Honestly, Im beginning to have second thoughts about Tour Guide. 90% of the time I'd mulligan this just to get a better chance at getting Wildfire, which is honestly the best card in this list. I might at some point experiment with Shivering Sorceress or add in one Devolving Missiles to have a better matchup against paladin and priest, because tall decks really tests this deck.
I find that Multicaster is really not required because the deck is fairly midrange, and most of the time Im just playing two cards per turn at most. I'd rather be discovering stuff, and there's 5 tutor cards in there already.
Not having Ice Barrier still peeves me, but I think its better to chance it off discovers because some games its just useless, and you'd want to be aggressive if you can. Might experiment with Fire Sale in exchange for Starscryer if things get too aggressive.
Edit: I think I should at least mention that Rune of the Archmage is still just too good to ignore completely. Its not 'random bs go' because the spells will target enemies whenever it can, so 90% of the time it'll just clear board, or do some small damage to opponent's face. Mage has a massive weakness to tall boards, and this is an easy way out of it. Maybe 2x would be too much, but if we're sticking to the big spells ping mage idea, then at least 1 would be fitting.
I had become an in-game friend of Swizard before his "fame", after playing against him in Wild ladder ages ago, both using interesting decks. You know, the old way.
Don't worry mate, they will nerf or ban Hunter and Warrior questlines soon enough and you'll come back to us!
I see you've already decided, but I'll let you know I'm also a fan of Swift Assassin.
R
Being able to hit the hero seems fine to me, since it would just be an underpowered Fireball.
I'm a big fan of the Combo, but I do feel like 8 damage is a tad much. 6 would probably be fine. I know it doesn't double +Spell Damage that way, but that seems less important on cards that already deal quite some damage.
I also don't like how the effect is phrased. 'Deals' should probably be 'Deal' and the 'double damage' not specifically referring to the 4 damage feels weird to me, although I won't deduct for it.
Nirast
Healing Hail feels chaotic and doesn't really make sense.
Hail Storm is nice. The Combo makes sense to me and fits the art. But would maybe be fine as a 4-cost.
linkblade91
I like the second version of Scouting Owl better, since revealing doesn't really fit Druid's identity. But an unspecified cost increase feels weird, so I would probably make it target your opponent's next card and remove the enter in the middle.
anchorm4n
It should probably have a school and feels a little strong. You should probably reduce the cost reduction.
Right now you'll always want to wait keep it until you want to use Flamestrike or have Lethal, so you might consider reducing the costs permanently. A 2 or 3 Mana reduction would work well because you get two powerful spells in any case, but you can also get your Mana back.
Demonxc95
Seems balanced considering you need a Shadow spell + 3 Mana to get the effect, so you don't have a crazy amount of Mana to spend on minions. It's also less annoying due to the cost limit, but could end up helping your opponent that way. Overall a nice card, but it could be fine just returning your own minions, since that's what it already focuses on.
New iteration of my card. Since the effect requires you to perform a miracle turn to make it worthwhile, I figured out a 1 mana minion will be better.
AeroJulwin
I quite like this card. I guess it only shuffles one copy of each duplicate, right? For instance, if you have two Frostbolt, you'd get one extra (and not two).
R
I find the name a bit too descriptive, if that makes sense. Other than that, pretty cool effect.
anchorm4n
I find the effects a bit too strong, considering you don't need to pay any mana to get them. Besides that, the names don't seem appropriate for legendary cards. I would come up with fancy names that are still related to their respective element. Something like Flamus and Glacius but less lame lol
Yeah, I dislike the bundles. The Rexxar skin is rad but I'm not a big fan of the others in the bundle. I do like all the "cheer" skins though, but damn that's a high price to pay =/
I love the tyrande and valeera skins and dont care about the others and ofc theyre both in seperate bundles aswell
I understand where you're coming from, winrate alone isn't a sole measure of deck performance but when you measure the performance over time it gets far more informative.
