All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • One Last Turn - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    Linkblade91
    As I said before, I'm not so sure about the balancing, the but card looks absolutely great!

    Wailor

    Living Paradox is a perfectly fine card, but it's not particularly inspiring. If you find nothing better to go with though, then it's not a bad choice.

    Commission Artist seems a bit off to me. As mentioned, Sigils aren't really something that players tend to stack a lot of at one time since their effects don't really work together (directly anyway). I must also say that I don't understand the flavor.

    Chromomancer Enrera has a typo in the name (should be "Chronomancer"). It's my favorite effect of the three, but since it erases itself after it's played, it's weird that it works as a minion that can't ever actually function as a minion (not necessarily unprecedented since Whizbang does exist, but it's still weird. The only reason reason Whizbang is a minion is because he's Neutral and therefore (at the time anyway) needed to be a minion).

    R
    I'm sorta surprised I haven't seen this type of effect before. I'm not sure about its balance, but I suppose it's pretty neat.

    BasilAnguis
    This is a really chaotic card and I sorta love how chaotic it can be, but I also wouldn't submit it. It's just too much.

    Moondreamer

    This has some good flavor and cool mechanics, and there are certainly ways to take advantage of it. It'd probably need more support to be good, but that's easy to print.

    My only real concern, and this isn't really a huge deal, but I feel like in practice it'll just be run as a 1-mana cantrip and the "repeat EoT" effect will just end up being a bonus that's sometimes there as opposed to something the deck is designed to take advantage of.

    AeroJulwin
    This is a really cool effect in theory, but its banking on a 3 mana 0/6 to survive your opponent's turn and also appears to require you to already be winning to get a chance of any good value out of it.

  • Official Mobalytics Tier List

    So I have thoughts about the latest tier list and let's go through the decks one by one.

    1. Pirates - like yeah great aggro deck but also has essentially been the same since rising tides give or take a few new tools. If you lose to this its your fault.

    2. Timeliness - also a bad deck, but it can highroll so hard that you don't even get to play the game with your good deck and for that reason hits number 1 on my nerf list (equipment timeliness interaction)

    3. Ezreal Kenin - lol what? Like don't get me wrong infinite card advantage Ionia is always a valid deck because it is only 1 deck but that being said I find the champ pkg here lacking as a win condition and more often you just let them die so you can draw more cards.

    4. Kindred Nasus - new equipment sac cards are scary who doesn't want infinite 7/7's in a undying deck, and for one mana? Probably not nerfable unless you make the 7/7 cost 8 or something. 

    5. Kaisa - yeah honestly I like her she's easy to beat and is champ focused midrange eith only 1 decent win condition. Very balanced since her spell got put to slow speed.

    A tier is mostly more infinite card advantage shenanigans,  we have a Gwen deck which is cool, Evelyn Viego still doing their thing, Annie, Darkness, Scouts.

    All good stuff, so basically I only see 1 nerf that's needed (time lines equipment) because it's less of a deck and more I get to roll 2 dice each turn and hope they combine into something broken.

    Oh also deep, azir irelia, Lurk, with ekko and Kaine being solid B tier options.

  • How to Complete Castle Nathria's Neutral Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!

    Nice point!

  • How to Complete Castle Nathria's Neutral Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!

    For real? The achievement's text says "minions", so I am quite surprised about this!

  • Two New Anime-Inspired Skin Bundles Have Arrived to Hearthstone's Shop

    Staff Pro

    Guldan who? Nemsy has taken over WL skins as of late a lot, eh?:d

  • Hearthstone's Latest Legendary Quest Chain - Battlegrounds-Only Edition for Cosmetic Rewards

    First impression was, "Wow, another Quest chain!". Until I realized it was nothing but BG. Deleted and moved on to Ranked Standard.

  • One Last Turn - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Feedback

    linkblade91
    Should specify when during last turn, but besides that the effect looks great. Personally, I would make it a Combo to prevent the player from pulling an expensive combo two turns in a row and give them more motive to empty their current hand first.

    Demonxz95
    Felwarper Satyr is indeed a little basic. You should probably go with Divining Cartomancer. It'll likely see some good use in certain classes, although something about card draw being a requirement to get card draw just doesn't sit right with me personally.

    Wailor
    Living Paradox has cool flavor, but the effect is a little plain.

    I like Commission Artist, but not Sigils.

