Looks good, although I like the uneven stats better. Also, compared to Death Blossom Whomper, I think the instant cast is a lot stronger. Of course there's more to take into account, like the Outcast as a requirement and the slight cost difference, so I'm not 100% sure on balance, but I feel like it's currently on the stronger side.
Moondreamer
I like the new Squeamlish. I just remembered that Druid mainly has big single-target healing, making the previous effect more of a "heal your hero more". That's probably why you made it affect +Health as well? This new effect fixes that problem and is also more interactive.
However, I don't like the new statline. 7 health is already a lot, but keep in mind that this is in the same set as Crystal Power. For only 1 extra Mana, this could be a 2/12, making it extremely difficult to remove. A good way to bypass this would be to have the passive only affect your other minions. The phrasing also doesn't sound completely natural to me. I propose this phrasing instead:
"Whenever you restore Health to a(nother) friendly minion, excess healing is converted into Health."
(Also, you accidentally put my name on linkblade's feedback)
I actually thought about this for a while: I ultimately went with "discard" because it gives the idea of you (momentarily or definitively) losing resources from your hand, but I agree that it's extremely debatable.
Demon Hunter didn't receive buffs just in the Relic department, as the new "discard" archetype got some love as well.
So I wouldn't call the hyper aggressive buffed cards above a "discard" archetype, it's more like a shuffle archetype as only Kryxis the Voracious actually discards cards for DH
Another Squeamlish design, this one more focused on the initial idea of Healing Druid. This allows a fully healed minion to get extra Health when healed, hopefully improving the lackluster Healing Druid cards and allowing some experimentation with old and underperforming neutral minions.
Aggressively statted for 4 Mana but Healing Druid needs a big push and this card still requires synergy, so this feels more than fair to me.
Some quick feedback:
Show Spoiler
Wailor - I like the new Deathmetal Encorer much more! It's a simple card but does its thing well. Well done!
Arkasaur- Very interesting concepts! You should absolutely go with Premeditate in my opinion. I'll give you some conflicting feedback: I think Wailor's off when he says that the card should be a minion. As a spell it can sit in your hand and do nothing, sure, but as a minion there's no way it wouldn't be busted. Rogue has waaaay too many ways to bounce minions. On a cheap minion, they could bounce it a bunch of times and get insane value as early as turn 3-4, on a mid to late game minion it would be a worthless effect (Shuffle Rogue wants to win in the early to midgame). Gloomblade is unprintable. If this card existed, Rogue would have a Wild OTK that you can pull off on turn 3 with a lucky hand, probably on turn 4-5 on average using Academic Espionage and a Preparation or two.
Linkblade - I really like the concept of a weapon allowing your board to essentially get Windfury. Very very hard to judge how good the card would be without playtesting it but I think at 4 Mana it would probably be absolutely busted. Also a very scary weapon in the same class that has access to Inara Stormcrash on the following turn.
I like it, but the name could be better (unless it's an actual type of wrench, but I couldn't find anything in Google)
AeroJulwin
I liked the previous statline more, as it allowed it to be useful even if you don't trigger the effect. That said, the new one has the advantage of being easier to trigger, so I'm not sure.
Moondreamer
I'd probably drop the "giving Health" part and give it vanilla stats or Taunt to make up for it.
Arkasaur
Premeditate is the better card, but it should really be a Battlecry minion. Probably a vanilla one (something like a 2/3/2 or a 3/3/4), as the effect isn't immediately impactful and needs setup.
Equipment is a really old concept, spawned in Magic decades ago.
In magic equipment never really was that good unless it:
made the wearer untouchable (in lor this would be spellshield)
Buffed way above rate (like give 10/10 for 1 mana)
have a low cast and equip cost (cutlas would be an example for that)
gave the wearer broken keywords (like in LoR double attack, scout, overwhelm, elusive, lifesteal)
...or were almost free while giving the most broken keywords at fast speed (embercleave cought)
To be honest: I doubt that riot will hit the mark with equipments as with a large card pool as we have in LoR and the countless possible interactions there won't be the right manacost/powerlevel for equipments.
