anchorm4n

Congrats Xarkkal, I'm really happy for you!

Feedback:

Nirast:
[spoiler]The easy part first: it should stay neutral. I'm not really sold about the card without being able to put a finger on the sore spot. The text looks too long but is correct. The paragraphs are fine. Hm. I guess I need more motivation to run this. You should make it cost 3.[/spoiler]

Pokeniner:
[spoiler]I …

I'd like to try to make a Demon Hunter card this week because there was only a small number of entries for this class over the last weeks and the Outcast mechanic works well with this week's theme. 

My first idea is a blacksmith that toys with [card]warglaives of azzinoth[/card]. I find it very hard to balance …

First of all, I'm really pissed that someone basically copied my card (Shard Mage) with their Orderkeeper Henley. It isn't exactly the same, but the idea of using unspent mana crystals was unique and I find it suspicious that someone should have come up with it by coincidence. Even if that was the case, can't people check the already submitted …

I was missing [card]Spiritsinger umbra[/card] for a few months now. To make things worse, I'm stupid and used to dust my rotating cards so I have basically zero Ungoro legendarys. Nevertheless, I decided to buy some packs with gold, 3 Ungoros among them. First pack: boom! [card]Spiritsinger umbra[/card]. It's really crazy because that worked with [card]bloodreaver gul'dan[/card] a few weeks …

I agree that this was the hardest boss so far (3 chapters finished). What did the trick for me was a [card]spectral cutlass[/card] from the 2 mana "discover a weapon from another class" spell on curve.

Quote From grayghost39

@ anchorm4n: Maybe something like this? I agree the effect doesn't need to be legendary. It doesn't stack (twice doesn't become thrice) so having two just makes it more consistent. It also isn't that powerful and hard to pull off; something like this is probably destined to be meme-y which is okay. I lowered …

You should add "(targets chosen randomly)" at the end of it. Interesting idea! I'm not sure if it has to be a legendary, though. It needs quite a setup and the reward isn't that good, at least as long as you don't give her the [card]solarian prime[/card] treatment ("(targets enemies if possible)") which might actually be …

Won my first game with the Druid list, completely destroying a Demon Hunter. Makes me consider crafting [card]Ysera, unleashed[/card] after all...

More feedback for page 3:

Xarkkal:
[spoiler]I'd very much suggest to go with the first one. It has the simplest design and the text just looks better. Don't over-complicate an already great card![/spoiler]

grumpymonk:
[spoiler]I agree with Xarkkal, the second art looks better. I'm not convinced by the name, though. What does a star have to do with …

Really cool concept! I think it's a little too much of the same mechanic to fit into one expansion, but that isn't necessarily a bad thing since you could cut them down to the best cards among them. Mage makes me a little concerned about gaining too much spell damage, but that heavily depends on consistency which I'm really bad …

Quote From anchorm4n

I have that idea of doing something that is dependend of your mana crystals. I hope it's not to close to BloodMefist's Shaman legendary... Here's my first try:

So at 10 mana you could combo it with a Fireball to get a more complicated Pyroblast. This card shines when you manage to …

Feedback time!

Me0203:
[spoiler]I like Lightning Aspect the most effect-wise, the other two feel a little forced. That said, the flavor is a bit off since there's no lightning in the art.[/spoiler]

Pokeniner:
[spoiler]I like your idea, but it doesn't feel right in Mage. Hard removal isn't part of their class identity. Warlock probably would be the class …

I have that idea of doing something that is dependend of your mana crystals. I hope it's not to close to BloodMefist's Shaman legendary... Here's my first try:

So at 10 mana you could combo it with a [card]fireball[/card] to get a more complicated [card]pyroblast[/card]. This card shines when you manage to keep it alive for a turn …

Congrats Wailor! That was a close one indeed. No shame in a second place with these strong competitors. 

(Sidenote: When does season 1 end? The finalist voting really shouldn't be open for the finalists themselves. I chose the middle way and only rated my own card this time. If I had given Wailor's card 1 star, I'd have won.)

Ever felt dirty playing that T0 net deck or getting away with some insane RNG win that was totally undeserved? Here's the place to ease your mind! We'll listen, we'll understand and most importantly: we won't judge.

I'll start with a confession of BM. I was playing Disco Lock and queued into a golden Odd Warrior. My first mistake …

Wow, that's an incredibly strong field of finalists this week and I'm proud to be part of it. I have a feeling the results will be very close, the overall level is just so high!

Quote From doingtheobvious

The one thing, the only thing that prevented me from being interested in the PlayStation 3 and onward that Sony has yet to catch on to? One of the things that made the PlayStation 2 what it was and such a roaring success?

Backwards compatibility.

Seriously, it isn't hard to just program stable …

Quote From Dermostatic

Is it... Netherwalker?

That's correct! Well done, you're next.