All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • New Neutral Minion - Pyrotechnician

    Chance that it gets into shaman. That's it. No other class plays as many fire spells easily, and warrior dont need something like this.

    A rather poor option without vanilla stats. I dont see where this gets to honestly.

  • New Neutral Minion - Merch Seller

    Prevents one draw from your opponent in exchange for a random spell.

    Arena card at best, because no one will be playing this just to prevent one draw, and it might make it worse as well. Most decks dont tend to rely so much on topdecks, and if your tech is simply to prevent topdeck wins then you've more problems than just including this in your deck.

  • New Neutral Minion - Outfit Tailor

    Lol its just a power crept Shattered Sun Cleric

    Will this see play, I think there's a definite chance. Getting a 2/2 buff out of nowhere, with the possibility of getting even better, that's just good stuff. But 3 mana though...might be too slow, unless you're playing a handbuff deck.

  • New Neutral Minion - Tony, King of Piracy

    The ultimate combo killer deck.

    If your opponent hasn't have this card in hand, and dont have their combo pieces, the game is practically over. A particularly harsh killer of classes like druid or rogue, where most of their wins come from drawing and playing tons of cards per turn.

    Fortunately, such grief will likely be curtailed, because this card is just theotar all over again. It forces the opponent to need this card or suffer the consequences of having their deck yeeted out. Wont be too surprised if this gets into ETC at the very least, or more likely it'll just get nerfed to 6.

    Imagine conceding from this card, not pleasant to say the least.

     

    Edit: Well, I think Im missing the mark here. Its not a battlecry, so the effect overturns if it dies or gets silenced. So much for that argument. Why'd this card be 5 mana then is beyond me, because in what world will anyone bother playing this card? So you can steal one card off your opponent? Bear in mind that you spent 5 mana doing that, and your opponent didn't, for the same exact result.

  • What's Up With Out Of Cards? [Staff Responses]

    Thank you Flux for sharing this detailed insight about the site. It saddens me that this awesome site isn't getting the traffic is deserves but I do understand this game is almost 10 years old and things are not what they used to be. I do look forward to the OoC experience on OoG and look forward to how we can keep the HS content and this community alive going forward.

    💜💜💜

  • Blizzard Reveals 3 New Neutral Festival of Legends Cards Including the Legendary Tony, King of Piracy

    Tony might just get nerfed, because its really reminding me of theotar all over again.

    Its not what this card is doing that's the problem, the problem is that the card's viability forces every deck to need to play it. If you dont have this card, you're an aggro deck that doesn't care, or you just get screwed out of a game. Having it means you have a chance, just a chance to reverse this bs.

    Imagine using this against druid, and they dont have an answer. No early game, and then no late game as well. Yes, team5, this card can end games on card draw rng alone.

  • Blizzard Reveals 3 New Neutral Festival of Legends Cards Including the Legendary Tony, King of Piracy

    Merch Seller has the potential to lock people out of the game. There are many, many, many dead spells you can draw that won't destroy Merch Seller, so if you don't have card draw in-hand when it drops, you can find yourself unable to reach your deck. This is one of the most severe anti-combo cards ever printed as it ALWAYS costs a draw to a deck dependent upon draw. This has the grimly ironic effect of making all the cheap draw Blizz has introduced utterly necessary just to survive.

    And it's sitting right next to a neutral that swaps decks. We're looking at a denial package that any class can play that can, at the very least, crush one archetype.

    Previously obscure cards like Prosecutor Mel'tranix and Disarming Elemental might actually make this lock stick long enough to get something done. I'd be almost okay with a soft-lock like this if it wasn't for the fact that after you get done forcing your opponent to play Casino Mage, you can follow it up with deck-stealing and perma-immunity.

    Reno needs to not be in this rotation, btw. It will make Jailer even more noxious.

  • New Neutral Minion - Audio Amplifier

    Its that activator for druid.

    But for most other classes the best part of this card is that it increases the maximum number of cards in hand. Often enough a value that's understated nowadays in hearthstone.

    At very least this means druid wont be getting another bs ramper.

