All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Card draw power creep is a major issue

    Quote From AngryShuckie
    Show Spoiler
    Quote From dapperdog

    …

    1) But I'd argue that its deliberate made that way by the devs, to increase interactivity (and therefore, subjectively, fun). Play a couple of games in classic and suddenly the game may be fairer (Lack of removals means more minion activity) but honestly unless you're specifically playing miracle rogue you're basically playing 1-2 cards per turn. The mechanics were simple, and there's very little reason to think because nearly everything is predictable: druid ramp on 2, zoo curvestone, turn 4 giant, etc.

    In order to break that cycle you have to either 1) increase the rate and efficiency of card draw, or 2) increase card generation. They balance that out by designing the cards with a lower statline or at a higher cost. So in effect you're trading tempo for card draw/generation.

     

    2) I wouldn't say that an increased in card draw efficiency makes the game less interesting. Looking at the meta in the earliest history of hearthstone and honestly, the games were fairly predictable and repetitive. The most extreme example would be to look at hunter's history. The early parts were entirely made up of face/midrange hunters that practically played nothing but curvestone. It was not until Master's Call was introduced that we had hunter actually playing off curve and keeping cards in hand for a bigger finish. Similarly shaman in barrens didn't really got anywhere until Primal Dungeoneer was introduced, which then proceed to make possible elemental shaman, doomhammer shaman, and arguably control shaman.

     

    3) We are moving towards a phase where the old definition of control can no longer exist because hearthstone has evolved past curvestone. And that's not necessarily a bad thing. The ultimate objective should be to keep the value just low enough that control decks can exist, but high enough to give decks stuff to do instead of having their stuff repeatedly removed from board every turn. In my view, the best meta should ideally be 50-50 no matter the archetype, and avoiding polarising rock-paper-scissors games.

    …

     

    4) That is…until we were given this freakish meta to exist in.

    …

     

    5) A small note: You referenced Primordial Explorer in the third paragraph, which I assume should be Primal Dungeoneer instead

    Responding to each point in turn:

    1)

    Show Spoiler

    I agree it was very likely deliberate, and I don't disagree with improving draw a bit, but I do think they have massively overshot what was necessary. I actually think priest's card draw is in a good and healthy spot right now it has some again, but it's the outlier. As with shaman a couple of months ago, it looks like it hasn't got much, only because everyone else has a tonne.

    Whether it increases interactivity is questionable though. If it mostly benefits aggro and combo, then where is the added interactivity in practice?

    Regarding the simple mechanics of Classic, I think that's an entirely separate matter. Part of why I disliked the Barrens meta was because it felt a lot like Classic in terms of its simplicity, and certainly not for lack of card draw. Meanwhile Hearthstone's history is riddled with fancy and interesting cards/effects that didn't need the amount of card draw we have today.

    As for the statline reduction - or lack thereof - that's arguably where a lot of power creep exists. Vanilla stats haven't moved an inch since Classic, but the stat cost associated with effects (not just card draw, but including it) has reduced significantly. Tempo loss for card draw is small to nonexistent these days, which is exactly why aggro and combo can afford to run so much of it.

     

    2)

    Show Spoiler

    Since you raise hunter, I would point out you have forgotten spell and big-beast-recruit hunter, both driven largely by K&C, and both existing before Master's Call arrived. Neither had much in the way of card draw, but they still functioned fine without taking the usual play-minions-on-curve route, partly because there wasn't such a strong need for card draw. The best anyone had was Elven Minstrel, so the amount needed to compete with other classes was far lower than what we have today. Master's Call helped bring (aggro) beast hunter back, but it wasn't required for hunter to be effective as a class. 

    This is why I think shaman's problem in Barrens was the amount of draw other classes had, rather than truly lacking any itself.

