Yeah, I don't agree with every card Cheese put into this set, but the effort he put into it is unmatched by a lot of people. This was a very long term project.
I think the art of Kill Command is just infamous for not matching up with any other card in the game, so the attempt to change the art seems to be to try to make it fit in with the rest of the game.
I realize it was a very weird choice, though I don't really have much of a connection with most of the SoU cards since I didn't play a whole lot during this time. Khartut Defender is a card that I have a love/hate relationship with and I feel that a lot of people do as well, so I picked it.
Interaction of Warsong Wrangler by people seem to be overlooking: Judging by the wording, it will also buff enemy copies of whatever Beast you choose. In most cases, this won't be a big deal, but it might be something to think about in Hunter mirror matches.
I seem to have missed this card when I last gave feedback. My mistake, even though you seem to have already submitted. Your card seems fine. It is effectively a Frost Nova in Priest. Not really your fault though since Freeze as a keyword has the problem of being very narrow with the flavor it allows.
Cg8889
Moss looks pretty decent, although I am slightly concerned about the amount of healing you can get by holding a lot of board clears.
Anchorm4n
I guess because I just play Midrange Hunter a lot that it helps me naturally think of Secrets. Thank you.
Burn it! feels like a pretty fine card, but it feels more like a Warlock card than a Hunter one as two of the three mechanics on the card are very distinctly Warlock. I question the Shadow spell type too since the card seems more like it would be a Fire spell to me. What the card does by itself though is good and I like it.
ChickyChick
Black Lotus is extremely problematic and opens up a lot of dangerous combo potential. If you just play win the game on the turn you play it, then there is no downside. The other two cards seem fine though, although I struggle to think of a practical application for Fungal Guard other than just being slightly larger than vanilla stats.
There are actually several mistakes in the letter.
"Weather" instead of "whether"
"whathering" instead of "weathering" (as far as I can tell, "whathering" is not a real word)
"Four" instead of "for"
Likely at least one other I didn't see.
I actually tossed around the idea that rather than simple writing mistakes that they actually might be intentional and putting them together might form a secret code or something. They seem almost too intentional to be just mistakes. As Flux mentioned, us on the Content Squad and Staff team have tried to put the pieces into place, but haven't quite figured anything out. Maybe someone else can?
There seems to be multiple problems with the card. The artwork looks like a real-life picture which does not fit the feeling of the game at all, the word "has" should not be in italics, and the card seems absurdly broken. You're also not allowed to use Golden cards. You absolutely need to start over.
DestroyerR
This card seems really sweet. My only concern is that there may be too few Razorpetal generators, although [Hearthstone Card (Heistbaron Toggwaggle) Not Found] was able to work with even fewer Lackey generators, so you are probably okay. The 100% less anachronism is also very appreciated. ;)
Cydonianknight
The first design is alright, but every time I've seen the design, it does always have the same problem of being fairly easy to nullify. I'd go with the second version, which I really like.
Ilphelkiir
The card seems fine, but it has the issue of using the K&C watermark which was at a time when spell schools did not exist yet (rendering the card completely non-function at the time it would've hypothetically been released). I would say this is a problem, but evidently it shouldn't affect your score that much since DestroyerR won last comp. Regradless, I still think this is something that you should change and I think it's bad to actively get in the habit of making this mistake.
Shatterstar1998
Rokkar, Forest Ambassador is quite the card you got there. I want to say it's fine, but unconditional Start of Game effects that provide an upside are dangerous (*cough cough* Genn *cough* Baku *cough cough*).
Fungal Giant seems extremely easy to discount to 0. Possibly too much so.
Scavenging Lasher however is quite nice. I like it.
Arkasaur
I too prefer the first one. It seems easier to use and I agree with Wailor in that it has better Ancient flavor. The second version seems like it relies on too much on everything happening your way.
Wailor
Definitely makes more sense as a Legendary. Probably safer too since even with as few Razorpetal generators as there are, being able to destroy multiple minions for so little mana is nothing to scoff at.
Hearthcards is down for me, so I can't share any cards, but I'll give feedback right now.
Show Spoiler
Demonxz95 - I don't think Rosa the Thorn works well because minions lose stealth when they attack before they deal damage, making the second ability useless.
Entanglement is interesting, but the effect should last longer. As soon as your opponent activates the secret, they could just pass the turn and their minion returns to normal. As far I can see, it only stops rush minions and certain combos. That being, said, I like the card otherwise.
Wait, really? Well shit.
Entanglement is supposed to be until their next turn. I made a mistake with the card text, and I didn't even notice it until you pointed it out, so thank you for that.
Do also note that it triggers "when" the minion attacks and not "after" it attacks. If a minion tries to trade, it'll become a 0/2 before the damage connects resulting in your minion not taking any damage, and their minion most likely dying.
I definitely figured that Magic Bloom wouldn't be that interesting, but flavor comps by nature are quite tricky to manage especially with added restrictions.
Nonetheless, I do have two more cards I made.
Rosa is a woman who lives in a rose able to control the entire plant system of her forest, hiding in her giant rose until ready to strike.
When you do something that nature doesn't like however, sometimes it'll strike you back and entangle you in its roots, leaving you weak and helpless until someone can get you out.
EDIT: Noticed a mistake with Entanglement after Grumpymonk pointed it out. Corrected.
Feedback
Nirast
Aside from a typo (should be "Mandragora", and not Madragora), this card seems fine. My only concern is that I don't know how many people that Dormant minions will retain damage when they go Dormant (I didn't at first). The DH part also seems a bit tacked on as this doesn't really look like much of a DH card, although I suppose it has synergy with Ace Hunter Kreen.
