All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Dawn Of The Dead - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Alright, alright. No Colossal minions. :(

    New design uses the idea of self-freezing as a way to preserve both minions and heroes in the ice, allowing them to be more resistant to enemy threats. Four mana 2/6 statline because I feel like people prefer slightly underpowered designs but I feel like it could be pushed to 2/7.

    Don't feel super at ease with this week's competition so I'll forgo feedback on other designs. I enjoy most of them, though. Interested to see if anyone gets anywhere close to the real designs we'll see soon enough!

  • Dawn Of The Dead - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    I have been busy today. I can finally give feedback.

    Linkblade91
    These cards are all quite solid. I don't think the effect of Lord Tamakeen being permanent is that bad since there's not (presumably) not too many ways to take advantage of it in a way that's too broken. Izelair is a pretty good replacement if you don't want to go with Tamakeen.

    Wailor
    I'm all for Instructor Razuvious (either version). They're both really cool cards, but unfortunately I don't think they'd be allowed for entry.

    Arkasaur

    Gothik the Harvester may be too powerful (or it may not since no one else seems to be batting an eye at it), but its place in DK's arsenal is quite solid and it fits the bill of being the "smaller, simpler Legendary" (in the same vein as Altruis for Demon Hunter) quite nicely.

    Lady Deathwhisper is a really cool effect that hybrids other classes, but in a way that feels very unique to Death Knight. My only complaint is that 8/4 for 6 is a really weird statline.

    AeroJulwin
    Yallesh is a cool self-Freeze card. No problems here.

    Moondreamer

    While I appreciate the creativity here, I think you should avoid using Colossal at all costs here. There is about a 0% chance that it will appear in Death Knight's actual initiate set, so it doesn't make much sense to use it here. The card is also incredibly weak since it's Frozen first and the Bone Spike is not particularly threatening.

    That said, self-Freeze of some type is a design space that you could build something cool with (like AeroJulwin has for Yallesh).

    BloodMefist

    Painsmith Raznal is a balanced effect and it's good with weapons. I'm not a WoW guy, so I don't know if self-damage is a think in Death Knight like it is in Warlock.

    Lard Marrowgar can be quite cool. I think deck destruction can be a cool part of Death Knight looking at the cards that they have in KotFT and it seems that Blizzard would've intended to make it a part of the class. I can't speak much for balance, but the direction here is solid.

    FooBars
    Lady Deathwhisper is a fine, albeit slightly "wordy" effect. I prefer the first version because of its Rush and therefore can be able to use the effect right away, whereas the second version is just a vanilla 7 mana 6/8 unless it survives a turn, which is not reliable.

  • Riot Reveals New Improvise Mechanic Coming to Legends of Runeterra in the "Awakening" Expansion

    Staff Pro

    ah, ok

  • Dawn Of The Dead - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Feedback

    linkblade91

    I like Sapphiron as a payoff card, however Lord Tamakeen is definitely my favourite of the 2. Being able to gain Armor instead of Health feels different and unique from the other classes.

    Your update of Izelair is definitely simpler but doesn't feel as elegant to me.

    Demonxz95

    Agree with others about Frostheart only doubling damage, and that version would be my favourite of yours.

    Alexandros is good, but might scale too quickly as your opponent can't remove stats effectively, giving it a soft taunt. Teribus probably comes down too late, when other classes cards are dealing similar damage earlier — I think the effect could also be a bit complex to understand without seeing it.

    Wailor

    As others have said, you can't submit the Runes with this card. That said I'd choose the second version to draw a weapon and then Discover. Feels neater and the effect is immediate allowing you to get some quick value based on the weapon.

    Arkasaur

    I like both of these — I'd probably make Lady Deathwhisper a 6/6, so that it has the potential to stick around a bit longer and get more use out of it's effect, since it's not inherently strong on it's own.

    AeroJulwin

    Stealth feels a bit strange to have here, I'd personally remove it, but the Deathrattle is great. Like the idea of freezing your own minions for a benefit.

    Moondreamer

    I wonder if Death Knight would be given a Colossal since that was an expansion specific keyword. It also seems like a 7 mana do nothing kind of card which I'm not too keen on.

    BloodMefist

    Painsmith seems great, perhaps it could be buffed to a 3/5?

    Removing cards from your own deck feels like a major downside, so unless it received very strong support I think Lord Marrowgar would be a bad Legendary to play.

     

  • Riot Reveals New Improvise Mechanic Coming to Legends of Runeterra in the "Awakening" Expansion

    Obviously Jax's Origins gonna be something like Kayn's Cultists, but did u notice? They're both no-Bandle double region units! Now i want them to update Senna to be Shadow Isles/Demacia, please, i need her with her husband.

