All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • New Paladin Spell - Service Bell

    3-mana draw 2..most of the time? Is there a way for Paladin to shuffle cards? Are there any cards that want to be shuffled?

    I don't see why this needs to cost 3 tbh. Maybe there's some whacky build that runs only specific class cards and wants to tutor them, but other than that I don't see this being good.

  • New Paladin Spell - Divine Toll

    Seems to expensive to matter tbh. Great when you're ahead on the board and decent if you're far behind, but too unpredictable if you're just even and that's going to happen most of the time.

    Why spend 7-mana to give a minion +10/10 if you can do just that for 0-mana with Garden's Grace.

  • New Paladin Minion - The Countess

    As if it wasn't enough that Rogue impersonates everyone, now Paladin impersonates Rogue.


    It's a decent card but honestly it's just not good enough to beat out Cariel + Smite as a finisher. Random legendaries are fun but a lot of them rely on synergy to do anything. I mean think about what this does when you get Topior, or Lady Darkvein....just nothing.

    I want Pure PAladin to be a thing again, but this just won't do I think. You can't even run it with Brann or ZOlaa because they're neutrals.

    Oh and don't ccome with the "you can run neutrals and just draw them before this". Paladin doesn't have enough draw to make that a viable strategy. You want to play this on 7 and start to pressure with free legendaries. Unless there's a way to tutor Smite or Kazakusan this is just a pipe dream.

  • Hearthstone Designers Cora Georgiou and Leo Robles Clarify How Rogue's Kidnap Secret Works

    If your job is to communicate clearly and you don't do that job, but you produce a beautiful painting, you may be a good painter, but you're a crap communicator and didn't do your job. It isn't creative that they did their job badly; they may have been creative doing something other than their job (I don't agree, but ymmv) but still, the job didn't get done.

    The card literally doesn't explain itself and is so ambiguous that the designers had to give it a FAQ before it's even released. Its entire outcome is "surprising and unprecedented" because no one knew even remotely what it must do just from card text. The fact that you guessed it correctly is of no moment -- good for you I guess? I've guessed HS cards correctly and that doesn't make ambiguity better. Further, the point here is that this card and cards like it don't solve their issues with mouseover text. Ysera is a bizarre example to use because people criticized that card even in beta and still do, so you're undermining your own case, and people have been satisfied with Hero cards that use mouseover text appropriately, so the job can be done correctly. HS has done better in the past and is now commiting to doing worst going forward.

  • New Mage Minion - Chatty Bartender

    Honestly really powerful. A continuous Consecration that also gets protected by the Secrets that fuel it is really powerful, especially now that we also have the Neutral Secret cheater that allows for better combos.

    I could see Secret Mage being a thing, activating this on curve shouldn't be a problem and it can straight up lock out certain strategies.

     

  • New Hunter Spell - Collateral Damage

    What a fun new Rogue card.

    Seriously, there's no way any Hunter deck would want this unless they can somehow cheat it out. Unless you randomly generate this it won't see play.

    That being said, if your opponent has only 1/1s that's 15 damage face

  • New Hunter Minion - Ara'lon

    I mean it's just good. Bunch of stats, good effects.

    Wildseeds really just seem to be a self-contained package that boosts any midrange strategy that doesn't rely on resurrecting beasts.

    I could even see this in Big Beast Hunter if they just drop Revive Pet altogether and embrace the Wildseed fully.

  • New Druid Minion - Death Blossom Whomper

    Seems really strong if you can build a good deck around it. With the Location the tempo you can gain from this could be pretty nuts.

    I hope this doesn't enable the next "ramp to 6 to fuck your game" deck

  • New Neutral Minion - Sinstone Totem

    We have seen neutral totems before... but rarely in actual play.  This is just ungood

  • New Demon Hunter Spell - Dispose of Evidence

    Seems alright. Going -1 for a decent attack buff might not be good enough in the long run though.

    I mean, what even are the payoffs for this? I guess you can recycle with Fossil Fanatic or get more tempo on your Vanguard, but all things considered this isn't nearly comparable to pre-nerf Twin Slice.

  • Murder at Castle Nathria

    So it's looking like deathrattle druid might be the main theme for the mini set, for a class with multiple deathrattle support cards this set they only got one class deathrattle and its a massive legendary

  • New Neutral Minion - Dredger Staff

    Super good!  I like that this will hit ALL minions in your hand.  Will probably be auto-include in Odd DH or any other mini-minion builds. 

