Unrepentant Myrmidon is a suprise kill that can be a bit unfun to go against, so I'm not too fond on it.
Although the same could be said about Seraphina, I find her much more interesting. Being a one-off, not depending on being on hand, needing spells to deal the final blow… All these things make the card work much better, IMO.
wooder27
Hey, welcome to the design corner!
I like that you decided to showcase an important character for the WoW lore, but her effect doesn't feel appropriate for Warrior. I'd probably redesign the card as a Shaman legendary (she's a Shaman, after all) with the text "Your weapon has Windfury and Poisonous". Another option would be to make it a Rogue card (which fits the effect a bit better), but you'd probably need to change the character in that case.
AeroJulwin
Twilight Enchantress is my favorite of your cards, as her power level is more appropriate than Leech Glyph.
Ice Sculpting isn't bad, but it doesn't look like a Warrior card.
Demonxz95
Pretty solid card, but not overly exciting. Not much to add, as it seems quite balanced.
Wow, Big Demon Hunter is pretty good! And fun, too! One high point I encountered was against a mage who discovered Objection! early on, and also had a second one in his ETC band. This card would normally be fatal against a big minion deck, but DH runs enough smaller guys (Crushclaw, for example) that I was able to thwart those secrets before playing my important dudes. Solid victory!
So in card games there is what is commonly referred to as a deck shell.
Essentially the central theme of your deck that let's you win games.
It consists of things like synergy, a curve, draw for deck thinning, wincons, creatures, and legendaries.
Then you have your tech, your answers to the current meta game, they can be landmarks (artifacts), or spells, or creatures with aura effects or on play abilities.
The mistake I commonly see in eternal is that people either build a deck with 100% tech or 100% shell they can't mix the two.
Lurk is lurk and does lurk things
This is a ping deck it pings and does ping things.
In reality you have one handful of tech, and one handful of shell and not a lot of laddering flexibility.
When I build my decks I try to be as flexible as possible.
Yes this is a ramp deck but it has 3 avalanches, 3 blighted, 3 harsh winds, and 3 tavern keepers.
Thats the tech ^ but that doesn't stop me from turbo leveling asol on mana 7
So if you want to build a p and z ping spam deck, then your "shell" is Annie Ezreal sometimes splashes Katarina.
Includes 3 conservatory, and 3 broadmanes for wincons.
Even if you're trying to build something original you need to follow the "shell" and tech formula.
Too much shell in eternal and your deck is inflexibile, too much tech and now you insta lose certain ladder matchups.
The key to being good at winning in a large cardpool is not mastering matchups or win tables its being able to go into 90% of games with confidence that you will win regardless of the 500 cards your opponent might use.
Interesting choices overall, I have to say I'm a bit surprised Hawkstrider Rancher dodged a nerf though. That card is just completely bonkers and wins games for Undead DK almost on its own (curves very nicely into Nerubian Swarmguard). Undead Priest getting hit is a bit sad, but I guess that can't be helped.
If I had to guess, I think management simply decided that the costs are too high and overwatch 2 isn't giving them the returns they want. So they had to axe something, and the PvE aspect is deemed the less risky choice, on top of saving loads of man hours.
A shame really, because what we left with now can be said to be definitely overwatch 1.5 instead of 2.
Finally they're going to unnerf the old From the Depths, a long overdue buff. Unfortunately, we had to go all around the world buffing tons of other warrior cards before team5 finally realised that this was the one thing they needed to do all along. Still probably going to change the mana reduction to 2 instead of 3.
Other buffs not so interesting. Chorus Riff doesn't need a buff, but the riffs are overall so weak its perhaps unsurprising that they decided to do it.
As for the nerfs,
Pretty much I can see why all of those are getting nerfs. Stuff like Sinful Brand simply shouldn't exist alongside so much face damage potential. Besides, its toxic as hell trying to avoid getting destroyed out of nowhere. Shades of quest mage in stormwind.
Its funny how Predation is being targetted here, when its far better to simply just nerf Lady S'theno to give everyone back their dust because predation at 0 mana is probably one of the few things that keeping her alive anyway.
Anub'Rekhan nerf is a bit harsh, because outside of big druid the entire class is 100% dependent on it. Not sure what team5 is going to do with this. Maybe nerf it to 9 mana? or grant only 4 armor. Because we all know why this is getting nerfed, and that's because of its unfortunate combo with zok.
