Elfensilver's avatar

Elfensilver

LV.8
575/600 XP
Joined March 2019 663 posts 3,575 XP 595 achievement pts

Comments

663 total
+1
Colourful Casting - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

Thank you for the great suggestion, and best of luck to you!

5 years ago
0
New Mage Minion - Reckless Apprentice

This is a great card for all modes.

5 years ago
+10
New Mage Minion - Mordresh Fire Eye

Remember Jan'alai the Dragonhawk? This is just better in everyway. And is this a guitar playing undead? What's happening in the Barrens?!

5 years ago
0
New Paladin Minion - Cannonmaster Smythe

The soldiers look rad. Kind of a weird card, I'm not sure what this battlecry represents.

5 years ago
0
New Neutral Minion - Kazakus, Golem Shaper

Any aggressive deck with a low curve as well as any greedy control deck could use this. Only midrange decks wouldn't include this, I think.

5 years ago
0
New Neutral Minion - Primordial Protector

Looks like a card that may give rise to a new archetype akin to Spitefull decks. Mages have some elemental synergy and lots of spells, so they could very well use this. Shaman has (so far) only [card]Tidal Wave[/card] and …

5 years ago
+1
Colourful Casting - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

@anchorm4n

I think it compares favorably too [card]Bloodbloom[/card], which was somewhat playable. Cost and stats are a good callback to the original Kael'thas, but the choice of school seems off: from a quick search in the wowpedia I've found …

5 years ago
+1
Colourful Casting - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

@Demonxz95

[spoiler]thematic and comprehensible effect, great stats for effect and cost, nice art – but way to strong. I suppose most if not all druid spells are nature spells, and druid (especially in wild) has a few high cost …

5 years ago
+1
Colourful Casting - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

I'm pretty happy with this one, but I'd still appreciate any feedback, especially on how to boil down the text.

Edit: I will change the spelling of' Whenver' and the bolding of shadow, thanks for pointing that out! 'To …

5 years ago
0
New Neutral Minion - Shadow Hunter Vol'jin

Pretty meme-y, could become centerpiece of a strong deck, but that's a hard nut to crack.

5 years ago
0
New Neutral Minion - Razormane Raider

I think it's quite good. Especially for aggro decks- clear one smallish minion, and then get 5dmg to a random enemy- Basically deal 5dmg twice, and with any luck you get to keep a body.

5 years ago
0
New Neutral Minion - Spirit Healer

So essentially a Paladin/Priest card.

5 years ago
0
New Neutral Minion - Blademaster Samuro

A great If. Might be an option for a non-control card that wants to pull of a combo, but for most classes a two card combo won't be reliable enough.

5 years ago
0
New Neutral Minion - Peon

Flavorful: a competent minion (he has access to all the spells!) but he will only work if violence is used. Yay.

5 years ago
0
New Neutral Minion - Mankrik

Nice card, but I don't think it will see play since it doesn't support any archetype.

5 years ago
0
New Warlock Spell - Imp Swarm (Rank 1)

The green fel glow synergizes well enough with the purple border, but the art is somewhat unfocused, the imp is not really centerstage. Not a great design, not a great card.

5 years ago
0
New Shaman Minion - Bru'kan

Assuming most shaman spells are of the nature type:

This, +[card]Lightning Bloom[/card] +[card]Tidal Wave[/card] (assuming it's a nature spell) is a comeback against almost any board. + [card]Dunk Tank[/card] is playable by turn 6/8. + [card]Torrent[/card] is overkill against …

5 years ago
0
New Shaman Spell - Chain Lightning (Rank 1)

Great card, especially with any spell damage.

5 years ago
0
New Priest Spell - Desperate Prayer

Well, just more support for quick cycling. Not much to speculate about.

5 years ago
0
New Hunter Minion - Sunscale Raptor

Any 1/3 beast should be playable, but I wonder if this makes the cut. Yes, it has a clear upside, but this will force some awkward trades, and I would assume that the frustration about these and the comparably low …

5 years ago