AeroJulwin

Thanks! I was really proud of this card, so I'm glad it won!

[quote from="BloodMefist"]I like Library, but the flavor feels good and bad at the same time. Silencing makes sense, but it feels kinda weird for a library to destroy a minion that is silenced. Maybe some other effect for already silenced …

[quote from="Demonxz95"]This feels like it might be too slow and impractical to work as good removal since you need to silence the minion you want to kill first, wait 2 turns (meaning your opponent will be able to attack twice …

I believe locations' effects should be ones that wouldn't quite be worth spending a card on as a single-cast spell/battlecry, and I think this fits that nicely. I'm also very happy with the flavor.

It's supposed to make …

Quote From adamsleungcn

This wouldn't count for the competition since it transforms into the same card type. And I think you should stick with Serin regardless. You're right that it's not easy to transform it …

[spoiler text=adamsleungcn]This is an amazing improvement. The card is now clearly focused and the new art properly works for the Colossal keyword. What makes this a particularly good Colossal minion is that you gave the Serin's Hair strong synergy with …

[spoiler text=More Feedback]

[spoiler text=adamsleungcn]I think the Boom Sugars are really cool and the minion and hero versions of the Boomship would be good cards on their own, but I think the three versions together become a little …

[spoiler text=Feedback]

[spoiler text=linkblade91]I also prefer the 3-Cost version, mainly because I feel the other one might make some very big swings as a location. I do agree it could maybe be a 4-Cost, since at 3 Mana it's …

Change of plans. I'm sticking with my crime scene idea a little longer. This should make more sense:

To clarify: the card keeps its original cost when transformed.

Edit: Just checked the site out on my laptop …

Here's a very cool idea. Proper balance is impossible though, so tomorrow I'll try to get a second idea as well. It might still work since it's mutually exclusive with other Deathrattle triggering cards.

Is it obvious enough …

[spoiler text=BloodMefist]Bad Romance is very funny, but Covetous Shade is a far more interesting card. It seems very fun to play and I particularly like that it can't just swap both stats with the same minion (if I understood …

Here it is:

Should it be rare or epic?

We're going fast this week! Here's some early feedback while I try to come up with an idea that could match at least one of these amazing cards. Seriously, this week is nuts. I already see multiple 5-stars.

[spoiler …

[spoiler text=LazyKid]Nice effect. Both the summon and upgrade criteria fit DH well and even go well together. There are a few things that could be improved. If your card summons a token, you should include it in the submission. And …

[quote from="linkblade91"]What happens if your opponent doesn't have hard removal in hand, and must rely on "the old fashioned way" to get rid of a 10/7 or a 15/12 with several Divine Shields on it?[/quote]

--> [card]Moonfang[/card]

Already submitted mine, but here's some feedback regardless:

[spoiler text=Feedback]

[spoiler text=Demonxz95]Stealth and secrets fit nicely together. I don't think the upgrade is implied as it could have been a +2/+2. However, this is actually not uncommon for …

Lots of stuff has already been mentioned, but there's one more thing I'd like to add: 8 finalists is quite a lot. It's not strange for it to be half of the participants. My proposal is to reduce the amount …

[spoiler text=Feedback]

[spoiler text=Demonxz95]I did consider the token issue on my card, but since it requires far more than you can submit I figured people would get the general idea.

I really like both effects, but agree Stringpuller …

Been waiting for an excuse to use this one for a while.

Note that it can also pull spells from Rogue itself. I figured it made the most sense to include the entirety of each school.

[spoiler text=More Feedback]

[spoiler text=R]I don't mind the use of a character that already exists in another fictional universe. Art is art. But I do think the art should show some actual fire. I do like its effect, most …