The one time big dhunter is competitively viable, and then we nerf it naught but three weeks after. Just amazing.
Shameful that they made $1bn in loot box sales and couldn't give the team the resources to maintain OW1 live service while creating whatever they wanted OW2 to be. Look at the content Epiq manufactured for Fortnite during the same time period.
Overwatch 2 and the pve mode started out extremely ambitious ("we want to redefine what a sequel is"), maybe even too ambitious as it turns out.
This highlights a harsh reality in game development: You can't plan fun. They clearly tried out a lot to make it happen, as seen during the Blizzconline 2021, but if you try to make something happen for 4 years, and you still have no clue how to do it, then maybe it's best to let it go. Especially when you wanted to maintain a live service game in addition to the pve development that has no end in sight.
This is actually kinda similar to the development of Hearthstone's Mercenaries if you think about it. This mode was also in development hell for a long time, got delayed almost an entire year (first teased on the darkmoon roadmap), while never being able to deliver a experience that was entertaining for the majority of the playerbase. The difference is that instead of deciding to scrap it, they instead tried to tie all the loose ends they had together and atleast decided to release something, even it was dissapointing for a big part of the playerbase.
In the end I'm still somewhat optimistic about Overwatch's pve missions. Sounds like with Season 6 they finally begin to tell the Story they wanted to tell through regular, although smaller, pve mission releases. I remember how cool it was to play the retribution event for the first time, and to think about getting something like it every 9 weeks makes me excited enough.
I guess this whole thing is the peak of the development shift that happened early last year. No more are they holding everything they have back for years and years and years, to then finally release everything they have at all once in a huge bombastic release. Instead they release as it gets finished to ensure a constant stream of fresh content. The defintion of a live service game.
At least I got a couple weeks in of the Wave + She-Hulk combo before I lost it. Bought them both with tokens, too :( All well; back to an older deck, I guess.
While I'm in the middle of internally debating if I should get an Imgur account (and then if I do, actually doing it), here's a card.
Spell Damage Hunter works perfectly for this since it's an established archetype and it still has few enough cards to fit within the requirements.
"spell with Spell Damage" is supposed to be a shorthand for "spell that has benefitted from Spell Damage" since there's not enough text space to write all of that down. I hope that's clear enough.
I've been waiting for an excuse to use spell handbuffing in a comp again ever since it finally became legal in MotLK. Leech Glyph provides Mage with a bit of healing, which might not fit its identity, but that's why the healing is not very high, even compared to Neutral cards. However, the Lifesteal should become more valuable in a deck with spell damage cards. And since it specifies damaging spells, the card pool will most likely be favorable.
Edit:
Leech Glyph was obviously a bit expensive, but I didn't want to make it a 1-Cost to avoid it being a direct powercreep on Magic Trick. For some reason I didn't think of it yesterday, but of course I should've just made it a battlecry. So here's the new and improved version:
My second idea is Ice Sculpting. Warrior has Frost spells now, but so far the only one that actually Freezes is Snowed In. Ice Sculpting is a defensive tool that can be used to freeze a large minion and summon a copy for yourself for later or it can be played together with a buffed up Taunt minion to put a big wall on your board.
I built the most aggressive deck in LOR history and you want to lurk into me?
Get wrecked play something you built yourself
Why do you think I run six pings?
It's called interaction even in aggro my decks can do something about 5 iq plays
And you know what funny this **** isn't even optimized yet, once historic ladder comes out and pro players steal my deck without crediting me they will swap like 2 ratios and be like S tier thanks for all the credit.
Definitely agree with Big DH. Been playing that deck for a while now coz it's skill cap isn't as high as spell or outcast DH. I don't even have Brutal Annihilan and still win games. Pulling out a Xhilag of the Abyss on turn 5 with the coin is an instant win.
Kind of a separate question, but does anyone else do this? Once I hit 1000 wins, I hardly play that class anymore since I want to get them all to 1000 eventually. Feels a bit silly, since I now have a super sweet portrait to use.
I did this as well in the past, but not anymore. All my classes are above 1600 wins except for Death Knight which is only at 600 wins currently. The gap is really too big and to main a single class in a somewhat stable meta is just too boring for me personally. The 1000 wins DK hero portrait is also not that amazing. The one for Demon Hunter is though.
Cranky Hibernator would be the first card to use Freeze in Druid and is probably my favorite. It's a defensive card that can be used against both wide and tall boards, depending on the option you choose.
