+1 to a a lot of what AngryShuckie is saying. When discussing an MTG card that seemed to violate some rules, a friend of mine quipped that the text on each MTG card basically reads "here's how I break the rules." Creatures don't get to attack the turn they're summoned, except when their text includes Haste, for example. It's easy to point to new card designs and see them as breaking rules, but a lot of times the point of a card is to do something novel, and the fundamental rules aren't violated.
I think a lot of the original red lines here aren't really red lines that the game has crossed, as they were in the original game:
Felguard destroyed a mana crystal in Classic Hearthstone
The existence of armor made having a health total that exceeded 30 possible for multiple classes in Classic Hearthstone
Tech cards like Mana Wraith could impact the cost of key cards for your opponent in Classic Hearthstone. Not as strong as Loatheb by a mile, but it's still there
There were no rules that said you couldn't restrict your deck to singleton, or evens only, or only shadow spells, etc., in Hearthstone ever - they just didn't make sense without payoffs
On a related note, there are some newer effects here that have reasonable precursors:
Sigils are similar to Secrets
Objectives are similar to end-of-turn triggers on minions
Dual class cards operate in some strange middle space between neutral and class cards, and focus on shared identity of those classes (i.e. we're not seeing massive card draw added to Priest via Mage/Priest class cards - there's more commonality than that)
I think there are some real rule breaks here - like being able to gain up to 20 mana, or hold up to 12 cards, or having a card that always shows up in your opening hand - but mostly these are examples of effects which have been tuned up and down over the history of Hearthstone, not red lines that have been crossed.
I think the most egregious examples of rule breaks are breaks to constants (e.g. your starting hand is random, you only have 90 seconds to take your turn). Rule breaks on varying systems (e.g. how many cards can you have, how much mana can you have) is generally much more manageable because those are resources that are designed to change over the course of the game, so there are already cards that interact with them, making balance easier to judge. This is why Guff works (there have been lots of mana cheat tools in Druid, so Blizzard has some sense of how OP that would be and took out Maly before releasing this), and Valdris was never interesting (12 cards isn't that many more than 10, and you want to play cards, so you'll rarely get there), but Quests and especially Open the Waygate have made very problematic metas (while the OG Nozdormu was a pain for randomly generated effects).
Honestly, I don't think I'd want to see most of the other core rules of the game crossed. The balance on these things is just too hard. But I could imagine seeing more examples of Sigil-like or Objective-like spells added to the game, and maybe even secrets. One kind of wild thing I'd love to see would be a Core set with secrets for every class plus an expansion with secrets for every class released all at once at the start of a rotation. That would add enough secrets to make them work for any class, it would equalize that "I do stuff on your turn" feature that some classes have but other don't, and it would eventually rotate out so as not to become a permanent feature of the game.
I bet this is just the beginning. Chi-Ji is just the first I'd imagine. If you'd like to look at a current progression chart for Star Wars Galaxy of Heroes ( I game I invested both a ton of time into, as well as *thousands* of dollars.) Then look at this:
Granted the game has been out for awhile now, but that's a fairly updated (as of end of last year) farming guide infographic. And each "legendary" or equivalent character requires usually 2-3 new characters, in addition to 3 old characters. Now Mercs is vastly different, and I suspect that the grind will not be as nearly bad as SWGOH is...
...but it does give you an idea/taste of what a farming progression path could possibly look like.
I like to think of it a bit differently and say there are basic rules established from the start of the game:
Turn order, starting hand size and who gets the coin.
Decks are shuffled with random card order (both before and after the mulligan).
Draw a card and gain a mana crystal each turn. (Start with 0 mana crystals before turn 1.)
Each turn lasts 90 seconds (plus minor modifications for turns 1 and 2, and going down to 15s if you're AFK).
Max hand size is 10 and mana cap is also 10.
You have a hero power that is refreshed each turn and an associated hero that starts at 30 health.
All cards and hero powers cost a specified amount of mana.
Card types do the following:
Spells are 1-time effects.
Weapons are hero attack modifiers on that player's turn.
Minions are... actually too much to bother explaining the rules for here.
Hero cards are glorified spells that always give you a new hero power and some armour.
I'm gonna be honest: half of why I wrote all these out was so I could justify calling hero cards glorified spells. I refuse to put them on a pedestal until they get something other than a battlecry/choose one/combo effect and they are no longer just complicated 1-time effects.
A bunch of rules for keywords that no one has time to go into fully. Secrets (and maybe quests) are the only ones that really need special rules, the rest are all just shorthand.
I'm sure I missed some, but you get the point. That all defines 'Hearthstone'. Tavern Brawls, Duels and solo stuff can change some rules of course.
