I think a lot of people that play net-deck auto-win decks want to have their cake and eat it too.
I've caught flack on forums for admitting that I happily will rope those players (ideally for 7 turns playing excellently though I know I'm going to lose). And am vocal about not enjoying stale metas with obviously overpowered decks running rampant.
People, the amount of time I'm allotted a turn is for me to decide as are my opinions. They are as valid as yours and I don't call it BMing, I call it protest.
It honestly should be run, but it’s not a card I own so I didn’t include it. I didn’t end up running Saidan the Scarlet either because I didn’t unpack him
I do agree to some extent that it feels underwhelming when new archetypes don't immediately take off after they're released. But:
1) Don't forget the roation cycle. This is the last expansion of this year so completely new stuff will naturely have a hard time against archetypes that got support throughout the whole cycle so far. Sometimes things come to together two or three expansions later.
2) For some people, figuring out what works and what doesn't is part of the fun. It's no challenge and therefor less rewarding to put together "robot decks" as you call them on day 1 and go down a mirror match spiral of doom. Remember that we are only one week into the expansion yet, it takes some time to figure things out. My personal take is that they should completely abolish the theorycraft stream with the pros by the way.
3) As others have already pointed out, not every archetype is supposed to be competitive. Unfortunately, Burgle Rogue is one of them.
4) Try to tune it down a bit. I certainly know how it feels when you perceive an injustice and people rush to defend that perceived injustice on top of that. Yesterday's Formula 1 finals did that for me when my wife defended everything about Verstappen and I flat out told her she wouldn't come to the same conclusions if the roles were reversed. It ended with me leaving the room because I didn't want to spoil the race for her (she's the fan, I'm most certainly not). What I'm trying to say is: Sometimes we should just agree to disagree and move on. Just keep things polite.
Thanks, but no thanks. I dont buy skins as a rule, and only a small part of the BG heroes is a huge waste of money imho. Better to buy the paid rewards track and get free skins and other goodies if you want skins.
Afterwards I checked my achievement and found....6 points of progress. So what happened? Obviously it counted something but clearly not anything involving Divine Spirit. It also can't be any of the regular health buffs since Will gives +3 health which would have left me with an odd number of progress. It similarly can't just be the buff applied by Bless itself because that would just be 4 points of progress.
Does anybody have ideas what is happening here and how to properly exploit it?
that's wrong, dirty Rat is 2-6 , Bless buff heal by 2 , so it goes 2-8 , than transform to 8-8 and so it gets the +6
However, my achievement worked exactly as it should have with the following plays: Kabal Talonpriest buff applied to a Northshire Cleric (both played in the same turn), then 2x Divine Spirit into Bless on the subsequent turn for a 26/26 Cleric. My achievement is now at 25/200.
EDIT: My second attempt with the same deck resulted in a gain of 0 despite buffing a Kabal Talonpriest to 11/11. I don't recall exactly what buffs I put on him when, but he got at least one Talonpriest buff and the Bless buff (and maybe a Focused Will buff?), and was not at full health when I cast Bless on him. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
EDIT: Third attempt, buffed Reliquary of Souls (at full HP) with Divine Spirit and Bless, made no progress...
This let me thing there is a possibility that is not coded as a sum , but a one time buff , i have to try ..
edit: i managed to do 100/200 progress with a 131/131 minion , im pretty sure it was right since i have done some buffs with obelisk quest priest hp .
Maybe just me, But after trying a few games, I feel achievements becoming more and more grindier.
250 hunter secrets, 300 mana Iceblood Tower, 300 damage Cariel Weapon, 200 Xyrella deathrattles are just a few examples.
For some, it's fine, because Wild sets can help a lot. But Hero Card achievements are the worst. You only have 1 card, and it's not always gonna be playable in every single game.
Probably just gonna wait until they fixed the bugs. It's amusing how they can't bring a fully function expansion after all this year.
