dapperdog

The intention, Im guessing, is for us to play a bunch of copied [card]astral automaton[/card], and then when they inevitably get wiped out we play this and get an entire board of big burly bots that threaten lethal.

The …

Its just a poor card.

The high cost, priest's inability to gain loads of minions in hand quickly, and the fact that its a card that essentially means your deck dont matter, sort of like the old prestor druids …

Forget the overheal, that's a fringe benefit. The main point is that this heals for 8, and is not completely worthless in mirrors.

Im always wary about giving priest sustain cards because that class is freaking annoying to face …

Its basically [card]shadow word: void[/card] except slightly better because it'll prevent 2 damage per minion no matter their size.

The problem? Well, shadow word void was never a genuine contender even on its day. So even an updated version …

Three cards, three directions for priest to go.

Except we all know where priest is going next expansion, its going to be control and we'll all be hating the card [card]grace of the highfather[/card] at the end of that …

Unironically the best card in the rogue set.

So much utility, so cheap, it'll fit into anything including miracle. And that's probably the most rogue-thing you would want out of your expansion.

Cute but its never going to be as good as it seem.

Basically you play a mech on 2, it survives and you graft this onto it and get back a coin. Nice and easy. Well, what happens if …

This one's a weird one, because it can just as easily be the best card and be completely trash at the same time.

Hard to assess this card. I think the only deck that'll play this would be menagerie …

Tutors your mimiron, that's it. It plays little to no other useful function.

Voltron prime perhaps? But come on. The superior card is still the non-titan legendary.

Its a thief card so it'll see play no matter how shit it is.

But this is card isn't shit, its actually pretty good. The main problem is whether this card gets seriously considered in real rogue decks, and …

Combine this with [card]fan of knives[/card] to do 2 damage to everything for 3 mana. Hmmm...no

Probably not good enough to be honest, unless there's some lifesteal shenanigans involved.

The card is only good forged but quite useless in most other situations, and even after forged its only a middling card, a card that requires support to do anything useful.

So get forged and then graft yourself onto …

Im giving this card high marks for the potential to do well in most rogue decks. We've seen cards like these before, and they almost always work

This card is a bit of an anomaly because of its reliance …

I sincerely hope mech rogue or whatever menagerie built rogue may have next expansion comes up good because from what Ive seen Im not impressed. Lots of their gameplan see to be either too slow, or too dependent on something …

I dont know what got under your skin, but your rant is exquisite. Usually I'll read through comments like these, turn my other cheek and walk off, but what the hell, since you clearly care enough about my initial, very …

One of the weirdest cards Ive ever seen printed.

Is it better than [card]barrel of monkeys[/card]? No. But that's hardly the point. Its clearly printed to combo with other cards. Wouldn't be too surprised to see the legendary interact …

Its a bad one, but its primary function is to bluff of which at least this card is fine.

Basically, you'd never really want to ever use this secret. If your opponent throws a minion into yours chances are …

Its honestly not great.

Those worms will never reliably stick even in the early game and this card is only ever good with high damage minions. Too many conditions for a straight class like hunter.

I dont know what this will be used for, I just know that it'll 100% see play before rotation, and it'll be insanely good.

Because why not. This practically punishes your opponent from dropping minions and not dealing with …

Hunter secrets tend to be annoying to test against, so this card gets good marks from me. In fact its probably one of the few cards from hunter thus far that slots in perfectly into hound hunter, probably going to …