So the problem here is that all the other mercs have gotten a lot of characterization even before their dedicated books. Cariel got a lot of character in Kurtrus' book, both Tavish and Scabbs, despite being relatively simple characters overall, have been quite well established in both Xyrella's and Kurtrus' book. Bru'kan is similarly established and Guff arguably received more characterization in all the other books rather than his own.
Meanwhile I barely know how I would describe Dawngrasp. I guess the best description would be the as an "academic" type, focussed on research and such? They come off as way more off a plot device than a character. They show up with Kazakus (for reasons not yet revealed) only to get captured by the Alliance and sent to Stormwind to kick off the Horde gang's journey there and then in Stormwind they're yet another plot device to help Scabbs break out of prison and later assist in the Deadmines.
Now it seems like they're going to be the big "uniter" against the greater evil and...I just don't buy it. From what we have so far Dawngrasp doesn't have the charisma to believably end the fucking race war. They're just...bland, which would be fine if they remained a supporting character with little personal agency (like Scabbs and Rokara to some extent) but when they are apparently the centerpiece of the grand finale...that just kinda worries me.
I think people are overrating Unstoppable Force. It's an arcanite reaper that you can either go face with, or you can use the 5 damage to hit a bigger minion into the opponet's face. It's a huge risk/reward card. (you still take the damage and either damage or kill the minion, but then the opponent takes the same amount of damage. I'm not sure if it's "great", but the hero power is half decent so I'm sure it will be in some decks.
I think it would have been better if it said "...in addition your hero is immune while attacking minions. But lower the damage of the weapon to 2 attack. That way the weapon is encouraged to be used as minion control/anti minion damage. And not just used as a weird arcanite reaper.
It has been confirmed by Bliz that Sketchy Information will summon a copy of Korrak. With Forsaken Lieutenant if you hit some with 3 attack it will summon a new Korrak
Well, he/she hasn't even received a book of Mercenaries chapter yet
general lack of contribution to the overall story.
That does not mean that he/she won't be important for the end. We know for example already that he/she spied out Kazakus and claims to know the true potential of the Naaru shards. There is certainly room for Varden to play a big role in the finale.
In fairness, we already saw them being happy to help Scabbs escape the Stockades and subsequently get the still-living Horde crew to help in the Deadmines. It sounds like they are just going to be continuing that role to get presumably Rokara and Tavish to look past their clans' fight for AV to deal with Onyxia and Kazakus. It even makes some sense that a blood elf mage would take that role, what with the blood elves previously being high elves and part of the Alliance of Lordaeron, and Dalaran being neutral, so I doubt Dawngrasp was ever invested in the whole Horde vs Alliance thing anyway.
None of that makes Dawngrasp "the most bestest and important character evarrrrr UWU"; it just makes them rational. Besides, the flavour text says "for one who", not "for THE one who", so it is quite likely Dawngrasp won't be alone in taking that stance. Given his own chapter, Scabbs is probably focused on Onyxia/the naaru shards rather than the faction war too, even if he's less naturally inclined to.
You’re finally awake! That fall looked really bad. Demon Hunters? Mercenaries? What are you talking about? Come on, I just unpacked a Golden Moorabi, let’s go build a Freeze Shaman deck.
Pretty interesting deathrattle legendary that will see some experimentation. It's quite the funny that this card will be good if the honorable kill mechanic is bad and vice versa. It's not that threatening though being a 3/5, so probably won't be too annoying
This + Saidan the Scarlet will be bonkers and probably a reno heal if you went greedy on all the hand buffs. Considering all the big minions paladin got this expansion, it's a good thing the lifesteal lasts 1 turn
Magister is a humble title for one who united warring armies against the greatest threat to Azeroth.
Please tell me they're not gonna make Dawngrasp "the most bestest and important character evarrrrr UWU" after 6 books of barely any characterization and general lack of contribution to the overall story.
So this minion basically pays for itself, if you draw the 3 cost spell, you're technically getting a zero cost 3/1 + specific spell tutor. You can also build your deck to have a certain number of spells, or maybe some crazy combo OTK deck will arise that we haven't thought about yet.
I've been fairly busy with stuff, so I haven't had that much time to do anything here. Least I can do is give you guys my thoughts on your stuff. I will likely be trying to find a new card design altogether if I can.
Wailor
Well I can see you've already submitted. Your card is pretty good though, so I can see it doing pretty well.
AeroJulwin
Inspiring Ballad is fine. I definitely prefer Pied Piper.