  • New Neutral Minion - Roosting Gargoyle

    I"ve never been a fan of battlecry specific tribe buffs.  I can see it in Arena with Hunters, but that's pretty much it

  • New Neutral Minion - Anonymous Informant

    I really like this because it flows really well from turn to turn instead of this turn only which would make it less impressive

  • The Countess is a New Legendary Paladin Card Revealed for Murder at Castle Nathria by Masaru

    Can still put neutrals in your deck if you plan to use this as a finisher once you've drawn all your neutrals. No idea of the viability of such an archetype but technically don't need a pure deck - like how some duplicate decks played zeph. 

  • New Neutral Minion - Dinner Performer

    Pretty situational unless you are running a good amount of deathrattle minions that can help you at low cost like Loot Hoarder

  • New Neutral Minion - Creepy Painting

    You would really need to set up this minion.  If you were able to get Stoneborn General into play or Scrapyard Colossus or remarkably a colossal minion to die when this thing is in play... then it's great.  But that requires a LOT to do it. 

  • New Demon Hunter Spell - Sinful Brand

    I feel like there is some decent ways to abuse this, As long as you need two hits to kill a minion this is basically 1-mana deal 4 to face, which is pretty good in a class that's all about that.

    I wonder if there's some way to really combo this (only Immolation Aura in Wild thus far)

  • New Neutral Minion - Scuttlebutt Ghoul

    Eh... Secret Mage couldn't care less about this, at least in wild.  With standard I don't see a lot of people playing it.

    Paladin could use it since it summon taunters and they love to handbuff. 

    Rogue MAY use it, but I'm not sure why other than to be more defensive to build up a combo swing.

    Hunter on the other hand I can see utilizing this since it will help them to protect their beasts they want on the board.  But that is my impression. 

  • New Neutral Minion - Murlocula

    I want to love this minion for like ever.  Murloc decks are rampant, and gladly are not pigeon holed in only Paladin and Shaman.  The idea of this thing coming out for free and with Lushwater Scout giving it Rush and +1 attack is amazing... I seriously love it already

  • Murder at Castle Nathria Final Card Reveals - See All 35 New Cards

    Okay, here's a few comments on the new cards, and the full set in general;

    - Secret mage is looking possible. One of the chief problems I have with the archetype in standard is the loss of Kirin Tor Mage, and team5 just went up and print another one in anonymous informant. So it is then possible to just play a secret along with orion for some value.

    - Dude pally on the other hand looks weak as shit. In fact either team5 is planning for something in the midset or the idea really is for steward to simply upgrade your hp. There's only one way to flood board with dudes, an emphasis on growing one instead of multiple dudes, and the fact that the support cards for it are weak as hell. 

    - Totem shaman might be possible, but Im not holding my breath. Both Gigantotem and Carving Chisel are really good cards, but totems themselves are relatively weak until The Stonewright is played. And with no way to tutor it, and no way to snowball like Totemic Reflection, its looking too slow to go against aggro decks and most control can easily deal with the multiple 0 attack totems. It needs a card that increases the likelihood of the totems actually surviving, and a decent comeback mechanism. Midset perhaps?

    - Warrior has some neat cards. Will this support the damaged archetype? Perhaps not. But I can see some form of rush/taunt midrange warrior coming

    - Creepy Painting has the potential to be the standout card in this expansion. This copies even enemy minions.

    - Thief priest looking like its ready to ensure no one in hearthstone is having any fun

    - Some form of aggro dhunter might be on the cards. Alot of good cheap cards this time round. Sadly, I think everyone would just be playing control relic dhunter instead.

     

    In terms of which class got the best stuff this expansion. Probably dhunter, followed by hunter and then druid. Shaman has a few good cards, priest has support for thief, secret rogue is shit but the others are fairly good, warrior needs testing, paladin is all over the place, warlock has imps and one really powerful card but otherwise meh.

    Dhunter is the only class in my opinion where there's few to no bad cards. The archetype can suck, but it looks functional.

  • New Neutral Minion - Stoneborn Accuser

    Solid, but not an autoinclude.  I can see this making it's way into DH, Hunter, perhaps some low cost minion decks.  5 for 5/5 is meh, but smack someone in the face for 5, that is worth looking into.  Even Shadow Priest could run with this 

  • New Neutral Minion - Masked Reveler

    Icky... Who would run this  I know there has to be something out there that will make this fun, but I'll be damned if I can see it right now

  • New Neutral Minion - Stoneborn General

    We can all see the deathrattle manipulators (Priest and Rogue, looking at you) really abusing this nasty sucker.  Even in Paladin with Cavalry Horn this would really suck for your opponent if they don't have an answer for it.  That's potentially 16 damage to your side of the board on minions you probably don't want to lose. 

  • New Neutral Minion - Muck Plumber

    This kind of disruption is probably the weakest. It feels like 1 star because the only time you'll ever see it is when it pops up randomly.