I'll probably go with Gunslinger, as it's the generally preferred option. People seem to be very divided regarding its flavor, so here are two alternate names for it:
Quick Draw is a middle ground that keeps some wild west flavor while also being more generic than Gunslinger.
Swift, on the other hand, goes all the way in the flavor-agnostic direction.
Keep in mind I still plan for all the cards to be wild west themed (I designed it as an expansion exclusive keyword, after all)
Its another rainbow DK card. But this card has immense potential, given that the meta will likely be slower.
There are some good things to hit like Gnome Muncher, or Nerubian Swarmguard, but I feel that 3 mana do nothing is perhaps a tad too slow for most metas to be consistent.
Ive played Blood Tap decks and those were solid, but blood tap is substantially better being only 2 mana whereas this card is 3 mana, and less consistent, but does enable you to play rainbow instead of BBU. I think at the end its likely only good in this one expansion, before fading away to irrelevance.
Given that the game would be slower because of rotation there's a small possibility that this card gets some sort of attention.
But likely its just too slow, and too conditional. If any of the many 'discover a spell' minion like Venomous Scorpid or Vulpera Scoundrel comes back to standard this card loses any sort of niche it can ever have.
I seriously dont know what shaman will be doing next expansion, given how the class more or less got destroyed in the last patch.
Whatever it is, unless elemental shaman comes back or at least there being more elemental synergy this card is trash. Comparable to stuff like Gyreworm, a decent card in a tribal deck but cant breathe outside of it.
Fun addition to Wild Menagerie Warrior which has gotten quite some support over the last year (Mistake and Hookfist-3000 being the most recent examples). It's probably still too fair to be considered meta relevant, but if you get out a Ringmaster's Baton early, things can get spicy.
Its not a blood control card, more like a card for rainbow DK.
There's some good things about this card. Firstly, its guaranteed to make a minion even if its oozed away. And secondly, gaining health (or losing it) is not exactly hard for any DK that plays at least one blood rune.
Best case scenario is playing this on curve and getting a 4/4 on turn 4-5. Not too bad for a 3 mana card that does 6 damage.
Solid card for DK. Too bad its restricted only to likely 1-2 decks at most.
Assuming you can trigger this easily on 4, its not a bad minion in of itself.
But its spiritual predecessor Oil Rig Ambusher had a better statline and is more consistent. But it saw no play even when barrens were first introduced. Granted that then there wasn't any synergy with combo cards.
The main problem would be figuring out where this card actually fits into. Since both draka and Sinstone Graveyard will still be in standard, its never going into any miracle builds, and tempo rogue has pirates. Unless combo synergy eclipse both, this card doesn't have a chance in hell.
This is precisely what I thought would be the problem with the rune system. It keyholes players into playing very specific designs of decks. Most likely team5 already figured out the perfect 25 cards, leaving only 5 flexes. In other words, there's no point debating cards like these - its viability is dependent on the deck's viability. You cant play this card in other archetypes like a second win-con (like how you can fit denathrius into implock for that reason). Its either going to work because rainbow DK works, or its going to be unplayable, because rainbow DK sucks.
This card can literally be played in any DK deck, if not for the rune system. And it might make archetypes like blood, unholy or frost less one dimensional.
As for the card, well, its certainly a finisher. There's a good reason why team5 disabled generating/discovering this card and that reason is because its plain insane. Its either going to outright win you the game or build a board that will do it a turn after.
Will it make rainbow DK playable though? Well, Im not that optimistic but it can happen. If we somehow get a rainbow expensive spell, we might even tempt a Barbaric Sorceress build.
Its massive health pool is what really makes this card good. If you can somehow heal it back, like Circle of Healing, or Fan Club, then its an amazing card for its cost.
But more likely someone will find a way to OTK the opponent out from this card. Fortunately, priest does not yet have a card that heals minions multiple times.
If thief decks are still in, then there's definitely a good reason to play this card. Unfortunately, in every other deck this is just plain inconsistent at best. The real question is why play this instead of a card that does what you want 100% of the time.
I will concede, that against certain classes like DK or warrior, chances are good you'll discover a card you need in that matchup. Because against control warrior you'll likely get a more aggressive spell, vice versa.
