Yeah but Wild Spirits is just a good card to play. It doesn't win you the game by itself, it's just gives you the tempo you need to compete with other decks.
Wildseeds already got a pretty brutal nerf with the Stag (which carried you against Mage and Druid harder than anything else in the deck).
We don't nerf good cards for being good, we nerf them for being too good or somehow warping the meta around them. Wild Spirits does neither.
I just felt that if we're going to nerf all three good classes then the natural winner would be hunter, as evident before the last nerf. Wild Spirits has such a crazy winrate then, and I cant see why it wouldn't be the case if both rogue and druid gets nerfed. That card is one of the best card in quest hunter of all things, kinda shows us alot.
This time, I think team5 would scale everything down to give the bad classes a chance, and outside of buffs, I think rogue, druid, mage and hunter needs some toning down to accomplish that. Maybe warlock as well, but I wouldn't push it.
I think I've seen somewhere a graphic with runestones bundles and they were indeed the exact amounts you need to buy certain things, like preorder bundles etc
but how that will actually turn out only time will tell, it's blizzard in the end
Why would they nerf Hunter and more importantly why Wild Spirits of all things? The class is already close to dead and only Quest Hunter is a thing and Wild Spirits is certainly not what breaks that deck
I know that the plan is to nerf standard cards, but I wish they would nerf Grey Sage Parrot in wild. Changing it to spells that cost 6 or more. The endless extra turn in wild quest mage is almost impossible to beat once they have the pieces. They can have 5 extra turns.
My proposal for this week. Honestly very proud of this design. This is my final design unless some textual inconsitency pops up that I might have missed.
Some quick feedback:
Show Spoiler
Linkblade - Massive Macaw is cool, I dig the design. I'd say go for that one. I personally despise designs like Izzy and I think they will never be printed as they just pose way too many problems. From the moment an effect like this is printed the design space for expensive spells in any class will be forever restricted because every class can have every spell, they can allow classes to work around inteded weaknesses (imagine giving, for example, a Standard Ramp Druid access to powerful board clears such as Whirlpool or Twisting Nether), they can create silly and overpowered combos (you've suddenly given every single class access to Potion of Illusion), they would complicate the UI during deckbuilding (something Hearthstone really cares about, rightfully).
Wailor - I'd go with the Murloc. Having an incentive to put spells in Murloc decks is a concept I'm fond of, especially considering how minion-heavy Murloc decks usually are, and Silver Hand Commander is probably too strong as is, especially at an odd mana cost.
Demonxz & AeroJulvin - Good designs! I'd personally go for the second wording on Yogg though, so that it's consistent with other similar effects. The text also doesn't visually look any worse, so there's no reason not to.
R - Incorporating weapons is a cool idea, but the card is most likely quite overpowered at 4 mana. The amount of value and stats you could get on turn 4 or even turn 3 with coin is just absurd. This should be at least 5 mana. And even then, it would be quite an insane card.
Adam - I'd go with Arcaneburst Dawngrasp.Relic Chest is fundamentally broken: if it's supposed to upgrade after each played Relic then it's both extremely overpowered at 3 Mana (this would be, like, a 7-8 Mana effect) and the wording is incorrect. If it's not supposed to upgrade after each use, then it shouldn't be called a Relic. The other two cards are okay-ish but have incorrect wording/spelling mistakes in them.
I think they are both problems, but the feelsbad is quite different. Sire Denathrius can be replaced by another win condition and that card would again be a problem on its own. However, with Theotar, the Mad Duke you can easily disrupt/remove your opponent's win condition for which they worked all game long on and that is just so annoying/punishing. All slow decks have to run this problem card just to either draw your opponent's win condition or hopefully get your own win condition back (before they play it) which is just stupid.
The disruption cost is too low and the probability to pull it off is too high because it is tied to the discover ability which is overpowered.
Take a look at the other distruption cards in this set in rogue (you gotta have secrets and you dont get to delete a card, but rather shuffle it back) and in priest (you actually have to invest the mana playing the copy to steal the original while Harvester of envy is on the board). The only thing these cards have over Theo is that they are 3/4/3, but when so many start at 40hp and some have abundant stalling, the tempo loss efeect is reduced.
Take a look at another disruption lego - Mutanus. It costs 7, it can't target spells (you can tailor more easily against this narrower ability) and most importantly, you don't get to discover the best of 3 options. Granted, Mutanus may sometimes be a good tempo play, gaining stats of a huge minion, but again with 40hp and so much freeze or freeze-like (solid alibi) effects tempo is not as dominant as it used to be.