     

    3)

    Show Spoiler

    I agree a redefinition of 'control' isn't the end of the world, but it does come with problems. Whether we are talking about control as fatigue decks or in the more Classic sense where they actually had finishers, there's a large part of the playerbase that most enjoys those decks. Those players have already taken an in-game beating for the last 16 months, and while I can only speak for myself here, I'm coming to the end of my tether with it.

    The collateral damage to meme decks is huge too. These decks often only find success against slow control decks. If those are removed, then cool meme cards like Elwynn Boar might as well not exist.

    Idyllic as a perfect 50:50 win rate spread would be, there must always be some degree of rock-paper-scissors, because decks are built to counter other decks. We don't want things quite so polarising as OG quest rogue, but there should be some deviation from 50:50.

     

    4)

    Show Spoiler

    I fully acknowledge that card draw is only so good as the cards it draws, and it cannot be held solely responsible. Mana reduction and burst from hand are also playing a part that is greatly inflated compared to previous years. Those two again benefit aggro and combo over control. Both have been problematic over the years of course, with a lot of burst damage being sent to the Hall of Fame and mana cheating often being cited as a load of bs. 

    What really concerns me is the current design philosophy seems to be to push all 3 to extreme levels, which runs completely counter to the design philosophy of the past, which had been explicitly stated to limit burst damage, and was clearly much more reserved with draw and cost reductions.

    They might not be changing the core mechanics of the game, but between them they are completely changing what aggro, control and combo even mean. If aggro's not worrying about eking out every last bit of damage because it never runs out of cards, and if combo can play everything so fast it doesn't need to worry about its own survival, and is control doesn't even know what to do anymore, is it really still the same game?

    I'm sure lots of people like the changes in design philosophy, but for me it is committing to every design choice that undermines the reason I was playing in the first place. Neither Wild nor Standard really let me play out the shenanigans I log on for anymore, and Classic doesn't even have the cards to try it with. The really frustrating thing is that it isn't burnout. There's lots I want to try in Stormwind, but deep down I know I'd much rather be in any meta between TGT and SoU. (I'd include DoD if it didn't mean pre-nerf Galakrond shaman *shudder*.)

     

    5) Whoops, yes, thanks. It shows how much I use that card! I have now corrected it.

    Its taken me a while to respond back, mostly because Ive been a little busier than usual. But just comment on each of your points of response, to my original response to yours;

     

    1. Specifically on this point: "If it mostly benefits aggro and combo, then where is the added interactivity in practice?". If an aggro player can sustain a tempo reload against control up until turn 8 (which was fairly impossible back in the day), that's added interactivity as a result of card draw. Just because control players are forced to play one or two cards per turn up until then, that's not a signal that interaction has not been improved by increased card draw. Besides which, there are examples of control decks that benefited from the increased card draw/generation like control priest.

    Also, I stand by my opinion about the tempo loss tradeoff with card draw/generation cards. You are right in pointing out that effects have been added into the vanilla statline, but I'd argue where card draw/generation are concerned this is not exactly true. Most card draw options have either slightly downgraded stats or are conditional because whereby they aren't it tends to create polarisations, like Voracious Reader for 2 mana, Skull of Gul'dan for 5, etc.

    Which is why Im all for some nerfs to mage simply because Cram Session and Refreshing Spring Water are specifically making the meta unbearable, because the card draw is insane and the conditions non-existent. Outside of these though, most cards draws are either conditional, at a high mana cost (like Overflow), or comes with a tempo loss.

     

    2. This is not really relevant to the conversation, but I'd like to point out that outside of DK rexxar, deathrattle hunter before Master's Call was mostly a midrange deck. But of course, its not a strictly aggressive one, so you have me on that.

    Also, shaman's problem is not strong card draw from other classes. Ive played doomhammer shaman before the midset, and it was honestly card draw that's the problem, because if I have the god hand I just win, so it was never about other classes' reload factor, it was about shaman's own inconsistent gameplan execution.