What's important is that nowhere does it say what card and hero power effects can and cannot do, including changing the original rules. In a sense there are no rules for card effects, there are only limitations on what the code is equipped to handle, at which point we can debate whether any red lines even exist to be eroded.
To speculate which basic rules change next, I don't actually see much that hasn't been messed with already. Even the distinction between card types has been blurred (albeit lightly) with Felsteel Executioner. Pretty much all that remains sacred so far is that weapons don't provide attack on your opponent's turn and secrets don't trigger on your own (but even that was different back in beta). I could believe they will one day print a weapon that's active on your opponent's turn, so long as it loses durability. The question is, is that actually useful enough to be worth making a card for it?
Mad Scientist is the MVP in my heart. I've had him in uncountable Secret Mage's seasons and in a lot of Hunters. Hyena should have an extra point for getting and surviving in Battlegrounds!
That might very well be it. I think I did enter the previous 2 boss fights with a Beast already dead I think. Most of the times I do not even read which attack the enemy mercenaries are using and usually just hit specific opposing mercenaries to get critical hits. I will try to be a bit more careful/efficient to get the remaining Chi-Ji tasks done, lest I do not have to redo the whole climb afterwards.
As far as we know, it should be just that you enter the boss fight with 3 Beasts alive. If one has died to normal encounters during your climb there, that's why it wouldn't have triggered.
Thanks, I was already using that exact same Nature team and my last attempt succeeded. Still not sure what prevented the trigger in the past, but this time around all 3 beasts remained alive and I really made sure (by keeping track) that no coins whatsoever were picked up except for spirit healer.
And I think this answers Basil's question about why there is a finalist vote to begin with.
No, not really. Of course downvoting your competition is a problem and risk, but there is no real way to combat that maybe outside a mod manually checking the votes to see if anyone was unfair.
My gripe with finalist stage is, again, abysmal number of votes compared to the main voting stage. This comp we had 17-34 votes per card in the main stage, and only 12 in finalists. In Make your own Luck it was 23-38 to 14. In Goons of Galakeond we had 15-37 votes to 14-17 in finals. Trend is consistent, about half of people who are interested in this thing dont partake in the most important moment of the comp. That makes finalist votes be much more biased due to a low number of votes.
A trend to notice when seeing the reports is also that the top finishers in the voting phase is almost always those with fewer votes received. It shows that as more people vote, the "fairer" your card is judged and more it drags towards 2.5 ish score. While top of the scoreboard is those with fewer votes, but if those fewer votes they have higher score ones. Basically, post late and hope the few people that see it like it a lot.
The only reason for the finalist stage that I can see is to avoid last minute posts and this luck I explained. But instead of a finalist stage we could just extend the voting only stage to 1 more day.
My proposal which i believe is most fair is to not allow voting at all in the submission stage! Instead 5 days we submit and they are hidden, then 2 days for voting where all are revealed at the same time. Perhaps post it on the main Hearthstone news page when that happens to attract more people into this thing, because let's be honest here, it's just the same 15ish guys over and over. A bit of publicity wouldn't hurt. And I don't believe the argument that "people dont wanna see custom content" is good, as we have a post comp summary where we announce the winner!
Who knows, its might just be another bug, like task 4's buggering requirements.
Maybe try with all six being beasts? It could also be that the game scans the final result and turns out that you need 3 beasts to stay alive on winning for this to trigger.
The slow but steady eroding of the red lines in HS
+1 to a a lot of what AngryShuckie is saying. When discussing an MTG card that seemed to violate some rules, a friend of mine quipped that the text on each MTG card basically reads "here's how I break the rules." Creatures don't get to attack the turn they're summoned, except when their text includes Haste, for example. It's easy to point to new card designs and see them as breaking rules, but a lot of times the point of a card is to do something novel, and the fundamental rules aren't violated.
I think a lot of the original red lines here aren't really red lines that the game has crossed, as they were in the original game:
On a related note, there are some newer effects here that have reasonable precursors:
I think there are some real rule breaks here - like being able to gain up to 20 mana, or hold up to 12 cards, or having a card that always shows up in your opening hand - but mostly these are examples of effects which have been tuned up and down over the history of Hearthstone, not red lines that have been crossed.
I think the most egregious examples of rule breaks are breaks to constants (e.g. your starting hand is random, you only have 90 seconds to take your turn). Rule breaks on varying systems (e.g. how many cards can you have, how much mana can you have) is generally much more manageable because those are resources that are designed to change over the course of the game, so there are already cards that interact with them, making balance easier to judge. This is why Guff works (there have been lots of mana cheat tools in Druid, so Blizzard has some sense of how OP that would be and took out Maly before releasing this), and Valdris was never interesting (12 cards isn't that many more than 10, and you want to play cards, so you'll rarely get there), but Quests and especially Open the Waygate have made very problematic metas (while the OG Nozdormu was a pain for randomly generated effects).
