Okay, thank y'all so much for your amazing feedback! Here is the new draft of my card:
Let's explain the changes I made: First of all I changed the art, as someone pointed out it wasn't rogue-ish enough. This led to me changing the whole flavour and putting it into the RoS-expansion. I really like that change though. A thief that calls their friends after finding out where the loot is seems extremely logical. Also I changed the 2/2 to a 2/1 to make it a bit weaker. I was thinking about doing that from the start, but I didn't want it to be bad as a standalone card without synergy. About the 'infinite value': I totally agree. I'm thinking about turning it into three copies, to make hand size an even more limiting cap, but that sounds extremely op for the cost (as hand size is defo not a problem that early in the game). What do you think?
I'm extremely happy with the design now though, thank you so much again for your help :)
I see the 1 Guardian Augmerchant, seems like a "I need filler", have you tried Grand Lackey Erkh? Seems like it might be a bit more Value since you're running a Lackey package in the deck.
She was already a free Hero, but getting her was unnecessarily hard/annoying. So it's pretty cool from the Devs to make this Skin easily available to Everyone.
Only older Burgle support cards do this. As of Rise of Shadows, Burgle cards now add cards from just any random class that isn't what you're currently playing.
A thank you, I left just before Boomsday and came back about a month ago so I didn't know they changed it. But yeah it does fit according to Witchwood
Just another consideration to add to this discussion - I'm pretty sure some of the chat at the beginning of year of the Phoenix was that team 5 would be introducing a new mode that will capitalise on your old/unused/wild cards. Might be worth hanging off until we know more about that, if you can
I'm not a fan at all of Sump Dredger: sure, 4/3 sounds great on paper but in practice it usually just ends up trading poorly, and that discard requirement can make it super awkward. I'd much rather have Mystic Shot.
Another card you should consider is Transfusion: I know it doesn't look as impressive as Brother's Bond since its only temporary, but in practice you can often save you Draven / Jinx which is huge.
The only caveat is there feasibly could be a day they do a huge overhaul in wild and buff a lot of unplayable cards to add hype to the game. However that will be no time soon if ever
Every hero is at least a bit sarcastic or passive aggressive, but at least Nemsy can be interpreted as being friendly. The trouble with Gul'dan is that he is really good at portraying the character of Gul'dan, which is great provided you want to sound like an arrogant villain.
It seems Morgl is the most popular. I found some new art and gave him a new name to fit.
Show Spoiler
I am not 100% satisfied with the art, but it was all I could find. If anybody else has anything better I would be very grateful. What do you think?
More Feedback:
@Xarkkal, Your card kind of reminds me of Ball of Spiders. It is a lot of mana to summon small minions. I think you could reduce it's cost to 4 or 5 and be okay.
I had originally put it at 5-mana comparing it to Call to Arms, but then had concerns about the very likely highroll of pulling 3 Carnassa's Broods. Which would be the same as draw 3 cards and summon three 3/2's, which is pretty strong even for 6 mana.
I also ideally wanted this to cost 6-mana so it would fit in on-curve with [Hearthstone Card (Queen Carnassas) Not Found].
Definitely struggling to find the ideal balance on this one.
As for your card, much better with some different art. My only complaint is how small he is, depending on resolution and how you can get it to fit in the oval, you might want to play with zooming in on the photo at least a little bit.
Nemsy Necrofizzle is FREE in the Hearthstone Shop for a Limited Time
To be fair, I never bothered and simply spoofed my location to get her back when she was 1st released, but fair point.
Two Quests Are Better Than One - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Okay, thank y'all so much for your amazing feedback!
Here is the new draft of my card:
Let's explain the changes I made:
First of all I changed the art, as someone pointed out it wasn't rogue-ish enough. This led to me changing the whole flavour and putting it into the RoS-expansion. I really like that change though. A thief that calls their friends after finding out where the loot is seems extremely logical.
Also I changed the 2/2 to a 2/1 to make it a bit weaker. I was thinking about doing that from the start, but I didn't want it to be bad as a standalone card without synergy.
About the 'infinite value': I totally agree. I'm thinking about turning it into three copies, to make hand size an even more limiting cap, but that sounds extremely op for the cost (as hand size is defo not a problem that early in the game). What do you think?
