I didn’t know Swizard was leaving! We were exchanging ideas in game recently and he was always a fun talking partner while trying to come up with something dumb and new. Thank you for keeping the series going however, for those of us who just want to have some dumb fun in this game.
I had a card I liked, but because Imgur is currently broken, I can't post it. It is on the Discord though.
EDIT: Got it through!
Nonetheless, it's time for me to do my part and post my feedback.
Me0203
Shadowfin Soulmancer has one pretty huge problem: Chronological inconsistency. You have a card that uses Soul Fragments, a mechanic from a year before spell schools existed, and combining that with spell schools. There's simply no place in the game's life that this card could be placed. It can't be placed in Year of the Phoenix because spell schools didn't exist yet. It can't be placed before then because neither Demon Hunter nor Soul Fragments existed yet. And it can't be placed after because then you'll have a card that is unusable in Standard because there's no Soul Fragment cards in the format.
Virulent Voidmaster is definitely better. It's easier to use and it doesn't have the same chronological problem that Shadowfin Soulmancer does.
Linkblade91
I definitely think going with Arcane Owl (specifically the first version) is the better way to go over Nightmare Lord or Nightmare Servant. I fully understand what you're trying to do with the other two cards, but it'll be a very hard sell for the competition.
BasilAnguis
Kirin Tor Prodigy is cool, although the discrepancy in power on each of the effects is a little bit off-putting. The Fire Combo effect is just blatantly much weaker than the other two.
Equilibrium has really cool flavor, but unfortunately that flavor will overlap with BloodMefist's card from the last competition. It also doesn't do anything without the Combo effects.
AeroJulwin
Gonna agree with everyone else and say that I like this card. It's simple and it feels like a card that Blizzard would print. I can see it doing pretty well.
Wailor
"but none of them is particularly good"
I disagree. I like both of these cards. I say Swift Assassin is a little bit better since it's more to-the-point on how you're supposed to use it and it's quite flavorful, but both of them are solid cards.
R
If I'm reading this right, this appears to deal 4 damage to one minion and 8 damage to adjacent minions. And that seems extremely powerful to me.
Nirast
I definitely prefer Hail Storm. It seems like it does what you want it to do more of the time and it seems a bit weird for hail to heal you.
Anchorm4n
It seems fine. Hot Streak is going to make any Fire spell broken, and that's not really avoidable so it's best to not worry about that.
I must ask though. Is it intended to not have a spell school? If that's the case, then balance is a complete non-issue and the card is 100% fine as is.
Good to see this series is still around! Yes, I do think more refined lists are out there after seeing gameplay footage from Dane, but this version looks fun too! And more importantly Anka finally found a home. I think I'll give this a try.
Oh, and I'll have to tinker on a deck first, but I wouldn't mind contributing to this series at all.
late on this, but as someone who's played for a similar amount of time and is currently experiencing the same dissatisfaction with Blizzard's handling of the Wild format (not to mention their interesting workplace practices recently that have led to me going full free to play) I truly hope Blizzard will do something to help fix Wild soon. until that (hopefully) happens, enjoy your break! its been a joy reading your articles, and they've been my main reason for checking out the site every day, but regardless of whether or not you return to the game, thank you for the contributions you've made to the community nonetheless.
One place to start would be this collection on Reddit Competitive HS; in particular the "Building or Choosing a Deck" sub-section. You can also search that subreddit for deckbuilding guides and a few more should pop up.
To see applications in real time, you could try searching "Deck Doctor" on YouTube. Firebat used to upload the ones he did on stream and I learned a lot from them. It looks like one of the guys that posts decks here (FunkiMonki) still does them so that might be worth checking out.
Personally, I really enjoy the trial and error process so I typically start with a super greedy core and then slowly remove the weakest cards with on-curve answers to how I've been losing and/or more draw/tutors to get to my win condition(s).
I hope you have fun turning your deck building dreams into memes!
So Thijs is probably one of the first HS-millionaires, 500 000 from HS 250.000 for the Aston Martin and the revenue from Twitch and Youtube. I used to watch his stream, he is always positive and just chatting and enjoying the game.
