You say 54% chance of seeing one copy of these cards by turn 1, then in the next sentence it's 46%.
I realized I have no clue how to calculate that. I figure going first in the mulligan since one slot is taken by the questline, that's 4/29, then 4/28, and if you toss those 2, then 4/27, then 4/26. Finally, 4/27 again to draw at the start of turn 1. If I add those together I get 73%, and multiplying gets me some ridiculously tiny number.
No Quest deck should run this over Venomous Scorpid. While one may think "wow, Quest synergy, must include", Scorpid is just a better card. A 3/4 that's only active for some of the game or an infinite/3 that always gets you a spell. The choice is obvious.
I feel people are really underestimating Primordial Protector in this deck. It's a tutor for your 7 drop AND for the reward, and it fulfils one of the requirements. You'll need to go off-curve if you go this route, but I'm not sure it matters, especially since you'll rarely be at the final step exactly on 7 mana.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Irebound Brute
I mean it is way too situational, even in DH that draws a lot it will be clunky probably
New Hunter Minion - Stormwind Piper
No, don't see it doint much of anything at al
Questing in Stormwind - Better Understanding Paladin's Rise to the Occasion Legendary Questline
You say 54% chance of seeing one copy of these cards by turn 1, then in the next sentence it's 46%.
I realized I have no clue how to calculate that. I figure going first in the mulligan since one slot is taken by the questline, that's 4/29, then 4/28, and if you toss those 2, then 4/27, then 4/26. Finally, 4/27 again to draw at the start of turn 1. If I add those together I get 73%, and multiplying gets me some ridiculously tiny number.
New Neutral Minion - Entrapped Sorceress
This is deckbuilding bait.
No Quest deck should run this over Venomous Scorpid. While one may think "wow, Quest synergy, must include", Scorpid is just a better card. A 3/4 that's only active for some of the game or an infinite/3 that always gets you a spell. The choice is obvious.
New Hunter Spell - Devouring Swarm
Interesting removal and value card...
New Shaman Minion - Spirit Alpha
Sounds nice, but then you think about it and it doesn't sound nice
New Rogue Minion - SI:7 Assassin
Hm interesting Vilespine Slayer but only works in specific deck
New Rogue Spell - Find the Imposter
Decent quest but not as good as some other
New Warrior Minion - Cowardly Grunt
card doesn't have synergy with itself, so there is a bit of problem there
New Priest Minion - Psyfiend
weird, but can be ok in shadow priest
New Neutral Minion - Lady Prestor
Fun but way too incosistent of effect
New Neutral Minion - Nobleman
yeah randomness on this one makes it not so good
New Rogue Minion - SI:7 Informant
it is no edwin, but good enough in questline deck
New Demon Hunter Minion - Felgorger
Tutor or just fel DH support, decent
New Druid Spell - Sow the Soil
it is decent as token druid finisher, health is not always important
New Demon Hunter Spell - Fel Barrage
it might line up sometimes in interesting ways
New Priest Spell - Elekk Mount
I think you might want to run this for various reasons
New Demon Hunter Weapon - Lion's Frenzy
well DH draws often enough for this to work in some decks
New Rogue Minion - SI:7 Operative
Questline fodder, and decent card overall
New Paladin Minion - Alliance Bannerman
Decent card, I can see this working
New Warrior Minion - Cargo Guard
Interesting spin on usage of pirates, but it makes controly spin on pirate package possible
New Shaman Spell - Investment Opportunity
Maybe just maybe, but probably not, not impactful enough
New Rogue Minion - Loan Shark
Nah way too hard to use properly
New Neutral Minion - Encumbered Pack Mule
Maybe some decks want this, but nothing to write home about
Questing in Stormwind - Better Understanding Priest's Seek Guidance Legendary Questline
I feel people are really underestimating Primordial Protector in this deck. It's a tutor for your 7 drop AND for the reward, and it fulfils one of the requirements. You'll need to go off-curve if you go this route, but I'm not sure it matters, especially since you'll rarely be at the final step exactly on 7 mana.