Like gangplank Sejuani for example another meta bilgewater staple is always just happy at the top of the meta, reminds me of what Shen decks used to be...I consider pirate aggro to be similar based solely on its solid performance longterm.
But when updates come in and new decks aren't outperforming these old archetypes why play them at all? Then you run into a problem where longterm players just get bored of seeing the same thing over and over,
Like you could play Kenin right now with bounce girl, there are versions of that deck that do very well and are arguable far better than Lee Sin but until that list is perfected and is crystallized into something longterm nobody is gonna play.
Then even worse potentially, without a dominant new deck to speak of, you then have nothing to build and tech against. Yes Azir Irelia might have been op (sitting at 53% right now very respectable) and TF Fizz (dead) so they needed hard nerfs and it took too long, I just think there's a happy medium.
We want to see new decks at the top if the tier list but not oppressing players to the point of frustration.
Thanks, everyone. I'll probably submit Swift Assassin, since it has had a better reception. I also like it better (even if the art from the other card is much cooler)
More feedback:
R
I like Wild Flame, but I don't think adjacent minions need to take double damage. Just 4 damage to 3 minions seems quite strong for 4.
I'd also change the name since the current one is too similar to Wildfire
Nirast
I agree Hail Storm is your better card. The Fire Combo part is a nice touch. My main issue is that the artwork isn't very good.
linkblade91
I really like the version that reveals a card. I could see it winning the comp.
My main issue is that it probably shouldn't be a Beast, since Astral Tiger isn't.
anchorm4n
Honestly, the cost reduction doesn't worry me as much as the fact that you can generate extra Fireballs with this card. With this two cards plus the regular Fireballs you can put in your deck, that's 24 face damage.
Demonxz95
The fact that it only targets cheap minions is a bit weird, but I guess it's necessary so that the card isn't broken. Other than that, seems fine.
I already know that a lot of the player base don't care about Wild nor Wild players, and I'm not complaining, just pointing out that it's pretty shitty for people that don't play the mode (The same could go for the duels quest, but I'm biased about it because I enjoy the mode).
1. You are definitely complaining.
2. You see that you are biased, yet you complain about it anyway.
3. It's not about other players not caring about Wild. It's about Wild not being a money-making game mode for Blizzard, so there's no reason to reward playing it. In fact, I'm sure Blizzard sees Wild as a necessary evil and would prefer it if no one played Wild.
4. Newer players are completely unfamiliar with Wild cards, and they certainly don't own any.
5. You don't even have to win the games. Just put some random Core cards together and collect your free packs, you ingrate.
Demonxz95 - I can't stand Vanish, so you might lose a point from me there, but I also don't play many low-cost minions so it wouldn't bother me as much in practice.
anchorm4n - I care about board presence…a lot :( All of my decks seek to hit the board, so this could be pretty painful in my own experience. What about something like "Fire Combo: The next one you play this turn costs (1)." That way the other spell goes back to full cost; that would allow you to readjust the base spell more favorably, and mitigate a crazy Hot Streak turn.
Nirast - I'll be honest: I don't like either one. Healing Hail is an okay play on Healing Rain, but the flavor is very weird (you're being pelted with ice-rocks; why is it healing you?). Hail Storm is just Blizzard with extra steps. I'm not sure if either of them would find a home somewhere.
R - A reverse-Meteor that can also go face if you want it to? That sounds super good. I personally don't feel like Fire Mage needs more face-damage spells: it needs to be encouraged to actually use its board for once.
Wailor - Swift Assassin being connected to Poisons and thus gaining Poisonous is perfect flavor, so I would choose that one. The Scribe is wonky and redundant when we already have the simple-and-clean Lab Partner.
BasilAnguis - I like the version you posted in Discord, with the "Frost Combo: Gain 5 Armor." A nice connection to Ice Barrier, the bold text flows nicely, and you probably don't need the Prodigy to Freeze someone because you just played a Frost spell (and thus did it already).
AeroJulwin - It's okay. It's a little better than Blessing of Kings, but I don't know if it is worth running in one's deck.