In constructed however, the question really is will this actually clear the board? 3 damage is hefty, but most common minions tend to be on 4 health or more so this can clear mostly tokens while leaving the more important minions alive.
Likely its only a real consideration for controlock. In other archetypes its too conditional, too slow, or just plain useless. Auto include in highlander, if nothing else.
Demonxz95: I think that objectives are pretty cool, they open up the ability to play the card flexibly early or late game. It does kind of limit card text space but I think you did well in terms of making the effects still feel interesting (the boarclear especially is really cool). The Demon Hunter one does kind of bore me since it's just drawing cards to get some units, maybe making it work on something different like Outcast could be cool?
Wailor: I prefer transmute, I think it's just a really cool keyword and opens up a lot of possible designs. As for the designs themselves, I think Chimera is really cool but I'm on the fence about the others. Maybe something that cares more about the card it's transmuting could be cool (Like, for example, a card that transmutes a minion in hand into one with more/less Attack). Also, you should specify whether it is random or targetted (Ratsearcher should either say random or have some specification like Discover or "your leftmost minion in hand")
linkblade91: I like your keyword since it allows for cool and unique chains, but I think that Electric Soloist and ETC aren't great uses of it since the effect doesn't change based on which minion does the Encore. I think things like "Encore: Attack the lowest-health enemy" or "Encore: Destroy this minion and give its stats and keywords to a random adjacent minion" would lead to more interesting play patterns.
anchorm4n: I think that Stamina is a bit of a doomed keyword since it's so hard to keep units on board in HS (think of how often Inspire cards triggered more than once). You seem to be aware of this in that you made them very low Stamina requirement cards, but that makes them very similar to a start of turn effect. That said your designs specifically are really good and balanced so I think you could submit it anyway but if you have other ideas those might be worth thinking about.
AeroJulwin: Scrap feels a little too basic for me to go for it but I tend to make overly complex designs so take that with a grain of salt.
Dolphinslayer: Duplicate feels like a pretty solid design, you just need to think of a third card that makes cool use of the effect. I think Spell Damage sounds useful so maybe a balanced version of that scrapped card could work.
linkblade91: I like Launch as a keyword but your cards specifically (except Krazzle) feel a little too much like battlecries to me. I think if you design some cards that you don't want to play as your first card (like how Finale is put on card generation) would make it feel more mechanically distinct.
Almaniarra: I like the keyword but the card text around whether something is infected or applies "infect" is unclear (for example, you Infect a minion but you also give your weapon infect to make it infect other characters).
Infect should probably exclude heroes the same way poisonous does, because you're severely limiting your own design space here. The cards you made for it are interesting, but I'm not sure how well they would perform, since you generally don't want to wait a turn for a minion to die. Blood Boil is the only card like this they printed so far and that one functions more as an AOE where if the surviving targets attack your hero that will simply guarantee your hero will get some health back.
And keep in mind that Blightfang, which is half of the existing infect cards, has its infection effect trigger when the targets die.
Well, actually i have something like these in my mind too but i didn't add them just because of the rules since they don't have the actual keyword.
Solid card for aggro druid. But unfortunately, aggro druid is not just dead I simply dont see it ever coming back. Because in what world will we play aggro druid and not just plain unholy DK, which is practically the same thing but better.
However, this card is pretty good nevertheless...for a bad deck nobody plays.
Its a better Seance, and you get to choose whether the buff triggers or not.
One of those weird keyword cards that would probably be more often played untriggered. Because I cant see this ever seeing play in a board based priest deck.
Its the kind of card that makes you want to tear what remains of your hair off your head.
But fortunately, this card is not easy to take full advantage of. Firstly, it needs to be equipped before it improves, and secondly it takes combo cards to improve it. These two conditions, added with the fact that this card is 3 mana, should more or less prevent the usual turn 5 death from draka, or early 10/10s from Sinstone Graveyard. And there's always ooze, if nothing else.
Wont be too surprised to see this nerfed either way. Hearthstone has consistently show that mana cheating, however convoluted, will almost always be broken at some point.
Im pretty sure this card will see play. But not so sure if its ever going to be as good as it looks.
Basically what it essentially does is to negate the self damage from weapon attacks, or force a hp from your opponent. It'll never realistically corner your opponent into suboptimal plays, or negate as much damage as Lightforged Cariel does. But for a 3 mana investment its fine, I guess. Control pally usually plays enough holy spells that we can see this triggering at least 5 times per game.
