I'm not a fan of the spider cards, as Dormant doesn't seem to be part of Rogue's identity. Maybe a Sap effect would work better, at least for the Quarter (not for Maexxna, she would turn into Vanish on steroids).
About Razuvious, I kinda prefer the second one because of how dumb it is (in a good way), but it'd probably work better as a Neutral or as part of a core/initiate set, as it's kinda basic for an expansion legendary.
anchorm4n
I find this effect to be a little hard to balance and make interesting at the same time. Right now, it will almost always deal 8-10 damage, which is too little variance for it to matter. On the other hand, making it cheaper would definetly break the card. I'd probably turn his effect into an AoE, while also lowering the Cost.
Dolphinslayer
The first Sapphironhas a very interesting effect, but it's probably too expensive for it to work properly. The Mage version isn't bad either (but be careful, the Infused version needs to say "Battlecry"). Not a fan of Maexxna, though.
I think your two options are:
Find a character that makes sense with DKSapph's effect but also makes sense as a 4-ish Mana minion.
Go with the MageSapph after adding Battlecry to the Infused version and maybe finding a better art for it.
Demonxz95
I agree with linkblade, Skeletal Smith is your better card and also in that it's kind of too swingy as a 2-Mana card. I'd probably make it more expensive (with better stats ofc) and maybe also give it Taunt. At this point I'd suggest making it a Warrior card, but that'd go against what your aiming for XD
CursedParrot
I like your idea about having a Quarter cycle. The second version is better, but it feels a bit too good. I'd probably make it 2 Durability, as rising the Cost to 2 would likely kill the card.
Depending on how some people are feeling on a giving day LOR "sucks" right now.
There's a lot of salt, a lot of hate, on reddit specifically.
People don't know what decks to play, and as soon as they find a list it's invalidated by another.
Oh man these midrange lists sure are strong, nevermind ryze is toxic combo is too good, how about them Swarm decks? Then we go back to midrange again and the circle continues.
Meanwhile the deck brewers are doing crazy **** and winning games.
We have a new competitive yeti list on mastering runeterra with Darius, we have daybreak at top of S tier on mobalytics.
The reality is that this meta is like jello, it keeps changing shape and nobody knows what's going to happen.
To me that's exciting.
It's dynamic, it's moving, it's constantly changing, a world where anything is possible.
But to the salt lords who have to keep their edge because it's their career or livelihood or their claim to fame this meta is cancer.
They say one deck is top tier, and next week it's not. They say Nora is everywhere then Nora drops 5%. They say FTR doesn't exist and then FTR hits 55%.
This truly is the card game of champions right now and I'm going to enjoy every drop of it till rotation hits.
Let the salt lords cry, and the hardcores get mad, I'm having a blast.
I wonder what's going to happen but unless they look into these issues below, I'm not holding my breath. These are my takes and I would like to hear your thoughts as well:
General
The cost of cards shouldn't be reduced below 1 Mana, no matter what. Mana cheat went way overboard that a hard rule must be applied. That means cards like Emperor Thaurissan and Insight can reduce the cost down to 1 Mana, similar to how Arcane Luminary functions. This rule will keep Pillager Rogues and Secret Mages to not spam 0-Cost cards.
If necessary, a card should have alternative/different variant for Wild format. For example, Contract Conjurer might be OK in Standard but not so much for Wild.
A graveyard system must be implemented so Big Priests can't resurrect same minion over and over again. Right now, if Blood of G'huun dies once, you can play 2xResurrect cards right away. Here, I propose you can play Resurrect only once if G'Huun died once. This rule will also affect N'Zoth cards and similar ones, to a degree.
Druid
Play Floop's Glorious Gloop to gain infinite mana, if utilized well. How about a hard cap, which you can gain up to 10 Mana Crystals, even if you have Guff Hero card played? Like, you have gained 9 Mana and spent them, then 2 minions killed but only one is granted to you, not two. It also shouldn't stack with cards such as Solar Eclipse.
Wildheart Guff should have 15 Mana Crystals at max, not 20.
