anchorm4n

Feedback time! It's amazing how creative you guys are. I was worried when I read the theme because there are tons of Hero Powers between all the Dungeon Runs and stuff, but what you came up with in that short of a time is very impressive!

DestroyeR:
[spoiler]I'm really not sure about this, but I have concerns about two …

First idea for this week. A control tool for mage and I really like the character. How do you like it? Is turn 6 too early for this? 

Edit: Someone on imgur told me it's way too strong, something I feared right from the start. Do you think it would be still OP behind a highlander restriction?

…

Wow. This is insane. 

The 3 "o"s looks like a good place to go on. Cool, fool, pool. Hm.

I'll try and write down my thoughts about this like last time. Maybe someone is able to pick up a piece and we'll get there together. 

"cop folded shoplifters"

DestroyerR told us it's an anagram, so rearranging the letters presents us not only with a coherent answer but also with a hint at a specific card which is …

Quote From DestroyerR

well, maybe a bit Less outside of the box... the anagram does answer the interview question coherently (meaning it’s closer to a set), but consider this: if the anagram only reveals the set, how come that alone is enough to discover the card?  

Okay, so say it was an anagram of "They …

I assume it's that code thing where the letters get substituted, haven't you done one of those before? If I remember correctly they are usually solved by taking short words like "cop" in this case and see if the riddle makes sense if that means "the" or "and". There are other similar tools to crack these that I don't remember …

I guess it's about the sentiment that Arthas looked like the winner of the last competition right from the start, which became a thing because it was your theme. If I remember correctly someone said something along the lines of Arthas not being made for the competition, but the competition themed to fit Arthas, which came up again when you …

Spell Mage did it for me at first try. [deck]15517[/deck]

I second this. Your fear of people putting too much emphasis on the description is understandable but I don't think it will be a big issue. It's still up to the voters to decide if they read it or not and up to the creators if they add one or not. 

If Xarkkal doesn't mind I'd also like to …

Quote From Xarkkal

Quote From Elfensilver

 

Xarkkal:

 

Show Spoiler

Compare to Call to battle, this is just weaker. The art and idea are nice, but: you do not need the 'targets chosen randomly', and it's a feels-bad-man-epic card , because it needs a weak legendary to make it somewhat …

I know I have no one to blame but myself for messing up my submission, but as I'm by far not the first to do so, I'd like to suggest the addition of a tool to prevent these mistakes. I imagine a preview button or a dedicated page where you can see your entry and have to confirm your submission …

I'm confused. 

Demon Hunter initiate - only one I, no U
Ashes of Outland - no A
Galakrond's Awakening - no A
Saviors of Uldum - no U
Rise of Shadows - no W
Naxxramas - no A
Goblins vs Gnomes - no I
Blackrock Mountain - no A
The Grand Tournament - no A
League of Explorers - …

Yeah, it was the first iteration versus the last one. The description is also completely written with the second card in mind. I submitted on mobile and only saw the top part of the card with the art and the cost. The one I wanted to submit somehow ended up in another folder.... Im really angry with myself now. 

…

Shiiiiiiit I choose the wrong version of my card in the gallery and submitted the wrong card. I guess that can't be helped, can it?

I'd really like to make Sylendra work. How do you like this version: 

More Cenarius flavor and more impact from the Treants. The 5/5 threshold could be reached by turn 8 (without ramping). At worst (assuming you don't play it on curve) this is a 4 mana 3/2 that summons two 1/1s with taunt, at best it's a …

Feedback!

Elfensilver:
[spoiler]I like both of the cards, but I have a strong feeling that Geode Elemental's art is already in the game. I can't place it right now, sorry. I'm also not sure if Elementals are very fitting for druid, maybe you can find another character for that cool effect. You should also take a look at the …

Here are my ideas for this week:

I admit this is a bit boring, but the art just yelled for a choose one druid spell and I think it might be useful. Wasn't sure at all about which watermark to put on this.

A refuel for Discolock. I'm not sure about the wording and if this …

Congrats! What impressed me most was the depth of the card (even though I needed your explanation to understand it). Well done!

Quote From JFK

Come on, guys, it's obviously Carnivorous Cube!

That's right! You're next, JFK :-)