Task 6: Complete Heroic Ivus with at least 3 Beasts in Alterac Valley does not trigger for me, I already completed it 2 times. Could it perhaps be that all 3 beasts need to live at the end of the climb?
During both tries, 1 beast died, but I have never seen this kind of requirement in this game mode.
One of the best aspects of Hearthstone is that the game is easy to learn, it's nested in a firm set of rules. Over time, Blizzard has slowly but steadily eroded some of those though:
- Genn & Baku and the Highlander cards completely altered our perception of deckbuilding
- Dual class cards mingled stuff that was strictly seperated
- Silas Darkmoon allows you to influence the board state
- Quest(line)s always start in your hand
- Sigils and the Alterac cards with an ongoing effect trigger on future turns
- there are several tech cards that negate or hinder key effects of your opponent's cards (like Counterspell and Loatheb, Nerub'ar Weblord and Boompistol Bully, various forms of Silence and so on and so forth)
I guess designs like those are necessary to keep the game fresh and exciting, but the range of possibilities is finite and it makes me wonder what comes up next. Decks with 40 cards? A new card type? The long discussed graveyard? 15 Mana cards for Druid?
Whatever it may be, it feels like the devs have raised their speed when it comes to introducing new stuff that breaks the formerly known rules. Wildheart Guff, Curse of Agony and the ongoing effect cards were all new stuff introduced in the last expansion. While I'm all in for exciting cards and interesting design, they long term alter the game as we know it and sometimes limit design space in a significant way.
Personally, I'd like to see more cards that reward catering to deckbuilding restrictions like Genn & Baku, the Highlander cards and Darkbishop Benedictus. They are challenging but also very rewarding and we haven't fully explored much of the possibilities yet. On the other hand, I'm skeptical about increasing ressources like Mana Crystals, hand space and life total because it speeds up the power creep significantly. Maybe I'm just nostalgic but I like that I more or less know what to expect from a game of Hearthstone.
All that said, I'm curious to hear your thoughts about the slow but steady eroding of the red lines in HS. Which rule do you want to see broken next? What new design makes you feel concerned?
So I finally complete task 4, and I can confirm that if you;
- Took no boon coins; spirit coins are okay
- and took no potatos. To be frank, I'd skip them altogether, because you want to face the bosses with all mercs having a passive.
You can then complete this task when you finally beat this fking boss with only casters. Because nothing is more grating than beating this thing and then finding out that you're screwed because of a bug
Here's a few tips for those trying. I did it with shadow/holy team
- Choose the helmet whenever you can
- Always beat the heroic mercs whenever you can, because the treasures here are invaluable
- Always position those with helmets or higher health merc on the sides.
- And above all; start by sniping the middle boss (the one with 150 health) because he deals a ton of damage and the side bosses are much more easier to manage.
One frustrating time to be sure. And Im not entirely certain you can do this with only rare mercs. Wont be too surprise if team5 eventually nerfs this task because its a massive gatekeeper against casuals.
Yeah, it's pretty awkward. Looking through the many synonyms of 'attack', I'm surprised at how few could be viable alternatives for fairly non-specific physical attacks. 'Strike' would be a decent alternative, but that's about it, and even that can be synonymous with spell attacks.
You can use 'ability' most of the time. Context will normally make it clear whether it is a damage dealing one or (in Pokemon terminology) a 'status move'.
I think, for me, the ideal number of finalists would be about 4 or 5, but I agree setting a percentage is also a good idea. Granted it comes with a set minimum of 3 spots. 25-30% sounds good.
Admittedly I have not quite got there yet, so I was just parroting what looked to be the solution others had said since your comment, and was also consistent with my understanding of usual task 'rules'.
I'll happily admit my mistake if Chi-Ji isn't the required part of it. Heck, if Chi-Ji isn't needed, I'll even argue further against Blizz and their dumb use of "complete" if it isn't even consistent!
Updated the original article based on the new information we got from the live servers so far: now the event is live in all regions, all 10 Tasks seem to be available from the get go (the patch notes didn't tell us the whole truth, or the live implementation missed the mark).
As players make their way through these Tasks, we also find out about potential bugs and workarounds. As noted in the text now, Task 4: Invokers of Hope gives people trouble. It still got to be full Casters team, but you shouldn't pick up any Class Boons or Bombs along the way (Chi-Ji does NOT have to be a part of the team, apparently).
It hardly seems to matter how much I try to improve my designs or interact in voting. I vote fairy? I get hammered with 1's. I don't vote at all? I get hammered with 1's.
Which…makes it increasingly unappealing to contribute at all.
I don't exactly think it's relevant to my proposal, but it's a concern nonetheless. And I think this answers Basil's question about why there is a finalist vote to begin with. Finalists not being able to vote also prevents them from downvoting their competition. So you might be able to sneak into the finals this way, but it won't increase your chances of winning.