Mage
Kirin Tor Mage cries in the corner because Kabal Lackey and Anonymous Informant are much better. These cards should reduce the cost of secret to 1 Mana, not zero. While at it, their cost should be upped by 1 Mana.
Contract Conjurer should cost 1 less for each secret controlled. Maybe make him 7 Mana, perhaps?
Priest
New graveyard system, please look above.
Some resurrect cards Big Priests use should have mana cost raised by one. Candidates are; Resurrect+Eternal Servitude.
Shadow Essence should summon 3/3 or 4/4 minion, not 5/5.
Illuminate should cost 1 Mana and reduce the cost of spell by 2, not 3.
Radiant Elemental limits design for future Priest cards, which has proven pretty much with Mind Sear. This card belongs to Ungoro expansion and it's Elemental. Thus, I propose the following change: "Your Elementals have +1 Health" which looks thematically fitting.
Rogue
Maybe not a problem right now but either increase the condition for The Caverns Below or change its reward to set minions to 3/3 instead of 5/5.
Swordfish should either have 2 durability or grant +1 Attack.
Cutlass Courier has very good stats for his ability if compared with similar cards. Reducing his stats to 1/4 looks like a right balance choice.
That's all what I can think of. Let me hear your thoughts. With the insight shared from Blizzard, I really look forward to see Wild format grow even better.
Anything is definitely an improvement over the current version of Maexxna. I am slightly worried about how strong it is to bounce since Rogue definitely has the means of bouncing and playing this a bunch to lock down your opponent's board for several turns at a time, although sine this will eat up quite a bit of resources and they need a good board presence to be able to use that strategy, I guess it might be fine.
Arachnid Quarter is fine, though it does kinda strike as just a Freeze for Rogue, which I realize is the intention, but it might feel a bit weird to some people. Maexxna is definitely the most flashy card of the two.
As for Instructor Razuvious, if you do decide to go with him, do go with the first version. It might possibly come off as a bit lazy to reuse the same exact card for two competitions in a row to some people, but it's still a pretty solid card.
Wailor
I like it. It's good Nerubian flavor and Rogue mechanics. My only suggestion is maybe consider giving it Stealth to start with.
anchorm4n
Judging by the stats, it seems that it's meant to work with all Mana Crystals as opposed to just full or just empty ones (it wasn't quite clear at first). So it might be a bit problematic given that Priest also has many ways of summoning copies of it for cheap.
Dolphinslayer
The Death Knight version of Sapphiron, Tomb Guardian has an effect that's kinda neat, although damaging Frozen enemy minions usually defeats the point of Freezing them in the first place unless the effect is quite strong. And even though this is quite strong, it does result in it playing a bit awkwardly especially since it costs so much mana.
The Mage version is kinda cool. I like the flavor of summon a Frozen copy of a thing. The AoE Infuse effect is quite a cool upgrade (even though only 4 is quite small for this amount of upgrade), but it won't really help you if you don't have a way to deal with the board on the same turn that you play it. The Infuse (4) is also missing the brackets around the 4.
Maexxna, Broodmother seems hard to make good use of since it wants you to have a lot of Beasts die meaning you're probably spamming Beasts and then hold it in your hand for a significant amount of time which somewhat goes against the nature of spamming Beasts in the first place. It seems like most of the time, it would be better to just play a Timber Wolf instead. That said, I admire the creativity of the Infuse stipulation.
CursedParrot
I definitely prefer the second version.
My problem with the first version is that it's a location that actively encourages you to not use it since you want to keep playing Taunt minions to pump its damage while it just sits on the board and does nothing until you decide to use it at the time you need to.
The second one is mostly just "play it and use it", which is what I feel most locations should be like. Maybe you might wait for a better time to use it, but it still wants you to use it.
I was thinking it would have been cool if we'd gotten a cycle of "Quarter" cards in the miniset for each quarter, so here's two ideas I had on how to represent the Military quarter. Which one do you think is a better design?
Update that was posted on Blizzard forums, of course by community vs Blizz:
On your phone, go to Settings > Game Dashboard > enable “Use Game Dashboard” and “Game Dashboard Floating Icon”
Open Hearthstone, click on the round Game Dashboard icon
Change optimization settings from “Standard” to “Battery Saver”. Game will prompt to restart. Accept the prompt.
