As someone who wants a female Death Knight skin, this is an especially low-blow. I just know they'll use this as their excuse not to make another one :(
Edit: I've seen the skin, and I don't like it. I guess I feel better?
I actully like the skin, so it makes it even worse for me...
Going to leave this feedback thread here. Speaking of feedback:
Wailor
I do definitely prefer Living Typhoon myself, though if you do choose to go with Calia Menethil, I would suggest reorganizing the textbox. I think it would look better if you just strung them all along together (like Zilliax or Al'Akir) rather than give each one a separate line.
AeroJulwin
Super simple is just sort of the name of the game in this competition.
At 0 mana for Spell Damage +1, it will definitely see play at some point. Mage in particular would definitely like this with Arcane Bolts and Vexallus.
Me0203
I too prefer Nutty Buddy over Inlet Scavenger. More fun in my opinion.
Machadogps
I do agree that the Fel Spell Damage is not as overpowered as it looks like it should be, although it does limit the design of cheap Fel spells for Warlock pretty significantly.
Little future note here: The best way to use the Discussion Topic is to post your card(s) here first to get relevant feedback and then submit your entry when you're happy with the card in its current form.
R
Unfortunately, I do think that it needs to use "gain" and thus, would invalidate the card.
BasilAnguis
I appreciate the attempt at what you're trying to do, and Echo and Choose are both keywords that would work well together.
But I feel like the text is bloated too heavily with a lot of bold words and it's actually sort of hard to read. I think you should try something a bit simpler.
Neoguli
Chronax is an elegant use of the prompt, but I feel like it might actually be quite powerful since you can stack your first draw with no cost.
Dragonbone Ritual is unfortunately not valid due to the use of the word "Galakrond".
That's a mistake on their end. They clearly stated it was going to be available after the Twitch event was over. I have a feeling some people are gonna be demanding refunds lol.
I would personally like to submit Bonedragon Ritual, but I doubt that including a keyword that needs only one bit of non-bold text would qualify, which leaves me with Chronax as probably my best bet to stand out among the competition.
It's unfortunate that Galakrond falls through the cracks on this prompt, but ultimately Yes, a card Invoking Galakrond would get you in trouble :(
Fel Damage +2 on a 1-drop with premium stats (and the Dredge) is a lot in my opinion. You'd also have to consider that, if such a card existed, Fel Warlock probably wouldn't see much additional help: with such a strong cheap card waiting in the wings, how much more could they push the archetype without going overboard?
I think it's a cool card, don't get me wrong; I just think +1 would have been safer.
There are quite a lot of changes this season between the changes of hosts, prizes, and finals. I figure people will probably have a lot to say. Here's your place to do so.
As someone who wants a female Death Knight skin, this is an especially low-blow. I just know they'll use this as their excuse not to make another one :(
Edit: I've seen the skin, and I don't like it. I guess I feel better?
I am baitd, but i do have tons of gold and already spent some gold on buying cosmetics anyway, so it isn't different from that for me, but damn can't skip it this time around because i also really want that portrait
Honestly, the value isn't that great. You get a chance at getting a hero skin for your 1000 gold / 1000 runestone entry. It's certainly better than previous offerings which you get effectively nothing (4 packs, 120g, 120 dust) if you get to 3 wins, but this is going to bait players into buying it when the mini-set is just around the corner.
I would personally like to submit Bonedragon Ritual, but I doubt that including a keyword that needs only one bit of non-bold text would qualify, which leaves me with Chronax as probably my best bet to stand out among the competition.
Is fel damage +2 really that strong in current warlock? Look, at first glace it looks absolutely broken, but if you see the pool, it's not actually that good.
I'll finally go with Living Typhoon, as people seemed to prefer it over Calia unanimously.
I'm still not sure about balance, though. It seems very weak right now, but giving it stat points seems too much. Maybe a 4/4 statline is okay? It would help to trigger Overkill and I don't want to go for Honorable Kill because it doesn't fit the flavor as much.
Feedback:
linkblade91
I see you already submitted. Very cool card, which also has a good shot at winning.
Demonxz95
Both are solid cards.
If you go for Thunderaan, I'd make it simply use Mega-Windfury and maybe make it cost 6 (you can also give it +1 Health if you do this). Also, maybe it should be a Shaman card?
With this change, I'd prefer Thunderaan, but if you're not comfortable using Mega-Windfury, Raptor is also good (even if I'm a bit triggered to see a Raptor that doesn't use the 3/2 statline lol).