I looked into the last few transparency reports and found a good example. In Make Your Own Luck, you submitted Arcane Power and it got five 1's. Admittedly, one of those was from me. That's because it's a major downgrade from Kirin Tor Tricaster and doesn't bring anything new to the table besides being a spell. It was a good idea, but a second set of eyes could have easily pointed out that Kirin Tor Tricaster already exists. Which is why I think you should follow Demon's advise and try the feedback threads.
Also, getting 1's sucks and there will always be a few unjust ones. This might sound stupid, but try not to focus on the negatives too much, because that will get frustrating. I personally only really check the averages.
Can confirm this seems to be the workaround, will update the text accordingly. Do not pick any class boons, and if you stumble onto a bomb, you might as well restart too. Chi-Ji does not seem to be necessary to have in the team.
I don't think it's a bug. The task says "complete" which always requires the merc associated with the task (Chi-Ji in this case) to be part of the team. Now, we can argue that "complete" having that meaning is dumb 'til the cows come home, but that's not a QA issue.
they wouldnt touch Hysteria cause its a standard card. wild is the issue here. and btw warlock pulls this combo off way more easily and consistent. 2 deathspearkers and the tiller is enough. 60 seconds dmg. if u face some high armour deck just play both tillers speakers and hysteria for 120 dmg. emperor reduces the cost and the way warlock draws is fast enough i was able to defeat a 80 armour druid by turn 10 . I had only 3 cards in the deck so u can see how fast the deck can draw and consistently pull the combo.
One year ago drawing the whole deck by turn 10 was a Wild thing, now it is done by multiple classes as a game plan in standard. Powercreep is very, very real.
Picked up Mercs again after a long long time just to get this "free" Merc. My collection is rather limited and I have to complete all Blackrock and Alterac, but let's see if the mode can redeem itself to my eyes.
Update: did Drakkisath, Rend and Razorgore and man, so difficult lol
I second the reduction of finalist spots proposal. There shouldn't be a fixed number of spots but a percentage of the initial number of participants.
Almost all competitions lately have been getting around 12 entries, and 8 finalist spots. That's... just eliminating the bottom 4. It's too little, the "finalist" stage feels more like "semi finals". I'd argue to keep it to 25% of initial entries, to really make it about the top brass since that's what the finalist stage is about.
Or, we could ditch the finalist stage entirely. I'm not sure why it exists honestly, the number of voters is always so so much lower than the initial 2 stages. It only lasts 1 day and so many of would be voters forget, dont know about it, are locked out of it as pointed above, or dont care enough to vote another time if their entries didnt make it.
I agree with all of the above.
Sorry for not participating much in the last few competitions... life got in the way and I felt a little burnt out of ideas. Did my best to cast my votes though so there's that. Thanks again to Shadows and everybody else who was part of organizing the competitions, you're doing an amazing job!
I second the reduction of finalist spots proposal. There shouldn't be a fixed number of spots but a percentage of the initial number of participants.
Almost all competitions lately have been getting around 12 entries, and 8 finalist spots. That's... just eliminating the bottom 4. It's too little, the "finalist" stage feels more like "semi finals". I'd argue to keep it to 25% of initial entries, to really make it about the top brass since that's what the finalist stage is about.
Or, we could ditch the finalist stage entirely. I'm not sure why it exists honestly, the number of voters is always so so much lower than the initial 2 stages. It only lasts 1 day and so many of would be voters forget, dont know about it, are locked out of it as pointed above, or dont care enough to vote another time if their entries didnt make it.
So the new expansion has dropped and what we are seeing from Galio and Gnar is good.
They are beaters and they beat things.
They have lists the can perform in the A and S tier.
Or you can just pilot Elise to a 60% winrate.
Like this is the thing, aggro, aggro-midrange these archetypes are kinda done.
Like you can release a million Champs that fit in as competitive beaters but statistically it is just more of the same.
Like gnars best deck is Zigs aggro, a deck that literally has existed for ages and has long since been competitive. Like it makes sense he burns and he's a big threat that cycles itself of course thats good.
But its also just a better version of things that we've already seen in a deck that has already existed.
Please Riot release control Champs, release alt wincons, give us more TF style cards, just anything other than hey here's a highly competitive card that goes face.
Pokemon TCG Live Launches in Canada Today - Everything You Need to Know
Yeah I’m super happy this will work on mobile because that was my main gripe with TCGO
2x2x2 Hearthstone Decks to Play on Twosday - Off-Meta Deck Fun!
Lol, this totally made my Twosday morning.