    By the cards, both r cute, low cost things of a new mechanic, generally being the best in the archetype or the good fodder for the deck, the double-regions are weird but cool, Fireth has sense being epheremal who is a thing in both regions lets say, and the hookmaster is good lore, daughter of a noxian invader and a ionian fisherman? Love that (?

  • Dawn Of The Dead - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Two similar ideas:

    The first one is designed to act in a similar way to a Snowball Fight! or Mass Hysteria. The difference from those cards is that they could hit an enemy multiple times and this will always switch sides for each attack, e.g. enemy, friendly, enemy, friendly etc.

    'Temporarily' means it loses the effect after attacking and 'opposing minion' was an attempt at removing the ambiguity from saying enemy/friendly minion — is it Lady Deathwhisper's enemy/friendly minion or the opponents?

     

    For the second one, I wanted a similar feeling effect but with less complexity. As it needs to kill an enemy, the attack needed to be higher.

     

    Feedback coming up in a second post

  • 4 New Quest Rewards for Hearthstone Battlegrounds Revealed by Blizzard

    "[thing] has/have [effect]"  is a permanent passive

    "give [thing] [effect]"  is a one time effect

    "at the start/end of your turn, give [thing] [effect]"  is a one time effect that triggers every turn

     

    It was stated in an earlier reveal that these rewards effect the rest of the game.  Therefore the effects stick around, and "start/end of turn" refers to start/end of every future turn.  The only exception being if the text only says "give [something]".  (I would be pretty surprised if that's now how that works)  Hope that clears things up.

  • Riot Reveals New Improvise Mechanic Coming to Legends of Runeterra in the "Awakening" Expansion

    Interesting!

  • 4 New Quest Rewards for Hearthstone Battlegrounds Revealed by Blizzard

    It isn't always clear which of these go off exactly once and which happen every turn, so one assumes that they are every turn. If they vary, then the writing is awful.

  • Riot Reveals New Improvise Mechanic Coming to Legends of Runeterra in the "Awakening" Expansion

    Staff Pro

    You wanna know why I think Riot didn't reveal the keyword description?

    They're improvising.

  • Riot Reveals New Improvise Mechanic Coming to Legends of Runeterra in the "Awakening" Expansion

    Staff Pro

    Indeed, the flavor text is basically 100% confirmation.

  • Riot Reveals New Improvise Mechanic Coming to Legends of Runeterra in the "Awakening" Expansion

    It's kinda hard to imagine it's not Jax. The cards seem to be supporting a Runeterran champion and they referenced him in Fireth's flavor text.

  • Riot Reveals New Improvise Mechanic Coming to Legends of Runeterra in the "Awakening" Expansion

    Staff Pro

    I dont think that is actually Jax, even tho the looks and the entire mechanic plays off him strongly.

  • New Hearthstone Battlegrounds Season and Special Content Coming Soon - Unique Rewards Track and Pass, Added Mechanics, Minions, Heroes, & More!

    It lets them put a uniform worldwide runestone price on shop items, and then they can adjust for variations in real currencies by changing the price of runestones in a given country. It's a lot easier to change that one price than to go through the entire shop and adjust the price of every item for each region.

    So, instead of being a shady move like Nightmare suggests, it's actually just an efficient business move that has nothing to do with obfuscation or psychological tricks.

  • Riot Reveals New Improvise Mechanic Coming to Legends of Runeterra in the "Awakening" Expansion

    Glad Riot decided to implement Jax as a bit of a comical character, he works better this way than if they tried to play it straight with him. I expect him to be a menace, whether he fights with a fishing rod, a frying pan or a lamppost.

  • 4 New Quest Rewards for Hearthstone Battlegrounds Revealed by Blizzard

    Staff Pro

    Pilfered Lamps seems preeeeeeeeeeeeeetty good!

  • New Noxus Card - Ionian Hookmaster

    Staff

    A new Common Noxus Unit, Ionian Hookmaster, has been revealed!

    Ionian Hookmaster Card Image

    Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!


    Learn more about Worldwalker

    Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!

  • New Shadow Isles Card - Fireth, Reaper of the Sands

    Staff

    A new Epic Shadow Isles Unit, Fireth, Reaper of the Sands, has been revealed!

    Fireth, Reaper of the Sands Card Image

    Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!


    Learn more about Worldwalker

    Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!

  • Marvel Snap's Featured Location This Week is Gamma Lab - Hulk SMASH!

    My hype for this game was insane, now after months available in some regions I totally lost interest for the game

  • How to Complete Castle Nathria's Druid Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!

    I've noticed that you put 3 copies Dispossessed Soul in your Flower Power Standard deck, which is why I can't use copy deck feature and play that.