I am also glad that Kibler returned since this is not an official tournament.
I must thank you once again, this time particularly for letting me hear Valeera the Nice's "Greetings (Mirror)" emote, which I'd probably not encounter otherwise. The "ugh, you're too much" shows she's just as sickened by her own saccharine act as we are, and is a beautiful complement to her attack voiceline ("No more Mrs Nice Elf") showing she's had enough of this job :P
I've actually got a little bit extra now, as one of the tournament admins was kind enough to share with us. ;) But yes, I wish we would've had that at our fingertips from the get go, would've made everything easier and much faster.
#Updated now with the full planned tournament schedule, player matches, pairings, and so on.
Not my best idea ever, but I've wanted to try my hands at a working Flame Leviathan for some time.
Feedback:
R
I like it. Nice idea!
Wailor
Solid effect and Christmas flavor! Nice one :)
AeroJulwin
Nice idea, but I think you need to add "card" after "duplicate". I like how this is both a strong tool for Control decks and hits the flavor on spot at the same time. Great work!
Im surprised that you managed to find the timeline for this thing. Cannot have been fun combing through his massive streams for this specific information.
Well, at least someone has done it so we don't have to :)
Bit late for my own party, but work has been busy for a few weeks now. Here's my idea:
I'm still undecided if it should be a Rare or an Epic and if it should cost 4 or 5 mana. The 5 Cost version would mean a Flamestrike and a free Fireball when you're at 7 Mana which seemed a bit too mediocre so I went with the 4 Cost version for now. What makes this really hard to balance though is Hot Streak. The most extreme scenario would basically be a Fireball and a free Flamestrike (Hot Streak into Fiery Lessons = 2 Mana) which might be okay since nobody cares about board presence anyway. I'm looking forward to your feedback!
linkblade91
I like the owl / wisdom flavor. Cost increase in Druid feels a bit off though. 4 stars for the Battlecry version. I don't like the Deathrattle iteration though, sorry.
Nirast
I was considering doing something similar to your second version with my card, but Mage already has too many AOE cards. Going down the Breath of the Infinite road is tempting for this comp, but overall I like your first version more right now, if only because I don't see a connection between a Fire combo and protecting your own minions. Are they building a camp fire to find shelter from the hail? Maybe you could go full Frost and make it a Frost Combo with a damage increase?
R
I'm sorry but I don't get the flavor of the first card. If you choose to go with this, there's a typo in "Corrupt" and you'll lose points if you don't add a second card for the corrupted version (which is nearly impossible because of the art). The Fire spell looks more interesting. I like that one.
Wailor
Very hard to decide because both are cool. The Rogue card is one of that simple but very cool designs, but the Mage minion has more potential as you've described yourself. My guess is that the Rogue one has a better chance to get high ratings because you know what you can expect from the card at the first glance.
BasilAnguis
Both are cool, but I agree that the Priest card is useless without the Combo activator so making it a minion might be a good alternative. That said, the Mage card looks super nice! Already my favorite concept so far, it just needs a little polish - basically what the others said: maybe only draw one card, freeze one enemy minion, or increase the cost.
AeroJulwin
Solid card, nothing to critizice here. Well done!
Me0203
The Murloc somehow doesn't appeal much to me. The Warlock card is much better, but as the others have already said, repeating the Battlecry isn't the most creative approach. I do like the suggestion to word it "Battlecry and Shadow Combo" though, that might help hiding the repetition a bit and is already established in the game.
Just some advice on Standard packs, seeing as we're getting 3 free packs from the quests. I started doing this "trick" since Standard packs were released and it's saved me on quite a few new packs from recent expansions.
Save your Standard packs for the next expansion once you're happy with your current standard collection. Same can be said with class packs that we get from Book of Mercs.
There's a specific breakpoint with opening packs where they have very little value. After 230 packs it's not worth it. See Bot Mathematician's video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdOmANK5A3o
I'm more of a collector and thus never got into deck building in Hearthstone although I'm playing HS since the very beginning. Since the meta is getting more and more boring for me, I want to take a look at deck building. I feel, it is a good point in time, since next year a lot of sets will rotate and the card pool will be rather small.