I did this and it "works". Given that there is a work around like this, I doubt that Blizz would do anything else unless another update destroys our connection. But at least there is an option.
I initially put it in the nerfs section, since the cost increase means it comes down later. But the devs are hinting that it's a buff in the patch notes, so who am I to argue?
I really wanted to make a third card, but I couldn't think of anything good at the moment.
Everyone keeps adding to the thread while I'm busy typing up feedback for previous posts >_> Picked the wrong time to do this, evidently.
I like Skeletal Smith more than Grobbulus. Grobb is quite slow and needs everything to line up well to chain his effect. That being said, the Smith would be one of the cheapest "summon a copy of this" cards out there, so hitting that perfect 1-2 punch might feel extra bad for opponents.
My first three attempts, with which I am probably the happiest with the first Sapphiron.
The Death Knight version of Sapphiron is probably the best of the three, I agree. It is thankfully an 8-Mana "do nothing", more or less, because it plays extremely well with Frost Queen Sindragosa from the turn before.
Did you know that Fleshshaper depicts Grobbulus? That's so lame. Let's make him into a proper Legendary card. He starts off as a small AoE that can keep growing into a bigger AoE. It's easy to play around, but if your opponent's strategy is largely centered around small minions, then it can be quite a problem.
Skeletal Smith is an attempt to push a weapon synergy for Death Knight since the class doesn't feature anything like it yet, but it fits right at home in the class. In some type of Blood/Frost deck, turn 1 Bone Breaker into turn 2 Skeletal Smith can be a pretty strong curve. Alternatively, it also works with Blood's handbuffing cards.
I really wanted to make a third card, but I couldn't think of anything good at the moment.
With Mind Blast that's 15 damage to their face on turns 10+, plus a 5/5 body. Not saying that's a deal-breaker, but it is a lot of damage from "nowhere". This is also a class-specific, Legendary-only check on Wildheart Guff, which is not something I'm a fan of.
@Wailor - I think "Crypt Reaver" sounds cooler, but I don't see why you can't use "Crypt Fiend". Surprised it hasn't been used by Hearthstone already. Also, a card like Crypt Lord would beg to differ about the stat-line lol. The 4/4 Nerubians are all tokens. If you want to change it to avoid butting heads with Scourge Illusionist, I say 'go for it'.
There are more characters already in the game than I'd have thought. Heigan has an interesting ability according to Wowpedia though, so here's my first idea:
As Argentinian, I'm now certain I'll never be able to spend money on the game. They increased the value by a 600% and now you need a week of the basic salary to pay a bundle: waaaaay more that what I'm willing to pay. It's just sad
Hello friend. Really happy to be here! I would like to introduce you to a game website we just developed that is trap the cat. Consult and give me advice.
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
First batch of feedback:
About Razuvious, I kinda prefer the second one because of how dumb it is (in a good way), but it'd probably work better as a Neutral or as part of a core/initiate set, as it's kinda basic for an expansion legendary.
I think your two options are:
Blood Magic
Didn't we have this one a few months ago?
The LOR Meta Is Better Than Its Ever Been
Depending on how some people are feeling on a giving day LOR "sucks" right now.
There's a lot of salt, a lot of hate, on reddit specifically.
People don't know what decks to play, and as soon as they find a list it's invalidated by another.
Oh man these midrange lists sure are strong, nevermind ryze is toxic combo is too good, how about them Swarm decks? Then we go back to midrange again and the circle continues.
Meanwhile the deck brewers are doing crazy **** and winning games.
We have a new competitive yeti list on mastering runeterra with Darius, we have daybreak at top of S tier on mobalytics.
The reality is that this meta is like jello, it keeps changing shape and nobody knows what's going to happen.
To me that's exciting.
It's dynamic, it's moving, it's constantly changing, a world where anything is possible.
But to the salt lords who have to keep their edge because it's their career or livelihood or their claim to fame this meta is cancer.
