All Comments

we definitely need more elementals for it to be consistent 

I hope this works in demonhunter

If spell only will still be played this can be good

Mysterious Challenger, is that you?

Joking aside, I definitely don't think this will be as strong as our mysterious friend, but it might be a fun to try out secret paladin for a bit again.  I'm most curious to see what other potential interactions there will be, such as if you can silence the soldiers to prevent it from returning as a secret, or if you can play a secret while the same secret is currently a soldier (I would assume yes, but you know what they say about assuming).

It's no secret that I like cards that become more useful later in the game.  I'm not crazy about the fact that the effect is applied at random, but I guess that's the price that you pay for a pretty good power level.

Great card for making secrets work efficiently

Seems very interesting. Difficult to evaluate a mechanic we've never seen before, but I don't think a board of 3/3s is ever that bad...

That will super bum me, and a number of other people out as well, if they have to wait to do a pre-release for the day before.  That seem so stupid

It doesn't matter how bad paladin secrets are if you can cast them for free.  It's like a weaker, slower mysterious champion.  The plus side is that this comes out much sooner, which could be a really nice way to start off the match.

Needs some buff before being dropped

All aboard the fishy caravan!

Lot's of people talking about regular draw like the Warlock legendary, not so many people talking about the incredible synergy with Shadowstep, Tenwu of the Red Smoke, Secret Passage, and Field Contact. Combine those with Scabbs Cutterbutter and Efficient Octo-bot and you got the makings of a new Miracle Rogue.

nice art, bad card

A basic cheap murloc, indispensable!

Card draw in hunter is nice, but the fact that it's somewhat targeted could be good or bad.  At the very least it helps thin out the deck, which in the late game could be a godsend, even if the cards that it actually draws aren't all that amazing.

This is pretty amazing really.  Rogue tends to suffer from the dings that you take when attacking with face and from a lack of healing.  With Kingsbane in wild this has the potential to be absolutely brutal!

too conditional  to see play

This type of Secret doesn't worked in the past for paladin

Given the name, I wish this stole a card from your opponent's hand.  Regardless, it's not a bad card, although how useful it is will depend on what hero powers you're offered.

a fine card, nothing more 

Another shaman murloc.  This one is pretty good.  Reminiscent of Possessed Villager, but with better stats and tribal synergy.  Me likey!  Plus it doesn't hurt that this little guy is "totes adorbs".

Holy spell draw, Batman!  The card draw is nice, especially for one mana.  The first thing I want to do with this card is find a way to abuse the targeted tutoring effect to draw the exact card that I want.  Unfortunately, I'm having a hard time thinking of a paladin holy spell that has a lot of abuse potential.

pretty good sticky card 

won't see play

Good stats for the cost, and a good effect.  If you're playing an elemental deck, I'd say this is an auto include.  Not quite on the level of Fire Fly, but definitely not a bad card.