However I can't find any real detailed guide about how to approach deck building at all. The best one I found is the Beginners Guide over at Icy-Veins, which is quite superficial.
Can you recommend any good guides (YT or Twitch Videos would be okay too), that go beyond the basic tips?
Yeah... no time to keep going through hours of streams in the hopes of learning something like this that should've been clearly announced in the first place. It's delayed my efforts and I was just about resigned to talk about it without any specified time included, then updating only once we actually made sure.
It's been on our radar for the past few days as well, they just haven't been very forthcoming with sharing all useful images, details, and so on (plus the qualifier was supposed to take place and finish on Monday, but because of the surprise patch and issues that followed had to be cut in half and also played on Tuesday). Kind of annoying when you're trying to get a full picture. But as Flux points out, it's never a guarantee we catch these things timely or manage to put everything together, so thank you for spreading the word here!
I'm curious about that starting time, as that's the one thing I didn't see publicly announced on Twitter or Discord and couldn't get a reply about. Perhaps you know more. Did he only mention it on his stream in passing?
Agreed that the details aren't really out there. I went through his twitter several times and couldn't find out much myself. It was only in reddit that I saw the time in the first place. Chances are good he explained it in his streams, but I dont have the time to shift through all that.
It's been on our radar for the past few days as well, they just haven't been very forthcoming with sharing all useful images, details, and so on (plus the qualifier was supposed to take place and finish on Monday, but because of the surprise patch and issues that followed had to be cut in half and also played on Tuesday). Kind of annoying when you're trying to get a full picture. But as Flux points out, it's never a guarantee we catch these things timely or manage to put everything together, so thank you for spreading the word here!
I'm curious about that starting time, as that's the one thing I didn't see publicly announced on Twitter or Discord and couldn't get a reply about. Perhaps you know more. Did he only mention it on his stream in passing?
We should be front paging this soonish thanks to Aesan - but props for posting about this on the forums (discussion ftw!) because we don't always cover every single community-run event.
Some great players taking part though and Cora is going to be donating any winnings so that's awesome of her.
Also, no one get angry at Aesan if he doesn't get it up, you can get angry at me instead. I feel bad for saying he's going to do it when it's possible that he could run into scheduling problems - we've all been there at some point.
The Dead Never Rest! A Full Guide to Graveyard Deathrattle Rogue on the Wildest of Wednesdays
I didn’t know Swizard was leaving! We were exchanging ideas in game recently and he was always a fun talking partner while trying to come up with something dumb and new. Thank you for keeping the series going however, for those of us who just want to have some dumb fun in this game.
Combo Harvester - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I had a card I liked, but because Imgur is currently broken, I can't post it. It is on the Discord though.
EDIT: Got it through!
Nonetheless, it's time for me to do my part and post my feedback.
Shadowfin Soulmancer has one pretty huge problem: Chronological inconsistency. You have a card that uses Soul Fragments, a mechanic from a year before spell schools existed, and combining that with spell schools. There's simply no place in the game's life that this card could be placed. It can't be placed in Year of the Phoenix because spell schools didn't exist yet. It can't be placed before then because neither Demon Hunter nor Soul Fragments existed yet. And it can't be placed after because then you'll have a card that is unusable in Standard because there's no Soul Fragment cards in the format.
Virulent Voidmaster is definitely better. It's easier to use and it doesn't have the same chronological problem that Shadowfin Soulmancer does.
Kirin Tor Prodigy is cool, although the discrepancy in power on each of the effects is a little bit off-putting. The Fire Combo effect is just blatantly much weaker than the other two.
Equilibrium has really cool flavor, but unfortunately that flavor will overlap with BloodMefist's card from the last competition. It also doesn't do anything without the Combo effects.
"but none of them is particularly good"
I disagree. I like both of these cards. I say Swift Assassin is a little bit better since it's more to-the-point on how you're supposed to use it and it's quite flavorful, but both of them are solid cards.