Aerojulwin
I like its simplicity, but it's too much as a Neutral card. For instance, Druid can pull 10 damage for 0 Mana using this and Moonfire. Remember Malygos Druid was a thing for many years, and two Arcane Lilies are almost as strong as him but cost no Mana.
I'd recommend either reducing its Spell Damage to 1 or making it a Mage card, as this class doesn't have too many Arcane spells that can go face.
Me0203
I'd go with Nutty Buddy for sure, even if I'm not a huge fan of its name. I'd love Blizzard to experiment with Overload conditions a bit more, as all existing cards trigger when the card is played.
machadogps
I see you already submitted, but this card is too strong. Spell Damage +2 is too much for a 1 drop, especially one with premium stats and another effect on top.
R
Your comment made my day xD
I'd say it needs the word "Gain". Maybe Choose One is debatable, but even then I'm inclined to say it needs the word.
BasilAnguis
I didn't realize Choose Twice didn't use the word "or" like Choose One does. Good call! Even then, I'm not sure if its wording is consistent, as it probably needs the word "Gain".
If it is allowed, however, I really enjoy its concept, but I'd do a couple things to improve it:
Make it a legendary as you said.
Correct a minor spelling error: you should end the text with a full stop (.) instead of a semicolon (;).
Get rid of the "Spellburst: Adapt" part. It adds needless complexity and the card is strong enough without it. Also, doing this would leave Echo as the only cross-expansion keyword (which will probably become evergreen sooner or later, now that there's precedent for it).
I fucking hope you meant ten of the rewards, because that wording makes it sound like once you reach level 10 you need to buy the pass if you want to progress any farther.
New Hearthstone Shop Deals Bring in Omen to Celebrate Lunar New Year, Huln Highmountain, & Spirit Bru'kan
He does have one.
New Hearthstone Shop Deals Bring in Omen to Celebrate Lunar New Year, Huln Highmountain, & Spirit Bru'kan
Omen looks nice, but lacks a unique Hero Tray afaik. No gameplay, yet, but I might pass on him.
New Hearthstone Shop Deals Bring in Omen to Celebrate Lunar New Year, Huln Highmountain, & Spirit Bru'kan
Hasn't Bru'kan suffered enough? Maybe give him some paint instead.
Prepare for Tribal, Make it Double - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Congrats to Nobudy and Wailor!
ahahahah bugs be gone
lol
(Got my one win with this deck.)
Heroic Brawliseum Returns on February 1 With a New Hero Skin & Legendary Quest Reward
I actully like the skin, so it makes it even worse for me...
I hate heroic Brawl enough without it
Keyword Katastrophe - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Going to leave this feedback thread here. Speaking of feedback:
Super simple is just sort of the name of the game in this competition.
At 0 mana for Spell Damage +1, it will definitely see play at some point. Mage in particular would definitely like this with Arcane Bolts and Vexallus.
I do agree that the Fel Spell Damage is not as overpowered as it looks like it should be, although it does limit the design of cheap Fel spells for Warlock pretty significantly.
Little future note here: The best way to use the Discussion Topic is to post your card(s) here first to get relevant feedback and then submit your entry when you're happy with the card in its current form.
I appreciate the attempt at what you're trying to do, and Echo and Choose are both keywords that would work well together.
But I feel like the text is bloated too heavily with a lot of bold words and it's actually sort of hard to read. I think you should try something a bit simpler.
Chronax is an elegant use of the prompt, but I feel like it might actually be quite powerful since you can stack your first draw with no cost.
Dragonbone Ritual is unfortunately not valid due to the use of the word "Galakrond".
Get a Free Lightkeeper Xyrella Battlegrounds Skin by Watching Hearthstone on Twitch Through January 23
That's a mistake on their end. They clearly stated it was going to be available after the Twitch event was over. I have a feeling some people are gonna be demanding refunds lol.
Keyword Katastrophe - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
It's unfortunate that Galakrond falls through the cracks on this prompt, but ultimately Yes, a card Invoking Galakrond would get you in trouble :(
@machadogps
Fel Damage +2 on a 1-drop with premium stats (and the Dredge) is a lot in my opinion. You'd also have to consider that, if such a card existed, Fel Warlock probably wouldn't see much additional help: with such a strong cheap card waiting in the wings, how much more could they push the archetype without going overboard?
I think it's a cool card, don't get me wrong; I just think +1 would have been safer.