  • New Neutral Minion - Static Waveform

    This card is just scary, because regardless of what happens this will be overstated for its cost.

    Yes, its very likely this wont do that 5 damage, but your opponent will still have to respect the minion and either take damage or attempt to get rid of this monster.

    Probably hard to justify removing this card in most if not all aggro decks. Its just solid stuff.

  • Blizzard Reveals 6 New Neutral Festival of Legends Cards Including Metrognome & Stereo Totem

    You might be right, that is why I asked. My interpretation seems broken while yours are reasonable for an interesting effect. I wish it were "Then increase both!" at the end because I can understand there will be a value increase but is it for former or latter or both? Just writing "Then increase!" without specifics can cause confusion to readers.

  • New Neutral Minion - Metrognome

    Probably too slow, but it does remind me of Spirit of the Frog, so there's a chance.

    The fact is that you can easily get two cards out with a body that's just decent for 3. Aggro decks might like this as an option, though in my opinion most aggro decks that not enrage warrior tends to draw rapidly, far more than this card can offer.

  • New Neutral Minion - Stereo Totem

    Too slow to be any good. Even if totem synergy got anywhere, or shaman somehow makes a swarm deck, this is just not doing anything on board, which is crucial.

    The best thing you can say about this is that its a soft taunt that can snowball games. Maybe that's enough, if shaman can swarm easily and take advantage, but Im doubtful. Anchored Totem is by far more powerful than this and that card saw no play in standard.

    Other classes wouldnt even bother, so no point discussing that.

  • New Neutral Minion - Frequency Oscillator

    Its not bad, most likely the meta would be slow enough to support the usual tribal deck so any mech synergy is worth it.

    Mech decks needs a 1 drop, and this is one such.

  • New Neutral Minion - Amplified Elekk

    Cheated out or not at all.

    Maybe in hunter, maybe in shaman. Not much else aside from that.

  • New Paladin Spell - Starlight Groove

    They're making Paladin into a full Tank. Complete with Cariel and all that.

    Now for the weapons...

  • Words of Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Hey everyone, i'm super late this week D:

    A new keyword for hunter! Lean in more in the Hunter fantasy by gaining bonuses for successfully hunting something in a turn!

    • Reptile Fetcher - Functionally a 2 mana 4/3 if you can activate Predator. Of course you can hit something else of higher priority other than the Crocolisk. The purpose of the card is to also offer you something to hunt in the case the enemy has no minions. The crocolisk is just the vanilla 2/3 one, hope it's clear enough that it doesn't need a token.
    • Night Hunt - Hit and track your prey! A little less efficient damage/mana value but the Rush carries over to the next turn allowing you to play a Beast and attack right away to trigger another Predator next turn.
    • Cobraptor - Very proud of the name first of all lol. But the card is similar in that it promotes beast play and hunting fantasy. You select your mark and sick your pet onto it next turn, hopefully killing it for Predator. If you are already in a chain of kills you can make killing the cobraptor super hard with stealth. He's beefy enough to benefit from Night Hunt too, possibly taking down 2 to 3 targets even.
  • What's Up With Out Of Cards? [Staff Responses]

    Hearthstone is so beyond dead, it's actually hilarious. Card games as a whole have been on a decline - 

    Seeing a 20-minute video essay on that Nerdslayer channel for Hearthstone will be hilarious.

     

    And then if Blizzard finally kills Hearthstone, we're also not completely fucked.

     

    Ah yes, Out of Card Games would then be the best title.

  • [Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)

    Pro

    That's correct! Your next :-) 

  • Blizzard Reveals 3 New Neutral Festival of Legends Cards Including the Legendary Tony, King of Piracy

    Tony is a really hard card to be certain on but I don’t think he’s breaking anything right now, there’s some reason the be concerned in wild but I don’t think it’s pushing anything over the edge, yet, hopefully. Myra’s rogue is a concern but I think the hoops rogue’ll have to jump though for what’s not even an otk are too much. It might make the cut in mill druid as a tech against less draw heavy decks to kill opponents with your fatigue, but it hopefully isn’t enough to break the game, yet, hopefully. Will probably never see play in standard atleast atlest outside of funny inclusions in thief priest.