Sadly, this can never fit into anything outside control. It forces you to give up tempo and for pally that's usually a death sentence. Unfortunate. Because imagine this negating damage from Blood Crusader and cheat out something big with no drawback.
Ok, but will Vampiric Blood summon a 10/10 or two 5/5s?
Again I am just guessing based on how they're worded, but it should summon two 5/5s. Vampiric Blood gives you 5 Health to start, then gives you 5 Health a second time with the Corpse bonus.
Its a better but less consistent Siamat, and that card only ever saw play in highlander decks
In other words, I dont think this card will make it. Just imagine the amount of bs cards you have to play just for this card to be good. Even in pally, where menagerie builds are possible this card cant fit because of racist discrimination against neutral cards.
Its best fit is highlander, the land where anything stands a chance for a call up.
Its a support card for something warlocks love to do and as such like Malchezaar's Imp it has to be respected despite there not being any obvious combo now.
Of course, this card hasn't a snowball's chance in hell to survive past its first turn, but for what's it worth its still a 1/3 for 1 and that's fine as long as you're not keeping it for some combo.
The main problem is its high cost, and there not being any cheap cards that actively allows you to take advantage of it. Assuming that team5 is pushing rainbow DK hard (and it seems like they are) then we can easily assume that there must be some card not revealed that will make this better.
But honestly though, the card is too slow even with a 0 mana card that adds to health.
Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Festival of Legends! Finale Keyword, New Priest Keyword, Everyone Gets Weapons
So the way I understand it, the class that gets a skin doesn't get a class pack. So no class packs for Mage, Druid and Warrior
Edit: Oh wait, this is incorrect, didn't actually check which class packs the other 2 options provided, they do give a druid and warrior class pack.
Words of Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I'll probably go with Gunslinger, as it's the generally preferred option. People seem to be very divided regarding its flavor, so here are two alternate names for it:
Quick Draw is a middle ground that keeps some wild west flavor while also being more generic than Gunslinger.
Swift, on the other hand, goes all the way in the flavor-agnostic direction.
Keep in mind I still plan for all the cards to be wild west themed (I designed it as an expansion exclusive keyword, after all)
New Death Knight Spell - Harmonic Metal
Its another rainbow DK card. But this card has immense potential, given that the meta will likely be slower.
There are some good things to hit like Gnome Muncher, or Nerubian Swarmguard, but I feel that 3 mana do nothing is perhaps a tad too slow for most metas to be consistent.
Ive played Blood Tap decks and those were solid, but blood tap is substantially better being only 2 mana whereas this card is 3 mana, and less consistent, but does enable you to play rainbow instead of BBU. I think at the end its likely only good in this one expansion, before fading away to irrelevance.
New Priest Location - Fan Club
1 mana heal for 6 at any time? Even outside of synergies this card is in contention for a nod.
Its like Desperate Prayer, but more useful. No doubt its going to see play at some point.
New Neutral Minion - Ghost Writer
Given that the game would be slower because of rotation there's a small possibility that this card gets some sort of attention.
But likely its just too slow, and too conditional. If any of the many 'discover a spell' minion like Venomous Scorpid or Vulpera Scoundrel comes back to standard this card loses any sort of niche it can ever have.
New Shaman Minion - Brass Elemental
I seriously dont know what shaman will be doing next expansion, given how the class more or less got destroyed in the last patch.
Whatever it is, unless elemental shaman comes back or at least there being more elemental synergy this card is trash. Comparable to stuff like Gyreworm, a decent card in a tribal deck but cant breathe outside of it.
New Neutral Minion - The One-Amalgam Band
Fun addition to Wild Menagerie Warrior which has gotten quite some support over the last year (Mistake and Hookfist-3000 being the most recent examples). It's probably still too fair to be considered meta relevant, but if you get out a Ringmaster's Baton early, things can get spicy.
New Death Knight Weapon - Arcanite Ripper
Its not a blood control card, more like a card for rainbow DK.
There's some good things about this card. Firstly, its guaranteed to make a minion even if its oozed away. And secondly, gaining health (or losing it) is not exactly hard for any DK that plays at least one blood rune.