Me0203 - The Soulmancer is naturally comboed with Soul Shear, but that's kind of it. The DH doesn't have many worthwhile Shadow spells; not like the Warlock does. While I like Soul Fragments more, the Voidmancer might be more viable overall.
They split apart the last couple of bundles. Too bad they didn't split up this one (for North America). I want Frost Fairy Jaina, but there is no way in hell I will abide that Rexxar abomination in my collection.
Interesting opinion but it's not one that I agree with.
Unbalance make it impossible to build a good deck due to the polarizing match up table.
For example the only way to counter Azir/Irelia during it's prime was to play aggro decks, these decks got farmed by Tresh/Nasus if you tried to build something to counter Tresh/Nasus then it would get farmed by Azir/Irelia, there was no way to build a deck that was good or even decent against both. And let's not get into Trundle/Lissandra who made any deck that couldn't win before turn 8 unplayable.
Finally you can't just base a deck power level based on win rate alone, Pirate Aggro always had a solid win rate due to how easy to play it is. You just play on curve and go face then finish your opponent with burn effects but if your early aggression get countered you might just well hit concede. Lee Sin/Zoe despite the the lower win rate is much better deck than pirate because of all the counter play it provides.
This is terrible news. Swizard has been a major presence in our lovely Out of Cards community, and I've had plenty of fun matches and in-game conversations with him. You will be greatly missed, my friend.
Even more distressing is that the state of the game could be so bad as to drive away dedicated players like Swiz. Personally, I've also been very frustrated with how many things have been handled recently, but the game is still enough fun for me that I'm sticking with it. I sincerely hope Blizzard's approach changes soon, so they stop alienating and discouraging their players.
Ladder experiences are driven by heroes and Villains. You as the deck brewer have something to prove you want to beat that meta deck into the ground everyone else says is so op, but what happens when there are no villains anymore.
Lor is a fascinating case study because it is essentially the most balanced digital card game in existence to the extent that they will never need to rotate cards and only live balance changes will effect potential deck performance outcomes.
Case and point, Pirate aggro! People stopped playing this deck largely out of boredom but it still puts up numbers I'm talking 57% percent winrates currently right now making it essentially one of the best decks in the game.
But it isn't a villain and it's isn't played enough to be worth counter brewing against and very little satisfaction comes from beating it.
Lee Sin by comparison is not an amazing deck hovering between 51 and 52 percent winrate but it's play patterns are dynamic enough to stick in the mind of the looser.
You are getting beaten 100% when Lee Sin kicks you down to 0. My point is for me personally I find myself playing LOR far more when there is essentially a boss deck to beat, and far less when people can run any midrange soup and win.
Don't pressure the devs to hotfix too fast in the future, enjoy each stage of the meta as it progresses, and let things breathe a bit...otherwise it's just gonna be Bilgewater for literally the next 10 years of this games life cycle.
Fallen hero is an interesting inclusion. Why not Amplified Snowflurry? Its basically another tour guide.
I think there's enough justification to swap Deep Freeze with Rune of the Archmage, which will likely improve your matchup against midrange decks that aren't paladin. Deep freeze doesn't curve into dawngrasp anyway.
I'd like to squeeze out one extra damage from hand for the HK. But I'll try Amplified as I see that all similiar deck lists contain it. But I don't think, that "Random BS, go!" is a better tactic than freezing enemies 1-3+ times.
@anchom4n Thank you, but this deck really seems to go more into the big direction
I found that Regis played a similar deck to mine recently. Haven't watched it yet. Maybe this gives me more inspiration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixPf9CDcfbY
The Dead Never Rest! A Full Guide to Graveyard Deathrattle Rogue on the Wildest of Wednesdays
It had been a while since I built or posted a decent wild deck. Hope to answer the call and post something soon.
Gift Exchange
His comment is a year old so he probably does not remember.
