Couldn't have said it myself. 'Bronze players' bemoan the game 1 per 1k as much as the diamond and legend players do. That is a standard statistical real fact!!
Seriously, the top squeaky wheels receive the most grease...
sorry i was totally wrong i must comprehend that most of the players are special kids like you who prefer flashing lights and shiny animations (and above all the rimotion of mechanics and cards that are perceived as unfair)
to a balanced game that includes aforementioned cards and mechanics, and i promise i will not keep the "bronze players argument" even if seems that the average MMR is low as much as the understanding of the game and the playing skill
Nerfs were pretty much as expected, and Im glad to know I'll be getting a bunch of dust thanks to the very slight wildseed nerf.
But buffs hmmmm...
- The buffs to the two relic cards in dhunter are a bit strange because I was sure they'd just buff Relic of Phantasms instead, that card being shit for obvious reasons at 3. I guess the idea here is that dhunter does so badly against implock that Relic of Extinction got the nod instead.
The change to Relic Vault makes it so it curves into Relic of Dimensions on second use. A not insignificant buff. Abyssal depths is at least competent, but I doubt it'll suddenly make the class tier 2.
- Changes to pally's dude cards are still not going to make the class playable. Team5 should just bite the bullet and call this expansion a dud for paladin. And why not? Implock and hunters are too fast, build bigger boards, shaman and mage can freeze the board for 4-7 turns, and pure pally's a meme, even after this pathetic buff to the invitations.
Should have at least reverted Cariel's nerf. I doubt these changes bring pally anywhere above midtable.
- Warrior buffs are good, but without any solid card draw options the class will remain weak. Probably at least they wont be below 40% power level. Honestly though, just revert the nerfs to From the Depths. I know its unpopular, but the power level of other decks have gone to the point that I dont think that matters too much. And besides which, there's no more scam nellie, so what's the problem with warrior having conditional discounts? We're quite content to have shaman cheat a billion murlocs out after 3, rogue playing their whole hand in one turn, or druid getting a 5 mana advantage, and apparently this is a problem?
- Rogue buffs would be impactful. But secret rogue will remain shit. Halkias may have stealth now, which substantially makes the card more powerful but that wouldn't alter the fact that the secret package itself is shit. If Kidnap got buffed to 'when' instead of the current 'after' I'd be singing another tune. But guess that's not forthcoming.
The buffs to Bibliomite and Magnifying Glaive are perhaps an indication of how difficult it is to balance the game between 30 and 40 health. The mite can do about 10 damage or at least 5 early game before being removed. And that matters, but not so if you have 40 health. And so where does this end? Now every aggro deck has to have reload, or be able to push a massive minion by turn 3, because if they dont they get destroyed by value because with 40 health the opponent can afford to greed. Druids will likely never play without renathal for that reason.
Eventually we're going to reach a point where aggro decks simply destroys 30 health simpletons whereas struggle against 40 health chads. Is this really where we want to head towards? Game being decided after hearing the intro sound effects? Pally's too slow, warrior has no reload, dhunter can no longer burst, and they all suck because they're facing 40 health greed classes and 30 health ultra aggro decks.
Maybe team5 should review Prince Renathal before the damage gets worse.
For my initial design this week, I propose Squeamlish, the clumsy Druid from Rise of Shadows.
The aim of this card is to push the Healing Druid archetype that was only really tried in Rise of Shadows. To make the card more interesting and open up brand new Druid strategies, Squeamlish doesn't just double the amount of Health restored by cards such as Crystal Power or Healing Touch but she also doubles the amount of Health given by cards, making some underplayed cards such as Mark of the Wild and Mark of Nature a viable choice for some decks.
Just a small note: be careful about the competition requirements! They specifically mention that the archetype you choose must not have been supported for more than two expansions.
This would, for example, disqualify both of Adam's first proposals (both Holy Paladin and Taunt Warrior have been pushed for countless expansions) and the unfortunately already submitted card for Murloc Paladin, another archetype that's been supported for quite a number of expansions by now.
I once said that my two favorite patches in Lor history was 1 the massive champ re-work (Katarina still viable to this day) and sundisc rework (still viable too)
But this patch beats both of them.
It hit Kaisa hard the number 1 offender of this expansion, but it hit Bard, Annie and Illoi my 3 picks for over powered Champs from the streamer expansion.