Honestly, I don't think I'd want to see most of the other core rules of the game crossed. The balance on these things is just too hard. But I could imagine seeing more examples of Sigil-like or Objective-like spells added to the game, and maybe even secrets. One kind of wild thing I'd love to see would be a Core set with secrets for every class plus an expansion with secrets for every class released all at once at the start of a rotation. That would add enough secrets to make them work for any class, it would equalize that "I do stuff on your turn" feature that some classes have but other don't, and it would eventually rotate out so as not to become a permanent feature of the game.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
I bet this is just the beginning. Chi-Ji is just the first I'd imagine. If you'd like to look at a current progression chart for Star Wars Galaxy of Heroes ( I game I invested both a ton of time into, as well as *thousands* of dollars.) Then look at this:
Granted the game has been out for awhile now, but that's a fairly updated (as of end of last year) farming guide infographic. And each "legendary" or equivalent character requires usually 2-3 new characters, in addition to 3 old characters. Now Mercs is vastly different, and I suspect that the grind will not be as nearly bad as SWGOH is...
...but it does give you an idea/taste of what a farming progression path could possibly look like.
Элем шаман альтерак
English or GTFO.
Happy Twosday! Celebrating Hearthstone's 10 Most Influential 2 Mana 2/2 Cards
It was on this Patch 1.0.0.3890 (2013-10-02)
Snowpocalypse 2
Why has there been almost no clue discussion compared to previous events?
I'm stuck on You can never forget the classic yellow Christmas tree.
The slow but steady eroding of the red lines in HS
I like to think of it a bit differently and say there are basic rules established from the start of the game:
I'm sure I missed some, but you get the point. That all defines 'Hearthstone'. Tavern Brawls, Duels and solo stuff can change some rules of course.
What's important is that nowhere does it say what card and hero power effects can and cannot do, including changing the original rules. In a sense there are no rules for card effects, there are only limitations on what the code is equipped to handle, at which point we can debate whether any red lines even exist to be eroded.
To speculate which basic rules change next, I don't actually see much that hasn't been messed with already. Even the distinction between card types has been blurred (albeit lightly) with Felsteel Executioner. Pretty much all that remains sacred so far is that weapons don't provide attack on your opponent's turn and secrets don't trigger on your own (but even that was different back in beta). I could believe they will one day print a weapon that's active on your opponent's turn, so long as it loses durability. The question is, is that actually useful enough to be worth making a card for it?
The slow but steady eroding of the red lines in HS
Next I want the physical barrier between players removed so I can punch my opponent in the face when he pulls some RNG bullshit.
Happy Twosday! Celebrating Hearthstone's 10 Most Influential 2 Mana 2/2 Cards
When was that? It's only counted friendly beasts for as long as I've played, and I've been around since just after Naxx.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Yeah, i most likely wont. I might not do any, since i would first have to finish BRM, which i dont really want to :/
The slow but steady eroding of the red lines in HS
Thanks for the additions! I was just giving examples, no claim for totality ;-)
Happy Twosday! Celebrating Hearthstone's 10 Most Influential 2 Mana 2/2 Cards
Hyena WAS nerfed. It used to count all beasts, no just friendly ones.
Other
### Reno Chaoslock
# Class: Warlock
# Format: Wild
#
# 1x (1) Armor Vendor
# 1x (2) Defile
# 1x (2) Dirty Rat
# 1x (2) Plot Twist
# 1x (2) Zephrys the Great
# 1x (3) Brann Bronzebeard
# 1x (3) Dark Skies
# 1x (3) Zola the Gorgon
# 1x (4) Hullbreaker
# 1x (4) Kazakus
# 1x (4) Voidcaller
# 1x (5) Deck of Chaos
# 1x (5) Envoy Rustwix
# 1x (5) Skull of the Man'ari
# 1x (5) Zilliax
# 1x (6) Entitled Customer
# 1x (6) Keli'dan the Breaker
# 1x (6) Reno Jackson
# 1x (7) Enslaved Fel Lord
# 1x (7) Lord Godfrey
# 1x (7) Mutanus the Devourer
# 1x (8) Archwitch Willow
# 1x (8) Enhanced Dreadlord
# 1x (8) Fel Lord Betrug
# 1x (8) Mo'arg Forgefiend
# 1x (9) Krul the Unshackled
# 1x (9) Mal'Ganis
# 1x (9) Voidlord
# 1x (10) Bloodreaver Gul'dan
# 1x (10) N'Zoth, the Corruptor
#
AAEBAa35Ax6ODsIPwxaFF+CsAti7Atm8At/EAufLApfTAujnAtvpAsPqApz4AqCAA9qbA4mdA/yjA+usA8S5A+6/A/TOA73jA/bjA5LkA6bvA8z5A4L7A8aABNOFBAAA
#
# To use this deck, copy it to your clipboard and create a new deck in Hearthstone
The slow but steady eroding of the red lines in HS
Void Contract destroys decks, too (half of each)
Also, there are more subtle deckbuilding altering cards like Kazakusan, Kazakus, Golem Shaper, Prince Keleseth, Prince Taldaram, Prince Valanar, Drek'Thar or Vanndar Stormpike. All mage or hunter cards which work only if your deck contains spells only (Font of Power, Apexis Blast, To My Side!, Rhok'delar).