Best case scenario is playing this on curve and getting a 4/4 on turn 4-5. Not too bad for a 3 mana card that does 6 damage.
Solid card for DK. Too bad its restricted only to likely 1-2 decks at most.
New Rogue Minion - Beatboxer
Assuming you can trigger this easily on 4, its not a bad minion in of itself.
But its spiritual predecessor Oil Rig Ambusher had a better statline and is more consistent. But it saw no play even when barrens were first introduced. Granted that then there wasn't any synergy with combo cards.
The main problem would be figuring out where this card actually fits into. Since both draka and Sinstone Graveyard will still be in standard, its never going into any miracle builds, and tempo rogue has pirates. Unless combo synergy eclipse both, this card doesn't have a chance in hell.
Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Festival of Legends! Finale Keyword, New Priest Keyword, Everyone Gets Weapons
Anticipating:
Weapon Silence
Noise Marine decks
Hunter playing Southern Rock
New Druid Minion - Peaceful Piper
More Beast draw for my Moonfang deck
New Death Knight Spell - Climactic Necrotic Explosion
First, a rant.
This is precisely what I thought would be the problem with the rune system. It keyholes players into playing very specific designs of decks. Most likely team5 already figured out the perfect 25 cards, leaving only 5 flexes. In other words, there's no point debating cards like these - its viability is dependent on the deck's viability. You cant play this card in other archetypes like a second win-con (like how you can fit denathrius into implock for that reason). Its either going to work because rainbow DK works, or its going to be unplayable, because rainbow DK sucks.
This card can literally be played in any DK deck, if not for the rune system. And it might make archetypes like blood, unholy or frost less one dimensional.
As for the card, well, its certainly a finisher. There's a good reason why team5 disabled generating/discovering this card and that reason is because its plain insane. Its either going to outright win you the game or build a board that will do it a turn after.
Will it make rainbow DK playable though? Well, Im not that optimistic but it can happen. If we somehow get a rainbow expensive spell, we might even tempt a Barbaric Sorceress build.
New Priest Minion - Heartbreaker Hedanis
Its massive health pool is what really makes this card good. If you can somehow heal it back, like Circle of Healing, or Fan Club, then its an amazing card for its cost.
But more likely someone will find a way to OTK the opponent out from this card. Fortunately, priest does not yet have a card that heals minions multiple times.
New Neutral Minion - Hipster
Probably crap, but niche crap.
If thief decks are still in, then there's definitely a good reason to play this card. Unfortunately, in every other deck this is just plain inconsistent at best. The real question is why play this instead of a card that does what you want 100% of the time.
I will concede, that against certain classes like DK or warrior, chances are good you'll discover a card you need in that matchup. Because against control warrior you'll likely get a more aggressive spell, vice versa.
New Warlock Minion - Opera Soloist
Solid card for arena.
In constructed however, the question really is will this actually clear the board? 3 damage is hefty, but most common minions tend to be on 4 health or more so this can clear mostly tokens while leaving the more important minions alive.
Likely its only a real consideration for controlock. In other archetypes its too conditional, too slow, or just plain useless. Auto include in highlander, if nothing else.
Words of Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Feedback:
Demonxz95: I think that objectives are pretty cool, they open up the ability to play the card flexibly early or late game. It does kind of limit card text space but I think you did well in terms of making the effects still feel interesting (the boarclear especially is really cool). The Demon Hunter one does kind of bore me since it's just drawing cards to get some units, maybe making it work on something different like Outcast could be cool?
Wailor: I prefer transmute, I think it's just a really cool keyword and opens up a lot of possible designs. As for the designs themselves, I think Chimera is really cool but I'm on the fence about the others. Maybe something that cares more about the card it's transmuting could be cool (Like, for example, a card that transmutes a minion in hand into one with more/less Attack). Also, you should specify whether it is random or targetted (Ratsearcher should either say random or have some specification like Discover or "your leftmost minion in hand")
linkblade91: I like your keyword since it allows for cool and unique chains, but I think that Electric Soloist and ETC aren't great uses of it since the effect doesn't change based on which minion does the Encore. I think things like "Encore: Attack the lowest-health enemy" or "Encore: Destroy this minion and give its stats and keywords to a random adjacent minion" would lead to more interesting play patterns.
anchorm4n: I think that Stamina is a bit of a doomed keyword since it's so hard to keep units on board in HS (think of how often Inspire cards triggered more than once). You seem to be aware of this in that you made them very low Stamina requirement cards, but that makes them very similar to a start of turn effect. That said your designs specifically are really good and balanced so I think you could submit it anyway but if you have other ideas those might be worth thinking about.