    Chronomancer Enrera has a great effect, but erases herself from existence the moment she's played, so it should probably be a (cheaper) spell.

    R
    The effect isn't the most unexpected, but for the same reason it fits into Hearthstone well and I think it will do pretty good. With the amounts of Mana it can get you, you should definitely stick to refreshing. Otherwise its sole purpose would become to skip a turn and then play something big next turn, which doesn't sound fun in Druid and makes it feel like a Legendary effect.

    I like the first Moonwell Keeper art better and don't forget to capitalize the M on the second "mana".

    BasilAnguis
    This card has amazing flavor and is a strong contender, but I do have some issues with the effect. It only barely passes the prompt requirement, because Looped Time isn't added to your hand until the next turn, so it'll play the cards from last turn guaranteed. But if this was actually printed, I don't see why it wouldn't just be added to your hand immediately? Not that you'd want to use it on the same turn, but it just feels a little forced to fit the comp.

    Despite also helping your opponent, it should probably still be a Legendary so that time loops within time loops are a special occasion and cannot consistently create infinite loops. And I predict having to pay 5 Mana upfront makes this not worth playing unless it creates a wincondition. I also think Mage will have a hard time getting more value out of this than their opponent, because you have to pay 10 Mana and Mage has a lot of targeted effects that could be harmful to yourself. So I'm not sure if it even needs to replay your opponent's cards as well.

    Still a very cool card, though.

    Moondreamer
    The flavor is nice and I hope this gets more support in the future. Going off of other people's feedback, how about making it a minion?

  • Slow Site Reveals a New Forged in the Barrens Demon Hunter Card - Sigil of Flame

    Nice!

  • Fan Community Spotlight - Phoenix's "Ascella Academy"

    It's interesting, thanks!

  • Steward of Scrolls

    Thanks a lot!

  • Fellow card designers, I have a request.

    Damn i'm sorry to hear that you're going through tough times. While i've gone through semi-similar experiences before, i don't have BPD so i can't imagine how you feel. I really enjoyed a lot of your custom hearthstone sets. If you need help feel free to reach out to me even though we are basically strangers and will to respond as soon as I can, and try focus on what you want to do after your medication.

  • Marvel Snap's Featured Location This Week is The Triskelion - Fill Your Hand!

    well thanks for the explanation, my issue is I only have iOS devices, my only option is to emulate android device in my pc and use VPN, yeah.... you know my hype was massive for this game but I am losing interest, I like to start playing game since the beggining like hearthstone from the beta

  • Hearthstone's Latest Legendary Quest Chain - Battlegrounds-Only Edition for Cosmetic Rewards

    That last quest will probably be the first one that will be too hard for me to do. I'm trash at that mode and very rarely come in first. It could take me 30 games before I get first, and I'm not willing to spend that much time at this within two weeks.

    I might be trash at Hearthstone as a whole, but that's besides the point.

  • Hearthstone's Latest Legendary Quest Chain - Battlegrounds-Only Edition for Cosmetic Rewards

    They do, at least this is what they communicated. 

    • [Resolved 8/31] The team is aware that any existing Battlegrounds-only Weekly Quests players had prior to the 24.2 patch were deleted when 24.2 went live. It is intended that these Weekly Quests will not be offered going forward, but it is not intended that those players already had would be deleted went the patch went live. Those deleted Weekly Quests will be returned to affected players in an update coming soon.

    https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/hearthstone/t/242-known-issues/93860

     

  • A Closer Look at Hearthstone's New In-Game Reporting Feature - Developer Insights and Other Details

    Oh, I always thought the goal is to prolong the game as long as possible to get more xp.

  • Hearthstone's Latest Legendary Quest Chain - Battlegrounds-Only Edition for Cosmetic Rewards

    I did the first one, expecting it was only 1 quest grrr, i didn't read this news because I never play BG unless I have to.
    After the first one i went back here to see what this is all about......exactly nothing.......deleted the follow up.  and done.

  • Hearthstone's Latest Legendary Quest Chain - Battlegrounds-Only Edition for Cosmetic Rewards

    I'm just frustrated that I lost a weekly BG focused quest when the patch went out. I still haven't seen if there are plans to address that for players who lost out on that chunk of XP.

  • A Closer Look at Hearthstone's New In-Game Reporting Feature - Developer Insights and Other Details

    That behavior sounds about right.