But thats not all it basically hit every other potentially problematic archetype too, thralls, aphelios P and Z, Xerath (hourglass spam) and buffed Ash and Anivia if that's your thing.
Beyond that we see some nice tweaks to followers and spells for under represented archetypes.
Like dont get me wrong I thought fixing thr dmg done by the last two expansions was in possible but they got it in 1 goof stuff guys, even aggro 4/4 got hit and like I didn't even think about that.
What a good time to be a Lor player, because outside of these 4 Champs the game was perfectly balanced and diverse
Goodbye, Annie, Bard, Illoi, and Kaisa nobody is going to miss you.
there will always be more bronze players than the rest. i think there is less than 1% of accounts that have ever reached legendary. so yeah blame the devs for trying to make the game more fun for the vast majority.
Fair enough. Fun is subjective, and I almost didn't put that second paragraph in my comment because I worried it would distract from the overall point.
In general, what I hope for is a variety of viable decks with a variety of play styles and no clear dominant one. As a secondary concern, I hope that today's viable decks are different from the ones we had 2 months ago or that we will have 2 months from now. It sounds like Rubin is making a lot of metrics that address my secondary concern, but none for the primary one.
It's been a while since I last made cards for older expansions.
Clearly...! I always forget Rush was only released in Witchwood. That's the time I started playing Hearthstone, so to my brain Rush has just always been a thing.
Anyhow, I'll be going with Moonglow Stalker. Here's the changed version. I also 'buffed' the stats because powercreep. Although the more I think about, the less sure I am. It can provide a strong removal later on, so I don't want it to be too cheap, but on the other hand, you do need to pay for a big minion first. Please let me know what statline you think makes more sense.
I am glad someone finds these guides useful, so I am more than okay with writing them :)
It goes without being said that all kinds of feedback (expressed in a civil way, of course) are more than welcome: if you all think you have a tip, a strategy or something else that I forgot to mention and that you deem worth the spot on the guide, do not be afraid to comment it or to DM me!
Hearthstone isn't an abstract game where all that matters is the numbers. The developers put a lot of effort in artwork, animations, voice lines and sound effects for a reason. If a card makes a lot of players have a bad experience, then that is a problem, even if balance-wise the card is not an outlier.
Also I don't buy the argument that it's the "bronze" players doing most of the complaining. I think that the most vocal people tend to have a lot of time and thought invested into the game and that typically translates into being well above average in terms of MMR.
What worries me a bit is that most of the dev comments talk about how a card functions in the current Standard meta. Those same cards are playable in Wild, Duels and Arena as well though, so I think balance changes should be more about what the correct power level for a card is and less about the meta.
I understand you can't fully judge a card in a vacuum, but over-focusing on the current Standard meta means you can break balance in other modes and also that you might have to undo nerfs and buffs when new cards enter Standard.
Also there might be fun cards that see no play because their power level is way too low. Those may not get the attention they need if your question is "how do we boost this class?" instead of "why is no-one playing these cards?"
Had really hoped that they wouldve buffed metamoprhis and warglaives for DH
The dude pally buffs are pretty insane but without better and more ways to summon them, i dont think will matter
And i still dont see odd pally commpeting against rest of the meta, same for odd dh in wild.
Disapointed is no macaw nerf, though i lvoe snowfall change, macaw repeating iti was the annoying thing, the thign that made you not able to play the game
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
Couldn't have said it myself. 'Bronze players' bemoan the game 1 per 1k as much as the diamond and legend players do. That is a standard statistical real fact!!
Seriously, the top squeaky wheels receive the most grease...
How to Complete Castle Nathria's Druid Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!
Untapped Potential didn't work for me (Darkmoon Rabbit + Survival of the Fittest pulled with one Bud)
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
sorry i was totally wrong i must comprehend that most of the players are special kids like you who prefer flashing lights and shiny animations (and above all the rimotion of mechanics and cards that are perceived as unfair)
to a balanced game that includes aforementioned cards and mechanics, and i promise i will not keep the "bronze players argument" even if seems that the average MMR is low as much as the understanding of the game and the playing skill
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
i suppose who like to play cards that "feels unfair" is not included in everyone
Runeterra Game Designer Steve Rubin Shares His Thoughts on Ideal Patch Outcomes
True, it would suck if they were to nerf some of the new decks just to go back to a meta dominated by tralls or Azir/Irelia.