Hearthstone's Winter Veil Event Begins! 6 Free Packs, Free Shop Hero, Festive Bundles, Greatfather Winter Magni Skin Now Available
Exactly, I would also use Tyrande, but I've no use for the other two. Jaina is the one, I really want. Oh well.
My Gifts Belong to ME!
2 years later, still works like a charm :)
+1
Gift Exchange
I ask because this was my first reaction: I should just hit auto-fill and see what happens. Since you've already done it, I am curious on the results!
Gift Exchange
And? :)
Spellschool Mage + HP
I took some inspiration from your build, made one of my own. So far looks promising with a few wins.
# 1x (1) Tour Guide
# 2x (1) Wildfire
# 2x (2) Amplified Snowflurry
# 2x (2) Manafeeder Panthara
# 2x (2) Pandaren Importer
# 2x (2) Starscryer
# 2x (2) Wandmaker
# 2x (4) Deepwater Evoker
# 2x (4) Reckless Apprentice
# 1x (4) Varden Dawngrasp
# 2x (5) Arcane Overflow
# 1x (5) Taelan Fordring
# 2x (6) Grey Sage Parrot
# 1x (7) Clumsy Courier
# 1x (7) Magister Dawngrasp
# 2x (7) Mask of C'Thun
# 1x (8) Mordresh Fire Eye
# 2x (9) Rune of the Archmage
AAECAf3VAwabzQPY7AOd7gOx9wOgigSoigQM97gD+84D/tED+90D0+wD1uwDyfkDkoEEk4EElIEEoZIE+6IEAA==
Honestly, Im beginning to have second thoughts about Tour Guide. 90% of the time I'd mulligan this just to get a better chance at getting Wildfire, which is honestly the best card in this list. I might at some point experiment with Shivering Sorceress or add in one Devolving Missiles to have a better matchup against paladin and priest, because tall decks really tests this deck.
I find that Multicaster is really not required because the deck is fairly midrange, and most of the time Im just playing two cards per turn at most. I'd rather be discovering stuff, and there's 5 tutor cards in there already.
Not having Ice Barrier still peeves me, but I think its better to chance it off discovers because some games its just useless, and you'd want to be aggressive if you can. Might experiment with Fire Sale in exchange for Starscryer if things get too aggressive.
Edit: I think I should at least mention that Rune of the Archmage is still just too good to ignore completely. Its not 'random bs go' because the spells will target enemies whenever it can, so 90% of the time it'll just clear board, or do some small damage to opponent's face. Mage has a massive weakness to tall boards, and this is an easy way out of it. Maybe 2x would be too much, but if we're sticking to the big spells ping mage idea, then at least 1 would be fitting.
Quitting HS
I had become an in-game friend of Swizard before his "fame", after playing against him in Wild ladder ages ago, both using interesting decks. You know, the old way.
Don't worry mate, they will nerf or ban Hunter and Warrior questlines soon enough and you'll come back to us!
Combo Harvester - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I'm a big fan of the Combo, but I do feel like 8 damage is a tad much. 6 would probably be fine. I know it doesn't double +Spell Damage that way, but that seems less important on cards that already deal quite some damage.
I also don't like how the effect is phrased. 'Deals' should probably be 'Deal' and the 'double damage' not specifically referring to the 4 damage feels weird to me, although I won't deduct for it.
Hail Storm is nice. The Combo makes sense to me and fits the art. But would maybe be fine as a 4-cost.
Right now you'll always want to wait keep it until you want to use Flamestrike or have Lethal, so you might consider reducing the costs permanently. A 2 or 3 Mana reduction would work well because you get two powerful spells in any case, but you can also get your Mana back.
Hot Take Card Inbalance Is Healthy For CCG's
I actually agree with Nifty on this one. Back when they first managed to fix Azir/Irelia I put out a post similar to his.
It’s painful fighting the same thing over and over again. Especially if you can’t beat it.
Conversely, fighting a wide variety of decks, but all of them feel the same, is pretty boring.