I opened Shadowcrafter Scabbs and Cera'thine Fleetrunner on the first day of the expansion, and was really excited to try out Burgle Rogue too. And it's certainly a cool deck that does some powerful stuff. The early tempo you can get from Double Agent and Wildpaw Gnoll thanks to how they interact with Maestra of the Masquerade is awesome, and Contraband Stash is a great payoff card that benefits from smart playing (e.g. by picking spells from Wand Thief that will always target enemies, picking high-value deathrattles from Reconnaissance, or maybe holding back a bit when playing Shadowjeweler Hanar to avoid losing out on the tempo value you might otherwise get from the Contraband Stash).
It's a sweet deck, and when it goes off it's incredibly fun. I played a game where, between Reconnaissance and Contraband Stash, I generated a full board of Greyboughs and become untouchable. A part of me feels the same way you do about wanting to see it be more competitive so that I can win more and enjoy these sweet moments.
The reality, though, is that cards and archetypes are intentionally not created equal. Thesearticlesby Mark Rosewater back in 2009 speak to how MTG goes about designing for different players. Together I think they paint a good picture of how cards and archetypes will naturally vary in strength because they're basically serving different constituencies. As I see it, Burgle Rogue is likely always going to occupy some Timmy/Johnny design space, and probably won't be terribly competitive. That's not to say that every individual player can't find success with it (e.g. Rogue has some nice disruption tools that can really mess with OwlTK Warlock), but it's naturally going to be weaker because it's built to serve a set of players who care more than the average player about the "how" of winning.
To the broader point about issues with the metagame, I think you're right that it's in an unhealthy place right now. You need only tune in to one of Kibler's streams to see a player who is famous for winning with "Timmy decks" frustrated at every turn by the efficiency of the top tier decks.
This works brilliantly. I think the deathrattle proc'ed about 60 times times in a single game - seemed like it would go on forever, but it did eventually resolve rather than break the game with an infinite battlecry.
EDIT: I should mention that I tried this twos ways - killing the Kobold Illusionist before dropping Spammy Arcanist (to spawn 1/1s that Spammy would kill for sure), and setting up the board to have the battlecry kill the original Kobold Illusionist (by ensuring there was a 1-Health and 2-Health minion on board to chain into the Illusionist). The former didn't work (which surprised me, since the chaining works fine otherwise), but the latter did twice. So, there's some amount of setup required to get Spammy to kill a played version of the Illusionist, but it worked like a charm otherwise.
Tried it and can confirm that it works as well.
You only really need to drop the illusionist to 1, because on death it'll just continue the chain from there. A handy backstab works wonders in this regard. Just need to make sure that illusionist is the one that gets summoned.
We are pushing out a deploy now and we're going to be reverting to our original video ad provider.
We'll probably give the new unit a shot again in the future but its still too early and problems need to be worked out. I know our ads are annoying but they keep the site online and my, hopeful, goal is that ads we do display aren't a major pain in the ass.
This works brilliantly. I think the deathrattle proc'ed about 60 times times in a single game - seemed like it would go on forever, but it did eventually resolve rather than break the game with an infinite battlecry.
EDIT: I should mention that I tried this twos ways - killing the Kobold Illusionist before dropping Spammy Arcanist (to spawn 1/1s that Spammy would kill for sure), and setting up the board to have the battlecry kill the original Kobold Illusionist (by ensuring there was a 1-Health and 2-Health minion on board to chain into the Illusionist). The former didn't work (which surprised me, since the chaining works fine otherwise), but the latter did twice. So, there's some amount of setup required to get Spammy to kill a played version of the Illusionist, but it worked like a charm otherwise.
Killing Kenin is easy. Drag the Kenin with a challenger wait for the necessary bounce counter with board interaction, aka single, vile or mystic.
So the key is that you are responding when Kenin comes down on turn 4 every kenin deck functions this way and knowing when a play is guaranteed to happen is very powerful.
Why is it guaranteed? Because you developed threats and youre pressuring life total.
Now you're running meta decks, they don't have challengers, or vulnerable, or board interaction besides pokey stick and thats it. So yeah you're gonna get pooped on by a combo deck that just stuns and plays solitaire with itself when really the best best way to stop that from happening is throwing the table.
But yeah waiting till turn 5 for a sweeper is pretty much guaranteed to loose if that's what we are talking about lol, you have to answer things on curve with kenin and then if that fails try the sweeper thing after taxing their answers.
