Everyone is playing Odd Questline Hunter in Wild, a stupidly oppressive deck, and they haven't done anything to curb its power? It's so boring and frustrating to play against and control decks autolose against it. Please do something, Blizzard!
I don't mean to be dismissive but Wild is *MUCH* less likely to have anything curbed. Yes they occassionaly nerf severely degenerate decks (like D6 warlock) but there's a reason it's called "Wild". If you aren't into over the top/high power level decks Wild may not be the best mode for you.
Ugh, that is really very annoying I have to say. I mean come on, how difficult can it be to trigger the effect of The Immovable Object. I probably do not even care if it counted perfectly correct, just count something like +1 at the bare minimum would suffice for me.
A lot has been said about the amount of OTK decks in this tournament and the meta in general, but I'd like to add one more piece to the pile: The final Demon Hunter mirror match that decided the World Championship was completely decided by draw RNG. I'm no particular fan of any of the two contestants but I felt sorry for Glory right from the mulligan. He did an awesome job making the best out of his draws, but that just isn't enough when Yogg favors your opponent.
As a non BG player... could somebody explain to me how mechanic "Avenge" works? Unable to find it on the search. For Dazzling Lightspawn When 2 other minions dies it applies this effect??
I've had several ideas for this prompt, but none of them is particularly good. To avoid overloading this thread, I'll post the two I like the most.
Swift Assassin can be played without the Combo to clean small minions or with the combo to take on a big one. Nature spells in Rogue tend to be Poisons, so there's that.
Archmage's Scribe can potentially gain Spell Damage +3, but in order to do so, you need to play a lot of spells before it, which goes against what you want to do with a Spell Damage card, so you need to plan properly before playing it. The ideal scenario would be to play non-damaging spells like Arcane Intellect or Hot Streak before it. It also has synergy with Sorcerer's Gambit.
Feedback:
Me0203
Welcome to this subforum! It's always nice to see new faces.
Shadowfin Soulmancer is a bit tricky, since Soul Fragments are a thing from the Year of the Phoenix, before spell schools were introduced. Some people here tend to dislike this sort of inconsistencies, so I'd discard this idea. It's a shame, because it was quite solid otherwise.
Virulent Voidmancer is a bit on the bland side, but it seems quite balanced.
Finally, whether you decide to go with one card of another, you should definetly put an expansion watermark. If you have doubts about how to do this, you can ask for help :)
linkblade91
I would refrain from using uncommon class and school combinations. They're too hard to evaluate, since we lack context about the expansion they would be in.
That said, I think both have potential:
Nightmare Lord could easily be a Neutral card, since Shadow is the most wide-spread school (Warlock, Priest, DH and Rogue have access to it). If you decide to go with this route, I'd reduce the damage output to 2 and make the card cost 3.
Nightmare Servant is very cool and fitting for Druid, somewhat reminiscent of Gibberling. I'd change the spell school to Nature (while making the minion a Treant or something) or to Arcane (and the minion could be an astral animal, like the scout owl Tyrande used in Warcraft 3).
AeroJulwin
I really like Protector's Grace. Quite usable even without activating the Holy combo.
BasilAnguis
I like both of them, the usage of several schools fits both Mage and Priest.
I like how Kirin Tor Prodigy's effects are all very fitting of their spell school. I agree with Aerojulwin that it's a bit too strong, especially the Arcane Combo part.
Equilibrium, while simpler, also has a very flavorful baseline. I appreciate its yin-yang theme, in that the Shadow Combo gives a Holy spell and vice-versa. If you decide to go with it, an easy solution would be to make it a minion. Something like a 3 Mana 3/3 would be balanced, I think.
I'm personally not a big fan of simply repeating the battlecry. It's effective, but slightly boring, so I like the new Shadowfin Soulmancer best. It does need to belong to an expansion though, which should probably just be the same as other Soul Fragment cards.
Shadow Druid
I think the main issue with unusual combinations is that they're not on an equal playing field. They don't have much to compare them to, so people might be hesitant to give bonus points.
That being said, your first idea really didn't fit Druid, but your new idea is quite nice. I particularly like how the combo doesn't just duplicate the minion, but its effect as well. It's not something Druid has really done before, but still feels like it fits Druid's identity, which I enjoy. Balance looks good to me.
BasilAnguis
I quite like the idea of getting multiple combos, although I find that putting the keyword multiple times on the same card severely limits your options, as Equilibrium proves.
Equilibrium doesn't have an effect if you play it without the conditions, which I don't think should ever really happen. And its effects are quite boring. Kirin Tor Prodigy is far more interesting, but feels unbalanced. Even though you won't be able to play it on-curve, it can still give a lot of value and should probably be a 3-cost. I also think just drawing a single spell for Arcane would be more balanced.
Solitaire play won't be fixed with this patch, simply cause we don't have cards that counter your opponent hand, and thus very few lines of play other than just "make the best turn every turn"
A lot of the cards we had to play around were removed from the game (mind control tech, spell breaker, Harrison Jones, vanish, Leeroy, ...) and we got very little to replace them. Until this is not fixed the game will always be solitaire.