Linkblade91
Pretty good new rendition of ETC. Nightfall feels significantly worse than the other two, though I guess that's just sort of on flavor with the original ETC with how Power of the Horde was by far the worst of the original Power Chords.
Anchorm4n
I love myself a good Metallica pun and I think you've good yourself a good card right here.
Nirast
A fun idea, but there's absolutely a way to break this. I'm not sure what that way is yet, but someone is going to find one. The artwork is not too great either unfortunately.
Contrary to what other people are saying, the card doesn't need to specifically exclude itself since Discover cards can no longer Discover themselves anyway.
Arkasaur
An'she Mythsinger is a fun idea, but it definitely can get abused quickly. Reverberating Hymn is balanced, but these types of basic designs don't usually do so well unless there's some type of specific aspect to them.
Fedrion
A fine idea on paper, but I do agree that spending 5 mana on one spell that doesn't do anything (unless you control multiple Secrets) does not seem like the way to go for Hunter. You might be able to get away with doing that in a class like Priest or Warrior, but definitely not Hunter.
It is also a little bit weird to be a Scholomance card given that Scholomance didn't contain any Secrets or synergy cards for them in Hunter.
Can you stop with making the same incessant post please? 1) This isn't the place to complain about that. You think blizzard devs look at the OOC card reveals for feedback? 2) It doesn't really contribute to anything. 3) Copy/pasting the same comment to 3 threads is just spamming.
It had to be said ; get creative! “True strength comes from within your deck” is a whole lot less inspiring.
All Card Flavor Text for Hearthstone's Fractured in Alterac Valley Expansion Which Releases December 7
So the problem here is that all the other mercs have gotten a lot of characterization even before their dedicated books. Cariel got a lot of character in Kurtrus' book, both Tavish and Scabbs, despite being relatively simple characters overall, have been quite well established in both Xyrella's and Kurtrus' book. Bru'kan is similarly established and Guff arguably received more characterization in all the other books rather than his own.
Meanwhile I barely know how I would describe Dawngrasp. I guess the best description would be the as an "academic" type, focussed on research and such? They come off as way more off a plot device than a character. They show up with Kazakus (for reasons not yet revealed) only to get captured by the Alliance and sent to Stormwind to kick off the Horde gang's journey there and then in Stormwind they're yet another plot device to help Scabbs break out of prison and later assist in the Deadmines.
Now it seems like they're going to be the big "uniter" against the greater evil and...I just don't buy it. From what we have so far Dawngrasp doesn't have the charisma to believably end the fucking race war. They're just...bland, which would be fine if they remained a supporting character with little personal agency (like Scabbs and Rokara to some extent) but when they are apparently the centerpiece of the grand finale...that just kinda worries me.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Warden of Chains
It really speaks to the level of powercreep when a 4 mana 3/8 taunt (situational) is considered bad. Oh how far we've fallen.
All Card Flavor Text for Hearthstone's Fractured in Alterac Valley Expansion Which Releases December 7
Sacrificial Summoner
A Fullmetal Alchemist reference.
New Demon Hunter Spell - Field of Strife
Definitely one of the weaker and also most uninspiring designed landmark card we've seen so far.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Flag Runner
It's stickier than flesh-eating ghoul but requires more setup. May be decent in arena but for now I'm writing it off.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Battleworn Vanguard
Slightly better than umberwing since it can synergize with your base hero power. May see play in aggro/token decks.
All Card Flavor Text for Hearthstone's Fractured in Alterac Valley Expansion Which Releases December 7
I did know that Sacrificial Summoner relates to Dr.Boom...
All Card Flavor Text for Hearthstone's Fractured in Alterac Valley Expansion Which Releases December 7
just can't wait to start opening my 145 card packs!
New Demon Hunter Weapon - Dreadprison Glaive
Bad weapon card considering alternates that DH has available. May see next rotation.
New Warrior Spell - Iceblood Garrison
Whirlwind on every turn will be very useful to stop aggro and make use of enrage mechanic
New Warrior Hero - Rokara, the Valorous
I think people are overrating Unstoppable Force. It's an arcanite reaper that you can either go face with, or you can use the 5 damage to hit a bigger minion into the opponet's face. It's a huge risk/reward card. (you still take the damage and either damage or kill the minion, but then the opponent takes the same amount of damage. I'm not sure if it's "great", but the hero power is half decent so I'm sure it will be in some decks.