------- Bonus-------
You want a real mind **** the best Kenin card is the Lee Sin challenger granter because it's let's Kenin beat other Kenin decks. That's all the proof I need that board interaction is the best counter to everyone's favorite combo deck.
-----Extra Bonus----
The best pantheon deck has gone up 2% on mobalytics just by hard teching challenger dragon. Honestly I probably wouldn't stop there there's an argument for laurent protégé as well.
okay so you are trying to take your chance to kill the lvl 1 Kennens with a Yasuo on curve on turn 5?
Good luck at succeeding with that buddy and not get denied/recalled
I am really not buying this card since it will rarely hits more than 2 units. You rather invoke a 3 mana stun 2 units than using this card that is niche at best
like name a 1 tier deck right now that cares about the 2 power or less clause
This is Boltzmann's take on Freeze Shudderwock Shaman. This deck performs very well against Pirate Warrior. In this video, we go into some depth, on the structure of the deck and justifications for different card inclusions. If you have questions, please post them below, and I am sure Boltzmann will respond.
Game clip:
0:16 Stress relief against Pirate Warrior :-)
Deck introduction and breakdown:
3:15 Introduction to Boltzmann's Freeze Shudderwock Shaman, compared to EnDjinn's Freeze Shudderwock Shaman (from yesterday's video) 5:10 The origins of the Boltzmann Freeze Shudderwock Shaman deck 6:30 Card justifications - Healing Rain vs Snowblind Harpy 7:10 Card justifications - Armor Vendor 8:02 Shudderwock / Freeze logic 8:33 Card justifications - Loatheb / Snowfall Guardian / Macaw 9:21 Card justifications - Windchill / Bolner / Sleetbreaker / Zentimo 10:00 Final thoughts on the deck
Games:
10:38 vs Odd Hunter 20:28 vs Pirate Warrior
Closing thoughts:
24:39 Final impressions on the deck 26:20 - 28:32 For Doomhammer Discord Server
In fairness, that's a reasonable way to assess fun for a lot of individuals. Frankly, I think it's a pretty concise description of the Johnny/Jenny player archetype (and dips a bit into the Timmy/Tammy archetype as well). It's also understandably frustrating to feel like a lone Johnny/Jenny in a sea of Spikes.
The Chillwind Yeti bug makes it pretty clear that little to no manual testing goes into these achievements. I can imagine some poorly written unit tests that might exist and make it look like the code works as intended, but clearly no one ever bothered to try and do this achievement in Standard because you literally can't get the right version of Yeti in Standard.
Regarding Bless, I've got a new wrinkle to add here. After reading all of this I thought I might test a hypothesis, so I played my first Bless Priest game (which happened to be in Wild). I thought maybe there was some bug resulting in bad integer division (e.g. if it were dividing by 5, let's say, then any buff lower than 5 Attack would count as 0, anything between 5 and 9 would count as 1, etc.). That sort of thing might account for why a huge buff was only counted as 6 points.
However, my achievement worked exactly as it should have with the following plays: Kabal Talonpriest buff applied to a Northshire Cleric (both played in the same turn), then 2x Divine Spirit into Bless on the subsequent turn for a 26/26 Cleric. My achievement is now at 25/200.
EDIT: My second attempt with the same deck resulted in a gain of 0 despite buffing a Kabal Talonpriest to 11/11. I don't recall exactly what buffs I put on him when, but he got at least one Talonpriest buff and the Bless buff (and maybe a Focused Will buff?), and was not at full health when I cast Bless on him. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Every meta. Why?
I think a lot of people that play net-deck auto-win decks want to have their cake and eat it too.
I've caught flack on forums for admitting that I happily will rope those players (ideally for 7 turns playing excellently though I know I'm going to lose). And am vocal about not enjoying stale metas with obviously overpowered decks running rampant.
People, the amount of time I'm allotted a turn is for me to decide as are my opinions. They are as valid as yours and I don't call it BMing, I call it protest.
