Unfortunately no, we do not allow people to edit or remove their cards after submitting :( We always suggest people come here first if they want feedback on their ideas.
I can understand not making the card editable, but what about the description below it? Say you make a typo in it? Also totally missed this thread before I submitted my entry. Used to posting in a forum submission thread and all that. Guess the HearthPwn version of the competition I always played in needs to phase out of my head.
What I made (might help someone avoid making a copy):
I know that with some digging around, it can all be found. Just a little surprised that there isn't a single page somewhere that explains it clearly and shows them all. The watermarks are actually quite difficult to see. I know I can see the different icons if I open the collection manager, use the bottom left filter - but I have to scroll up and down. It isn't very clear to beginners, for example.
When I was talking about "Answers" I was referring more to those cards that can help you respond to enemy threats OR make him think twice before he even commit his actions, as an example, Deny vs those big slow game changing spells OR ruination vs a units centered deck.
Not all regions have these kinds of "Answers" and even if they have something, it require certain conditions that can be played around in many ways.
I'm just hoping for more diverse options and multiple answers, as long as they are equally represented between all regions and not get focused on a select few which limits deck-building.
Thank you all for giving feedback! I decided to stick to the Freezing Mage Secret but added the 1 damage AOE as Wailor suggested. I figured it woud become half a blizzard that way, which makes for nice flavor. Linkblade's critic was very helpful, too - I tried to explain worries along your line of thoughts away in the card description. Finally, thanks to Almaniarra for helping me out with the name!
Here's more feedback:
@Lemushki
Show Spoiler
The idea, the art and the name are cool, but in all else I have to agree with linkblade. Sorry :/
@Elfensilver
Show Spoiler
I would go with the Hunter Secret but the reduce the number of dormant turns as Demon suggested. I feel you, finding art is my biggest obstacle, too. Often enough I pick the art first and then design all the rest around it because it is so frustrating if you have a cool idea but can't find art that fits it. Most of the time, I find my stuff here: www.artstation.com Search for Hearthstone but be very careful to check if the art is already in the game. Usually you have to scroll down a bit until you find fan art. Please let me know if you find another page like this!
@thepowrofcheese
Show Spoiler
The power level of both iterations of Tricks of Trade is quite high because of the Discover effect. I would suggest to tune it down by casting a random secret from another class. City Watch would be a powerful addition to Mech Paladin, I like that one too.
@MenacingBagel
Show Spoiler
I would suggest to check the wording with already existing cards, I'm pretty sure it should say "At the start of your turn". The rest of it is fine, it would be interesting to try this out. Nice synergies with lackeys, Pogo Hoppers and Battlecry minions in general.
@Wailor
Show Spoiler
Haha, I like the flavour of the rabid dog. I used the art and the same concept in the CDC 1.08, "The price of power". It was called Rabid Track Hound and had Battlecry: Draw 2 cards and Deathrattle: Deal 5 damage to your hero. I didn't make it to the finals with it, but maybe your idea will be better received. From your other cards, I liked the explanation and the flavor of Squid Tactics a lot, but I'm not sure if the card isn't too strong.
@Wendeee
Show Spoiler
I like both of them. As was already pointed out, Another Card to Play might be too situational, so Self Harm would be my choice. Maybe you could find a better name for it… what about Masochism? :D For the art problem, look at my feedback for Elfensilver.
Naw, you guys are making total sense. I'll try to keep it tasteful, but hey, I'm as opinionated as the next player and do enjoy a good drink with my forum thumping. I'll keep it to a minimum is what I'm trying to say, haha
So far really enjoying the tone here. Hearthpwn is just obequitous 'jump-down-the-throat on what op posted'. Pick any random thread and the first reply is always one sentence knocking someone down no matter how relevant or not what they had to say was. Yay for being over it
You are posting deliberately antagonistically rude titles and whining when you get a swift, strong response?
That makes you come across as an ignorant idiot. I won't be reading your posts.
I would find it really useful to have a way of identifying the expansion of a card on the hover. Currently the only place I can see for sure is of I'm on a deck page. I can inspect the anchor to see what the CSS class is. I know that OoC has the icons, and the cards have a different design(?). What I'd like is a page with a helpful overview of the OoO icons (and card designs) that I can reference?
After facing the "same" meta decks a number of games in a row (as inferred from their meta opening strategy), the opponent overflows with salt and plays Demon Hunter in the Kael'thas Tavern Brawl until they're so dirty the Roomba tries to scoop them up.
Very similar for me, 1 legendary some epic, little bit of golden. Meh, feels annoying. The only fun thing was I opened 2 albatross which are worth 100dust each.
Has riot confirmed this is a stand alone card and not just a token form Grizzled Ranger?
I was under the impression that it was just a token but then I noticed the rarity gem. I checked Escaped Abomination (and Valor) to confirm that tokens don't have a gem, so it looks like it's collectible.
I'm interested to see if the premium stats will make up for the lack of effects. My guess would be no but then again when played on-curve, it's almost certainly going to trade for two cards (unit+unit or unit+spell).
