Well, I already pointed out my thoughts on Discord. Nirast appears to share the same thoughts too.
Wailor
I like Argus Hopebringer. The effect is a little bit situational to use, but in the proper deck, it'll probably do its job pretty well. I really like the artwork too. Thumbs up overall.
Gust Incarnation has a pretty nice idea that fixes the inherent problem with Windfury. I get that Windfury is sort of a Shaman keyword (at least in terms of flavor), but I feel like I would prefer it if it were a Neutral card, if only because Windfury is such an underpowered keyword.
Sneaky Rodent is a fun Stealth-synergy card. I like it!
R
A cool idea that will probably stand out since I don't imagine Poisonous synergy will be too prevalent in this comp.
Nirast
A bit on the weird side, but it's a fine piece of cross-synergy all the same.
Neoguli
Water Vortex is a pretty neat card, but it won't be eligible since Freeze doesn't count for this comp. Wispering Sorcerer is a nice pun and it seems balanced, although it's a very weird and probably suboptimal way to use Spell Damage.
BloodMefist
A nifty idea, and it makes sense for there to be a Lifesteal synergy card in the set where it originated (and not something stupid like Deathaxe Punisher). I must ask though, is it intended to be able to hit your own stuff? It should probably be lowest-Attack enemy and I don't think that would be broken as it requires a bit of setup and a good Lifesteal minion to play at a time that you would want to use the effect on. It also avoids weird interactions such as if the Lifesteal minion itself was the lowest-Health minion.
AeroJulwin
Pretty nice job overall. I do agree with Wailor though that the art and set clash perhaps a little bit too much.
Hey, I got two DS Paladin cards that happen to work perfectly for this.
Titanic Sentinel may have its Attack reduced to 7 based off of some previous feedback about it, but here they are for you guys! And I didn't feel like remaking it just yet. XD
Now that Link and I both have DS Paladin cards, let's see something else! (if you have it of course)
Battlecry effects take place before the minion is entered into the battlefield. This is why things like "Battlecry: Deal X damage to all minions" don't affect the battlecry minion.
No, they don't. This is an old piece of false information. It will count itself when the Battlecry triggers.
I bizarrely can't think of anything for the side-comp at the moment, but let me contribute with some feedback.
Anchorm4n
A funny idea, but I'm very worried about its growth rate particularly in the early game. If you play one on turn 1 and then the other on turn 2 (or even just Coin it out), then I struggle to see a world in which you'll struggle to win the game. The only real counter to it is Silence or bouncing it. So it's not impossible to deal with, but it doesn't feel particularly fun to me.
Bananenparty
I like this. It's a little bit difficult to use given that it costs 7 mana and you'd need to play a Deathrattle minion on the same turn to get any good value out of it (and the fact that it only has 4 Health is not helping that), but I do enjoy the core concept.
Neoguli
It seems good when you use it on an enemy minion and it seems weak when used on one of your own minions. Thus, it ends up feeling less like a Deathrattle-synergy card and more like a tech card against Deathrattle minions (and not a particularly impactful one either).
TheHoax91
A cool idea to add spell type weaknesses to the regular game, but it's not that useful with this particular card. Priest only has 6 Shadow spells that deal damage and 3 of them are exclusive to Wild.
Wailor
Glorious Vrykrul is "cute" but it doesn't feel particularly practical to use. This is fine as a weird "pack filler" card, but it ultimately doesn't make the best card for these competitions. Fleshfeasting Crow on the other hand is really good.
MenacingBagel
This feels extremely similar to Neoguli's card and basically everything I said about that card also applies to this one.
BasilAnguis
A funny idea in theory, but I feel like the Bomb aspect would be more frustrating than it is fun, and it's also bad to give your opponent an extra copy of a minion.
Arkasaur
This is a really cool card, but it doesn't feel particularly Druid to me, at least as far as mechanics go. Perhaps in the future if we get support for a Deathrattle Druid, then this card would be perfect. The name Squashling is already used so you should think of a new name for the token (though I honestly don't blame you for not remembering the card).
Alright, time for feedback. I literally hit Legend for the first time today, so I'm feeling pretty good!
Nice one, congrats! What deck did you use? Did you do the deed in Standard or Wild? Enjoy that card back, I hope your experience was as great as mine when I first made it :)
I agree with Grumpymonk that Rigged Sigil is a bit weird given that Secrets don't have two-sided effects or the potential to backfire if used at the wrong time.
Warding Glyphs is okay.
Sacrificial Summon is, as noted, a better Spellbender. Spellbender has never been of Mage's better Secrets, but the discrepancy in power level is still kinda insane. A logo also appears to be visible in the bottom-right.
FieselFitz
I think you've done good, but I'm afraid I'm going to have to say no to Hold the Line! It's almost a strictly better Ice Barrier, which is something I can almost get behind as Armor is supposed to be a strength and key mechanic of Warrior, but the big problem here is the random Warrior weapon. I could equip a Whetstone Hatchet, or I could equip a Gorehowl. There's too much variance in size.
This one gave me a bit of trouble.
But I prevailed!
Ended up getting lucky on this one and all my words were in roughly the same place.
Would you say that that's...
What you want?
Playing as Shaman... watching it play a handbuffed minion and then Revolving it... sadness and pain.
Sorry for being late for feedback.
I like Argus Hopebringer. The effect is a little bit situational to use, but in the proper deck, it'll probably do its job pretty well. I really like the artwork too. Thumbs up overall.
Gust Incarnation has a pretty nice idea that fixes the inherent problem with Windfury. I get that Windfury is sort of a Shaman keyword (at least in terms of flavor), but I feel like I would prefer it if it were a Neutral card, if only because Windfury is such an underpowered keyword.
Sneaky Rodent is a fun Stealth-synergy card. I like it!
Hey, I got two DS Paladin cards that happen to work perfectly for this.
Titanic Sentinel may have its Attack reduced to 7 based off of some previous feedback about it, but here they are for you guys! And I didn't feel like remaking it just yet. XD
Now that Link and I both have DS Paladin cards, let's see something else! (if you have it of course)
Congratulations MrRhapsody!
"or really any female character that speaks some sort of incomprehensible gibberish"
There's one in particular. Perhaps part of a ritual to summon some dark demonic being?
Finalist voting is live!
No, they don't. This is an old piece of false information. It will count itself when the Battlecry triggers.
Look at Blackwater Cutlass and then look at Bloodclaw.
I know the latter card was from 3 years ago, but it's just insulting and I love it. XD
Pretty quick one for me. *thumbs up*
That boy man ain't right.
I bizarrely can't think of anything for the side-comp at the moment, but let me contribute with some feedback.
First idea.
I'm unsure if the connection is strong enough if that makes sense. That's just sort of an inherent problem with some classes in this comp.
Cool in theory, though how quickly you can reduce its Cost will be of concern.
Standard with Pirate Warrior. Here you go!
Some extra feedback
I agree with Grumpymonk that Rigged Sigil is a bit weird given that Secrets don't have two-sided effects or the potential to backfire if used at the wrong time.
Warding Glyphs is okay.
Sacrificial Summon is, as noted, a better Spellbender. Spellbender has never been of Mage's better Secrets, but the discrepancy in power level is still kinda insane. A logo also appears to be visible in the bottom-right.
Perfect and fun way to start the day (unintentional rhyme, haha).