apply a watermark to a card without a rarity, which is good for tokens
À La Card - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Ok, always thought i should pick the Watermark for the most recent Expansion. How can i make a custom one?
Will try to mess with the text so i can get rid of the single word.
Thx
Edit:
Still not sure how i did it but i messed around a little and got a Costum Watermark - it didn't work at first but i still got it :)
Also messed with the Text so i do not have a Single Word in the last line.
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
Don't forget that they also usually do a pretty large event in October for Hallow's End. This was likely just a themed way to showcase the new single-player content as well as put some stuff in the store to test the waters for the class specific bundle (Needs work for my money).
À La Card - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
My other idea wasn't going over well so decided to go back to the drawing board. Came up with the below:
You can think of it like a precursor to Zephrys the Great but this comes from your deck instead of a resource generation. Need that Brawl really bad? Play this with 5 remaining mana crystals to try and grab it (obviously still can whiff if you have multiple cards in your deck of that certain amount but that is to be expected).
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
maaaaan(....
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
Wait what? It is Heroic Brawliseum ???
I guess I didn't read that right when it was announced... I couldn't imagine, they would choose 1000-gold cost Tavern Brawl during so called "3-Week Event"...
I was so sure, we will just get Brawliseum, maybe because the Heroic version of it didn't appear for such a looong time. Now that's a disappointment right? Huge disappointment :(
Even tho I had a great results this month (66% winrate with Face Hunter), as a F2P player, I am not willing to risk 1000 gold for it... Peace, i'm out for this week :(((
À La Card - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
BasilAnguis
FieselFitz
À La Card - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I like it. I think the Balance is good alltough 3 Damage can kill a lot of minions these days but i still think the card is fine.
À La Card - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thanks for feedback! Unfortunately, my sin is to go hard on unique design and forget the story behind the card. That's why you may not exactly resonate with it, but tbh the theme around it's effect can be interrpretated by combining the damage from your hero power and the ominousity of the chandelier to also damage the other hero. They are merciless, and even dissapointed that there is no third hero to damage - I want to include that in the potential flavor text.
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
None of the above I'm afraid; there is no anagram here either.
The words all relate, in some way, to the card's name.
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
Only paid entries =(
Why No Bilgewater Nerfs?
Hey look, Swim and Mobalytics edited their tier lists and multiple bilgewater decks got knocked down a tier. Is it time for you to change opinion again?
Swim actually put two targon decks in tier 1 now. Is Targon Actually Good After All?
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
Being good helps, but being lucky helps significantly more
Why No Bilgewater Nerfs?
Haha, I honestly wouldn't even put it past the guy.
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
This is exactly what needs to be done - as a wild main, I also want to play this in wild format, and I'm pretty sure a significant portion of the community rathers standard. This change alone will improve the experience significantly.
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
is there will be free first try?
À La Card - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thanks for the feedback! The text format is actually taken after Competitive Spirit. Not sure if i should use a more modern text like the one you gave, or stay in line with previous iterations of this sort of secret.
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
I really wish the tavern brawl was toggleable Standard/Wild. As a Wild only player, I don't have a Standard collection. I could make a janky budget deck but then if I likely go 0-3 it's just a huge loss and I would have been better without entering. If I could play with a Wild deck I have experience with, my chances would be much better.
Really, if Blizz only makes it either Standard or Wild, then one half of the playerbase is bound to be unsatisfied.
Week 3 of the Forbidden Library - Heroic Brawliseum & the Magic of Dalaran Card Back Returns
Good point. If we get a “real” big event next month, then I’ll be satisfied.
À La Card - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Alright just forget about the Dragon (and the Squirrel I edited out because it was awful). I had to dig hard, but I've found some nice fitting art and I'm excited to hear what you think about this:
Do you think the balance is okay? I thought it important to restrict the damage dealt to minions. I could imagine making it cost 5, deal 3, buff +2/+2 or cost 3, deal 2, buff +1/+1. #makehunterwinawcdc