It seems fine. Hot Streak is going to make any Fire spell broken, and that's not really avoidable so it's best to not worry about that.
I must ask though. Is it intended to not have a spell school? If that's the case, then balance is a complete non-issue and the card is 100% fine as is.
Thijs' Legends Invitational Is Taking Place Today and Tomorrow (Dec 22-23) - Community Event With Giveaways and Activities
Nice to see Kleenex winning the qualifier, guy has been a great player in the Benelux scene for years and is also just a nice dude. Very deserved.
Searching for an in-depth deck building guide
Thank you very much :D I'm right now taking a deep dive into the Reddit Collection!
The Dead Never Rest! A Full Guide to Graveyard Deathrattle Rogue on the Wildest of Wednesdays
Good to see this series is still around! Yes, I do think more refined lists are out there after seeing gameplay footage from Dane, but this version looks fun too! And more importantly Anka finally found a home. I think I'll give this a try.
Oh, and I'll have to tinker on a deck first, but I wouldn't mind contributing to this series at all.
Quitting HS
late on this, but as someone who's played for a similar amount of time and is currently experiencing the same dissatisfaction with Blizzard's handling of the Wild format (not to mention their interesting workplace practices recently that have led to me going full free to play) I truly hope Blizzard will do something to help fix Wild soon. until that (hopefully) happens, enjoy your break! its been a joy reading your articles, and they've been my main reason for checking out the site every day, but regardless of whether or not you return to the game, thank you for the contributions you've made to the community nonetheless.
Searching for an in-depth deck building guide
One place to start would be this collection on Reddit Competitive HS; in particular the "Building or Choosing a Deck" sub-section. You can also search that subreddit for deckbuilding guides and a few more should pop up.
To see applications in real time, you could try searching "Deck Doctor" on YouTube. Firebat used to upload the ones he did on stream and I learned a lot from them. It looks like one of the guys that posts decks here (FunkiMonki) still does them so that might be worth checking out.
Personally, I really enjoy the trial and error process so I typically start with a super greedy core and then slowly remove the weakest cards with on-curve answers to how I've been losing and/or more draw/tutors to get to my win condition(s).
I hope you have fun turning your deck building dreams into memes!
Thijs' Legends Invitational Is Taking Place Today and Tomorrow (Dec 22-23) - Community Event With Giveaways and Activities
So Thijs is probably one of the first HS-millionaires, 500 000 from HS 250.000 for the Aston Martin and the revenue from Twitch and Youtube. I used to watch his stream, he is always positive and just chatting and enjoying the game.
I am also glad that Kibler returned since this is not an official tournament.
A Site for Hearthstone Sounds - HearthSFX
I must thank you once again, this time particularly for letting me hear Valeera the Nice's "Greetings (Mirror)" emote, which I'd probably not encounter otherwise. The "ugh, you're too much" shows she's just as sickened by her own saccharine act as we are, and is a beautiful complement to her attack voiceline ("No more Mrs Nice Elf") showing she's had enough of this job :P
Thijs' Legends Invitational Is Taking Place Today and Tomorrow (Dec 22-23) - Community Event With Giveaways and Activities
I've actually got a little bit extra now, as one of the tournament admins was kind enough to share with us. ;) But yes, I wish we would've had that at our fingertips from the get go, would've made everything easier and much faster.
#Updated now with the full planned tournament schedule, player matches, pairings, and so on.
Frozen Festivities - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Not my best idea ever, but I've wanted to try my hands at a working Flame Leviathan for some time.
Feedback:
Thijs' Legends Invitational Is Taking Place Today and Tomorrow (Dec 22-23) - Community Event With Giveaways and Activities
Im surprised that you managed to find the timeline for this thing. Cannot have been fun combing through his massive streams for this specific information.