AeroJulwin: Scrap feels a little too basic for me to go for it but I tend to make overly complex designs so take that with a grain of salt.
Dolphinslayer: Duplicate feels like a pretty solid design, you just need to think of a third card that makes cool use of the effect. I think Spell Damage sounds useful so maybe a balanced version of that scrapped card could work.
linkblade91: I like Launch as a keyword but your cards specifically (except Krazzle) feel a little too much like battlecries to me. I think if you design some cards that you don't want to play as your first card (like how Finale is put on card generation) would make it feel more mechanically distinct.
Almaniarra: I like the keyword but the card text around whether something is infected or applies "infect" is unclear (for example, you Infect a minion but you also give your weapon infect to make it infect other characters).
Words of Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Well, actually i have something like these in my mind too but i didn't add them just because of the rules since they don't have the actual keyword.
New Druid Minion - Peaceful Piper
Solid card for aggro druid. But unfortunately, aggro druid is not just dead I simply dont see it ever coming back. Because in what world will we play aggro druid and not just plain unholy DK, which is practically the same thing but better.
However, this card is pretty good nevertheless...for a bad deck nobody plays.
New Priest Spell - Power Chord: Synchronize
Its a better Seance, and you get to choose whether the buff triggers or not.
One of those weird keyword cards that would probably be more often played untriggered. Because I cant see this ever seeing play in a board based priest deck.
Probably see play in control, and nowhere else.
New Rogue Weapon - Record Scratcher
Its the kind of card that makes you want to tear what remains of your hair off your head.
But fortunately, this card is not easy to take full advantage of. Firstly, it needs to be equipped before it improves, and secondly it takes combo cards to improve it. These two conditions, added with the fact that this card is 3 mana, should more or less prevent the usual turn 5 death from draka, or early 10/10s from Sinstone Graveyard. And there's always ooze, if nothing else.
Wont be too surprised to see this nerfed either way. Hearthstone has consistently show that mana cheating, however convoluted, will almost always be broken at some point.
New Paladin Spell - Starlight Groove
Im pretty sure this card will see play. But not so sure if its ever going to be as good as it looks.
Basically what it essentially does is to negate the self damage from weapon attacks, or force a hp from your opponent. It'll never realistically corner your opponent into suboptimal plays, or negate as much damage as Lightforged Cariel does. But for a 3 mana investment its fine, I guess. Control pally usually plays enough holy spells that we can see this triggering at least 5 times per game.
Sadly, this can never fit into anything outside control. It forces you to give up tempo and for pally that's usually a death sentence. Unfortunate. Because imagine this negating damage from Blood Crusader and cheat out something big with no drawback.
New Death Knight Minion - Screaming Banshee
Again I am just guessing based on how they're worded, but it should summon two 5/5s. Vampiric Blood gives you 5 Health to start, then gives you 5 Health a second time with the Corpse bonus.
New Neutral Minion - The One-Amalgam Band
Its a better but less consistent Siamat, and that card only ever saw play in highlander decks
In other words, I dont think this card will make it. Just imagine the amount of bs cards you have to play just for this card to be good. Even in pally, where menagerie builds are possible this card cant fit because of racist discrimination against neutral cards.
Its best fit is highlander, the land where anything stands a chance for a call up.
New Warlock Minion - Void Virtuoso
Its a support card for something warlocks love to do and as such like Malchezaar's Imp it has to be respected despite there not being any obvious combo now.
Of course, this card hasn't a snowball's chance in hell to survive past its first turn, but for what's it worth its still a 1/3 for 1 and that's fine as long as you're not keeping it for some combo.
New Death Knight Minion - Screaming Banshee
It has potential but probably shit in practice.
The main problem is its high cost, and there not being any cheap cards that actively allows you to take advantage of it. Assuming that team5 is pushing rainbow DK hard (and it seems like they are) then we can easily assume that there must be some card not revealed that will make this better.
But honestly though, the card is too slow even with a 0 mana card that adds to health.