Personally, I like it when there is a big enemy to fight. What I don’t like is when every person I fight is that big enemy
Frozen Festivities - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
New iteration of my card. Since the effect requires you to perform a miracle turn to make it worthwhile, I figured out a 1 mana minion will be better.
Hearthstone's Winter Veil Event Begins! 6 Free Packs, Free Shop Hero, Festive Bundles, Greatfather Winter Magni Skin Now Available
I love the tyrande and valeera skins and dont care about the others and ofc theyre both in seperate bundles aswell
Quitting HS
classic = no resource generation = great
Hot Take Card Inbalance Is Healthy For CCG's
I understand where you're coming from, winrate alone isn't a sole measure of deck performance but when you measure the performance over time it gets far more informative.
Like gangplank Sejuani for example another meta bilgewater staple is always just happy at the top of the meta, reminds me of what Shen decks used to be...I consider pirate aggro to be similar based solely on its solid performance longterm.
But when updates come in and new decks aren't outperforming these old archetypes why play them at all? Then you run into a problem where longterm players just get bored of seeing the same thing over and over,
Like you could play Kenin right now with bounce girl, there are versions of that deck that do very well and are arguable far better than Lee Sin but until that list is perfected and is crystallized into something longterm nobody is gonna play.
Then even worse potentially, without a dominant new deck to speak of, you then have nothing to build and tech against. Yes Azir Irelia might have been op (sitting at 53% right now very respectable) and TF Fizz (dead) so they needed hard nerfs and it took too long, I just think there's a happy medium.
We want to see new decks at the top if the tier list but not oppressing players to the point of frustration.
Combo Harvester - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thanks, everyone. I'll probably submit Swift Assassin, since it has had a better reception. I also like it better (even if the art from the other card is much cooler)
More feedback:
I'd also change the name since the current one is too similar to Wildfire
My main issue is that it probably shouldn't be a Beast, since Astral Tiger isn't.
Hearthstone's Winter Veil Event Begins! 6 Free Packs, Free Shop Hero, Festive Bundles, Greatfather Winter Magni Skin Now Available
1. You are definitely complaining.
2. You see that you are biased, yet you complain about it anyway.
3. It's not about other players not caring about Wild. It's about Wild not being a money-making game mode for Blizzard, so there's no reason to reward playing it. In fact, I'm sure Blizzard sees Wild as a necessary evil and would prefer it if no one played Wild.
4. Newer players are completely unfamiliar with Wild cards, and they certainly don't own any.
5. You don't even have to win the games. Just put some random Core cards together and collect your free packs, you ingrate.
Combo Harvester - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Feedback:
Demonxz95 - I can't stand Vanish, so you might lose a point from me there, but I also don't play many low-cost minions so it wouldn't bother me as much in practice.
anchorm4n - I care about board presence…a lot :( All of my decks seek to hit the board, so this could be pretty painful in my own experience. What about something like "Fire Combo: The next one you play this turn costs (1)." That way the other spell goes back to full cost; that would allow you to readjust the base spell more favorably, and mitigate a crazy Hot Streak turn.
Nirast - I'll be honest: I don't like either one. Healing Hail is an okay play on Healing Rain, but the flavor is very weird (you're being pelted with ice-rocks; why is it healing you?). Hail Storm is just Blizzard with extra steps. I'm not sure if either of them would find a home somewhere.
R - A reverse-Meteor that can also go face if you want it to? That sounds super good. I personally don't feel like Fire Mage needs more face-damage spells: it needs to be encouraged to actually use its board for once.
Wailor - Swift Assassin being connected to Poisons and thus gaining Poisonous is perfect flavor, so I would choose that one. The Scribe is wonky and redundant when we already have the simple-and-clean Lab Partner.
BasilAnguis - I like the version you posted in Discord, with the "Frost Combo: Gain 5 Armor." A nice connection to Ice Barrier, the bold text flows nicely, and you probably don't need the Prodigy to Freeze someone because you just played a Frost spell (and thus did it already).
AeroJulwin - It's okay. It's a little better than Blessing of Kings, but I don't know if it is worth running in one's deck.