Well, at least someone has done it so we don't have to :)
Combo Harvester - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Bit late for my own party, but work has been busy for a few weeks now. Here's my idea:
I'm still undecided if it should be a Rare or an Epic and if it should cost 4 or 5 mana. The 5 Cost version would mean a Flamestrike and a free Fireball when you're at 7 Mana which seemed a bit too mediocre so I went with the 4 Cost version for now. What makes this really hard to balance though is Hot Streak. The most extreme scenario would basically be a Fireball and a free Flamestrike (Hot Streak into Fiery Lessons = 2 Mana) which might be okay since nobody cares about board presence anyway. I'm looking forward to your feedback!
Ignite Combo OTK Mage. 99-28 (78%) record from Bronze to Legend
I just killed a druid from 76 to 0 in a single turn. Check the replay
Quest Trading - Play A Friend!
Battletag: boandlkramer#2912
Region: EU
Trade Only?: yes, you first
Done
Hearthstone's Winter Veil Event Begins! 6 Free Packs, Free Shop Hero, Festive Bundles, Greatfather Winter Magni Skin Now Available
Just some advice on Standard packs, seeing as we're getting 3 free packs from the quests. I started doing this "trick" since Standard packs were released and it's saved me on quite a few new packs from recent expansions.
Save your Standard packs for the next expansion once you're happy with your current standard collection. Same can be said with class packs that we get from Book of Mercs.
There's a specific breakpoint with opening packs where they have very little value. After 230 packs it's not worth it. See Bot Mathematician's video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdOmANK5A3o
Hearthstone World Championship 2021 - Decklists, Results & Recap
Gaby reminds me a lot of the young savage at his peak. So much youthful cockiness.
Searching for an in-depth deck building guide
I'm more of a collector and thus never got into deck building in Hearthstone although I'm playing HS since the very beginning. Since the meta is getting more and more boring for me, I want to take a look at deck building. I feel, it is a good point in time, since next year a lot of sets will rotate and the card pool will be rather small.
However I can't find any real detailed guide about how to approach deck building at all. The best one I found is the Beginners Guide over at Icy-Veins, which is quite superficial.
Can you recommend any good guides (YT or Twitch Videos would be okay too), that go beyond the basic tips?
Spellschool Mage + HP
Not exactly what you are looking for, but maybe you can find some inspiration here:
https://twitter.com/ZachODR/status/1473338071030669329
Hearthstone's Winter Veil Event Begins! 6 Free Packs, Free Shop Hero, Festive Bundles, Greatfather Winter Magni Skin Now Available
>Notably, the Finley & Metzen image is a reference to Chris Metzen
Didn't they say that they are not doing vanity cards anymore?
[Duels] AgentCroque`s 12 Win Spiked Arms Pirate Warrior
Is adding Gruntled Patron a good idea?
Thjis Legends Invitational Tournament
Yeah... no time to keep going through hours of streams in the hopes of learning something like this that should've been clearly announced in the first place. It's delayed my efforts and I was just about resigned to talk about it without any specified time included, then updating only once we actually made sure.
Thjis Legends Invitational Tournament
Agreed that the details aren't really out there. I went through his twitter several times and couldn't find out much myself. It was only in reddit that I saw the time in the first place. Chances are good he explained it in his streams, but I dont have the time to shift through all that.
Thjis Legends Invitational Tournament
It's been on our radar for the past few days as well, they just haven't been very forthcoming with sharing all useful images, details, and so on (plus the qualifier was supposed to take place and finish on Monday, but because of the surprise patch and issues that followed had to be cut in half and also played on Tuesday). Kind of annoying when you're trying to get a full picture. But as Flux points out, it's never a guarantee we catch these things timely or manage to put everything together, so thank you for spreading the word here!
I'm curious about that starting time, as that's the one thing I didn't see publicly announced on Twitter or Discord and couldn't get a reply about. Perhaps you know more. Did he only mention it on his stream in passing?
Thjis Legends Invitational Tournament
We should be front paging this soonish thanks to Aesan - but props for posting about this on the forums (discussion ftw!) because we don't always cover every single community-run event.
Some great players taking part though and Cora is going to be donating any winnings so that's awesome of her.
Also, no one get angry at Aesan if he doesn't get it up, you can get angry at me instead. I feel bad for saying he's going to do it when it's possible that he could run into scheduling problems - we've all been there at some point.