Over 40 Card Changes Coming in This Week's Legends of Runeterra 3.13 Patch - Full Changes Detailed
1 mana Ancient Hourglass was really broken but will 2 mana be enough? We shall see ;)
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
The difference is that the new version has Stealth. The rest of it is just rewording it to fit on the card (and, IMO, improving clarity)
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
Nerfs were pretty much as expected, and Im glad to know I'll be getting a bunch of dust thanks to the very slight wildseed nerf.
But buffs hmmmm...
- The buffs to the two relic cards in dhunter are a bit strange because I was sure they'd just buff Relic of Phantasms instead, that card being shit for obvious reasons at 3. I guess the idea here is that dhunter does so badly against implock that Relic of Extinction got the nod instead.
The change to Relic Vault makes it so it curves into Relic of Dimensions on second use. A not insignificant buff. Abyssal depths is at least competent, but I doubt it'll suddenly make the class tier 2.
- Changes to pally's dude cards are still not going to make the class playable. Team5 should just bite the bullet and call this expansion a dud for paladin. And why not? Implock and hunters are too fast, build bigger boards, shaman and mage can freeze the board for 4-7 turns, and pure pally's a meme, even after this pathetic buff to the invitations.
Should have at least reverted Cariel's nerf. I doubt these changes bring pally anywhere above midtable.
- Warrior buffs are good, but without any solid card draw options the class will remain weak. Probably at least they wont be below 40% power level. Honestly though, just revert the nerfs to From the Depths. I know its unpopular, but the power level of other decks have gone to the point that I dont think that matters too much. And besides which, there's no more scam nellie, so what's the problem with warrior having conditional discounts? We're quite content to have shaman cheat a billion murlocs out after 3, rogue playing their whole hand in one turn, or druid getting a 5 mana advantage, and apparently this is a problem?
- Rogue buffs would be impactful. But secret rogue will remain shit. Halkias may have stealth now, which substantially makes the card more powerful but that wouldn't alter the fact that the secret package itself is shit. If Kidnap got buffed to 'when' instead of the current 'after' I'd be singing another tune. But guess that's not forthcoming.
The buffs to Bibliomite and Magnifying Glaive are perhaps an indication of how difficult it is to balance the game between 30 and 40 health. The mite can do about 10 damage or at least 5 early game before being removed. And that matters, but not so if you have 40 health. And so where does this end? Now every aggro deck has to have reload, or be able to push a massive minion by turn 3, because if they dont they get destroyed by value because with 40 health the opponent can afford to greed. Druids will likely never play without renathal for that reason.
Eventually we're going to reach a point where aggro decks simply destroys 30 health simpletons whereas struggle against 40 health chads. Is this really where we want to head towards? Game being decided after hearing the intro sound effects? Pally's too slow, warrior has no reload, dhunter can no longer burst, and they all suck because they're facing 40 health greed classes and 30 health ultra aggro decks.
Maybe team5 should review Prince Renathal before the damage gets worse.
All Balance Changes Coming to Hearthstone Battlegrounds - The Return of Grease Bot and Garr, Minion and Hero Updates, & More
Deathwing reverted, LET'S GO!!!
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
I am not understanding the change to Halkias. Does it now work even if the secret is still in your hand?
One-Set Wonder - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
For my initial design this week, I propose Squeamlish, the clumsy Druid from Rise of Shadows.
The aim of this card is to push the Healing Druid archetype that was only really tried in Rise of Shadows. To make the card more interesting and open up brand new Druid strategies, Squeamlish doesn't just double the amount of Health restored by cards such as Crystal Power or Healing Touch but she also doubles the amount of Health given by cards, making some underplayed cards such as Mark of the Wild and Mark of Nature a viable choice for some decks.
Just a small note: be careful about the competition requirements! They specifically mention that the archetype you choose must not have been supported for more than two expansions.
This would, for example, disqualify both of Adam's first proposals (both Holy Paladin and Taunt Warrior have been pushed for countless expansions) and the unfortunately already submitted card for Murloc Paladin, another archetype that's been supported for quite a number of expansions by now.
The Next Special Hearthstone Quest for Castle Nathria Is Here - This Time for an Extended Duration
You totally had me on "free".
God Tier World Waker Patch
I once said that my two favorite patches in Lor history was 1 the massive champ re-work (Katarina still viable to this day) and sundisc rework (still viable too)
But this patch beats both of them.
It hit Kaisa hard the number 1 offender of this expansion, but it hit Bard, Annie and Illoi my 3 picks for over powered Champs from the streamer expansion.