Frenzied Doomguard is a reimagination of the classic Doomguard, using Windfury in Warlock for the first time. He is better suited for removal, but can also be dropped on an empty board without discarding anything immediately, as he can rack a lot of damage if not removed.
Finally, Soulstealing Familiar has Rush, only used once in Priest. It's basically a Holy Water on a stick, but I think it works better than that card, which was pretty weak.
I play dhunter myself, but dont have felerin. Never came to my mind that I needed that card, but its tricky this one. It has a good play winrate, but I just dont like crafting legendaries that get weaker over time.
Stheno is one of those cards that pros will always be abusing, hence why it remains relevant despite its win rate tanking. Up to you on this one. Its probably one of the hardest to use legendaries Ive seen around, but it'll likely be playable until rotation next year.
But if you'd like to play dhunter, but dont want to spend any dust on legendaries, just play big dhunter. Probably the one and only time this archetype will ever see competitive without a major push from team5.
Charge is only used once in the Paladin, and Spell Damage is not on any Warlock cards:
The Myrmidon has seemingly lost his faith, and gains strength when others waver (i.e: their Divine Shields breaking). A solid handbuff target that can grow on its own (DS minions being good handbuff targets as well).
The Siren lures minions to their doom and gains magical power from their death. Don't know what you'd use her with right now; probably some OTK strategy with cards from her expansion.
Hearthstone's Twitter Teases Upcoming Balance Patch
Kinda curious as to what Rotten Applebaum is going to do for the meta, but willing to give it a fair chance
Prismatic Parlance - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Feedback:
Although the same could be said about Seraphina, I find her much more interesting. Being a one-off, not depending on being on hand, needing spells to deal the final blow… All these things make the card work much better, IMO.
I like that you decided to showcase an important character for the WoW lore, but her effect doesn't feel appropriate for Warrior. I'd probably redesign the card as a Shaman legendary (she's a Shaman, after all) with the text "Your weapon has Windfury and Poisonous". Another option would be to make it a Rogue card (which fits the effect a bit better), but you'd probably need to change the character in that case.
Ice Sculpting isn't bad, but it doesn't look like a Warrior card.
10 Top Standard Hearthstone Decks for Mid-May - Standard Meta Snapshot
Wow, Big Demon Hunter is pretty good! And fun, too! One high point I encountered was against a mage who discovered Objection! early on, and also had a second one in his ETC band. This card would normally be fatal against a big minion deck, but DH runs enough smaller guys (Crushclaw, for example) that I was able to thwart those secrets before playing my important dudes. Solid victory!
Shells Vs Tech
So in card games there is what is commonly referred to as a deck shell.
Essentially the central theme of your deck that let's you win games.
It consists of things like synergy, a curve, draw for deck thinning, wincons, creatures, and legendaries.
Then you have your tech, your answers to the current meta game, they can be landmarks (artifacts), or spells, or creatures with aura effects or on play abilities.
The mistake I commonly see in eternal is that people either build a deck with 100% tech or 100% shell they can't mix the two.
Lurk is lurk and does lurk things
This is a ping deck it pings and does ping things.
In reality you have one handful of tech, and one handful of shell and not a lot of laddering flexibility.
When I build my decks I try to be as flexible as possible.
Yes this is a ramp deck but it has 3 avalanches, 3 blighted, 3 harsh winds, and 3 tavern keepers.
Thats the tech ^ but that doesn't stop me from turbo leveling asol on mana 7
So if you want to build a p and z ping spam deck, then your "shell" is Annie Ezreal sometimes splashes Katarina.
Includes 3 conservatory, and 3 broadmanes for wincons.
Even if you're trying to build something original you need to follow the "shell" and tech formula.
Too much shell in eternal and your deck is inflexibile, too much tech and now you insta lose certain ladder matchups.
The key to being good at winning in a large cardpool is not mastering matchups or win tables its being able to go into 90% of games with confidence that you will win regardless of the 500 cards your opponent might use.
Flexibility + Adaptability
Thats what makes me king 👑
Hearthstone's Twitter Teases Upcoming Balance Patch
Interesting choices overall, I have to say I'm a bit surprised Hawkstrider Rancher dodged a nerf though. That card is just completely bonkers and wins games for Undead DK almost on its own (curves very nicely into Nerubian Swarmguard). Undead Priest getting hit is a bit sad, but I guess that can't be helped.