You can make them strong, open for multiple archetypes and therefore broken on selected wearers or weak unless selected wearers use them and very niche
Oi, are these quips really necessary? Usually a slippery slope.
TinTin, people took some umbrage with the "bronze players" comment, because it's really not the bronze casual players (who often just play, have fun, mind their business) complaining on Twitter or Reddit. It's more like your very invested hardcore crowd, lots of Legend holders. Make of that what you will.
Now not liking the direction of nerfs or whatever else in terms of balance is anyone's right and a fair argument, but that's different from the direction this took. With these changes it often seems like something will annoy one person while pleasing another.
Well, from my personal experience, it´s quite easy and common to get the DH location in Duels, while playing a deck with Relics, if you have any of them. If not, make a deck with any CN card you own, and the game should offer you an Relic bucket, but I didn´t test that, tho it might be worth a try. Good luck!
I tried Steamcleaner, but both the chess cards and the 6 added cards are considered to have started in the deck, so that didn't do anything spectacular. My opponent happened to play Ambassador Faelin though, so it was still useful.
One-Set Wonder - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
However, I don't like the new statline. 7 health is already a lot, but keep in mind that this is in the same set as Crystal Power. For only 1 extra Mana, this could be a 2/12, making it extremely difficult to remove. A good way to bypass this would be to have the passive only affect your other minions. The phrasing also doesn't sound completely natural to me. I propose this phrasing instead:
"Whenever you restore Health to a(nother) friendly minion, excess healing is converted into Health."
(Also, you accidentally put my name on linkblade's feedback)
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Recent Card Buffs, Including Demon Hunter's Relics and Pure Paladin
The Shadowverse community calls them Handless decks, which seems like a fair compromise between the two.
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Recent Card Nerfs, Including Celestial Alignment and Snowfall Guardian
If they provide the tools to create a deck that 95% of the player base cannot hope to use well, it's still a design fail.
The 6 Best Cards for Every Class in the “A Less Friendly Game of Chess” Tavern Brawl
The Deckbuilder should work for this brawl as well, at least it did in the past.
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Recent Card Buffs, Including Demon Hunter's Relics and Pure Paladin
I actually thought about this for a while: I ultimately went with "discard" because it gives the idea of you (momentarily or definitively) losing resources from your hand, but I agree that it's extremely debatable.
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Recent Card Buffs, Including Demon Hunter's Relics and Pure Paladin
So I wouldn't call the hyper aggressive buffed cards above a "discard" archetype, it's more like a shuffle archetype as only Kryxis the Voracious actually discards cards for DH
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Recent Card Nerfs, Including Celestial Alignment and Snowfall Guardian
The current miracle list going around has a VERY high skill cap. Even Zeddy confessed that he had difficulty mastering the deck.
One-Set Wonder - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Another Squeamlish design, this one more focused on the initial idea of Healing Druid. This allows a fully healed minion to get extra Health when healed, hopefully improving the lackluster Healing Druid cards and allowing some experimentation with old and underperforming neutral minions.
Aggressively statted for 4 Mana but Healing Druid needs a big push and this card still requires synergy, so this feels more than fair to me.
Some quick feedback:
Wailor - I like the new Deathmetal Encorer much more! It's a simple card but does its thing well. Well done!
Arkasaur - Very interesting concepts! You should absolutely go with Premeditate in my opinion. I'll give you some conflicting feedback: I think Wailor's off when he says that the card should be a minion. As a spell it can sit in your hand and do nothing, sure, but as a minion there's no way it wouldn't be busted. Rogue has waaaay too many ways to bounce minions. On a cheap minion, they could bounce it a bunch of times and get insane value as early as turn 3-4, on a mid to late game minion it would be a worthless effect (Shuffle Rogue wants to win in the early to midgame). Gloomblade is unprintable. If this card existed, Rogue would have a Wild OTK that you can pull off on turn 3 with a lucky hand, probably on turn 4-5 on average using Academic Espionage and a Preparation or two.
