Demonxz95

I realize I'm doing it a lot faster for this comp than normal, but I think it's just because of the general prompt. Here's yet another round of feedback.

[spoiler text="H0lysatan"]Infinite effects are usually somewhat dangerous, but I think …

Yeah, this brawl is glitched out hard.

Although I did have a lot of fun when I transformed my dyes with [card]Deck of Lunacy[/card] (that I generated from a [card]Wand Thief[/card], haha).

Feedback round 3.

[spoiler text="KANSAS"]I still have mostly the same opinion as I did before. Looks pretty good.[/spoiler]

[spoiler text="Bananenparty"]

Super flavorful, but the effect is unclear. Does "cast it yourself" mean that you cast the spell …

Round 2 of feedback.

[spoiler text="R"]

This is absolutely broken. At is absolute worst, it just ends the turn after your opponent plays a big card (no one is going to end their turn on turn 10 mana …

Since I don't anticipate this comp will go by particularly quickly, here's some relatively early feedback.

[spoiler text="Cydonianknight"]

I think this is a pretty neat card, although cards that interact with Legendary cards outside of generating them tend …

Quote From meisterz39

but it's not like Hearthcards has access to watermarks for any future years

This is where the custom watermark option is your best friend!

If you make a card doesn't …

Quote From meisterz39

Obviously legendary cards have higher power levels than non-legendary cards, but what are people thinking about adding Secrets to non-secret classes? The prompt seems to allow it, but because it would be your only possible …

Wow, I did not do good apparently. I feel like Vine Snare being submitted really hurt my score since the two cards ended up being really similar.

Nice job Arkasaur. You've got the next theme!

I'm really interested in seeing what you guys come up with.

"Drunhei" is actually a reference to Heidrun, a goat in Norse mythology.

Yeah, I don't agree with every card Cheese put into this set, but the effort he put into it is unmatched by a lot of people. This was a very long term project.

I think the art of [card]Kill …

I realize it was a very weird choice, though I don't really have much of a connection with most of the SoU cards since I didn't play a whole lot during this time. [card]Khartut Defender[/card] is a card that I …

Interaction of [card]Warsong Wrangler[/card] by people seem to be overlooking: Judging by the wording, it will also buff enemy copies of whatever Beast you choose. In most cases, this won't be a big deal, but it might be something to …

"[card]Mysterious Challenger[/card] got separated from his horse ([card]Galloping Savior[/card]), the horse didn't find him"

Ah, I see a problem with your theory. Which is that [card text="Mysterious Challenger's"]Mysterious Challenger[/card] horse is brown, whereas the horse in [card]Galloping Savior[/card] is …

You have a little over 23 hours left so submit.

Whoa, Golden Silence! Nice pull! (jk, jk, very good pack)

Quick feedback before sleep.

[spoiler text="Fedrion"]I seem to have missed this card when I last gave feedback. My mistake, even though you seem to have already submitted. Your card seems fine. It is effectively a [card]Frost Nova[/card] in Priest. …

There are actually several mistakes in the letter.

• "Weather" instead of "whether"
• "whathering" instead of "weathering" (as far as I can tell, "whathering" is not a real word)
• "Four" instead of "for"
• Likely at least …

Feedback round 2, here we go!

[spoiler text="KanzakiGin"]There seems to be multiple problems with the card. The artwork looks like a real-life picture which does not fit the feeling of the game at all, the word "has" should not …

Quote From grumpymonk

Hearthcards is down for me, so I can't share any cards, but I'll give feedback right now.

[spoiler]

Demonxz95 - I don't think Rosa the Thorn works well because minions lose stealth when …

I definitely figured that Magic Bloom wouldn't be that interesting, but flavor comps by nature are quite tricky to manage especially with added restrictions.

Nonetheless, I do have two more cards I made.

Rosa is a woman …