I'm extremely happy with the design now though, thank you so much again for your help :)
Datamined Details on Hearthstone's Black Temple Adventure Boss Fights - 17 Bosses to Fight, Demon Hunter Allies
Ok, here is what I think. We defeat MJ, then boom! Mecha-thun!
New Lackey Zoo [4/20 Nerfs]
I see the 1 Guardian Augmerchant, seems like a "I need filler", have you tried Grand Lackey Erkh? Seems like it might be a bit more Value since you're running a Lackey package in the deck.
Nemsy Necrofizzle is FREE in the Hearthstone Shop for a Limited Time
She was already a free Hero, but getting her was unnecessarily hard/annoying. So it's pretty cool from the Devs to make this Skin easily available to Everyone.
Two Quests Are Better Than One - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
A thank you, I left just before Boomsday and came back about a month ago so I didn't know they changed it. But yeah it does fit according to Witchwood
Two Quests Are Better Than One - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thanks, I'll change it up tomorrow. :)
Two Quests Are Better Than One - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I like the effect, although I see one problem.
The art is already taken. Cryomancer.
Two Quests Are Better Than One - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
My first template. I would really appreciate any positive and negative feedback on this.
Disenchant trash tier (and other) legendaries?
Just another consideration to add to this discussion - I'm pretty sure some of the chat at the beginning of year of the Phoenix was that team 5 would be introducing a new mode that will capitalise on your old/unused/wild cards. Might be worth hanging off until we know more about that, if you can
Two Quests Are Better Than One - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Edit: Found the answer thanks
Legends of Runeterra Patches Move Away From Treating Mobile Players Like Second-Class Citizens Unlike its Competitor Hearthstone
You'd never want a refund in LoR since you'll have all the cards
Draven+jinx
I'm not a fan at all of Sump Dredger: sure, 4/3 sounds great on paper but in practice it usually just ends up trading poorly, and that discard requirement can make it super awkward. I'd much rather have Mystic Shot.
Another card you should consider is Transfusion: I know it doesn't look as impressive as Brother's Bond since its only temporary, but in practice you can often save you Draven / Jinx which is huge.
Disenchant trash tier (and other) legendaries?
And tavern brawls :)
Nemsy Necrofizzle is FREE in the Hearthstone Shop for a Limited Time
Every hero is at least a bit sarcastic or passive aggressive, but at least Nemsy can be interpreted as being friendly. The trouble with Gul'dan is that he is really good at portraying the character of Gul'dan, which is great provided you want to sound like an arrogant villain.
Datamined Details on Hearthstone's Black Temple Adventure Boss Fights - 17 Bosses to Fight, Demon Hunter Allies
Any reward known ?
Nemsy Necrofizzle is FREE in the Hearthstone Shop for a Limited Time
Oh this is great, I've wanted Nemsy ever since they added her, but there was no way for me to get to a fireside gathering to obtain her.
Bug in the new update
It's probably because they haven't updated yet.
Nemsy Necrofizzle is FREE in the Hearthstone Shop for a Limited Time
Time to play warlock and get that 500 win :)
Datamined Details on Hearthstone's Black Temple Adventure Boss Fights - 17 Bosses to Fight, Demon Hunter Allies
I believe you will be playing as Aranna.
Two Quests Are Better Than One - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I had originally put it at 5-mana comparing it to Call to Arms, but then had concerns about the very likely highroll of pulling 3 Carnassa's Broods. Which would be the same as draw 3 cards and summon three 3/2's, which is pretty strong even for 6 mana.
I also ideally wanted this to cost 6-mana so it would fit in on-curve with [Hearthstone Card (Queen Carnassas) Not Found].
Definitely struggling to find the ideal balance on this one.
As for your card, much better with some different art. My only complaint is how small he is, depending on resolution and how you can get it to fit in the oval, you might want to play with zooming in on the photo at least a little bit.
Datamined Details on Hearthstone's Black Temple Adventure Boss Fights - 17 Bosses to Fight, Demon Hunter Allies
So what's Aranna's deal?
is she a reward for completing the adventure?
June's Card Back Revealed - Mystic Forest
this is a nice lookign card back really dig it
Nemsy Necrofizzle is FREE in the Hearthstone Shop for a Limited Time
Well she is very friendly but in sarcastic way, but she is my favorite warlock skin and I did go to a few firesides so I have her.
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
Backroom Bouncer?