So what this patch will achieve is remove fun and high skill solitaire play (alignement druid, warlock, garrot, ...) and replace it by boring and dumb solitaire play, and we'll have quest pirate, libram pally and aggro decks reign supreme once again, just like previous patches did.
That stance toward a so called more board centric game has been a bad choice in terms of interactivy, I whish we could at least be allowed to play fun stuff.
But yeah let's keep playing libram pally and aggro druid, that's soooo exciting
Big Spell MAge needs more proactive Big Spells. Dawngrasp is not the lategame win condition it needs. If anything you could buff it to always cast the highest cost spells or have the spells prioritize enemies.
Wildfire Mage needs a Fire tutor and I can guarantee it becomes competitive. 90% of the deck's problem is not being able to run spells outside of Wildfire. IF you give me the option to tutor a fire spell on turn 2 or 3 I can run Runic Orb, AI, Brain Freeze and whatnot to actually put together a functional deck.
It's part of the MMR rating adjustments we have covered a little while ago, and yes, it's far from perfect currently. I've had the same happen to me several times. Very frustrating. The system is keeping our internal MMR from season 1 in mind and not applying other factors correctly. Should you lose several times more than you win, you might still eventually start seeing the A.I. opponents again (as usual, better chance without a full team of lvl 30 Mercs). On the upside, you also now get a lot more rating for wins than previously so people manage to climb a lot higher than before.
First 2 ideas. I wanted Equilibrium to also do a little damage or a little healing but there wasn't enough space for that. Anyway, i do feel Kirin Tor Prodigy is better and cooler. Little neat effects that when stacked up after one of those classic mage-plays-15-cards-in-a-turn turns are the cherry on top for a wild display of magic.
=> that's the point of the change, making you spend more time playing the game in the hopes of getting some legendary coins. It's Blizzard we're talking about here
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
So the change to Alliance Bannerman is actually a buff to Handbuff Paladin? Pog
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
I don't mean to be dismissive but Wild is *MUCH* less likely to have anything curbed. Yes they occassionaly nerf severely degenerate decks (like D6 warlock) but there's a reason it's called "Wild". If you aren't into over the top/high power level decks Wild may not be the best mode for you.
Just my 2 cents.
Felwalker + Hand of Gul'dan interaction
Ah, thx a lot. I guess that's why.
Felwalker + Hand of Gul'dan interaction
Hand of Guldan is a Shadow spell, and Felwalker casts Fel spells.
Felwalker + Hand of Gul'dan interaction
Is it intentional for Felwalker to not draw 3 cards from Hand of Gul'dan?
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
Ugh, that is really very annoying I have to say. I mean come on, how difficult can it be to trigger the effect of The Immovable Object. I probably do not even care if it counted perfectly correct, just count something like +1 at the bare minimum would suffice for me.
Hearthstone World Championship 2021 - Decklists, Results & Recap
A lot has been said about the amount of OTK decks in this tournament and the meta in general, but I'd like to add one more piece to the pile: The final Demon Hunter mirror match that decided the World Championship was completely decided by draw RNG. I'm no particular fan of any of the two contestants but I felt sorry for Glory right from the mulligan. He did an awesome job making the best out of his draws, but that just isn't enough when Yogg favors your opponent.
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
Interesting side note for the Wild community: Salhet's Pride now tutors Alliance Bannerman.
Hearthstone's Patch Brought Smaller Battlegrounds Balance Updates, Blizzard Confirms Big Content Drop Expected Soon
That's exactly right. So you can drop your Avenge behind some taunts and have some tokens pop off and it can really get things moving.
Hearthstone's Patch Brought Smaller Battlegrounds Balance Updates, Blizzard Confirms Big Content Drop Expected Soon
As a non BG player... could somebody explain to me how mechanic "Avenge" works? Unable to find it on the search.
For Dazzling Lightspawn When 2 other minions dies it applies this effect??
Thanks!
Frozen Festivities - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
The flavor connection between Cast When Drawn and unwrapping gifts is solid enough, right?
Combo Harvester - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I've had several ideas for this prompt, but none of them is particularly good. To avoid overloading this thread, I'll post the two I like the most.
Swift Assassin can be played without the Combo to clean small minions or with the combo to take on a big one. Nature spells in Rogue tend to be Poisons, so there's that.
Archmage's Scribe can potentially gain Spell Damage +3, but in order to do so, you need to play a lot of spells before it, which goes against what you want to do with a Spell Damage card, so you need to plan properly before playing it. The ideal scenario would be to play non-damaging spells like Arcane Intellect or Hot Streak before it. It also has synergy with Sorcerer's Gambit.
Feedback:
Shadowfin Soulmancer is a bit tricky, since Soul Fragments are a thing from the Year of the Phoenix, before spell schools were introduced. Some people here tend to dislike this sort of inconsistencies, so I'd discard this idea. It's a shame, because it was quite solid otherwise.
