All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro
    Quote From R
    Quote From ShadowsOfSense

    You must create a card which can play other cards.

    Other "cards" or "spells"? For example Dirty Rat or Party Crasher is allowed?

    As Demon would put it, if this was a physical card game, both of your examples would cause a player to place a card from their hand onto the table, effectively "playing" it. I think "play" has a slightly different definition in Hearthstone because you have to truly pay the cost of a minion to trigger its Battlecry - as opposed to summoning it randomly, Recruiting it from the deck, etc. - but Tess Greymane was an example given to us by Sothis, and she can replay minions, so we have to assume minions are allowed as well.

  • Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Quote From ShadowsOfSense

    You must create a card which can play other cards.

    Other "cards" or "spells"? For example Dirty Rat or Party Crasher is allowed?

  • Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    I wanted Yogg to cast the spells regardless of whether you've played them yet. That way you don't have to spend a turn to play that expensive spell/number of smaller spells that are still in your hand before you can use Yogg effectively. But in case the phrasing is too unusual, I did make an alternative version that sticks to the "that didn't start in your deck" line.

    Alt version

    Edit: Noticed "spell" not being a plural.

    Edit: And the misspelling of "if"… Look, it was late at night, okay.

  • Dawn Of The Dead - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Congrats FooBar! Glad you refined your idea and managed to win with it :)

  • Mutanus vs Theotar: opinion on combo disruption

    I could not agree more!

    Theotar, the Mad Duke is another excellent example of how overpowered the discover ability truly is. This combined with opponent's hand disruption is just poor card design IMO. Often times it is not even random at all, because the hand size is small or contains duplicate cards.

    I believe Hearthstone would be a much healthier game overall if they changed the discover ability from choosing between 3 options to 2 instead. Heck, even keeping the 3 options but having 1 of them hidden somewhat similar to Vulpera Scoundrel would make it more balanced.

    These nerf suggestions are probably less exciting nor popular, but they do not outright kill the ability and still keep the original idea/spirit alive. 

  • Ornn Is Forging His Way to Legends of Runeterra in the Upcoming "Awakening" Expansion

    That's debatable Viego do not level up in the deck and require you to have other unit's on the board to get his engine going.

    Ornn will probably hit the board with Level 2 he can get stats from either hand or board giving him more flexibility, he buff himself on attack and summon a finisher, without hard removal or a stunt him it will be game over.

  • Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    A little education will go a long way.

  • Mutanus vs Theotar: opinion on combo disruption

    Pro

    Let me start by saying I enjoy combos: it's super fun to assemble your pieces, fend off the enemy, then administer the coup de grace. I also think that combo disruption is important for the game.

    I think Mutanus the Devourer is a perfect and well-balanced combo disruptor: he can only hit minions (he can do nothing about a Purified Shard already in hand, a game-winning Bloodlust, or any hero card you care to mention), he is expensive, and he chooses a random target. Using Mutanus to stop an enemy combo requires a lot of luck, a lot of mana, and some decent hand-reading. And perhaps best of all, he was part of a mini-set, making him easier to collect than most other legendaries.

    I hate Theotar, the Mad Duke. He is inexpensive, allows you to choose a target, can steal ANY card (not just minions), and worst of all, he allows your enemy to use your win condition against you. 

    I'll include my super salty story below here as a spoiler for anyone who cares to read it. Otherwise, feel free to respond to the opinions above. Agree? Disagree? Let's chat, friends.

    Show Spoiler
    I'm playing Quest Priest vs. Denathrius Druid. I'm working through my quest, answering my opponent's board, and just having a grand old time. I'm even putting on enough pressure that he has to play his Sire Denathrius early just to stay alive. Then he plays Zola the Gorgon to get a second Sire for later (he's Guff by now and has at least 13 mana). My response: Whirlpool, which honestly hurts my own board worse than his, but it gets rid of both of his Sires (one on board, one in hand). He has NO win condition. I complete my quest. He plays Theotar, the Mad Duke and ganks my Xyrella, the Sanctified, then plays it immediately. I did everything right, made the good plays, defeated his win condition, then lost to my own win condition because of one stupid card that didn't even require any skill or much luck to use.

  • Dawn Of The Dead - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    Congratulations to Foobars!

    Seven people gave me 5-stars in the first round, but not one in the finalist vote? That's quite a bummer :(

  • Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Two variations of the same idea. I think they count, given the examples provided by the prompt.

    I think the dude version will be preferred, but I don't know if the idea is inherently too aggro. Maybe they would be more balanced as Legendaries, dunno.

    EDIT: linkblade's Massive Macaw reminded me of another Druid Parrot I made back when Deadmines was announced. It's a bit too similar to both Pathmaker and Raid Negotiator, though.

  • Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    I have two initial ideas for this one; pretty satisfied with the Druid minion, but the Legendary I pre-nerfed twice already lol:

    Massive Macaw is the counter-point to Grey Sage Parrot: the Parrot replays Rune of the Archmage or Time Warp over and over again, so why can't the Druid resummon minions repeatedly?

    Izzy the Overachiever could be really fun, but Survival of the Fittest from the same set makes it scary. I upped her cost and swapped Battlecry for Spellburst to make it harder to cheat out a spell before it's time.

  • Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread


    Competition Theme: Cast On, Cast Off

    It seems like an awful lot of effort to play all these cards. If only they could help out somehow...


    Sothis is looking for some cards to be cast this week - so why not get the cards to do the casting?