They say one deck is top tier, and next week it's not. They say Nora is everywhere then Nora drops 5%. They say FTR doesn't exist and then FTR hits 55%.
This truly is the card game of champions right now and I'm going to enjoy every drop of it till rotation hits.
Let the salt lords cry, and the hardcores get mad, I'm having a blast.
MARVEL SNAP's Featured Location This Week is Camp Lehigh - Sound Off!
It took me a minute to figure out why Camp Lehigh gives you a 3 drop: it's because Captain America is one. :)
New Plans for Wild Format! What Could They Be?
Title says it all. Well, in case you haven't heard of, a developer called Matt London wrote a post on Twitter, indicating that Blizzard is planning to bring the best experience for Wild format.
I wonder what's going to happen but unless they look into these issues below, I'm not holding my breath. These are my takes and I would like to hear your thoughts as well:
General
Druid
Mage
Priest
Rogue
Shaman
That's all what I can think of. Let me hear your thoughts. With the insight shared from Blizzard, I really look forward to see Wild format grow even better.
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Feedback
Anything is definitely an improvement over the current version of Maexxna. I am slightly worried about how strong it is to bounce since Rogue definitely has the means of bouncing and playing this a bunch to lock down your opponent's board for several turns at a time, although sine this will eat up quite a bit of resources and they need a good board presence to be able to use that strategy, I guess it might be fine.
Arachnid Quarter is fine, though it does kinda strike as just a Freeze for Rogue, which I realize is the intention, but it might feel a bit weird to some people. Maexxna is definitely the most flashy card of the two.
As for Instructor Razuvious, if you do decide to go with him, do go with the first version. It might possibly come off as a bit lazy to reuse the same exact card for two competitions in a row to some people, but it's still a pretty solid card.
The Death Knight version of Sapphiron, Tomb Guardian has an effect that's kinda neat, although damaging Frozen enemy minions usually defeats the point of Freezing them in the first place unless the effect is quite strong. And even though this is quite strong, it does result in it playing a bit awkwardly especially since it costs so much mana.
The Mage version is kinda cool. I like the flavor of summon a Frozen copy of a thing. The AoE Infuse effect is quite a cool upgrade (even though only 4 is quite small for this amount of upgrade), but it won't really help you if you don't have a way to deal with the board on the same turn that you play it. The Infuse (4) is also missing the brackets around the 4.
Maexxna, Broodmother seems hard to make good use of since it wants you to have a lot of Beasts die meaning you're probably spamming Beasts and then hold it in your hand for a significant amount of time which somewhat goes against the nature of spamming Beasts in the first place. It seems like most of the time, it would be better to just play a Timber Wolf instead. That said, I admire the creativity of the Infuse stipulation.
I definitely prefer the second version.
My problem with the first version is that it's a location that actively encourages you to not use it since you want to keep playing Taunt minions to pump its damage while it just sits on the board and does nothing until you decide to use it at the time you need to.
The second one is mostly just "play it and use it", which is what I feel most locations should be like. Maybe you might wait for a better time to use it, but it still wants you to use it.
MARVEL SNAP's Featured Location This Week is Camp Lehigh - Sound Off!
Really nice for my shuri zero deck... I don't have any 3 drops (because I don't own sauron which I can also get for free from this)
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I was thinking it would have been cool if we'd gotten a cycle of "Quarter" cards in the miniset for each quarter, so here's two ideas I had on how to represent the Military quarter. Which one do you think is a better design?
Hearthstone's Server-Side Patch Today Brings Battlegrounds Balance, Arena Updates, and Bug Fixes
Update that was posted on Blizzard forums, of course by community vs Blizz:
I did this and it "works". Given that there is a work around like this, I doubt that Blizz would do anything else unless another update destroys our connection. But at least there is an option.
MARVEL SNAP's Newest Update Is Live - 7 Cards Go Down in Series, 6 Cards Receive Balance Changes
I initially put it in the nerfs section, since the cost increase means it comes down later. But the devs are hinting that it's a buff in the patch notes, so who am I to argue?