Lightforged Smiting
It honestly should be run, but it’s not a card I own so I didn’t include it. I didn’t end up running Saidan the Scarlet either because I didn’t unpack him
Every meta. Why?
I do agree to some extent that it feels underwhelming when new archetypes don't immediately take off after they're released. But:
1) Don't forget the roation cycle. This is the last expansion of this year so completely new stuff will naturely have a hard time against archetypes that got support throughout the whole cycle so far. Sometimes things come to together two or three expansions later.
2) For some people, figuring out what works and what doesn't is part of the fun. It's no challenge and therefor less rewarding to put together "robot decks" as you call them on day 1 and go down a mirror match spiral of doom. Remember that we are only one week into the expansion yet, it takes some time to figure things out. My personal take is that they should completely abolish the theorycraft stream with the pros by the way.
3) As others have already pointed out, not every archetype is supposed to be competitive. Unfortunately, Burgle Rogue is one of them.
4) Try to tune it down a bit. I certainly know how it feels when you perceive an injustice and people rush to defend that perceived injustice on top of that. Yesterday's Formula 1 finals did that for me when my wife defended everything about Verstappen and I flat out told her she wouldn't come to the same conclusions if the roles were reversed. It ended with me leaving the room because I didn't want to spoil the race for her (she's the fan, I'm most certainly not). What I'm trying to say is: Sometimes we should just agree to disagree and move on. Just keep things polite.
Every meta. Why?
Because my soul is already dead.
Last Call for Hearthstone Battleground's Pirate-themed Shop Skins - Buccaneer's Booty Leaves Soon!
Thanks, but no thanks. I dont buy skins as a rule, and only a small part of the BG heroes is a huge waste of money imho. Better to buy the paid rewards track and get free skins and other goodies if you want skins.
Last Call for Hearthstone Battleground's Pirate-themed Shop Skins - Buccaneer's Booty Leaves Soon!
Would love to buy these skins individually for gold.
A Site for Hearthstone Sounds - HearthSFX
I've started some work on making the voicelines available for all languages. I'll be sure to let you know if and when that eventually goes live!
Alterac Valley Achievements
that's wrong, dirty Rat is 2-6 , Bless buff heal by 2 , so it goes 2-8 , than transform to 8-8 and so it gets the +6
This let me thing there is a possibility that is not coded as a sum , but a one time buff , i have to try ..
edit: i managed to do 100/200 progress with a 131/131 minion , im pretty sure it was right since i have done some buffs with obelisk quest priest hp .
Alterac Valley Achievements
Maybe just me, But after trying a few games, I feel achievements becoming more and more grindier.
250 hunter secrets, 300 mana Iceblood Tower, 300 damage Cariel Weapon, 200 Xyrella deathrattles are just a few examples.
For some, it's fine, because Wild sets can help a lot. But Hero Card achievements are the worst. You only have 1 card, and it's not always gonna be playable in every single game.
Probably just gonna wait until they fixed the bugs. It's amusing how they can't bring a fully function expansion after all this year.
Every meta. Why?
I opened Shadowcrafter Scabbs and Cera'thine Fleetrunner on the first day of the expansion, and was really excited to try out Burgle Rogue too. And it's certainly a cool deck that does some powerful stuff. The early tempo you can get from Double Agent and Wildpaw Gnoll thanks to how they interact with Maestra of the Masquerade is awesome, and Contraband Stash is a great payoff card that benefits from smart playing (e.g. by picking spells from Wand Thief that will always target enemies, picking high-value deathrattles from Reconnaissance, or maybe holding back a bit when playing Shadowjeweler Hanar to avoid losing out on the tempo value you might otherwise get from the Contraband Stash).
It's a sweet deck, and when it goes off it's incredibly fun. I played a game where, between Reconnaissance and Contraband Stash, I generated a full board of Greyboughs and become untouchable. A part of me feels the same way you do about wanting to see it be more competitive so that I can win more and enjoy these sweet moments.