    As always, I can be reached through Discord or here on the site via PM if you have any issues to report.


    Competition Phases

    Here are the phases of this card design competition

    • Submission Phase: Starts on Mon, Aug 29 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400). Runs until Sat, Sep 3 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400)
    • Voting Phase: Starts on Sat, Sep 3 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400). Runs until Sun, Sep 4 16:00 EDT (GMT -0400)
    • Finalist Phase: Starts on Sun, Sep 4 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400). Runs until Mon, Sep 5 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400)
    • Winner Selected: After finalist voting concludes and we validate votes.

    Discussion Thread Rules

    No thread rules were added to this season. Please populate and manually edit this thread with them.

  • Out of Cards Changelog - 2022-07-04

    No fix and no feedback yet. Has anyone else noticed these mobile issues? Scrolling even stops for quite a few seconds. What is causing this? These lag/freeze issues are very annoying.

  • The New Awakening Set Is Genius

    Typically in these new sets I go card by card and try to weigh in on what's competitive for existing archetypes.

    But the genius of Awakening is now every region gets to play like Hearthstone warrior if it wants to, or Flesh and Blood a more recent card game released that seems to cough cough provide a little inspiration.

    Honestly all 3 new Champs Master Ip, Forge Master, and Weapon Master all look exceptionally viable.

    So let's weigh in on portal girl, I think she is strong if you have enough viable ways to slow down the game. So it'll be up to you if you want Freijord, Shadow or Ionia.

    5 drop scythe dude looks like the worst of the bunch only because we are playing a game where 5 drops come down as 6/6's with quick attack, and endless keywords that machine gun your board. He looks like thresh which is hard to play these days.

    Overall Awakening is positioned to hard shuffle the tier list because non of the released cards belong in existing archetypes and thats a good thing we don't want another bard situation.

  • New Freljord Card - Wrought Colossus

    Staff

    A new Epic Freljord Unit, Wrought Colossus, has been revealed!

    Wrought Colossus Card Image

    Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!


    Learn more about Worldwalker

    Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!

  • New Freljord Landmark - Ornn's Forge

    Staff

    A new Rare Freljord Landmark, Ornn's Forge, has been revealed!

    Ornn's Forge Card Image

    Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!


    Learn more about Worldwalker

    Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!

  • New Freljord Spell - Bellows Breath

    Staff

    A new Rare Freljord Spell, Bellows Breath, has been revealed!

    Bellows Breath Card Image

    Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!


    Learn more about Worldwalker

    Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!

  • New Freljord Champion - Ornn

    Staff

    A new Champion Freljord Unit, Ornn, has been revealed!

    Ornn Card Image

    Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!


    Learn more about Worldwalker

    Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!

  • Ornn Is Forging His Way to Legends of Runeterra in the Upcoming "Awakening" Expansion

    I would not play him as a 3x either but the way I build around him, makes basically every unit a threat. U literally "ram" through your enemies units and removals until you can finish him of. Mere statwise you will have a hard time to beat a forge deck IMO.

  • Marvel Snap Developer Discord Recap #10 - Card Acquisition, Cosmetic Loadouts, & More!

    Europe release when? :(

  • Ornn Is Forging His Way to Legends of Runeterra in the Upcoming "Awakening" Expansion

    Well he can level in deck and if he gets played on level 2 he is a huuge double trouble unit.

    It's kinda like a lvl2 Zed who has overwhelm already . 

    It doesn't look exiting for sure and maybe the fact that freljord has no spellshield will break ornn's neck but I also could see Ornn becoming the new Sion of Freljord 

  • Ornn Is Forging His Way to Legends of Runeterra in the Upcoming "Awakening" Expansion

    You really think he's strong? At 7 mana, you'd expect him to be a really big deal, but he seems a lot less impactful than Viego at 5 mana. 

  • Ornn Is Forging His Way to Legends of Runeterra in the Upcoming "Awakening" Expansion

    I only need 2 words to describe this champion: 

    Word 1: Strong

    Word 2: boring

     

  • [Custom Expansion, Completed] - HOLIDAYS AT UN'GOL ISLAND

    Quote From RealJC1234TheToonist

    Just want to request, is it possible to make an additional post for clarity where the expansion's cards are organized in a clear way? I understand you organized them by flavor but the way the cards were ordered doesn't have a consistent pattern (such as rarity, class or name in alphabetical order) so it's hard to wrap one's head around. (I dunno, I think it's just me.)


    The cards are already ordered consistently by class, they are just divided in two since each class has two different archetypes. I've also added neutrals to each relevant package to help viewers notice interesting synergies they might otherwise miss. Still, reordering them won't cost me much time, so sure. This is the expansion sorted by class and rarity:

    • ROGUE

    Show Spoiler




    • HUNTER

    Show Spoiler

     




    • WARLOCK

    Show Spoiler




    • SHAMAN

    Show Spoiler




    • PALADIN

    Show Spoiler




    • PRIEST

    Show Spoiler




    • DEMON HUNTER

    Show Spoiler




    • DRUID

    Show Spoiler




    • MAGE

    Show Spoiler




    • WARRIOR

    Show Spoiler




    • NEUTRALS

    Show Spoiler

  • Marvel Snap Developer Discord Recap #10 - Card Acquisition, Cosmetic Loadouts, & More!

    We want to give some more control over card acquisition but it will not be from boosters

    Even without any other details provided, this line is the big news. I hope they come up with something good.