But thats not all it basically hit every other potentially problematic archetype too, thralls, aphelios P and Z, Xerath (hourglass spam) and buffed Ash and Anivia if that's your thing.
Beyond that we see some nice tweaks to followers and spells for under represented archetypes.
Like dont get me wrong I thought fixing thr dmg done by the last two expansions was in possible but they got it in 1 goof stuff guys, even aggro 4/4 got hit and like I didn't even think about that.
What a good time to be a Lor player, because outside of these 4 Champs the game was perfectly balanced and diverse
Goodbye, Annie, Bard, Illoi, and Kaisa nobody is going to miss you.
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
there will always be more bronze players than the rest. i think there is less than 1% of accounts that have ever reached legendary. so yeah blame the devs for trying to make the game more fun for the vast majority.
Runeterra Game Designer Steve Rubin Shares His Thoughts on Ideal Patch Outcomes
Fair enough. Fun is subjective, and I almost didn't put that second paragraph in my comment because I worried it would distract from the overall point.
In general, what I hope for is a variety of viable decks with a variety of play styles and no clear dominant one. As a secondary concern, I hope that today's viable decks are different from the ones we had 2 months ago or that we will have 2 months from now. It sounds like Rubin is making a lot of metrics that address my secondary concern, but none for the primary one.
One-Set Wonder - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Clearly...! I always forget Rush was only released in Witchwood. That's the time I started playing Hearthstone, so to my brain Rush has just always been a thing.
Anyhow, I'll be going with Moonglow Stalker. Here's the changed version. I also 'buffed' the stats because powercreep. Although the more I think about, the less sure I am. It can provide a strong removal later on, so I don't want it to be too cheap, but on the other hand, you do need to pay for a big minion first. Please let me know what statline you think makes more sense.
How to Complete Castle Nathria's Hunter Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!
I am glad someone finds these guides useful, so I am more than okay with writing them :)
It goes without being said that all kinds of feedback (expressed in a civil way, of course) are more than welcome: if you all think you have a tip, a strategy or something else that I forgot to mention and that you deem worth the spot on the guide, do not be afraid to comment it or to DM me!
How to Complete Castle Nathria's Hunter Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!
Cool, I´m glad if it helps someone. Anyway, thanks for your work and putting this all together, Avalon :)
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
Not a fan of the battlecry packages for Control Shaman. They should have touched macaw/Sire combo.
Wonder how DH turns out.
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
Hearthstone isn't an abstract game where all that matters is the numbers. The developers put a lot of effort in artwork, animations, voice lines and sound effects for a reason. If a card makes a lot of players have a bad experience, then that is a problem, even if balance-wise the card is not an outlier.
Also I don't buy the argument that it's the "bronze" players doing most of the complaining. I think that the most vocal people tend to have a lot of time and thought invested into the game and that typically translates into being well above average in terms of MMR.
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
Vile Library gave the minion +1/+1, then repeated for each Imp you control. Have four Imps? That's +5/+5. Now it doesn't have that initial +1/+1.
Over 40 Card Changes Coming in This Week's Legends of Runeterra 3.13 Patch - Full Changes Detailed
I think that Ancient Hourglass should cost 3 mana now because the card already cost 2 mana
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
What worries me a bit is that most of the dev comments talk about how a card functions in the current Standard meta. Those same cards are playable in Wild, Duels and Arena as well though, so I think balance changes should be more about what the correct power level for a card is and less about the meta.
I understand you can't fully judge a card in a vacuum, but over-focusing on the current Standard meta means you can break balance in other modes and also that you might have to undo nerfs and buffs when new cards enter Standard.
Also there might be fun cards that see no play because their power level is way too low. Those may not get the attention they need if your question is "how do we boost this class?" instead of "why is no-one playing these cards?"
How to Complete Castle Nathria's Druid Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!
Thanks!
All Standard & Wild Hearthstone Balance Changes Detailed - Some Nerfs and Lots of Buffs Are Now on the Way
Had really hoped that they wouldve buffed metamoprhis and warglaives for DH
The dude pally buffs are pretty insane but without better and more ways to summon them, i dont think will matter
And i still dont see odd pally commpeting against rest of the meta, same for odd dh in wild.
Disapointed is no macaw nerf, though i lvoe snowfall change, macaw repeating iti was the annoying thing, the thign that made you not able to play the game