Great for both deathrattle and big-minion archetypes alike. Yes 10 mana seems like a lot, but there have been quite a few 10-mana cards that worked just fine, even in classes other than Druid. The thing they have in common is immediate board impact, and this guy has it twice. I think it's bound to see some play in competitive decks, so 4 stars.
I want to play this solely because there is a Barbarian ability in Pathfinder that lets you use another PC as an improvised weapon causing damage to both your target and whomever you used to bludgeon them with. Who knows... maybe you will get a Loot Hoarder tossed at their Colossus of the Moon. Then again, you could get Ozumat and just wipe their board.
Druid makes best use of it because of Guff, but even then you have the danger of pulling the other copy. I'll say 3 stars because mana cheat potential is strong, but downsides are equally strong.
Oh man I am looking forward to playing with this in Wild. Warrior has a lot of handbuff options available to it in recent sets that this would be a no-brainer for autoinclude in most builds
Sanguine Depths has a new best friend. T2 4/3 charging at you... sounds alright. a turn or two earlier than Kor'kron Elite, and requires a combo... but still decent.
That card is easier to get for 0 mana than Strongman, so it will see play for sure, atleast in control murloc shaman.
Strongman was good because it gave you a free big taunt after you'd spend all your mana on some big effect with no board impact.
This is a smallish lifesteal without initiative, which isn't nearly as good. However, Murloc synergy is already a thing these days, so I begrudgingly give it 4 stars.
If it weren't for pirates having innate lower health on average, this would be amazing. That being said, Pirate or Armor Warrior could run this to great effect. Either you had a few pirates die while this was in your hand, or some of your taunters died. Either way, you could infuse this rather quickly and get in at least one swing to bump up anything of yours that got hurt, but isn't dead. Also, could get your minions out of range of an Explosive Trap to be able to swing in.
This just has tons of control warrior players super happy. Of course yours are going to cost a little more on average. It can also give you a view into your opponent's deck and some of their strategy. Who cares if they see yours, if you're playing this... they know they have to be ready for the long haul anyway.
Probably one of the best cards in the game. Unironically.
Basically unless youre a control deck there's a good chance you'll be playing at least a minion a turn so this card is practically free after somewhere around 3-4 turns and with a 3/4 lifesteal body you'll get back a little tempo and some health.
This is not Corridor Creeper, by any stretch, but its really close. I expect to see plenty of this card.
I'm seeing this as a good card. If you're running Pirates with weapons, why not have another thing to swing in on your opponent. If they spend a turn casting a copy of the weapon, which they very well could play the next turn and punch you with it, that's mana that they can't use to thin out your side of the board... allowing you to go face... which is what Pirate Warrior does.
It could also be one of those situations where you don't care what dead cards they have in their hand, like if you play against Lightforged Cariel. They don't want to give up their The Immovable Object, so it clutters their hand.
For (2) mana, you get what you pay for. The hope of course is to have a board of Venomous Scorpids and you just annihilate their side. The reality is going to be more of a situation where you nettle down their forces by attrition and hopefully have a back up card to eliminate the rest of their minions.
Absolutely unplayable outside a very specific archetype. Even then, I can see choosing it from Amalgam when your totems are starting to snowball, but I'd hesitate to add it to the deck, so 2 stars.
OH gods I love this soooo much. The ability to remove a minion, albeit a random one, for the cost of a discard card you play is amazing. With Warlock having access to lots of mini-minion removal, you can easily combo out some removal with this. I'm looking forward to this
I've neve been so happy that Lightning Bloom got nerfed as when I saw this. The idea of this firing off super cheap/fast with some of the ways that Shaman has to get fatties on the board is gross.
I am really liking this totem support. Too bad there isn't a lot to make it ridiculous in standard, but in wild, this could be rather fun, especially with Even Shaman getting the Gigantotem
New Neutral Minion - Crooked Cook
Shadow Priest could benefit from that. I've gassed out with the deck so much that it hurts.
New Neutral Minion - Masked Reveler
Obvious deathrattle fodder, but it's so expensive! I can't give it more than 2 stars unless they drop that price tag.
New Neutral Minion - Invitation Courier
How will this work with Maestra of the Masquerade? If you drop this T2/3, and hope it doesn't die... will you be able to bump up your hand with it?
New Neutral Minion - Steamcleaner
I love it. Take that thief!
New Neutral Minion - Stoneborn General
Great for both deathrattle and big-minion archetypes alike. Yes 10 mana seems like a lot, but there have been quite a few 10-mana cards that worked just fine, even in classes other than Druid. The thing they have in common is immediate board impact, and this guy has it twice. I think it's bound to see some play in competitive decks, so 4 stars.