The reality, though, is that cards and archetypes are intentionally not created equal. These articles by Mark Rosewater back in 2009 speak to how MTG goes about designing for different players. Together I think they paint a good picture of how cards and archetypes will naturally vary in strength because they're basically serving different constituencies. As I see it, Burgle Rogue is likely always going to occupy some Timmy/Johnny design space, and probably won't be terribly competitive. That's not to say that every individual player can't find success with it (e.g. Rogue has some nice disruption tools that can really mess with OwlTK Warlock), but it's naturally going to be weaker because it's built to serve a set of players who care more than the average player about the "how" of winning.
To the broader point about issues with the metagame, I think you're right that it's in an unhealthy place right now. You need only tune in to one of Kibler's streams to see a player who is famous for winning with "Timmy decks" frustrated at every turn by the efficiency of the top tier decks.
Alterac Valley Achievements
Tried it and can confirm that it works as well.
You only really need to drop the illusionist to 1, because on death it'll just continue the chain from there. A handy backstab works wonders in this regard. Just need to make sure that illusionist is the one that gets summoned.
Honourable Mentions - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Good luck to the other finalists :)
Recent change to video ads?
We are pushing out a deploy now and we're going to be reverting to our original video ad provider.
We'll probably give the new unit a shot again in the future but its still too early and problems need to be worked out. I know our ads are annoying but they keep the site online and my, hopeful, goal is that ads we do display aren't a major pain in the ass.
Every meta. Why?
No one asked for quest warrior deck buff. No one
Alterac Valley Achievements
This works brilliantly. I think the deathrattle proc'ed about 60 times times in a single game - seemed like it would go on forever, but it did eventually resolve rather than break the game with an infinite battlecry.
EDIT: I should mention that I tried this twos ways - killing the Kobold Illusionist before dropping Spammy Arcanist (to spawn 1/1s that Spammy would kill for sure), and setting up the board to have the battlecry kill the original Kobold Illusionist (by ensuring there was a 1-Health and 2-Health minion on board to chain into the Illusionist). The former didn't work (which surprised me, since the chaining works fine otherwise), but the latter did twice. So, there's some amount of setup required to get Spammy to kill a played version of the Illusionist, but it worked like a charm otherwise.
Every meta. Why?
It is very often you make a thread, people disagree with you, and you start to insult people. Why do you do this?
New Meta Overview Bandlewood Part 2
Killing Kenin is easy. Drag the Kenin with a challenger wait for the necessary bounce counter with board interaction, aka single, vile or mystic.
So the key is that you are responding when Kenin comes down on turn 4 every kenin deck functions this way and knowing when a play is guaranteed to happen is very powerful.
Why is it guaranteed? Because you developed threats and youre pressuring life total.
Now you're running meta decks, they don't have challengers, or vulnerable, or board interaction besides pokey stick and thats it. So yeah you're gonna get pooped on by a combo deck that just stuns and plays solitaire with itself when really the best best way to stop that from happening is throwing the table.
But yeah waiting till turn 5 for a sweeper is pretty much guaranteed to loose if that's what we are talking about lol, you have to answer things on curve with kenin and then if that fails try the sweeper thing after taxing their answers.
------- Bonus-------
You want a real mind **** the best Kenin card is the Lee Sin challenger granter because it's let's Kenin beat other Kenin decks. That's all the proof I need that board interaction is the best counter to everyone's favorite combo deck.
-----Extra Bonus----
The best pantheon deck has gone up 2% on mobalytics just by hard teching challenger dragon. Honestly I probably wouldn't stop there there's an argument for laurent protégé as well.
New Meta Overview Bandlewood Part 2
okay so you are trying to take your chance to kill the lvl 1 Kennens with a Yasuo on curve on turn 5?
Good luck at succeeding with that buddy and not get denied/recalled
I am really not buying this card since it will rarely hits more than 2 units. You rather invoke a 3 mana stun 2 units than using this card that is niche at best
like name a 1 tier deck right now that cares about the 2 power or less clause
Darkseeker's channel - 13th November update: KOtsosKOtsos' Reno Evolve Shudderwock Shaman - ft. Archivist Elysiana
12th December update: Boltzmann's Freeze Shudderwock Shaman: Board locking Pirate Warriors!
This is Boltzmann's take on Freeze Shudderwock Shaman. This deck performs very well against Pirate Warrior. In this video, we go into some depth, on the structure of the deck and justifications for different card inclusions.
