I liked The Phoenix Chamber better, even if it collides a bit with Construct Quarter. I'm not sure about which iteration I'd go with, though. I'd say the Priest one, but I'm not sure about how dangerous the OTK potential would be.

Scarlet Monastery isn't bad, but it's effect feels closer to a Common than to a Legendary (not a fan of the art, either).

All of them are solid and with supperb artworks.

My clear favorite, though, is Bastion Arch (even if there are a lot of Priest cards here). Its effect feels very legendary and works very well with the location mechanic. I could see you winning the comp with it (again).

Very creative effect, I like it a lot. I'd suggest reducing the Durability to 3 or even 2, as 4 is basically for ever (especially if you consider you might want to keep a single minions inside the prison for several turns).

The effect is alright, but I don't like it as a Neutral card. I'd suggest going for Mage, as the class has some connection with Yogg, and it's also known for its random effects. Might also suggest reducing its cost to 2.

Not sure if you're new here, but welcome if that's the case!

Your card is pretty neat and I think it's balanced enough. I recommend writing a small piece of lore in the submission, as it's not as well known as other WoW locations, but it looks very cool and interesting.

The effect is neat and works well as a Neutral card, but it's way too expensive as a 5 Mana card. I'd probably go with 2 or 3 Mana.

Also, a quest pannel doesn't look very legendary, even if it fits the effect. I'd suggest swapping the art and name for something more grandious that also fits the effect, like a well-known library in the WoW lore or a time portal.

I'm not a fan of the spider cards, as Dormant doesn't seem to be part of Rogue's identity. Maybe a Sap effect would work better, at least for the Quarter (not for Maexxna, she would turn into Vanish on steroids).

About Razuvious, I kinda prefer the second one because of how dumb it is (in a good way), but it'd probably work better as a Neutral or as part of a core/initiate set, as it's kinda basic for an expansion legendary.

I find this effect to be a little hard to balance and make interesting at the same time. Right now, it will almost always deal 8-10 damage, which is too little variance for it to matter. On the other hand, making it cheaper would definetly break the card. I'd probably turn his effect into an AoE, while also lowering the Cost.

The first Sapphiron has a very interesting effect, but it's probably too expensive for it to work properly. The Mage version isn't bad either (but be careful, the Infused version needs to say "Battlecry"). Not a fan of Maexxna, though.

I think your two options are:

• Find a character that makes sense with DK Sapph's effect but also makes sense as a 4-ish Mana minion.
• Go with the Mage Sapph after adding Battlecry to the Infused version and maybe finding a better art for it.

I agree with linkblade, Skeletal Smith is your better card and also in that it's kind of too swingy as a 2-Mana card. I'd probably make it more expensive (with better stats ofc) and maybe also give it Taunt. At this point I'd suggest making it a Warrior card, but that'd go against what your aiming for XD

I like your idea about having a Quarter cycle. The second version is better, but it feels a bit too good. I'd probably make it 2 Durability, as rising the Cost to 2 would likely kill the card.

I'd say I prefer this over the actual DK Location we got, although not by much. Its flavor fits the effect, but not the expansion, although I guess this is to be expected from a end-of-year miniset. Not sure what else to say, it's a solid card. The art is improvable, though.

Pretty cool. I think 3 Mana would be an appropriate cost, compared to Infantry Reanimator. Finally, I don't know if Polluted Pool is a real Naxx location, but if it isn't, I'd probably try to find one that fits the effect (I'm sure there'll be one, considering Naxx is sort of a giant Frankenstein lab).

All your cards are solid, but my favorite is Fresh Digs. It should really use the miniset watermark, though, as Dredge isn't allowed on the main MotLK set.

I really like the basic idea of a witch that turns into a Dragon and how you combined both keywords, but I think the card still needs some polish:

• The Infused version should lacks "Colossal +X" right after Infused. Right now, there's no way to tell how many Colossal tokens you'll get.
• The art of both the Infused version and its token look pretty bad.
• The token should probably be body part, like with all other Colossal minions. I'd probably Google a multi-headed Dragon and make the tokens its heads to solve both issues.

 

I like both, but I'd say I prefer Corpse Researcher. It probably needs a better statline (2/1, probably), as a tutored Novice Engineer is not nearly enough.

I'd say Sadistic Spellweaver doesn't count, but Suspicious Diver is quite interesting. The artwork doesn't fit Hearthstone, however.

Koma is a cool idea, but such a creature would be classified as a Beast in actual WoW lore, so I'd discard it.

Effects of cards keeping enchantments under conditions they usually don't are always amusing, so thumbs up for that. I think it could easily be 2 Mana, since keeping buffs circumvents the main issue of Reborn (that is, how easy to remove they are after resurrecting).

Welcome! It's always awesome to have new people :)

All your cards are very solid for a newcomer. As a general tip for all them, they should use the Return to Naxx watermark, as they mix mechanics from all the year.

• Bonehull is interesting, but it looks like a Rogue card, so make sure to clarify it's Neutral in the description. I also think the tokens should be Discover and summon instead of just Discover, as it's way too slow right now.
• Suspicious Angler is cool, but another person had the same idea, so I'd advice going with another card.
• Anub'arak is my favorite of your cards. My only issue is the fact the tokens don't synergize with the main body, so I'd give Anub Taunt too.

I prefer Garrosh hands down. His effect is really cool and interesting; and also fits the character a lot.

Gul'dan's effect is also interesting (although not so much), but the main issue I have with it is how wordy it is, which makes the card look unappealing at first glance.

The new Jaina is cool, but I still prefer Thrall.

I like the damage version, as a Demon Highlander deck might be a bit too restrictive.