I agree that Illucia generates a worse feeling (not by much), but at least it was limited to one class. As an aside - with all her power, even pre first nerf, at 2 mana, she wouldn't have been able to disrupt Denathrius by herself
They wanna make sure the monetization is right first. I.e. such that we won't realize how p2w/greedy/etc everything will be until it's too late. They could even go for a very friendly approach to start off the game, then change it progressively towards having to spend more money in it or on loot boxes
I completely agree with your words. Yes, Mutanus can win the game or do a lot of disruption, but he is random and costs as much as 7 mana. I didn't liked Theotar right away even before the release. Even with 9 cards in hand, there is a very high chance of losing a valuable card. And this is happens every time. Also in return, something weak or completely useless is given. And it's only for 4 mana. For a very long time we had only a Dirty Rat, but now there are even more serious ways to spoil the opponent's game. I hope this card will be nerfed.
I think Theotar is quite a bit different from Illucia. There was really nothing you could do about the latter, since your whole hand got taken. Theotar can absolutely be played around in the deck stage - either have multiple win conditions, or have your sole win condition be malleable enough that taking out one card doesn't destroy it.
That type of disruption is healthy for the game IMO. It prevents so-called "solitaire" decks forming, where the opponent can't really interact with you because it's all about gathering the perfect combo in your hand.
- Would be surprised if Edwin, Defias Kingpin doesn't get a revert, making it the first card in hearthstone history to get buffed and then reverted in less than a month. If team5 do not wish to create history, then they'll likely hit two other cards, Sinstone Graveyard (for virtually creating impossible to counter giants before turn 6) or Necrolord Draka (wouldn't surprise me too much if the durability is reduced to 2, or cost goes up to 5)
Rogue has been dominating the meta in a very unhealthy fashion. Forget your implocks and aggro druid, this deck can finish up by turn 6.
- Im not sure what team5 will do to mage. Not introducing Living Dragonbreath into standard is just one of those boneheaded moves given that they're trying to push out one of the most obnoxious elements in hearthstone. At this point, its very likely Nightcloak Sanctum or Flurry (Rank 1) would be targets, but I think team5 would just nerf Wildfire and mordresh back to what it was and call it a day. Basically, team5's idea here would be to tone mage back to midtier and pray no one gets their board frozen 6 turns in a row too many times.
- Wildheart Guff? No. Someone in their design team evidently can't sleep without jerking off to this card, so it'll stay. What else then? Nourish back to 6 perhaps, because the Jerry Rig Carpenter into nourish is simply too good, so much so that every other choose one spell are barely considered.
Perhaps druids wont be nerfed at all. Basically ramp druid is living off the fact that it has a good matchup towards both mage and rogues, so removing that may solve much of the issues in of itself.
- Hunter will get another nerf somewhere. Probably Wild Spirits to 4. Or perhaps we'll finally see the quest get nerfed. Third condition from 2 spells to 3 likely.
- And of course, I think its fairly obvious both Kael'thas Sinstrider and mad duke are going to be nerfed. Sinstrider because they're never going to nerf brann or denathrius, and theotar because this one card is simply too good. This card is extraordinarily consistent. Too consistent.
Any chance of them looking at Prince Renathal at all? I still think its fairly evident team5 cant balance cards around 40-30 health. Best to address this now, before its too late. Its very likely there's a new class next expansion, so that's one extra tightrope you dont need baggage for.
Theotar gives me vibes from Illucia, in a meta with slow decks getting your wincon stollen is pretty frustrating, and a disruption card with over 50% presence in decks goes against they idea from disruption cards being overly played.
For the sake of consistency, it makes sense to allow minions as well. It'd be really weird to allow one and not the other as the distinction is seemingly arbitrary.
Nightshade Bud would have been an acceptable submission even if minions were not allowed because it can cast the spells from your deck; the minion part would've been considered non-relevant to the comp, albeit still a cool addition to the card. We debated a little whether or not minions should be allowed, and the group decided that they're fine. My opinion doesn't matter anymore *shrugs*
This was all an unnecessarily-verbose way of saying Yes, those two are fine. Dirty Rat, Party Crasher, Deathwing, Dragonlord, Ironforge Portal; pulling minions from the hand or deck (or the ether) are okay.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
Yeah but Wild Spirits is just a good card to play. It doesn't win you the game by itself, it's just gives you the tempo you need to compete with other decks.
Wildseeds already got a pretty brutal nerf with the Stag (which carried you against Mage and Druid harder than anything else in the deck).
We don't nerf good cards for being good, we nerf them for being too good or somehow warping the meta around them. Wild Spirits does neither.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
I just felt that if we're going to nerf all three good classes then the natural winner would be hunter, as evident before the last nerf. Wild Spirits has such a crazy winrate then, and I cant see why it wouldn't be the case if both rogue and druid gets nerfed. That card is one of the best card in quest hunter of all things, kinda shows us alot.
This time, I think team5 would scale everything down to give the bad classes a chance, and outside of buffs, I think rogue, druid, mage and hunter needs some toning down to accomplish that. Maybe warlock as well, but I wouldn't push it.