  • Dawn Of The Dead - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Feedback

    linkblade91
    I think Sapphiron is very fitting, but can get a little high on stats. Izelair, Fallen Lady is interesting, but quite strong and I think Lord Tamakeen's effect is far more fitting for DK. It should probably use the "for the rest of the game"-phrasing, though. And I don't think it would be exciting enough as an aura effect.

    Demonxz95
    "when"?

    I like Alexandros Mograine the least. I like how interactive Lady Frostheart is. Tripling is a bit unusual, she could "shatter" Frozen enemy minions when they take any damage for all I care. Might even add to the flavor. Probably better as a 4-Cost, since she already has a Freeze included. I also like Teribus the Cursed.

    Wailor
    I like the way the Runes work. I think they're unique and very fitting for the class identity. I hope to see a "package" prompt sometime in the future, but perhaps they would still work as tokens? I think I like the Deathrattle version a little better, because you'd get to see all of them in action instead of always Discovering the most valuable one. Once it's dead it leaves you the option to use them on a minion or on a weapon. But for the same reason I understand why you'd want the weapon draw on it.

    Also, you've gotta fix the tilted "I" in the second card's name. Did it just fall over or something lol?

    Arkasaur
    Gothik the Harvester is pretty straightforward. I like Lady Deathwhisper better. The effect is very fitting for DK. What I'm not entirely sure on is whether 6 Mana is too much considering you already need to get+spent Armor, but I suppose Frost spells could easily give you Armor back.

    Moondreamer
    It is unlikely the Colossal keyword will make a reoccurrence, so not everyone will like that you're using it outside of VttSC. Bone Spike is also an already existing card in both name and art, which I think is an issue.

    About the card itself, I think it works well as a Colossal minion, but it lacks synergy for an initiate Legendary. Link made a good point about the initial DH Legendaries: they both supported a specific mechanic (tokens dying and Outcast). You're clearly going for a Freezing friendly minions mechanic, but the card itself doesn't support any other cards that could be printed for that archetype. The Bone Spikes currently only buff one Frozen minion, which is already provided as Lord Marrowgar, so I think that could be improved.

    BloodMefist
    Painsmith Raznal is a very cool idea. The balance would be impossible to determine without knowing the hypothetical support for this. I don't think it should be any more difficult to remove than it already is, since it shouldn't have too hard of a time removing enemy minions on the turn you play it.

    Lord Marrowgar is underwhelming. It doesn't sound very exciting because you have to burn a lot of cards in a single turn to get a decent reward. Although the burn cards we've seen so far remove quite a lot of cards from your deck, they were rare to obtain. If DK would actually get this archetype, the average effect couldn't burn many cards or you wouldn't be able to afford using multiple. Otherwise you could only use them in an aggro deck, which I'm not sure fits the class identity.

    I would advice going the Mordresh Fire Eye route with this one, counting the burns throughout the entire game for a bigger reward. If you do go down that route, it would probably need to be an 8-Cost with a new statline.

  • New Hearthstone Battlegrounds Season and Special Content Coming Soon - Unique Rewards Track and Pass, Added Mechanics, Minions, Heroes, & More!

    I just hate that the passes can't be bought using gold. I'd literally be willing to spend 10k gold per expansion for both, so 5k each. Possibly even more. I'm not, however, willing to ever spend real money on this game. Their free to play model is HORRIBLE. I wish it was more like something like Legends of Runeterra.

  • The Pepper Thread - Share Some Good Vibes!

    Had one of those wacky games again. I won a game where everything seemed to go wrong at the start: I missed two turns because of disconnection, my Deepwater Evokers drew two Flurry (Rank 1) (what are the odds of that happening??), my Magister Dawngrasp was stolen via  Theotar, the Mad Duke, and my Quest Priest opponent finished his quest on time, around turn 10.

    However, I still won because I managed to steal the Purified Shard (which my opponent had apparently been keeping in his hand for the past 4-5 turns) using Theotar, the Mad Duke. This game can be funny sometimes. 

  • How to Complete Castle Nathria's Shaman Achievements for Rewards Track Experience - Great Deck Lists!

    Well, there is a way to do it in Duels. While you can add just one location to your starting deck, you can discover another two or three through buckets. I had numerous games with 4 locations in my deck easily.

    While talking about Duels, there is another cool way to progress the "Primordial Soup" Shaman Achievement. You can choose Fluctuating Totem as your starting Signature Treasure, which can proc Baroness Vashj effect on and on, if not killed (just make sure to place Baroness Vashj on the totems right side).

  • New Hearthstone Battlegrounds Season and Special Content Coming Soon - Unique Rewards Track and Pass, Added Mechanics, Minions, Heroes, & More!

    They said this will not happen