Both cards are solid, but I'd say I prefer Valeera, as she seems more fun.

Thrall's effect is a bit too abstract for my taste, if that makes any sense, but he's also cool. If you end up going with him, I like the alternate wording linkblade suggested the best, as it's also affects generated spells (unlike the second wording you suggested later)

You polished your previous card a great deal. Well done! My only issue now is that the words "minion", "weapon" and "spell" should be written in lowercase. This affects both Thrall himself and Windlord's Blessing.

I think the new machine gun Jaina is my favorite among your cards, but I don't play Hearthstone, so I don't have PTSD from Sire Denathrius. The freeze all enemies version might be a safer bet, considering this (although she should probably cost 9, considering she powercreeps Deep Freeze a lot).

I'm not a huge fan of the artwork, as it looks like a WoW screenshot. You can use the same art I used if you want, as I think it's the same outfit. If you decide to do it, PM me so we don't collide.

Regarding your versions, I think your most recent one is the most interesting, but maybe it could cost 4 Mana as well. Dunno, it looks strictly worse than the second one you posted (the one that says "replace").

Both are solid, but I prefer Thrall. Its callback to the Classic set and its strong lore basis is something that I think works really well for this comp.

Both are solid cards, although I prefer Gul'dan. I like the art, but I think it's more appropriate for a spell. If you still want to go with it, you should zoom it more as you said. Regarding the effect, it fits Gul'dan a lot (Demons are very classic Warlock stuff and Lifesteal ties to his Death Knight hero from KFT), but I you should drop the Highlander requirement or reduce the Cost, IMO.

Regarding Valeera, her effect is pretty interesting. It has a lot of potential, but it requires a lot of setup and is quite expensive, so I think you did a good job in this regard. What I don't like as much is the lack of connection to Valeera as a character, which I think should be the focus of this comp.

Very flavorful card.

I'd probably make a couple changes to the Blessings:

• Tidehunter's Blessing should probably give that Deathrattle to all friendly minions and not just Murlocs. It's still a Murloc generator, so I'd still be more useful in dedicated Murloc decks without making it useless in other builds.
• Windlord's Blessing should only relate to Nature spells, IMO. My two suggestions are either Discover a Nature spell at the end of your turn or gain permanent Nature Spell Damage +1.
• Stonemother's Blessing has a Common gem, while the other tokens don't.

I prefer Uther, but it's a bit strange to have such a character as just a 3 Mana minion. Maybe make it a 5/5/5 and make him summon two Recruits?

Not a fan of Anduin, as Immune is very scary.

The second effect is way too complex, IMO; but I like the first one a lot. It's very similar to my own Jaina, but I like the effect of yours a bit better.

In any case, there are some aesthetic improvements you could apply to both cards:

• Make the artwork focus more on Jaina.
• Get rid of the Classic watermark.
• If you go with the second effect, Arcane shouldn't be bolded.

I like the second effect better, but I'd go with the first statline, since the lack of immediate impact + high Cost may make it too hard to use.

I also thought of Madam Goya when I saw your card. In order to be more original and prevent it from being broken, I'd make it target enemy minions only and make it 4 Mana (as it's too good right now).

Reckless Seeker is very amusing. I'd go with it hands down.

I don't like the other card as much, since, as Demon said, seems like your opponent could easily sabbotage you. If you decide to go with him, I'd probably change it to a Battlecry that copies all cards your opponent played last turn instead, as that'd give the player much more control over the effect.

First of all, welcome to the fan creations community!

I prefer Mitter Joint, as the Mewtwo card is too complex. However, you should try to reduce the number of lines in the reward, as there's an unspoken rule that cards can't have more than four lines. If you can find better artwork, that'd also improve your card.

If you decide to go with the Mewtwo card, I'd change the flavor to something Warcraft related and would change the wording to something similar to Elise the Trailblazer, as the effect is actually very similar to her (the Discover part can be discarded all together because you end up getting all three cards at the same time).

The effect is very interesting and creative, so thumbs up for that.

Not sure if this is a bug or a feature, but this card is also very good in OTK decks, as the summoned minion is free (of course, you risk drawing the minion at the very next turn, but I'd say it's very worth the risk). As said, not sure if this is intentional, but if it's not, I'd simply move the trigger to the end of your turn, instead of the beginning.

Very solid cards as usual.

Stern Librarian has a bit of a flavor issue, as a huge Taunt doesn't seem very appropriate for a librarian. Some sort of big Demon like a Pit Lord would work better, IMO. Still, very solid card.

Spiritchanter Voluk is probably my favorite among the two. Not much to say, as I wouldn't change much (maybe I'd change the name of the token to [0]'s Chant instead of Voluk's Chant, but it's a very minor thing).

It's kinda like a reverse Framester, I like it.

I'd probably use another artwork (preferably some pirate with a treasure or coins) and maybe another watermark, but neither thing is a big deal.

Very cool card, although I'd probably make it a legendary. Even if you don't, you shouldn't use the word EVIL, as those are exclusively Lackey cards. Finally, there's also the issue that Rise of Shadows didn't have dual class cards, but I don't mind it too much, since it's a miniset and they could very well include them.

Since you posted many cards, I'll review them from most to least favorite:

• Shallow Waters is very cool in its simplicity. That said, it has some things to improve, as it would work better as a Battlecry minion (it compares poorly to Aquatic Form) and it shouldn't be dual class (as Sunken City didn't have those).
• Curious Experimenter has a very creative use of shuffle. Not much to add, as it's quite refined as it is.
• Pluxva the Soulbound is cool, but I don't like it as much as the other two.
• Waterfall Visions has a bit of a clunky text, but I don't think it can be expressed in a much better way.