The NYT crossword puzzle is also celebrating the day, fyi.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Task 6: Complete Heroic Ivus with at least 3 Beasts in Alterac Valley does not trigger for me, I already completed it 2 times. Could it perhaps be that all 3 beasts need to live at the end of the climb?
During both tries, 1 beast died, but I have never seen this kind of requirement in this game mode.
Blizzard Reveals Raid Boss Onyxia - New Legendary Hearthstone Card for Onyxia's Lair
I was talking about any immunity not just hero. But I was wrong cuz I forgot Violet Illusionist
2x2x2 Hearthstone Decks to Play on Twosday - Off-Meta Deck Fun!
Nice to see some decks that do not easily show up on HSReplay. Thanks!
The slow but steady eroding of the red lines in HS
One of the best aspects of Hearthstone is that the game is easy to learn, it's nested in a firm set of rules. Over time, Blizzard has slowly but steadily eroded some of those though:
- Ice Block negates lethal
- Amara, Warden of Hope raises your life total beyond 30
- Valdris Felgorge allows you to hold more than 10 cards
- Tickatus and Gnomeferatu destroy cards, Rin, the First Disciple even your opponent's whole deck
- Wildheart Guff allows you to gain more than 10 Mana Crystals
- Blastcrystal Potion destroys Mana Crystals
- Genn & Baku and the Highlander cards completely altered our perception of deckbuilding
- Dual class cards mingled stuff that was strictly seperated
- Silas Darkmoon allows you to influence the board state
- Quest(line)s always start in your hand
- Sigils and the Alterac cards with an ongoing effect trigger on future turns
- there are several tech cards that negate or hinder key effects of your opponent's cards (like Counterspell and Loatheb, Nerub'ar Weblord and Boompistol Bully, various forms of Silence and so on and so forth)
I guess designs like those are necessary to keep the game fresh and exciting, but the range of possibilities is finite and it makes me wonder what comes up next. Decks with 40 cards? A new card type? The long discussed graveyard? 15 Mana cards for Druid?
Whatever it may be, it feels like the devs have raised their speed when it comes to introducing new stuff that breaks the formerly known rules. Wildheart Guff, Curse of Agony and the ongoing effect cards were all new stuff introduced in the last expansion. While I'm all in for exciting cards and interesting design, they long term alter the game as we know it and sometimes limit design space in a significant way.
Personally, I'd like to see more cards that reward catering to deckbuilding restrictions like Genn & Baku, the Highlander cards and Darkbishop Benedictus. They are challenging but also very rewarding and we haven't fully explored much of the possibilities yet. On the other hand, I'm skeptical about increasing ressources like Mana Crystals, hand space and life total because it speeds up the power creep significantly. Maybe I'm just nostalgic but I like that I more or less know what to expect from a game of Hearthstone.
All that said, I'm curious to hear your thoughts about the slow but steady eroding of the red lines in HS. Which rule do you want to see broken next? What new design makes you feel concerned?
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
So I finally complete task 4, and I can confirm that if you;
- Took no boon coins; spirit coins are okay
- and took no potatos. To be frank, I'd skip them altogether, because you want to face the bosses with all mercs having a passive.
You can then complete this task when you finally beat this fking boss with only casters. Because nothing is more grating than beating this thing and then finding out that you're screwed because of a bug
Here's a few tips for those trying. I did it with shadow/holy team
- Choose the helmet whenever you can
- Always beat the heroic mercs whenever you can, because the treasures here are invaluable
- Always position those with helmets or higher health merc on the sides.
- And above all; start by sniping the middle boss (the one with 150 health) because he deals a ton of damage and the side bosses are much more easier to manage.
One frustrating time to be sure. And Im not entirely certain you can do this with only rare mercs. Wont be too surprise if team5 eventually nerfs this task because its a massive gatekeeper against casuals.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Thank you! I just did it and it was just as you said.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Yeah, it's pretty awkward. Looking through the many synonyms of 'attack', I'm surprised at how few could be viable alternatives for fairly non-specific physical attacks. 'Strike' would be a decent alternative, but that's about it, and even that can be synonymous with spell attacks.
You can use 'ability' most of the time. Context will normally make it clear whether it is a damage dealing one or (in Pokemon terminology) a 'status move'.
The Perfect Match - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I think, for me, the ideal number of finalists would be about 4 or 5, but I agree setting a percentage is also a good idea. Granted it comes with a set minimum of 3 spots. 25-30% sounds good.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
I can only imagine what a pain these are with a limited collection. But nice going so far!
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Admittedly I have not quite got there yet, so I was just parroting what looked to be the solution others had said since your comment, and was also consistent with my understanding of usual task 'rules'.
I'll happily admit my mistake if Chi-Ji isn't the required part of it. Heck, if Chi-Ji isn't needed, I'll even argue further against Blizz and their dumb use of "complete" if it isn't even consistent!