This card looks bad but its beefy enough to survive around 4 rounds. The big problem is exactly that it takes 4 rounds to see any value. At best, if curved on T4, it will generate ok-ish value by T8, and it gets worse the longer its delayed. I believe is way too slow for the current meta.
Descent of Dragons
I suppose the demon hunter tab is a bug.
Kayn Sunfury
Never thought this would be printed.
Top Secret - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I can understand not making the card editable, but what about the description below it? Say you make a typo in it?
Also totally missed this thread before I submitted my entry. Used to posting in a forum submission thread and all that. Guess the HearthPwn version of the competition I always played in needs to phase out of my head.
What I made (might help someone avoid making a copy):
Yogg-Saron, Hope's End
He's back!
Heroic Naxxramas
This was cool to get.
Eyes of C'Thun
Amazing animation.
Random
I whish this was an actual card back too.
Classic
The rarest card back, honestly.
Legend
Some say it's ugly, but I enjoy its simple look.
So Done With Hearthpwn.. Think I'm going here now.
Technically scorpions are arachnids, not insects.
New Lackey Zoo [4/20 Nerfs]
Keen to play around with this! Thanks for posting.
I don't have tekahn.. What would you replace with? I have that grand lackey guy
Is there an easy way to identify which expansion a card is from?
I did mean generally for HS. But, OoC specific, the deck page has the symbol (not the name) and the card page has the name (not the symbol).
Regions current situation
Here are a few examples of what I'm looking forward to:
Is there an easy way to identify which expansion a card is from?
I know that with some digging around, it can all be found. Just a little surprised that there isn't a single page somewhere that explains it clearly and shows them all. The watermarks are actually quite difficult to see. I know I can see the different icons if I open the collection manager, use the bottom left filter - but I have to scroll up and down. It isn't very clear to beginners, for example.
Regions current situation
When I was talking about "Answers" I was referring more to those cards that can help you respond to enemy threats OR make him think twice before he even commit his actions, as an example, Deny vs those big slow game changing spells OR ruination vs a units centered deck.
Not all regions have these kinds of "Answers" and even if they have something, it require certain conditions that can be played around in many ways.
I'm just hoping for more diverse options and multiple answers, as long as they are equally represented between all regions and not get focused on a select few which limits deck-building.
Top Secret - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thank you all for giving feedback! I decided to stick to the Freezing Mage Secret but added the 1 damage AOE as Wailor suggested. I figured it woud become half a blizzard that way, which makes for nice flavor. Linkblade's critic was very helpful, too - I tried to explain worries along your line of thoughts away in the card description. Finally, thanks to Almaniarra for helping me out with the name!
Here's more feedback:
@Lemushki
@Elfensilver
@thepowrofcheese
@MenacingBagel
@Wailor
@Wendeee
Is there an easy way to identify which expansion a card is from?
I’m not really sure what you’re asking here, so I’ll answer everything you could be asking- some of this will be obvious to you:
1. The watermark icon in the center of the card’s text area shows what expansion it’s from. Spiral for classic, gear for GvG and so on.
2. The full list of those expansions can be found in the Hearthstone in-game collection manager (or in a pull-down tab at hearthcards.net)
3. I believe the symbols used in the OoC deckbuilder match the watermarks (might be wrong on this).
So Done With Hearthpwn.. Think I'm going here now.
You are posting deliberately antagonistically rude titles and whining when you get a swift, strong response?
That makes you come across as an ignorant idiot. I won't be reading your posts.
Is there an easy way to identify which expansion a card is from?
I would find it really useful to have a way of identifying the expansion of a card on the hover. Currently the only place I can see for sure is of I'm on a deck page. I can inspect the anchor to see what the CSS class is. I know that OoC has the icons, and the cards have a different design(?). What I'd like is a page with a helpful overview of the OoO icons (and card designs) that I can reference?
Why do people play Tier 1 decks in casual mode?
ROFL!
Year of the Dragon Celebration Bundle - 45 Card Packs for $30, Includes the Special Year of the Dragon Packs
Very similar for me, 1 legendary some epic, little bit of golden. Meh, feels annoying. The only fun thing was I opened 2 albatross which are worth 100dust each.
Any way to clear my Hearthstone collection?
Thanks much!
Swaguar's Post-Nerf, Turn 8 Mecha'thun Warlock
Definitely have to give this a shot
New Demacia Card - Loyal Badgerbear
I was under the impression that it was just a token but then I noticed the rarity gem. I checked Escaped Abomination (and Valor) to confirm that tokens don't have a gem, so it looks like it's collectible.
I'm interested to see if the premium stats will make up for the lack of effects. My guess would be no but then again when played on-curve, it's almost certainly going to trade for two cards (unit+unit or unit+spell).
New Noxus Card - Citybreaker
This card looks bad but its beefy enough to survive around 4 rounds.
The big problem is exactly that it takes 4 rounds to see any value. At best, if curved on T4, it will generate ok-ish value by T8, and it gets worse the longer its delayed. I believe is way too slow for the current meta.