How To Build Consistent Meta Counters
Nope I told you, you can't just run p and z garbage with ping spam.
I swap once and youre done.
You have to build an actual deck
You know with cards and a strategy that is flexible into other matchups
Wincons etc
Blizzard Cancels Overwatch 2's PvE Mode - Roadmap 2023 Revealed
If I had to guess, I think management simply decided that the costs are too high and overwatch 2 isn't giving them the returns they want. So they had to axe something, and the PvE aspect is deemed the less risky choice, on top of saving loads of man hours.
A shame really, because what we left with now can be said to be definitely overwatch 1.5 instead of 2.
Hearthstone's Twitter Teases Upcoming Balance Patch
Finally they're going to unnerf the old From the Depths, a long overdue buff. Unfortunately, we had to go all around the world buffing tons of other warrior cards before team5 finally realised that this was the one thing they needed to do all along. Still probably going to change the mana reduction to 2 instead of 3.
Other buffs not so interesting. Chorus Riff doesn't need a buff, but the riffs are overall so weak its perhaps unsurprising that they decided to do it.
As for the nerfs,
Pretty much I can see why all of those are getting nerfs. Stuff like Sinful Brand simply shouldn't exist alongside so much face damage potential. Besides, its toxic as hell trying to avoid getting destroyed out of nowhere. Shades of quest mage in stormwind.
Its funny how Predation is being targetted here, when its far better to simply just nerf Lady S'theno to give everyone back their dust because predation at 0 mana is probably one of the few things that keeping her alive anyway.
Anub'Rekhan nerf is a bit harsh, because outside of big druid the entire class is 100% dependent on it. Not sure what team5 is going to do with this. Maybe nerf it to 9 mana? or grant only 4 armor. Because we all know why this is getting nerfed, and that's because of its unfortunate combo with zok.
The one time big dhunter is competitively viable, and then we nerf it naught but three weeks after. Just amazing.
Blizzard Cancels Overwatch 2's PvE Mode - Roadmap 2023 Revealed
Shameful that they made $1bn in loot box sales and couldn't give the team the resources to maintain OW1 live service while creating whatever they wanted OW2 to be. Look at the content Epiq manufactured for Fortnite during the same time period.
Blizzard Cancels Overwatch 2's PvE Mode - Roadmap 2023 Revealed
Overwatch 2 and the pve mode started out extremely ambitious ("we want to redefine what a sequel is"), maybe even too ambitious as it turns out.
This highlights a harsh reality in game development: You can't plan fun. They clearly tried out a lot to make it happen, as seen during the Blizzconline 2021, but if you try to make something happen for 4 years, and you still have no clue how to do it, then maybe it's best to let it go. Especially when you wanted to maintain a live service game in addition to the pve development that has no end in sight.
This is actually kinda similar to the development of Hearthstone's Mercenaries if you think about it. This mode was also in development hell for a long time, got delayed almost an entire year (first teased on the darkmoon roadmap), while never being able to deliver a experience that was entertaining for the majority of the playerbase. The difference is that instead of deciding to scrap it, they instead tried to tie all the loose ends they had together and atleast decided to release something, even it was dissapointing for a big part of the playerbase.
In the end I'm still somewhat optimistic about Overwatch's pve missions. Sounds like with Season 6 they finally begin to tell the Story they wanted to tell through regular, although smaller, pve mission releases. I remember how cool it was to play the retribution event for the first time, and to think about getting something like it every 9 weeks makes me excited enough.
I guess this whole thing is the peak of the development shift that happened early last year. No more are they holding everything they have back for years and years and years, to then finally release everything they have at all once in a huge bombastic release. Instead they release as it gets finished to ensure a constant stream of fresh content. The defintion of a live service game.
MARVEL SNAP's Latest Patch Brings Balance Changes, Card Acquisition Update, Ranked Changes, & More!
to reduce players frustration they should remove avatars/titles from collector boxes ... they are really annoying ...
MARVEL SNAP's Latest Patch Brings Balance Changes, Card Acquisition Update, Ranked Changes, & More!
At least I got a couple weeks in of the Wave + She-Hulk combo before I lost it. Bought them both with tokens, too :( All well; back to an older deck, I guess.
Prismatic Parlance - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
While I'm in the middle of internally debating if I should get an Imgur account (and then if I do, actually doing it), here's a card.