    Merch seller is a decent naga, maybe it makes the cut if naga decks resurface but it’s never gonna be the reason they do. At worst it’s a neat discover option in usually mage. People probably aren’t going to be running this in their decks solely for the disruption, but it does make predation cost 0.

    Outfit tailor is a neat handbuff payoff, it’s already usually a better silvermoon portal, and getting any handbuff on this card is amazing. If handbuff dk (or any handbuff deck) is good this could be a reason why

  • New Neutral Minion - Pozzik, Audio Engineer

    druid location support?

     

  • Blizzard Reveals 6 New Neutral Festival of Legends Cards Including Metrognome & Stereo Totem

    Staff Pro

    I think you pay 1 for a 2, then 2 for a 3, 3 for a 4, and so on. Being triggerable on only 1-costs is kibda busted. 

  • Blizzard Reveals 6 New Neutral Festival of Legends Cards Including Metrognome & Stereo Totem

    Audio amplifier looks to be the “wink wink” death beetle mentioned. As for the card itself, well I think it’s alittle too low impact for most decks, but with guff gone maybe druid is okay with it, also I’m not sure but I think this card might override guff/valadris and I think that’s funny.

    Static waveform is probably the best silence card that doesn’t need to be silenced can allack on its own and it’s downside while random is surprisingly minor given the stats, not enough to see play outside of silence though, it more or less replaces package runner for the deck not that it was ever around.

    Metrognome seems really neat. It might make the cut in decks with early curves and I think mech decks could really like it. If this card works based on original cost and not current cost it’d be even better but I don’t think it does.

    Stereo totem is a good totem (I think?). I could be very wrong but I think this slots into totem decks and handbuff decks rather nicely. I think totems are probably decent handbuff targets and this card is pretty cheap with the potential to snowball. I think this makes the cut in totem shaman and handbuff dk if they arise this expansion.

    Frequency oscillater is a kindling elemental for mechs, will see play if mechs do, maybe even if they don’t if amalgams and menagerie are really good.

    Amplified elekk is a decent big beast. If there’s a deck looking to cheat those out it might like this, there’s not much that does post rotation though so unless hunter or druid get alot of support for it this expansion this card is kinda useless

  • New Neutral Minion - Frequency Oscillator

    The most insufferable Mech Paladin can get (so far)

  • Blizzard Reveals 3 New Neutral Festival of Legends Cards Including the Legendary Tony, King of Piracy

    Reveal-season poopbombs like Tony, King of Piracy is why new sets haven't excited me for a long time; they just feel like a checklist that makes adapting to the new meta somewhat faster. The dev's commitment to effects people don't like while enthusiastically ignoring effects that people do like stops being outrageous and just gets tiring.

    In any event, you now have a one-slot fuel source for aggro. So long as aggro doesn't completely lose board, they have a reason to stay in the game. If they can burn their deck out of any answer to Tony, losing the game wins it.

    Remember how Warlock Quest turned an interesting limitation into a free win condition and how much fun it was to lose to that? So much fun that Wild became unplayable? Remember how you asked for more of that? You didn't? Well you fucking got it.

    Our best hope for this card is irrelevance. Our best hope for that is that the meta is literally so fast and horrible that slow decks destroy you before this can be reliably drawn. Again -- our best hope is that everything is such shit that this shit never sees play.

    Edit: I thought I'd mentioned it but apparently forgot: any aggro deck -- any deck, really, but this works best with aggro since aggro takes and holds boards -- that has two slots available, not one, can run this and The Jailer and get that inevitability on 10 going. If you're Druid, you can make going to 10 far more reliable.

    Also: why even bother fixing Wild if a month later you're going to toss it into a cesspool?

  • Blizzard Reveals 3 New Neutral Festival of Legends Cards Including the Legendary Tony, King of Piracy

    Well, Set ruined for me, I'm sick and tired of  "Steal /Swap cards" cards. looking like the next two years are going to be hot garbage meta in Standard.