    Since I don't care about my wild MMR, I just concede and move on. But it's really annoying. This should be against blizzard TOS.

  • Hearthstone's Latest Legendary Quest Chain - Battlegrounds-Only Edition for Cosmetic Rewards

    I'll attempt the questline, not because of the rewards, coz cosmetics mean nothing to me anymore in HS due to the overload there is now. There's always some weekly quests that are incredibly easy to complete in BG (I've got the "Deal 200 damage to enemy heroes." quest atm) 

    And it's always cool to dabble with the new updates, finding the quests must more fun compared to the buddies

  • Hearthstone's Latest Legendary Quest Chain - Battlegrounds-Only Edition for Cosmetic Rewards

    If your MMR is dumpstered in BG, half of the players will be afk from jump in a given game. The only reason nearly all of the players aren't afk is because Blizzard made an undocumented stealth change (that didn't see any discussion in social media) after the very first major overhaul of Battlegrounds where the MMR was reset that forced the track-pushers into games with anyone with a wide range of low MMR. This turboscrews the low MMR players trying to rank up, but Blizz is fine with that because what they don't want are the track-pushers to get infinite passive games in a row.

    What this means is that at the very lowest ranks, your lobby will be garbage and getting first place just requires you to get an early build online fast and you'll almost never be punished by another early build because half your opponents will be ghosts. It can still be frustrating and take time, but if you were going to run a BG game or two anyway, the 1st place win is inevitable.

  • How to Complete Castle Nathria's Neutral Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!

    The "No Country for Old Blanchy" achievement also counts one proc if you get lethal on the enemy hero with him.

  • What is the most popular game among users?

    This site will always be a mainly Hearthstone site, because most, if not all the developers/moderators here were working in Hearthpwn until it was sold.

    At least half of the userbase of this site, myself included, is/was also frequent Hearthpwn users, so we are interested in mostly Hearthstone among card games.

    Hell i use https://outof.cards/hearthstone/ link to only see the HS content, only other card game i was a fan of was Elder Scrolls Legends. RIP.

  • Hearthstone's Latest Legendary Quest Chain - Battlegrounds-Only Edition for Cosmetic Rewards

    Lol, I dont play BG these days but I really feel the grind with that final quest. Getting 1st place is fairly daunting, even back then when I played it casually. Lord knows what the average number of games it'll take to actually get it.

    Deleted the quest soon as I saw it. Probably made for exclusive BG players, I'd imagine. Just separate the damn game, blizz, they cant even use the gold gained in BG itself now. 

  • A Closer Look at Hearthstone's New In-Game Reporting Feature - Developer Insights and Other Details

    Apologies, I think I misrepresented myself. When I said achievement hunting, I meant I use the the achievements to determine the theme for my homebrew decks. I still make semi competitive decks that still aim to win and not solely to complete the achievement. So not achievement hunting in the traditional sense. I'd rather have a real match and not get an achievement than a rope match that wastes my time but get the achievement. I also don't have a lot of time to play so I get irritated when bots waste my time. Just come context why I get irritated. I usually play standard but feeling burnt out so I tried this out.

    It sort of went off tangent a bit lol. My original question was: are they really bots and is it worth the effort to report them? Though I guess from the responses, the answers are yes and no.

  • A Closer Look at Hearthstone's New In-Game Reporting Feature - Developer Insights and Other Details

    There's a pattern that comes up whenever I see the new expansion achievements. Generally speaking, the goal is for those achievements to be completed within 30-40 odd games, which is doable within 4 months if that's all you're playing, and then there's those which are absolutely mind boggling like Gone Fishin' which might as well be impossible if not insufferable even if thief rogue was all that was being played for 4 months.

    Fun is obviously not the goal, because none of them are. The goal is engagement, to get us to actually play certain decks or certain styles. Obviously not with the intention to win. Whirlpool required 12 minions on board, which means you're flushing away your own board which 90% of the time just never happens in a competitive match. Cards like Frantic Hippogryph (which hilariously I completed this almost exclusively against bots) will simply never see any competitive play, not even in bronze wild because the card is shit, I'd imagine team5 managing a smile thinking some poor sod gotta actually attack with this card 80 fucking times.

    And then there's the most infuriating thing; the xp reward only lasts 4 months. Why? For being too generous I'd imagine, can't fit it into the design document or that's one name crossed out of the bonus list for that year.