Spell Damage Hunter works perfectly for this since it's an established archetype and it still has few enough cards to fit within the requirements.
"spell with Spell Damage" is supposed to be a shorthand for "spell that has benefitted from Spell Damage" since there's not enough text space to write all of that down. I hope that's clear enough.
5 Legendary MARVEL SNAP Decks with Star-Lord - Dino Guardians, Nebula Control, & More!
Don't own Spider-Man but I'll make do with Doctor Octopus or Hobgoblin, I guess.
How To Build Consistent Meta Counters
You still don't get it do you?
You cant just stun and attack with Zed, you have no burn therefore you have no wincon
Any half smart player will just face tank and roll you.
Plz if you don't know how to play or build I will teach you
Prismatic Parlance - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I've been waiting for an excuse to use spell handbuffing in a comp again ever since it finally became legal in MotLK. Leech Glyph provides Mage with a bit of healing, which might not fit its identity, but that's why the healing is not very high, even compared to Neutral cards. However, the Lifesteal should become more valuable in a deck with spell damage cards. And since it specifies damaging spells, the card pool will most likely be favorable.
Edit:
Leech Glyph was obviously a bit expensive, but I didn't want to make it a 1-Cost to avoid it being a direct powercreep on Magic Trick. For some reason I didn't think of it yesterday, but of course I should've just made it a battlecry. So here's the new and improved version:
My second idea is Ice Sculpting. Warrior has Frost spells now, but so far the only one that actually Freezes is Snowed In. Ice Sculpting is a defensive tool that can be used to freeze a large minion and summon a copy for yourself for later or it can be played together with a buffed up Taunt minion to put a big wall on your board.
How To Build Consistent Meta Counters
I built the most aggressive deck in LOR history and you want to lurk into me?
Get wrecked play something you built yourself
Why do you think I run six pings?
It's called interaction even in aggro my decks can do something about 5 iq plays
And you know what funny this **** isn't even optimized yet, once historic ladder comes out and pro players steal my deck without crediting me they will swap like 2 ratios and be like S tier thanks for all the credit.
But no this time historic aggro is pretty Nifty
Prismatic Parlance - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Gorehowl already can kill Cairne.
Gorehowl starts with 7 Attack and Cairne has 5 Health.
10 Top Standard Hearthstone Decks for Mid-May - Standard Meta Snapshot
Definitely agree with Big DH. Been playing that deck for a while now coz it's skill cap isn't as high as spell or outcast DH. I don't even have Brutal Annihilan and still win games. Pulling out a Xhilag of the Abyss on turn 5 with the coin is an instant win.
10 Top Standard Hearthstone Decks for Mid-May - Standard Meta Snapshot
I did this as well in the past, but not anymore. All my classes are above 1600 wins except for Death Knight which is only at 600 wins currently. The gap is really too big and to main a single class in a somewhat stable meta is just too boring for me personally. The 1000 wins DK hero portrait is also not that amazing. The one for Demon Hunter is though.
Good luck! 👍🏻
Prismatic Parlance - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Now Gorehowl can kill Cairne.
Prismatic Parlance - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
10 Top Standard Hearthstone Decks for Mid-May - Standard Meta Snapshot
I play dhunter myself, but dont have felerin. Never came to my mind that I needed that card, but its tricky this one. It has a good play winrate, but I just dont like crafting legendaries that get weaker over time.
Stheno is one of those cards that pros will always be abusing, hence why it remains relevant despite its win rate tanking. Up to you on this one. Its probably one of the hardest to use legendaries Ive seen around, but it'll likely be playable until rotation next year.
But if you'd like to play dhunter, but dont want to spend any dust on legendaries, just play big dhunter. Probably the one and only time this archetype will ever see competitive without a major push from team5.
Prismatic Parlance - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Charge is only used once in the Paladin, and Spell Damage is not on any Warlock cards:
Not sure on the cost for either of them.
How To Build Consistent Meta Counters
Yeah you have no idea how to do it do you?
If you can't just jam board in your control deck you can't win?
But what happens when the aggro decks become so powerful they outstrip board presence?
It's called spells, one avalanche, one face smash, one anything that isn't just 1 drop ping ping ping.
You see it isnt that eternal isn't a competitive format, it's highly competitive.
It's just that your style of competitive play has no place in eternal.
Learn, grow, evolve.