Yu-Gi-Oh's 25th Anniversary Debuts the Pot Collection - 14 Mini Figurines Inspired by “Pot of” Cards
You really have to like these pots to display them in your home - the miniatures reflect the art well, but that just means they are ugly :/
MARVEL SNAP's Newest Update Is Live - 7 Cards Go Down in Series, 6 Cards Receive Balance Changes
Sandman is more of a sidegrade...
Yu-Gi-Oh's 25th Anniversary Debuts the Pot Collection - 14 Mini Figurines Inspired by “Pot of” Cards
Not well enough: This is two months too early.
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Everyone keeps adding to the thread while I'm busy typing up feedback for previous posts >_> Picked the wrong time to do this, evidently.
I like Skeletal Smith more than Grobbulus. Grobb is quite slow and needs everything to line up well to chain his effect. That being said, the Smith would be one of the cheapest "summon a copy of this" cards out there, so hitting that perfect 1-2 punch might feel extra bad for opponents.
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
The Death Knight version of Sapphiron is probably the best of the three, I agree. It is thankfully an 8-Mana "do nothing", more or less, because it plays extremely well with Frost Queen Sindragosa from the turn before.
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Did you know that Fleshshaper depicts Grobbulus? That's so lame. Let's make him into a proper Legendary card. He starts off as a small AoE that can keep growing into a bigger AoE. It's easy to play around, but if your opponent's strategy is largely centered around small minions, then it can be quite a problem.
Skeletal Smith is an attempt to push a weapon synergy for Death Knight since the class doesn't feature anything like it yet, but it fits right at home in the class. In some type of Blood/Frost deck, turn 1 Bone Breaker into turn 2 Skeletal Smith can be a pretty strong curve. Alternatively, it also works with Blood's handbuffing cards.
I really wanted to make a third card, but I couldn't think of anything good at the moment.
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
With Mind Blast that's 15 damage to their face on turns 10+, plus a 5/5 body. Not saying that's a deal-breaker, but it is a lot of damage from "nowhere". This is also a class-specific, Legendary-only check on Wildheart Guff, which is not something I'm a fan of.
@Wailor - I think "Crypt Reaver" sounds cooler, but I don't see why you can't use "Crypt Fiend". Surprised it hasn't been used by Hearthstone already. Also, a card like Crypt Lord would beg to differ about the stat-line lol. The 4/4 Nerubians are all tokens. If you want to change it to avoid butting heads with Scourge Illusionist, I say 'go for it'.
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
My first three attempts, with which I am probably the happiest with the first Sapphiron.
I ended up making a Mage version of Sapphiron, because of his connection with Kel'thuzad.
It was really hard to fit all of the text on Maexxna, so I ended up cutting the part that enabled your other beasts to have rush, too.
Either way, thanks for the feedback!
Yu-Gi-Oh's 25th Anniversary Debuts the Pot Collection - 14 Mini Figurines Inspired by “Pot of” Cards
They know their crowd : I like pot! ^^
Naxx Out? - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
There are more characters already in the game than I'd have thought. Heigan has an interesting ability according to Wowpedia though, so here's my first idea:
Hearthstone Naxxramas Shop Update - Price Adjustments, New Constructed Hero Skins, Mercenaries Bundles, & More
As Argentinian, I'm now certain I'll never be able to spend money on the game. They increased the value by a 600% and now you need a week of the basic salary to pay a bundle: waaaaay more that what I'm willing to pay. It's just sad
Hearthstone Naxxramas Shop Update - Price Adjustments, New Constructed Hero Skins, Mercenaries Bundles, & More
Hearthstone Naxxramas Shop Update - Price Adjustments, New Constructed Hero Skins, Mercenaries Bundles, & More
Agreed, the wrinkle line under his eyes really doesn't make him look attractive.
This is meant to be a high fantasy game, old man Varian hits too close to reality 😅
Hearthstone Naxxramas Shop Update - Price Adjustments, New Constructed Hero Skins, Mercenaries Bundles, & More
I'm extremely nervous that my country's pricing will increase soon coz the local currency value has weakened a lot compared to USD 😒
assignmentreviews
Hello friend. Really happy to be here! I would like to introduce you to a game website we just developed that is trap the cat. Consult and give me advice.