Me0203 - The Soulmancer is naturally comboed with Soul Shear, but that's kind of it. The DH doesn't have many worthwhile Shadow spells; not like the Warlock does. While I like Soul Fragments more, the Voidmancer might be more viable overall.
Hearthstone's Winter Veil Event Begins! 6 Free Packs, Free Shop Hero, Festive Bundles, Greatfather Winter Magni Skin Now Available
They split apart the last couple of bundles. Too bad they didn't split up this one (for North America). I want Frost Fairy Jaina, but there is no way in hell I will abide that Rexxar abomination in my collection.
Hot Take Card Inbalance Is Healthy For CCG's
Interesting opinion but it's not one that I agree with.
Unbalance make it impossible to build a good deck due to the polarizing match up table.
For example the only way to counter Azir/Irelia during it's prime was to play aggro decks, these decks got farmed by Tresh/Nasus if you tried to build something to counter Tresh/Nasus then it would get farmed by Azir/Irelia, there was no way to build a deck that was good or even decent against both. And let's not get into Trundle/Lissandra who made any deck that couldn't win before turn 8 unplayable.
Finally you can't just base a deck power level based on win rate alone, Pirate Aggro always had a solid win rate due to how easy to play it is. You just play on curve and go face then finish your opponent with burn effects but if your early aggression get countered you might just well hit concede. Lee Sin/Zoe despite the the lower win rate is much better deck than pirate because of all the counter play it provides.
Grinch Priest (Gift Exchange 2020)
Hello, 2021! This deck still works!
The Dead Never Rest! A Full Guide to Graveyard Deathrattle Rogue on the Wildest of Wednesdays
Ha! I knew Snowfall Graveyard would eventually become a build around :) Especially with Forsaken Lieutenant in the same set.
Quitting HS
This is terrible news. Swizard has been a major presence in our lovely Out of Cards community, and I've had plenty of fun matches and in-game conversations with him. You will be greatly missed, my friend.
Even more distressing is that the state of the game could be so bad as to drive away dedicated players like Swiz. Personally, I've also been very frustrated with how many things have been handled recently, but the game is still enough fun for me that I'm sticking with it. I sincerely hope Blizzard's approach changes soon, so they stop alienating and discouraging their players.
Quitting HS
THIS right here
Hot Take Card Inbalance Is Healthy For CCG's
Ladder experiences are driven by heroes and Villains. You as the deck brewer have something to prove you want to beat that meta deck into the ground everyone else says is so op, but what happens when there are no villains anymore.
Lor is a fascinating case study because it is essentially the most balanced digital card game in existence to the extent that they will never need to rotate cards and only live balance changes will effect potential deck performance outcomes.
Case and point, Pirate aggro! People stopped playing this deck largely out of boredom but it still puts up numbers I'm talking 57% percent winrates currently right now making it essentially one of the best decks in the game.
But it isn't a villain and it's isn't played enough to be worth counter brewing against and very little satisfaction comes from beating it.
Lee Sin by comparison is not an amazing deck hovering between 51 and 52 percent winrate but it's play patterns are dynamic enough to stick in the mind of the looser.
You are getting beaten 100% when Lee Sin kicks you down to 0. My point is for me personally I find myself playing LOR far more when there is essentially a boss deck to beat, and far less when people can run any midrange soup and win.
Don't pressure the devs to hotfix too fast in the future, enjoy each stage of the meta as it progresses, and let things breathe a bit...otherwise it's just gonna be Bilgewater for literally the next 10 years of this games life cycle.
Spellschool Mage + HP
I'd like to squeeze out one extra damage from hand for the HK. But I'll try Amplified as I see that all similiar deck lists contain it. But I don't think, that "Random BS, go!" is a better tactic than freezing enemies 1-3+ times.
@anchom4n Thank you, but this deck really seems to go more into the big direction
I found that Regis played a similar deck to mine recently. Haven't watched it yet. Maybe this gives me more inspiration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixPf9CDcfbY