@R
WCDC Season 6 Feedback Thread
There are quite a lot of changes this season between the changes of hosts, prizes, and finals. I figure people will probably have a lot to say. Here's your place to do so.
Get a Free Lightkeeper Xyrella Battlegrounds Skin by Watching Hearthstone on Twitch Through January 23
I have that skin in the shop right now for 200 crystals
Heroic Brawliseum Returns on February 1 With a New Hero Skin & Legendary Quest Reward
As someone who wants a female Death Knight skin, this is an especially low-blow. I just know they'll use this as their excuse not to make another one :(
Edit: I've seen the skin, and I don't like it. I guess I feel better?
Heroic Brawliseum Returns on February 1 With a New Hero Skin & Legendary Quest Reward
I am baitd, but i do have tons of gold and already spent some gold on buying cosmetics anyway, so it isn't different from that for me, but damn can't skip it this time around because i also really want that portrait
Heroic Brawliseum Returns on February 1 With a New Hero Skin & Legendary Quest Reward
Jesus Christ they are desperate for money.
Heroic Brawliseum Returns on February 1 With a New Hero Skin & Legendary Quest Reward
Honestly, the value isn't that great. You get a chance at getting a hero skin for your 1000 gold / 1000 runestone entry. It's certainly better than previous offerings which you get effectively nothing (4 packs, 120g, 120 dust) if you get to 3 wins, but this is going to bait players into buying it when the mini-set is just around the corner.
Heroic Brawliseum Returns on February 1 With a New Hero Skin & Legendary Quest Reward
I really hate them locking a skin behind heroic brawl (aka scam brawl)
even for DK which has like NO options at all
And i dont even mind paying for cosmetics, but id want them guaranteed. Not pay us for a CHANCE at a skin
Paying for a Chance at a Time Limiteed skin is such a shityt thing to do
Keyword Katastrophe - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I would personally like to submit Bonedragon Ritual, but I doubt that including a keyword that needs only one bit of non-bold text would qualify, which leaves me with Chronax as probably my best bet to stand out among the competition.
Keyword Katastrophe - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Is fel damage +2 really that strong in current warlock? Look, at first glace it looks absolutely broken, but if you see the pool, it's not actually that good.
Everything You Need to Know About Hearthstone Battlegrounds Season 3
Yeah, they will be gone
Everything You Need to Know About Hearthstone Battlegrounds Season 3
Yeah, free are some levels divided evenly from levels 3, 7, 11 etc. until level 39, just click the SPOILER to see details.
Keyword Katastrophe - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I'll finally go with Living Typhoon, as people seemed to prefer it over Calia unanimously.
I'm still not sure about balance, though. It seems very weak right now, but giving it stat points seems too much. Maybe a 4/4 statline is okay? It would help to trigger Overkill and I don't want to go for Honorable Kill because it doesn't fit the flavor as much.
Feedback:
If you go for Thunderaan, I'd make it simply use Mega-Windfury and maybe make it cost 6 (you can also give it +1 Health if you do this). Also, maybe it should be a Shaman card?
With this change, I'd prefer Thunderaan, but if you're not comfortable using Mega-Windfury, Raptor is also good (even if I'm a bit triggered to see a Raptor that doesn't use the 3/2 statline lol).
I'd recommend either reducing its Spell Damage to 1 or making it a Mage card, as this class doesn't have too many Arcane spells that can go face.
I'd say it needs the word "Gain". Maybe Choose One is debatable, but even then I'm inclined to say it needs the word.
If it is allowed, however, I really enjoy its concept, but I'd do a couple things to improve it:
Everything You Need to Know About Hearthstone Battlegrounds Season 3
I fucking hope you meant ten of the rewards, because that wording makes it sound like once you reach level 10 you need to buy the pass if you want to progress any farther.
Everything You Need to Know About Hearthstone Battlegrounds Season 3
Not sure if this is mentioned somewhere, but is the "quest/reward" system removed from the game with the new season?
Specifically the Castle Nathria mechanic where you have to complete the quest in game to get rewards like The Smoking Gun
Snowpocalypse 3
My Sixth Sense tells me that another snowball Collector is out there. A past Champion of the Contest is about to have a massive Moment of Triumph by delivering a Fatal Strike at the very end. Let us see today if my Prediction is going to Happen or not 😅
Amazon coins page broken (404, not found)
Thanks! Pushing out an update to fix references to this.