Soul of the Murloc Question

I'm playing Murloc Shaman. Just about every deck uses Soul of the Murloc x 2. 

I'm debating if this card is really that great. Against Warrior, Warpath seems to make quick work of the extra murlocs.

Against other faster decks (Hunter, Zoo), I wonder if 2 smaller minions might be better.

Just curious what others think?

Extra bodies to force to enemy to clear is always nice. Not every class has access to cards like Warpath, making it very time and resource consuming to clear the extra 1/1s.

Thank you both! 

Yes, along the lines of what the others have said, it is a case of working out when the card is good and against which match ups. As you say, it may struggle against Warpath, but fortunately that is limited to Warrior and most other classes will have a much harder time clearing your board effectively twice. 
It's a great card - it simply requires a little forethought before playing it and learning what answers to expect the opponent to have.

Best of luck! :-D

I still run 1 copy in my murloc shaman deck , I understand the argument against using it. 

Especially against warriors,  but I also run the stormbringer so if I'm left with a board of 1/1's I can possibly bounce back unless I'm gifted Duskfallen Avaina which in that case they're probably whisked away by a free brawl , twisting nether or whatever 

Once the buffs hit I imagine Overload Murloc Shaman is going to get pretty popular. At that time you will definitely want at least one copy of the card considering how easily you will drop tokens on the field and how well multiple cards can synergize with your board.

But it can deal with Brawl, try to bait or wait out for warrior to use both arpath first and keep it for Brawl to garunteed next turn damage with Bloodlust or Warleader . But usually they will have Dr. Boom and keep Brawl with rush mech to clear the left Murloc. Warrior is a bad matchup, even you play around removal spell very good but cannot end fast enough Dr. Boom is going to out value you very fast. 

Quote From RaveAnne

But it can deal with Brawl, try to bait or wait out for warrior to use both arpath first and keep it for Brawl to garunteed next turn damage with Bloodlust or Warleader . But usually they will have Dr. Boom and keep Brawl with rush mech to clear the left Murloc. Warrior is a bad matchup, even you play around removal spell very good but cannot end fast enough Dr. Boom is going to out value you very fast. 

While it's a bad match up it feels so good to out play or play around their nonsense. Henchclan Hags help against Dynomatic as well. 

As a follow up question, I would like to know everyone's thoughts on including Scargil. I'm surprised most of the pro decklists I see online don't include this card. I am using it and find it can be great for a powerful swing turn on 5 or 6 (i.e. drop Scargill plus one or two other murlocs for a tempo swing).  But I rarely see it in these lists... rather I'm seeing 2 x Hogsteed for example or other smaller minions.

Am I wrong for including it?

Quote From Starscream

As a follow up question, I would like to know everyone's thoughts on including Scargil. I'm surprised most of the pro decklists I see online don't include this card. I am using it and find it can be great for a powerful swing turn on 5 or 6 (i.e. drop Scargill plus one or two other murlocs for a tempo swing).  But I rarely see it in these lists... rather I'm seeing 2 x Hogsteed for example or other smaller minions.

Am I wrong for including it?

I think you don't want/need a temposwing on t5 or t6 you want to close out games around those turns. And you want to keep board control and that means less expensive minions, for example with rush. Scargil  is "only" good when combo-ed with another murloc and even than murlocs are not expensive so you only discount them with 1 or 2 mana.