Virulent Voidmancer is a bit on the bland side, but it seems quite balanced.
Finally, whether you decide to go with one card of another, you should definetly put an expansion watermark. If you have doubts about how to do this, you can ask for help :)
That said, I think both have potential:
I like how Kirin Tor Prodigy's effects are all very fitting of their spell school. I agree with Aerojulwin that it's a bit too strong, especially the Arcane Combo part.
Equilibrium, while simpler, also has a very flavorful baseline. I appreciate its yin-yang theme, in that the Shadow Combo gives a Holy spell and vice-versa. If you decide to go with it, an easy solution would be to make it a minion. Something like a 3 Mana 3/3 would be balanced, I think.
Combo Harvester - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
That being said, your first idea really didn't fit Druid, but your new idea is quite nice. I particularly like how the combo doesn't just duplicate the minion, but its effect as well. It's not something Druid has really done before, but still feels like it fits Druid's identity, which I enjoy. Balance looks good to me.
Equilibrium doesn't have an effect if you play it without the conditions, which I don't think should ever really happen. And its effects are quite boring. Kirin Tor Prodigy is far more interesting, but feels unbalanced. Even though you won't be able to play it on-curve, it can still give a lot of value and should probably be a 3-cost. I also think just drawing a single spell for Arcane would be more balanced.
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
Solitaire play won't be fixed with this patch, simply cause we don't have cards that counter your opponent hand, and thus very few lines of play other than just "make the best turn every turn"
A lot of the cards we had to play around were removed from the game (mind control tech, spell breaker, Harrison Jones, vanish, Leeroy, ...) and we got very little to replace them. Until this is not fixed the game will always be solitaire.
So what this patch will achieve is remove fun and high skill solitaire play (alignement druid, warlock, garrot, ...) and replace it by boring and dumb solitaire play, and we'll have quest pirate, libram pally and aggro decks reign supreme once again, just like previous patches did.
That stance toward a so called more board centric game has been a bad choice in terms of interactivy, I whish we could at least be allowed to play fun stuff.
But yeah let's keep playing libram pally and aggro druid, that's soooo exciting
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
imagine thinking the octo bot nerf mathers kekw
they did ot nerf otk decks (except owl)
they bufft otk deck because they nerfed te 1 good couter trogg
mage s not eveb touch
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
Not really imo.
Big Spell MAge needs more proactive Big Spells. Dawngrasp is not the lategame win condition it needs. If anything you could buff it to always cast the highest cost spells or have the spells prioritize enemies.
Wildfire Mage needs a Fire tutor and I can guarantee it becomes competitive. 90% of the deck's problem is not being able to run spells outside of Wildfire. IF you give me the option to tutor a fire spell on turn 2 or 3 I can run Runic Orb, AI, Brain Freeze and whatnot to actually put together a functional deck.
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
I doubt it considering this was only a quick pre-holiday patch to not make Christmas be all about a combo meta but I'll go and check.
EDIT: nope, still broken.
Our Thoughts on Hearthstone's Upcoming Nerfs and Buffs, Including Celestial Alignment and Magister Dawngrasp
Does anyone know that bugged achievements have been fixed or not?
Surprise Hearthstone Patch 22.0.2 Arrives Today! Irondeep Trogg Nerfed With 8 Other Cards, 4 Card Buffs
Does anyone know that bugged achievements have been fixed or not?
Worth Every Penny - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Congrats to linkblade91! And it wasn't even a Paladin card! :P
Jokes aside, cool idea :)
Hearthstone Mercenaries Brings in a Welcome Change to Obtaining Legendary Coins in Level 30 Heroic Bounties
It's part of the MMR rating adjustments we have covered a little while ago, and yes, it's far from perfect currently. I've had the same happen to me several times. Very frustrating. The system is keeping our internal MMR from season 1 in mind and not applying other factors correctly. Should you lose several times more than you win, you might still eventually start seeing the A.I. opponents again (as usual, better chance without a full team of lvl 30 Mercs). On the upside, you also now get a lot more rating for wins than previously so people manage to climb a lot higher than before.
Combo Harvester - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
First 2 ideas. I wanted Equilibrium to also do a little damage or a little healing but there wasn't enough space for that. Anyway, i do feel Kirin Tor Prodigy is better and cooler. Little neat effects that when stacked up after one of those classic mage-plays-15-cards-in-a-turn turns are the cherry on top for a wild display of magic.
Hearthstone Mercenaries Brings in a Welcome Change to Obtaining Legendary Coins in Level 30 Heroic Bounties
"some of the heroic bosses aren't easy to grind"
=> that's the point of the change, making you spend more time playing the game in the hopes of getting some legendary coins. It's Blizzard we're talking about here
Hearthstone Mercenaries Brings in a Welcome Change to Obtaining Legendary Coins in Level 30 Heroic Bounties
They didn't change this, I just played a match against AI
Make sure you're under 7000 rating AND use low level mercs/low level abilities/unequip any gear.
[Duels] AgentCroque`s 12 Win Spiked Arms Pirate Warrior
12-2 =)