All Hearthstone Battlegrounds Changes and Updates for the Upcoming Patch 24.2 - Minions, Heroes, Systems, Monetization
https://twitter.com/Celestalon/status/1562136962328174592
I think I've seen somewhere a graphic with runestones bundles and they were indeed the exact amounts you need to buy certain things, like preorder bundles etc
but how that will actually turn out only time will tell, it's blizzard in the end
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
Why would they nerf Hunter and more importantly why Wild Spirits of all things? The class is already close to dead and only Quest Hunter is a thing and Wild Spirits is certainly not what breaks that deck
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
I know that the plan is to nerf standard cards, but I wish they would nerf Grey Sage Parrot in wild. Changing it to spells that cost 6 or more. The endless extra turn in wild quest mage is almost impossible to beat once they have the pieces. They can have 5 extra turns.
Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
My proposal for this week. Honestly very proud of this design. This is my final design unless some textual inconsitency pops up that I might have missed.
Some quick feedback:
Linkblade - Massive Macaw is cool, I dig the design. I'd say go for that one. I personally despise designs like Izzy and I think they will never be printed as they just pose way too many problems. From the moment an effect like this is printed the design space for expensive spells in any class will be forever restricted because every class can have every spell, they can allow classes to work around inteded weaknesses (imagine giving, for example, a Standard Ramp Druid access to powerful board clears such as Whirlpool or Twisting Nether), they can create silly and overpowered combos (you've suddenly given every single class access to Potion of Illusion), they would complicate the UI during deckbuilding (something Hearthstone really cares about, rightfully).
Wailor - I'd go with the Murloc. Having an incentive to put spells in Murloc decks is a concept I'm fond of, especially considering how minion-heavy Murloc decks usually are, and Silver Hand Commander is probably too strong as is, especially at an odd mana cost.
Demonxz & AeroJulvin - Good designs! I'd personally go for the second wording on Yogg though, so that it's consistent with other similar effects. The text also doesn't visually look any worse, so there's no reason not to.
R - Incorporating weapons is a cool idea, but the card is most likely quite overpowered at 4 mana. The amount of value and stats you could get on turn 4 or even turn 3 with coin is just absurd. This should be at least 5 mana. And even then, it would be quite an insane card.
Adam - I'd go with Arcaneburst Dawngrasp. Relic Chest is fundamentally broken: if it's supposed to upgrade after each played Relic then it's both extremely overpowered at 3 Mana (this would be, like, a 7-8 Mana effect) and the wording is incorrect. If it's not supposed to upgrade after each use, then it shouldn't be called a Relic. The other two cards are okay-ish but have incorrect wording/spelling mistakes in them.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
I think they are both problems, but the feelsbad is quite different. Sire Denathrius can be replaced by another win condition and that card would again be a problem on its own. However, with Theotar, the Mad Duke you can easily disrupt/remove your opponent's win condition for which they worked all game long on and that is just so annoying/punishing. All slow decks have to run this problem card just to either draw your opponent's win condition or hopefully get your own win condition back (before they play it) which is just stupid.
The disruption cost is too low and the probability to pull it off is too high because it is tied to the discover ability which is overpowered.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
It's still too strong.
Take a look at the other distruption cards in this set in rogue (you gotta have secrets and you dont get to delete a card, but rather shuffle it back) and in priest (you actually have to invest the mana playing the copy to steal the original while Harvester of envy is on the board). The only thing these cards have over Theo is that they are 3/4/3, but when so many start at 40hp and some have abundant stalling, the tempo loss efeect is reduced.
Take a look at another disruption lego - Mutanus. It costs 7, it can't target spells (you can tailor more easily against this narrower ability) and most importantly, you don't get to discover the best of 3 options. Granted, Mutanus may sometimes be a good tempo play, gaining stats of a huge minion, but again with 40hp and so much freeze or freeze-like (solid alibi) effects tempo is not as dominant as it used to be.
I agree that Illucia generates a worse feeling (not by much), but at least it was limited to one class. As an aside - with all her power, even pre first nerf, at 2 mana, she wouldn't have been able to disrupt Denathrius by herself
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
the main problem of the whole game is Renathal. Remove him and it will be a good game again
Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
some ideas
Marvel Snap Developer Discord Recap #10 - Card Acquisition, Cosmetic Loadouts, & More!
They wanna make sure the monetization is right first. I.e. such that we won't realize how p2w/greedy/etc everything will be until it's too late. They could even go for a very friendly approach to start off the game, then change it progressively towards having to spend more money in it or on loot boxes
Mutanus vs Theotar: opinion on combo disruption
I completely agree with your words.
Yes, Mutanus can win the game or do a lot of disruption, but he is random and costs as much as 7 mana.