If you have questions, please post them below, and I am sure Boltzmann will respond.
Game clip:
0:16 Stress relief against Pirate Warrior :-)
Deck introduction and breakdown:
3:15 Introduction to Boltzmann's Freeze Shudderwock Shaman, compared to EnDjinn's Freeze Shudderwock Shaman (from yesterday's video)
5:10 The origins of the Boltzmann Freeze Shudderwock Shaman deck
6:30 Card justifications - Healing Rain vs Snowblind Harpy
7:10 Card justifications - Armor Vendor
8:02 Shudderwock / Freeze logic
8:33 Card justifications - Loatheb / Snowfall Guardian / Macaw
9:21 Card justifications - Windchill / Bolner / Sleetbreaker / Zentimo
10:00 Final thoughts on the deck
Games:
10:38 vs Odd Hunter
20:28 vs Pirate Warrior
Closing thoughts:
24:39 Final impressions on the deck
26:20 - 28:32 For Doomhammer Discord Server
Deck code: AAEBAaoICvoOl8cCi84Cw+oC7/cCy4UDtZgDqO4DhvoDi58ECt/EApvLAvPnAovVA5LkA+PuA9OABLmRBJWSBNySBAA=
For Doomhammer Discord Server:
https://discord.gg/nU2bkEV
https://youtu.be/ba7PAPi-uy0
Every meta. Why?
In fairness, that's a reasonable way to assess fun for a lot of individuals. Frankly, I think it's a pretty concise description of the Johnny/Jenny player archetype (and dips a bit into the Timmy/Tammy archetype as well). It's also understandably frustrating to feel like a lone Johnny/Jenny in a sea of Spikes.
Every meta. Why?
I'm saying that if new archetypes are introduced they shouldn't just be abandoned with a shrug.
Sadly this concept is a little too advanced for you guys. Have fun playing your brainless robot decks I guess
New Meta Overview Bandlewood Part 2
Event Horizon?
Alterac Valley Achievements
with this deck you will do it the rogue one in 2 games also counts for the Spammy Arcanist one
AAEBAd75AwLZ4wKljQQOzQO9BPW7At/jAvDmAsfOA+LdA+fdA6vrA/7uA6H0A5GfBPefBPylBAA=
Alterac Valley Achievements
The Chillwind Yeti bug makes it pretty clear that little to no manual testing goes into these achievements. I can imagine some poorly written unit tests that might exist and make it look like the code works as intended, but clearly no one ever bothered to try and do this achievement in Standard because you literally can't get the right version of Yeti in Standard.
Regarding Bless, I've got a new wrinkle to add here. After reading all of this I thought I might test a hypothesis, so I played my first Bless Priest game (which happened to be in Wild). I thought maybe there was some bug resulting in bad integer division (e.g. if it were dividing by 5, let's say, then any buff lower than 5 Attack would count as 0, anything between 5 and 9 would count as 1, etc.). That sort of thing might account for why a huge buff was only counted as 6 points.
However, my achievement worked exactly as it should have with the following plays: Kabal Talonpriest buff applied to a Northshire Cleric (both played in the same turn), then 2x Divine Spirit into Bless on the subsequent turn for a 26/26 Cleric. My achievement is now at 25/200.
EDIT: My second attempt with the same deck resulted in a gain of 0 despite buffing a Kabal Talonpriest to 11/11. I don't recall exactly what buffs I put on him when, but he got at least one Talonpriest buff and the Bless buff (and maybe a Focused Will buff?), and was not at full health when I cast Bless on him. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
EDIT: Third attempt, buffed Reliquary of Souls (at full HP) with Divine Spirit and Bless, made no progress...
Every meta. Why?
I don't understand how you can be this delusional.
"I should be able to win with any deck I choose. If a deck that I didn't choose wins that must mean the meta is wrong."
Are you actually a real person or are you just an algorithm trying to come up with the most outlandish takes on every matter?
BUt hey, let#s just take your advice and buff the cards people want to play, surely nothing can go wrong there, right?
Right?
RIGHT?