Lord Jaraxxus used to set your life to 15.
Also, Transfer Student cares for board.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
There are reports that if you use boons or mystery node it glitches out
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
This event is is terrible I don't want to do all those heroics at all
Happy Twosday! Celebrating Hearthstone's 10 Most Influential 2 Mana 2/2 Cards
Mad Scientist is the MVP in my heart. I've had him in uncountable Secret Mage's seasons and in a lot of Hunters. Hyena should have an extra point for getting and surviving in Battlegrounds!
Awesome post! Happy 22/02/2022 everyone!
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
That might very well be it. I think I did enter the previous 2 boss fights with a Beast already dead I think. Most of the times I do not even read which attack the enemy mercenaries are using and usually just hit specific opposing mercenaries to get critical hits. I will try to be a bit more careful/efficient to get the remaining Chi-Ji tasks done, lest I do not have to redo the whole climb afterwards.
EDIT: All tasks have been completed, yay!
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
As far as we know, it should be just that you enter the boss fight with 3 Beasts alive. If one has died to normal encounters during your climb there, that's why it wouldn't have triggered.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Thanks, I was already using that exact same Nature team and my last attempt succeeded. Still not sure what prevented the trigger in the past, but this time around all 3 beasts remained alive and I really made sure (by keeping track) that no coins whatsoever were picked up except for spirit healer.
Still 4 tasks left to complete. Good luck!
The Perfect Match - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
No, not really. Of course downvoting your competition is a problem and risk, but there is no real way to combat that maybe outside a mod manually checking the votes to see if anyone was unfair.
My gripe with finalist stage is, again, abysmal number of votes compared to the main voting stage. This comp we had 17-34 votes per card in the main stage, and only 12 in finalists. In Make your own Luck it was 23-38 to 14. In Goons of Galakeond we had 15-37 votes to 14-17 in finals. Trend is consistent, about half of people who are interested in this thing dont partake in the most important moment of the comp. That makes finalist votes be much more biased due to a low number of votes.
A trend to notice when seeing the reports is also that the top finishers in the voting phase is almost always those with fewer votes received. It shows that as more people vote, the "fairer" your card is judged and more it drags towards 2.5 ish score. While top of the scoreboard is those with fewer votes, but if those fewer votes they have higher score ones. Basically, post late and hope the few people that see it like it a lot.
The only reason for the finalist stage that I can see is to avoid last minute posts and this luck I explained. But instead of a finalist stage we could just extend the voting only stage to 1 more day.
My proposal which i believe is most fair is to not allow voting at all in the submission stage! Instead 5 days we submit and they are hidden, then 2 days for voting where all are revealed at the same time. Perhaps post it on the main Hearthstone news page when that happens to attract more people into this thing, because let's be honest here, it's just the same 15ish guys over and over. A bit of publicity wouldn't hurt. And I don't believe the argument that "people dont wanna see custom content" is good, as we have a post comp summary where we announce the winner!
2x2x2 Hearthstone Decks to Play on Twosday - Off-Meta Deck Fun!
This article is two great 😜
22nd of Fed is both a palindrome and an ambigram. The date will be read the same from left to right, right to left AND upside down!
2x2x2 Hearthstone Decks to Play on Twosday - Off-Meta Deck Fun!
Great one ! Good job team !
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
So technically you can have a bench of 3 beasts while piloting a non-beast team to victory and it'll still trigger?
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
I used Malfurion+Brukan+Anacondra and 3 beasts that I have not max'ed.
Unfortunately I cant remember exactly, but I think one of my beasts died early in the run. but not sure tho.
Just use the 3 mercs I said above, and try to pick all nature+damage treasures. brukan's double ability 1 treasure is also very very good.
with all that, I have not experienced any problems. best of luck to you
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Who knows, its might just be another bug, like task 4's buggering requirements.
Maybe try with all six being beasts? It could also be that the game scans the final result and turns out that you need 3 beasts to stay alive on winning for this to trigger.