     

    3 & 4 and conclusion

     

    Here's the thing: I don't think its preferable for there to be decks which plays nothing but removals with the win condition being solely attrition. Its even worse when these are the top decks in the meta (control warrior, odd warrior etc.). Curbing the card draw powercreep may help improve their game, but its not necessarily going to make the game fun. Its better, in my view, for control decks to actually have a win condition rather than fill their decks with reactive cards. Control shaman in barrens in a good example of that, being able to control the pace of the early game, while packing a win condition (al'akir + multiple nightmares, or headmaster keltuzad + perpetual flame) of its own.

    On the viability of meme decks, I will reiterate what I have said plenty of times, and is reflective in my own deck building philosophy: Everything you build must take into consideration of the current meta. And if aggro is commonplace, and your deck falls to that, it might be better to adapt by playing more anti-aggro tools like taunts. But bear in mind that the win rate will suck either way. You can't build a deck to meme out Elwynn Boar, then complain about the aggro decks farming you. That's exactly why its a meme deck: its a deck made entirely for fun, not for wins. If it were consistently winning, it wouldn't be a meme deck.

    I do sympathize with players who wishes to play more for meme than rank, but I feel its a little hypocritical to trumpet in favor of control decks - simply because it makes meme decks more viable.

    Also, I'd like to agree with meisterz39's assessment. In metas where attrition based control were prominent, it was mostly an awful experience. I like slower games myself, and was gleefully playing control bomb warrior before the last rotation, and was playing lots of control priest in the early parts of the barrens meta. But whenever I face up against a mirror match I often find myself silently praying my opponent just t1 concedes. And I think this is a general sentiment towards control decks in the community.

  • First Look at Hearthstone's Battlegrounds New Interface for Cosmetic Heroes and Bartenders

    Might be for streamers.

  • Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem

    The Demon Seed is an absolute menace in Wild, which is pretty unfortunate. But as far as Standard is concerned, my "scalding hot take" is that I actually think it's a brilliantly designed quest. It's a single card that enables a combo archetype focused on Free Admission to tutor out Stealer of Souls/Darkglare/Nightshade Matron, an aggro archetype focused on high tempo self harm cards like Flame Imp to cheat out Flesh Giant, and a control archetype that leverages Soul Rend and Altar of Fire for board clears and disruption respectively, with fatigue as a win con for control mirrors. It's true that not all of those decks are equally successful right now (nor should they be), but all of these archetypes can find ways to use this quest, and I think that's honestly really cool.

    To the extent that Quest Zoolock is too powerful right now in Standard, I'm not convinced Flesh Giant is the right target for a nerf. It's a dual-class card, making it less likely to see a nerf anyway, but as powerful as getting a cheap 8/8 is, it's not unstoppable. Any deck that wants to can tech in Big Game Hunter to clear it before it does anything, and there are lots of class-specific answers as well. The real problem, as others have pointed out, is that Battleground Battlemaster's drawback (being a slightly understated 5-drop) is too small a drawback to make it bad. Compare it to Windspeaker - a card that saw very little play - and it's a neutral card with double the effect of a class card for one extra mana. (Obviously it's slightly different - one effect is permanent, the other is an aura, but granting windfury rarely matters beyond a single turn anyway.) I think the only fix for the card would be to drive up the cost - probably to 7 or 8.

  • Satisfied Squirrel

    Great artwork.

  • Mailbox Dancer

    Great artwork.

  • Heavy Plate

    Great artwork.

  • Cowardly Grunt

    I love the little wobble he does.

  • Pizza Stone

    Is this the only card back without an animation?

  • Ragnaros

    My first card back.

  • Cupcake

    This used to be my default before the random one.

  • Random

    My default.

  • Stormwind's First Wild Deck Weekend Spotlight - Burgle Rogue, Highlander Demon Hunter, Divine Shield Paladin, & More

    Awesome seeing Maestra of the Masquerade up there. I theory crafted a similar idea of using Wyrmrest Purifier. Was so fun, but I went very greedy keeping almost all neutral minions in deck. Really fun deck overall. I'll try out this better version for sure.

