Does anyone know what these "Achievement Points" are good for? At first I thought I was getting XP for these, but then I noticed it was a separate thing.
WOW, congratulations for the idea to give this guy a card hahahah. Loved the idea of the corruption mad him a murloc, but because of the double detup, he need a tribe tag and I believed that there's no one who feets well =(.
Good idea and a interesting concept to a booster minion in Paladin. I don't know if it's possible (at least I dont remember a card with some similar text) but I believed it will be extra intresting if he maintain the Elemental tag.
Amazing, powerful and neat card. If really exists in the game, definitely see play. Sadly, for the few cards I have made, it seems that people don't usually like existing cards in a body in the competitions =(. For me, as a Magic player who see this occasionally, it's a 5-star.
I liked the first option, but is banana strong. Star Student Stelina is a legendary with a similar effect, but has Outcast and "Discover-ish" as limitations and don't discard, and this version is much more strong. Maybe change to the "old Corrupt", like Chaos Gazer, but with some changes, like Corrupt 2 cards or something like that.
Combo card! I imagine this'll be hated by a bunch of people in no time once someone figures out how to break it. Priest has plenty of spells, so this will definitely see play.
New Mage Minion - Firework Elemental
Decent stats and it has Elemental synergy, so it seems like a solid pick
New Shaman Minion - Magicfin
Murloc Shaman making a comeback after so long?
New Rogue Spell - Cloak of Shadows
Nice little cheat death, and it has great flavour too
New Demon Hunter Minion - Il'gynoth
Aldrachi Warblades' new best friend
New Neutral Minion - Costumed Entertainer
Maybe it'll see play in arena, but that's about it I think
New Warlock Minion - Midway Maniac
Should see play due to how easy it is for Warlocks to buff demons
New Priest Minion - Fairground Fool
Insane stats if you manage to corrupt it, which should be pretty easy to do
New Demon Hunter Minion - Insatiable Felhound
Great stats, even greater artwork!
New Demon Hunter Spell - Acrobatics
Demon Hunter is the king of draw, it seems
New Demon Hunter Minion - Stiltstepper
Seems rather vulnerable at 1 health, but maybe the 4 attack given to the hero will make up for that
New Demon Hunter Weapon - Dreadlord's Bite
Pretty good stats, but the best part is the artwork
New Hunter Spell - Jewel of N'Zoth
Glad they're pushing Hunter decks that aren't just face face face
New Shaman Spell - Deathmatch Pavilion
It's not bad, but it feels more like a Warrior card than a Shaman one
New Shaman Minion - Cagematch Custodian
Decent stats and gets the job done
New Paladin Minion - Carousel Gryphon
Decent enough even if you don't get to corrupt it
Early Darkmoon achievements for XP
Does anyone know what these "Achievement Points" are good for? At first I thought I was getting XP for these, but then I noticed it was a separate thing.
New Warlock Spell - Free Admission
Seems like a great addition to a Demon zoo type deck. Free imps!
New Priest Minion - Nazmani Bloodweaver
More things to combo with Galakrond, pretty scary
New Priest Minion - Nazmani Bloodweaver
Very minor effect, won't see play
New Warlock Spell - Free Admission
Decent card for cheating out ring matron. Big deck making restrictions though. Will see experimentation, but not good enough
Old Gods, New Tricks - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I made a feedback post, but acidentally deleted it =(.
Maybe later I try it again u.u.
Old Gods, New Tricks - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Some feedback in poor english u.u
Edit: Add some new feedbacks
MenacingBagel
WOW, congratulations for the idea to give this guy a card hahahah. Loved the idea of the corruption mad him a murloc, but because of the double detup, he need a tribe tag and I believed that there's no one who feets well =(.
Wailor
Good idea and a interesting concept to a booster minion in Paladin. I don't know if it's possible (at least I dont remember a card with some similar text) but I believed it will be extra intresting if he maintain the Elemental tag.
Demonxz95
Liked the idea and think is pretty solid, but it's simple so I don't know if the voters will be excited to the card.
linkblade91
Amazing, powerful and neat card. If really exists in the game, definitely see play. Sadly, for the few cards I have made, it seems that people don't usually like existing cards in a body in the competitions =(.
For me, as a Magic player who see this occasionally, it's a 5-star.
TheHoax91
Very flavorful and powerful, but like Demonxz95 said, need corrupt =/.
fungusABao
I liked, but for 9 mana can be very hard to Corrupt. Maybe try it at 7-mana and I think will be fine.
BloodMefist
I liked the first option, but is banana strong. Star Student Stelina is a legendary with a similar effect, but has Outcast and "Discover-ish" as limitations and don't discard, and this version is much more strong. Maybe change to the "old Corrupt", like Chaos Gazer, but with some changes, like Corrupt 2 cards or something like that.
Arkasaur
Loved. I think it's pretty good, strong and balanced. Excelent job.
Neoguli
Great idea in the use of corrupt. Maybe change the restriction to Spells, for Mage-flavor.
New Paladin Minion - Carousel Gryphon
Very solid card, but it lacks taunt or anything proactive. Still very decent minion and might still see some play
New Warlock Spell - Free Admission
I've gone on about it on like every Warlock card, but Demon Zoo is real and I'm interested in it. This seems really easy to essentially gain you mana.
New Priest Minion - Nazmani Bloodweaver
Combo card! I imagine this'll be hated by a bunch of people in no time once someone figures out how to break it. Priest has plenty of spells, so this will definitely see play.