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Updated the original article based on the new information we got from the live servers so far: now the event is live in all regions, all 10 Tasks seem to be available from the get go (the patch notes didn't tell us the whole truth, or the live implementation missed the mark).
As players make their way through these Tasks, we also find out about potential bugs and workarounds. As noted in the text now, Task 4: Invokers of Hope gives people trouble. It still got to be full Casters team, but you shouldn't pick up any Class Boons or Bombs along the way (Chi-Ji does NOT have to be a part of the team, apparently).
Pokemon TCG Live Launches in Canada Today - Everything You Need to Know
I am not from canada but I am, really excited about this! I stopped playing TCG online just because it was not on mobile.
Now that TCG LIVE is launching I really want to get into the scene again.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Have you tried to complete it with Chi-Ji in the team?
The Perfect Match - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I don't exactly think it's relevant to my proposal, but it's a concern nonetheless. And I think this answers Basil's question about why there is a finalist vote to begin with. Finalists not being able to vote also prevents them from downvoting their competition. So you might be able to sneak into the finals this way, but it won't increase your chances of winning.
I looked into the last few transparency reports and found a good example. In Make Your Own Luck, you submitted Arcane Power and it got five 1's. Admittedly, one of those was from me. That's because it's a major downgrade from Kirin Tor Tricaster and doesn't bring anything new to the table besides being a spell. It was a good idea, but a second set of eyes could have easily pointed out that Kirin Tor Tricaster already exists. Which is why I think you should follow Demon's advise and try the feedback threads.
Also, getting 1's sucks and there will always be a few unjust ones. This might sound stupid, but try not to focus on the negatives too much, because that will get frustrating. I personally only really check the averages.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Can confirm this seems to be the workaround, will update the text accordingly. Do not pick any class boons, and if you stumble onto a bomb, you might as well restart too. Chi-Ji does not seem to be necessary to have in the team.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
I don't think it's a bug. The task says "complete" which always requires the merc associated with the task (Chi-Ji in this case) to be part of the team. Now, we can argue that "complete" having that meaning is dumb 'til the cows come home, but that's not a QA issue.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
The workaround for now is (until they fix it):
This worked like a charm for me, so good luck everyone!
Deathspeaker + Tiller + Hysteria Combo...
One year ago drawing the whole deck by turn 10 was a Wild thing, now it is done by multiple classes as a game plan in standard. Powercreep is very, very real.
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Picked up Mercs again after a long long time just to get this "free" Merc. My collection is rather limited and I have to complete all Blackrock and Alterac, but let's see if the mode can redeem itself to my eyes.
Update: did Drakkisath, Rend and Razorgore and man, so difficult lol
Updated: Special Limited-Time Chi-Ji Event for Hearthstone Mercenaries Begins - Experienced Players, Get Ready for a Challenge
Same here. QA and testers have failed again. Not a big surprise to be honest. Just killing the dead mode even further.
The Perfect Match - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I agree with all of the above.
Sorry for not participating much in the last few competitions... life got in the way and I felt a little burnt out of ideas. Did my best to cast my votes though so there's that. Thanks again to Shadows and everybody else who was part of organizing the competitions, you're doing an amazing job!
The Perfect Match - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I second the reduction of finalist spots proposal. There shouldn't be a fixed number of spots but a percentage of the initial number of participants.
Almost all competitions lately have been getting around 12 entries, and 8 finalist spots. That's... just eliminating the bottom 4. It's too little, the "finalist" stage feels more like "semi finals". I'd argue to keep it to 25% of initial entries, to really make it about the top brass since that's what the finalist stage is about.
Or, we could ditch the finalist stage entirely. I'm not sure why it exists honestly, the number of voters is always so so much lower than the initial 2 stages. It only lasts 1 day and so many of would be voters forget, dont know about it, are locked out of it as pointed above, or dont care enough to vote another time if their entries didnt make it.
Mobalytics Stats & Why New Beaters Are Pointless
So the new expansion has dropped and what we are seeing from Galio and Gnar is good.
They are beaters and they beat things.
They have lists the can perform in the A and S tier.
Or you can just pilot Elise to a 60% winrate.
Like this is the thing, aggro, aggro-midrange these archetypes are kinda done.
Like you can release a million Champs that fit in as competitive beaters but statistically it is just more of the same.
Like gnars best deck is Zigs aggro, a deck that literally has existed for ages and has long since been competitive. Like it makes sense he burns and he's a big threat that cycles itself of course thats good.
But its also just a better version of things that we've already seen in a deck that has already existed.
Please Riot release control Champs, release alt wincons, give us more TF style cards, just anything other than hey here's a highly competitive card that goes face.