Linkblade91
Clearly this is an Alraune card in disguise. *wink, wink* (When are you going to keep going with that class by the way?)
This seems like a pretty fair card, though I feel like it could probably have one additional stat-point.
Cydonianknight
I think using Sklibb here is a pretty clever use of the prompt. The card does seem a little bit weak, although as Nirast pointed out, you can basically go infinite if you somehow control 2 copies of this. I don't know if that's a problem or not.
Wailor
I think this card is really flavorful, but I don't feel like Razorpetal synergy is really something to be pushed since there are only two cards that give them.
Pokeniner
I really like the artwork of this card, and I also really like the effect. I don't really see any flavor though.
Anchorm4n
This card feels really weird to me. I'm not sure if I like it. Name specific synergy for a random throw-away unplayable class Common doesn't exactly seem like my cup of tea, especially limited to one single card.
I realize this is a bit awkward after I criticized the card for being anachronistic, but I can see why people who wouldn't care would think highly of it. It's a really good card otherwise.
Although of course, Deathrattle DH is very unlikely to be good. DH in general didn't get that many great cards in this set, and although I love DH, it's probably about time they got bad cards.
Hypothetically, it's better than Landscaping which was pretty decent. But Druid could use those minions a lot better than DH can use these ones. It's probably not that good.
Wow, I did not do good apparently. I feel like Vine Snare being submitted really hurt my score since the two cards ended up being really similar.
Nice job Arkasaur. You've got the next theme!
I'm really interested in seeing what you guys come up with.
"Drunhei" is actually a reference to Heidrun, a goat in Norse mythology.
Yeah, I don't agree with every card Cheese put into this set, but the effort he put into it is unmatched by a lot of people. This was a very long term project.
I think the art of Kill Command is just infamous for not matching up with any other card in the game, so the attempt to change the art seems to be to try to make it fit in with the rest of the game.
I realize it was a very weird choice, though I don't really have much of a connection with most of the SoU cards since I didn't play a whole lot during this time. Khartut Defender is a card that I have a love/hate relationship with and I feel that a lot of people do as well, so I picked it.
My second choice would probably have been Bazaar Burglary.
Interaction of Warsong Wrangler by people seem to be overlooking: Judging by the wording, it will also buff enemy copies of whatever Beast you choose. In most cases, this won't be a big deal, but it might be something to think about in Hunter mirror matches.
"Mysterious Challenger got separated from his horse (Galloping Savior), the horse didn't find him"
Ah, I see a problem with your theory. Which is that Mysterious Challenger's horse is brown, whereas the horse in Galloping Savior is white.
You have a little over 23 hours left so submit.
Whoa, Golden Silence! Nice pull! (jk, jk, very good pack)
Quick feedback before sleep.
I guess because I just play Midrange Hunter a lot that it helps me naturally think of Secrets. Thank you.
Burn it! feels like a pretty fine card, but it feels more like a Warlock card than a Hunter one as two of the three mechanics on the card are very distinctly Warlock. I question the Shadow spell type too since the card seems more like it would be a Fire spell to me. What the card does by itself though is good and I like it.
There are actually several mistakes in the letter.
I actually tossed around the idea that rather than simple writing mistakes that they actually might be intentional and putting them together might form a secret code or something. They seem almost too intentional to be just mistakes. As Flux mentioned, us on the Content Squad and Staff team have tried to put the pieces into place, but haven't quite figured anything out. Maybe someone else can?
Feedback round 2, here we go!
Rokkar, Forest Ambassador is quite the card you got there. I want to say it's fine, but unconditional Start of Game effects that provide an upside are dangerous (*cough cough* Genn *cough* Baku *cough cough*).
Fungal Giant seems extremely easy to discount to 0. Possibly too much so.
Scavenging Lasher however is quite nice. I like it.
Wait, really? Well shit.
Entanglement is supposed to be until their next turn. I made a mistake with the card text, and I didn't even notice it until you pointed it out, so thank you for that.
Do also note that it triggers "when" the minion attacks and not "after" it attacks. If a minion tries to trade, it'll become a 0/2 before the damage connects resulting in your minion not taking any damage, and their minion most likely dying.
I definitely figured that Magic Bloom wouldn't be that interesting, but flavor comps by nature are quite tricky to manage especially with added restrictions.
Nonetheless, I do have two more cards I made.
Rosa is a woman who lives in a rose able to control the entire plant system of her forest, hiding in her giant rose until ready to strike.
When you do something that nature doesn't like however, sometimes it'll strike you back and entangle you in its roots, leaving you weak and helpless until someone can get you out.
EDIT: Noticed a mistake with Entanglement after Grumpymonk pointed it out. Corrected.
Feedback
Clearly this is an Alraune card in disguise. *wink, wink* (When are you going to keep going with that class by the way?)
This seems like a pretty fair card, though I feel like it could probably have one additional stat-point.
Congrats DestroyerR.
I realize this is a bit awkward after I criticized the card for being anachronistic, but I can see why people who wouldn't care would think highly of it. It's a really good card otherwise.
This is a pretty good Deathrattle DH card.
Although of course, Deathrattle DH is very unlikely to be good. DH in general didn't get that many great cards in this set, and although I love DH, it's probably about time they got bad cards.
A Sen'jin that gives you 5 Armor is pretty good. But maybe it's not even needed?
Hypothetically, it's better than Landscaping which was pretty decent. But Druid could use those minions a lot better than DH can use these ones. It's probably not that good.
Simple and good.
This can be kinda insane if it lives one turn. But that is quite an if.
Having Secrets be revealed for it to be buffed does make it a bit strange to buff. The best use for this card is probably in Paladin.