Linkblade - I really like the concept of a weapon allowing your board to essentially get Windfury. Very very hard to judge how good the card would be without playtesting it but I think at 4 Mana it would probably be absolutely busted. Also a very scary weapon in the same class that has access to Inara Stormcrash on the following turn.
The 6 Best Cards for Every Class in the “A Less Friendly Game of Chess” Tavern Brawl
I hate this brawl, but thank god for this article, makes a bit more bearable.
Glad to see article support for brawls.
Another Three Free Standard Packs Are Now Available Through Prime Gaming - The Final Stretch of Hearthstone Promotion
I know it's still far away, but maybe it's a good idea to save these standard packs for the mini-set if you don't buy it with gold or real money.
One-Set Wonder - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
New version of Deathmetal Encorer to differentiate it from Death Blossom Whomper.
Late feedback
The Darkin Saga: Awakening Is Legends of Runeterra's Latest Expansion - New Card Type, New Champion, and More
Equipment is a really old concept, spawned in Magic decades ago.
In magic equipment never really was that good unless it:
made the wearer untouchable (in lor this would be spellshield)
Buffed way above rate (like give 10/10 for 1 mana)
have a low cast and equip cost (cutlas would be an example for that)
gave the wearer broken keywords (like in LoR double attack, scout, overwhelm, elusive, lifesteal)
...or were almost free while giving the most broken keywords at fast speed (embercleave cought)
To be honest: I doubt that riot will hit the mark with equipments as with a large card pool as we have in LoR and the countless possible interactions there won't be the right manacost/powerlevel for equipments.
You can make them strong, open for multiple archetypes and therefore broken on selected wearers or weak unless selected wearers use them and very niche
Felstalker
More than 3 years have passed, but we do not forget.
A Less Friendly Game of Chess
I won with this team, but Kazakusan was late & Lady Prestor was dead last.
I had to replace Biology Project & Overgrowth.
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
Oi, are these quips really necessary? Usually a slippery slope.
TinTin, people took some umbrage with the "bronze players" comment, because it's really not the bronze casual players (who often just play, have fun, mind their business) complaining on Twitter or Reddit. It's more like your very invested hardcore crowd, lots of Legend holders. Make of that what you will.
Now not liking the direction of nerfs or whatever else in terms of balance is anyone's right and a fair argument, but that's different from the direction this took. With these changes it often seems like something will annoy one person while pleasing another.
Group Therapy! Need to blow off some steam? Mega salty? Here's the place!
WHY IS QUEST HUNTER STILL A FUCKING DECK. JUST DELETE IT ALREADY BLIZZARD, WTFFFFFFFFF
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
Always take a good look at yourself in the mirror when you wake up and brush your teeth!
A Less Friendly Game of Chess
it works, but Evolve itself, is Banned, so is Devolve. But you can still build a deck that works.
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
seems you have no other arguments........but im sure you think that you are still right....seek help boy
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Recent Card Nerfs, Including Celestial Alignment and Snowfall Guardian
I started playing Quest Hunter last night; good timing, huh?
The Darkin Saga: Awakening Is Legends of Runeterra's Latest Expansion - New Card Type, New Champion, and More
So after the waifu expansion we are getting the edgelord one.
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Recent Card Nerfs, Including Celestial Alignment and Snowfall Guardian
All those buffs to Rogue, and the entire class is still a Dumpster fire. Amazing.
The Next Special Hearthstone Quest for Castle Nathria Is Here - This Time for an Extended Duration
Well, from my personal experience, it´s quite easy and common to get the DH location in Duels, while playing a deck with Relics, if you have any of them. If not, make a deck with any CN card you own, and the game should offer you an Relic bucket, but I didn´t test that, tho it might be worth a try. Good luck!
Proof:
A Less Friendly Game of Chess
I tried Steamcleaner, but both the chess cards and the 6 added cards are considered to have started in the deck, so that didn't do anything spectacular. My opponent happened to play Ambassador Faelin though, so it was still useful.
A Less Friendly Game of Chess
Evolve Shaman for the win here!