New Neutral Minion - Party Crasher
I want to play this solely because there is a Barbarian ability in Pathfinder that lets you use another PC as an improvised weapon causing damage to both your target and whomever you used to bludgeon them with. Who knows... maybe you will get a Loot Hoarder tossed at their Colossus of the Moon. Then again, you could get Ozumat and just wipe their board.
New Neutral Minion - Dinner Performer
Druid makes best use of it because of Guff, but even then you have the danger of pulling the other copy. I'll say 3 stars because mana cheat potential is strong, but downsides are equally strong.
New Warrior Minion - Anima Extractor
Oh man I am looking forward to playing with this in Wild. Warrior has a lot of handbuff options available to it in recent sets that this would be a no-brainer for autoinclude in most builds
New Warrior Minion - Crazed Wretch
Sanguine Depths has a new best friend. T2 4/3 charging at you... sounds alright. a turn or two earlier than Kor'kron Elite, and requires a combo... but still decent.
New Neutral Minion - Scuttlebutt Ghoul
Secret decks always need defensive options, and this is a good one, but it is terrible without the kicker, so 3 stars.
New Neutral Minion - Murlocula
Strongman was good because it gave you a free big taunt after you'd spend all your mana on some big effect with no board impact.
This is a smallish lifesteal without initiative, which isn't nearly as good. However, Murloc synergy is already a thing these days, so I begrudgingly give it 4 stars.
New Warrior Weapon - Imbued Axe
If it weren't for pirates having innate lower health on average, this would be amazing. That being said, Pirate or Armor Warrior could run this to great effect. Either you had a few pirates die while this was in your hand, or some of your taunters died. Either way, you could infuse this rather quickly and get in at least one swing to bump up anything of yours that got hurt, but isn't dead. Also, could get your minions out of range of an Explosive Trap to be able to swing in.
New Warrior Spell - Conqueror's Banner
This just has tons of control warrior players super happy. Of course yours are going to cost a little more on average. It can also give you a view into your opponent's deck and some of their strategy. Who cares if they see yours, if you're playing this... they know they have to be ready for the long haul anyway.
Murlocula is a New Castle Nathria Card Revealed by Ben Heathstone
Probably one of the best cards in the game. Unironically.
Basically unless youre a control deck there's a good chance you'll be playing at least a minion a turn so this card is practically free after somewhere around 3-4 turns and with a 3/4 lifesteal body you'll get back a little tempo and some health.
This is not Corridor Creeper, by any stretch, but its really close. I expect to see plenty of this card.
New Neutral Minion - Stoneborn Accuser
Steep infuse cost, but it does hit face, so 3 stars.
New Warrior Minion - Suspicious Pirate
I'm seeing this as a good card. If you're running Pirates with weapons, why not have another thing to swing in on your opponent. If they spend a turn casting a copy of the weapon, which they very well could play the next turn and punch you with it, that's mana that they can't use to thin out your side of the board... allowing you to go face... which is what Pirate Warrior does.
It could also be one of those situations where you don't care what dead cards they have in their hand, like if you play against Lightforged Cariel. They don't want to give up their The Immovable Object, so it clutters their hand.
New Neutral Minion - Creepy Painting
Seems great for deathrattle decks or big minion archetypes. A bit fiddly, though, so just 3 stars.
New Warrior Spell - Riot!
For (2) mana, you get what you pay for. The hope of course is to have a board of Venomous Scorpids and you just annihilate their side. The reality is going to be more of a situation where you nettle down their forces by attrition and hopefully have a back up card to eliminate the rest of their minions.
New Neutral Minion - Sinstone Totem
Absolutely unplayable outside a very specific archetype. Even then, I can see choosing it from Amalgam when your totems are starting to snowball, but I'd hesitate to add it to the deck, so 2 stars.
New Warlock Spell - Suffocating Shadows
OH gods I love this soooo much. The ability to remove a minion, albeit a random one, for the cost of a discard card you play is amazing. With Warlock having access to lots of mini-minion removal, you can easily combo out some removal with this. I'm looking forward to this
New Warlock Minion - Flustered Librarian
So I guess the Imp meta also includes past imps from previous expansions and Classic?
New Shaman Minion - Crud Caretaker
Evolve fodder... nothing too interesting to see here
New Shaman Spell - Criminal Lineup
I've neve been so happy that Lightning Bloom got nerfed as when I saw this. The idea of this firing off super cheap/fast with some of the ways that Shaman has to get fatties on the board is gross.
New Neutral Minion - Dredger Staff
Great for Buff Priest, maybe decent if Quest Paladin comes back. I give it 3 stars.
New Shaman Weapon - Carving Chisel
I am really liking this totem support. Too bad there isn't a lot to make it ridiculous in standard, but in wild, this could be rather fun, especially with Even Shaman getting the Gigantotem