I didn't liked Theotar right away even before the release. Even with 9 cards in hand, there is a very high chance of losing a valuable card. And this is happens every time. Also in return, something weak or completely useless is given. And it's only for 4 mana.
For a very long time we had only a Dirty Rat, but now there are even more serious ways to spoil the opponent's game. I hope this card will be nerfed.
Best 12-Win Hearthstone Duels Decks to Play This Week - Kingsbane Reno, Relic Vanndar & More
Thanks for this! I appreciate each time the duels deck posts show up.
I had a slow start with the Drekthar Mage deck on this one but ended upp with 9 wins.
Last week or the week before that I had a probably 6-7 wins average every time with the Rush Warrior decks suggested in Heroic.
Even if you dont have all cards for a deck this is good ideas for anyone trying to get into duels mode
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
If you depend on one card (Denarius) then the issue is not Theotar, but your one card strategy.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
Denathrius because no dust refund. EZ
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
Macaw and/or Keal'thas ft . Brann are the problem
Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
My first idea hit a dead end. So I hope weapons count too.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
I think Theotar is quite a bit different from Illucia. There was really nothing you could do about the latter, since your whole hand got taken. Theotar can absolutely be played around in the deck stage - either have multiple win conditions, or have your sole win condition be malleable enough that taking out one card doesn't destroy it.
That type of disruption is healthy for the game IMO. It prevents so-called "solitaire" decks forming, where the opponent can't really interact with you because it's all about gathering the perfect combo in your hand.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
My comments on possible nerfs;
- Would be surprised if Edwin, Defias Kingpin doesn't get a revert, making it the first card in hearthstone history to get buffed and then reverted in less than a month. If team5 do not wish to create history, then they'll likely hit two other cards, Sinstone Graveyard (for virtually creating impossible to counter giants before turn 6) or Necrolord Draka (wouldn't surprise me too much if the durability is reduced to 2, or cost goes up to 5)
Rogue has been dominating the meta in a very unhealthy fashion. Forget your implocks and aggro druid, this deck can finish up by turn 6.
- Im not sure what team5 will do to mage. Not introducing Living Dragonbreath into standard is just one of those boneheaded moves given that they're trying to push out one of the most obnoxious elements in hearthstone. At this point, its very likely Nightcloak Sanctum or Flurry (Rank 1) would be targets, but I think team5 would just nerf Wildfire and mordresh back to what it was and call it a day. Basically, team5's idea here would be to tone mage back to midtier and pray no one gets their board frozen 6 turns in a row too many times.
- Wildheart Guff? No. Someone in their design team evidently can't sleep without jerking off to this card, so it'll stay. What else then? Nourish back to 6 perhaps, because the Jerry Rig Carpenter into nourish is simply too good, so much so that every other choose one spell are barely considered.
Perhaps druids wont be nerfed at all. Basically ramp druid is living off the fact that it has a good matchup towards both mage and rogues, so removing that may solve much of the issues in of itself.
- Hunter will get another nerf somewhere. Probably Wild Spirits to 4. Or perhaps we'll finally see the quest get nerfed. Third condition from 2 spells to 3 likely.
- And of course, I think its fairly obvious both Kael'thas Sinstrider and mad duke are going to be nerfed. Sinstrider because they're never going to nerf brann or denathrius, and theotar because this one card is simply too good. This card is extraordinarily consistent. Too consistent.
Any chance of them looking at Prince Renathal at all? I still think its fairly evident team5 cant balance cards around 40-30 health. Best to address this now, before its too late. Its very likely there's a new class next expansion, so that's one extra tightrope you dont need baggage for.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
Theotar gives me vibes from Illucia, in a meta with slow decks getting your wincon stollen is pretty frustrating, and a disruption card with over 50% presence in decks goes against they idea from disruption cards being overly played.
Hearthstone Is Getting Another Balance Patch - Coming Soon!
Denathrius is the problem, not the theotar...
Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
For the sake of consistency, it makes sense to allow minions as well. It'd be really weird to allow one and not the other as the distinction is seemingly arbitrary.
Marvel Snap Developer Discord Recap #10 - Card Acquisition, Cosmetic Loadouts, & More!
just give us the damn game already
Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Nightshade Bud would have been an acceptable submission even if minions were not allowed because it can cast the spells from your deck; the minion part would've been considered non-relevant to the comp, albeit still a cool addition to the card. We debated a little whether or not minions should be allowed, and the group decided that they're fine. My opinion doesn't matter anymore *shrugs*
This was all an unnecessarily-verbose way of saying Yes, those two are fine. Dirty Rat, Party Crasher, Deathwing, Dragonlord, Ironforge Portal; pulling minions from the hand or deck (or the ether) are okay.
Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
But Party Crasher is just slightly different neutral Nightshade Bud, isn't it?