  • [Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)

    Not a minion... Also lucent and bark don't pass the synonym test

  • Quest Hate

    I really wish I could get back all the money I've wasted on this game, and especially this expansion. Thanks Team5, for just straight up killing all of my enjoyment  with your lazy, untested garbage quest. I swear, they must have played one game with it against an aggro hunter that drew the nuts and just decided it was too slow to see play. Sigh,  fuck this shit, man, I need to learn to like a different game.

  • [Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)

  • [Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)

    Good guess because similar mechanic

  • [Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)

  • Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf

    yeah cause is so interesting dying on  6-7  by 20 damage while you where was still figuring out your build

  • Darkseeker's channel - 13th November update: KOtsosKOtsos' Reno Evolve Shudderwock Shaman - ft. Archivist Elysiana

    8th August update: WILD Aggro Pirate Priest, 7-0 run to Legend, ft. Shadowed Spirit!

    Another video on aggro Priest. This deck got me to legend!

    Stats: 7-0. My most efficient (lucky) run to legend ever.

    It is different to the Boltzmann deck that I played a couple of days ago.

    From my experience so far:

    - Shadowed Spirit felt like a cool inclusion.
    - Not sure about Void Shard?
    - This deck does not run Shadow Visions or Thrive in the Shadows - I did not miss those spells.
    - Ship's Canon never saw play... and so I wonder, is it needed?

    Credit to SinisterMe for making aware of this deck: https://twitter.com/Sinister_Me_/status/1424087028770222083 

    Original deck / deck idea from Goku.

    Deck code: AAEBAZ/HAgKRvAK79wMOoQTUBeUHkQ/7D+mwA7q2A5vNA9fOA6HoA/T2A4j3A6P3A633AwA=

    https://youtu.be/-AuwVbK1wgk 

  • Hearthstone Dueling in Stormwind - 12-Win Duel Decks to Take to Battle

    Congratulations!

  • [Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)

    It's a newer card

  • [Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)

  • Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem

    Care the explain why every time you deign to comment on a thread you go out of your way to thumb down every comment above you? You're in need of some serious forum etiquette learning.

  • Hearthstone Access - A New Mod Improves Accessibility for Blind and Visually Impaired Players

    I haven't done much Windows development, could a bot not send mouse events to the game while it is in the background? Using the mod to send keyboard events would mean that it wouldn't have to know the precise position of UI elements.

    It would also be able to get all the information it needs from the gameplay logs. Sure they default to disabled, but turning them on is pretty simple.

    As for reaching Legend, even if the bot only knows how to play a single deck, how many situations would the bot need to know how to respond to in order to maintain a 50%+ winrate, especially after D5? I'm assuming your account didn't start with a 13 star bonus in this scenario.

    Edit: I just remembered machine learning was a thing, like those AI that play SC2 at Grandmaster level. I don't know about reaching Legend in a couple of days given the amount of time that would probably be spent trying random shit before it learns what works, and all the RNG shit the game throws at you might be another layer of complexity.

  • Darkseeker's channel - 13th November update: KOtsosKOtsos' Reno Evolve Shudderwock Shaman - ft. Archivist Elysiana

    8th August update: Oakijak's Even Tax Paladin: Nerub'ar Weblord and Far Watch Post MVP!

    Warlock must pay their taxes. The tax man ALWAYS collects. A wonderful off-meta deck from Oakijak: Even Tax Paladin. Nerub'ar Weblord and Far Watch Post were the MVP cards!

    Deck code: AAEBAZ8FBrnBAs30Ao22A/y4A4XeA9j5AwzLBbEIiA7qD98U+NICnewClrYDysED9+gDmp8E1qAEAA==

    https://youtu.be/CJfmrq86erE