I think it would have been better if it said "...in addition your hero is immune while attacking minions. But lower the damage of the weapon to 2 attack. That way the weapon is encouraged to be used as minion control/anti minion damage. And not just used as a weird arcanite reaper.
New Neutral Minion - Korrak the Bloodrager
What about Xyrella, the Devout?
New Warrior Minion - Axe Berserker
It has vanilla stats, if you can't activate the honor kill it doesn't do anything. Not very useful imho
All Card Flavor Text for Hearthstone's Fractured in Alterac Valley Expansion Which Releases December 7
Well, he/she hasn't even received a book of Mercenaries chapter yet
That does not mean that he/she won't be important for the end. We know for example already that he/she spied out Kazakus and claims to know the true potential of the Naaru shards. There is certainly room for Varden to play a big role in the finale.
New Warrior Minion - Glory Chaser
Very good for the old quest warrior in wild, gives him an additional value now
All Card Flavor Text for Hearthstone's Fractured in Alterac Valley Expansion Which Releases December 7
In fairness, we already saw them being happy to help Scabbs escape the Stockades and subsequently get the still-living Horde crew to help in the Deadmines. It sounds like they are just going to be continuing that role to get presumably Rokara and Tavish to look past their clans' fight for AV to deal with Onyxia and Kazakus. It even makes some sense that a blood elf mage would take that role, what with the blood elves previously being high elves and part of the Alliance of Lordaeron, and Dalaran being neutral, so I doubt Dawngrasp was ever invested in the whole Horde vs Alliance thing anyway.
None of that makes Dawngrasp "the most bestest and important character evarrrrr UWU"; it just makes them rational. Besides, the flavour text says "for one who", not "for THE one who", so it is quite likely Dawngrasp won't be alone in taking that stance. Given his own chapter, Scabbs is probably focused on Onyxia/the naaru shards rather than the faction war too, even if he's less naturally inclined to.
All Card Flavor Text for Hearthstone's Fractured in Alterac Valley Expansion Which Releases December 7
This is incredibile.
New Warrior Spell - Shield Shatter
A very strong combo with Frozen Buckler, maybe 2 card combo doesn't seem very attractive but it's only 2 mana.
5 aoe for 2 mana y just crazy
New Neutral Minion - Korrak the Bloodrager
Pretty interesting deathrattle legendary that will see some experimentation. It's quite the funny that this card will be good if the honorable kill mechanic is bad and vice versa. It's not that threatening though being a 3/5, so probably won't be too annoying
New Paladin Spell - Hold the Bridge
This + Saidan the Scarlet will be bonkers and probably a reno heal if you went greedy on all the hand buffs. Considering all the big minions paladin got this expansion, it's a good thing the lifesteal lasts 1 turn
All Card Flavor Text for Hearthstone's Fractured in Alterac Valley Expansion Which Releases December 7
Please tell me they're not gonna make Dawngrasp "the most bestest and important character evarrrrr UWU" after 6 books of barely any characterization and general lack of contribution to the overall story.
New Paladin Minion - Stonehearth Vindicator
So this minion basically pays for itself, if you draw the 3 cost spell, you're technically getting a zero cost 3/1 + specific spell tutor. You can also build your deck to have a certain number of spells, or maybe some crazy combo OTK deck will arise that we haven't thought about yet.
Battle Of The Bards - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I've been fairly busy with stuff, so I haven't had that much time to do anything here. Least I can do is give you guys my thoughts on your stuff. I will likely be trying to find a new card design altogether if I can.
Well I can see you've already submitted. Your card is pretty good though, so I can see it doing pretty well.
A fun idea, but there's absolutely a way to break this. I'm not sure what that way is yet, but someone is going to find one. The artwork is not too great either unfortunately.
Contrary to what other people are saying, the card doesn't need to specifically exclude itself since Discover cards can no longer Discover themselves anyway.
A fine idea on paper, but I do agree that spending 5 mana on one spell that doesn't do anything (unless you control multiple Secrets) does not seem like the way to go for Hunter. You might be able to get away with doing that in a class like Priest or Warrior, but definitely not Hunter.
It is also a little bit weird to be a Scholomance card given that Scholomance didn't contain any Secrets or synergy cards for them in Hunter.
New Paladin Minion - Stonehearth Vindicator
It had to be said ; get creative!
“True strength comes from within your deck” is a whole lot less inspiring.
New Paladin Spell - Hold the Bridge
I was expecting no less from the flavor text :
