They do, it's the 6th bug from the bottom of the list with the fixed issues.
Edit: Although the wording leaves room for interpretation. Maybe we'll keep them and only people who unlock the cards in the future won't benefit any longer.
Adorable! And a nice play of words as well. Great work! Maybe move the artwork a tiny bit to the left so the bug can be seen better and I'd also change the watermark to a custom expansion. Probably 4 stars from me.
MrRhapsody
I've already expressed my love for this card. Favorite design this week! 5 stars from me!
Gear5PhoenixMan
I fear I have to agree with Wailor, I'm not a big fan either. If you choose to go with it nevertheless, I'd recommend to change the watermark to a custom expansion and move the text between brackets to the second line as well as the period behind the closing bracket. Probably 2 or 3 stars from me.
BasilAnguis
I also like Fetch! the most and I also agree it would be a better fit for Demon Hunter. Cool card! Probably 4 stars from me.
Wailor
Nice card, flawless execution as usual. My one worry is it might not be crazy enough to win. Probably 4 stars from me.
Demonxz95
Thanks for hosting this competition, it's always cool to mess around with goofy themes. Easily my facorite competition this season already! Regarding your cards, I agree with Wailor that Guy In A Bear Suit isn't the most creative way to interpret the prompt. Another Lightning Bolt is definitely funnier but not my favorite card in the thread either. Probably 3 or 4 stars from me.
I have yet to properly wrap my head around what we're supposed to do here / what would make for a cool card text, but I generally love special competitions so thumbs up for hosting this!
I'm sorry I couldn't find the time to provide feedback this week. I'll try to do better in our next competition. Thanks to everybody who gave advice on my idea!
I love that feeling of really having earned a win. Just came up against a Renathal Blood Death Knight with a golden Hero Power tray, I was playing Unholy/Blood Even Death Knight. Veeeery tough matchup. They have tons of life gain and board control, im basically relying on handbuff. Unless... Unless I draw my Hematurges early and outvalue them by coining out Alexandros Mograine on 6 and playing a second copy on 7. The second stage astalor on 9 sealed the deal. One of the rare times my opponent's "Well played" emote felt sincere. Thank you, stranger!
Real life is going really rough these days, that's why I've been absent for the last two weeks. New keyword competitions are kinda my favorites though so I'll try to find the time to participate this week. Here's a first idea I came up with when Overheal was revealed. The art is a placeholder for now.
This might be an unpopular opinion, but I think the new expansion is very interesting from a card design perspective. The flavor is through the roof, I really love it - but the effects of the cards are giga meh. Take this with a grain of salt because I'm a Wild player, but I have yet to see something I really want to try day 1 . It feels like all we get is Mana cheat and that's it. I'm disappointed, but there are still quite a few reveals to go so maybe this was only a slow start leading up to an amazing Finale.
The first line describes the basic effect of the card. The second line describes its effect once a certain condition is met. The third line contains a hint that is meant to help you find it in the card database.
Fun addition to Wild Menagerie Warrior which has gotten quite some support over the last year (Mistake and Hookfist-3000 being the most recent examples). It's probably still too fair to be considered meta relevant, but if you get out a Ringmaster's Baton early, things can get spicy.
I respect the creativity, but I feel like the mechanic is inherently OP. Also the art is a little all over the place, there's no common ground recognizable for me. Overall not my cup of tea, I'm sorry. (This would translate to 2 stars since all cards are well executed.)
Matthieu
Hey there, welcome to this part of the site! I like your keyword, it's pretty flavorful. That said, I'd like to echo Demon's concerns about the power level of the cards and also invite you to wait a bit longer for feedback before submitting in the future. With the help of a few other contestants you might have found ways to further improve your cards and thus bolster your chances at winning the competition.
linkblade91
I agree with Demon, Launch is the coolest Keyword of yours. All the cards look fun to play and like a great fit for the keyword. The only thing I'd like to question is if Booster Rocket should really be a Paladin card - other than the Anachronos similarity I don't see much support for that argument. I'd prefer it in Rogue where you have to weigh its effect against using other weapons and your Hero Power. Valeera also has stuff like Sap and Vanish which are kinda related.
Dolphinslyaer
While the keyword isn't super exiting, I really like what you did with it. Especially the Priest card is super cool! Two concerns: 1) If Duplicate really replays the whole card, wouldn't that create an infinite loop, even if the tooltip says "one more time"? 2) You're missing a third card ;-)
AeroJulwin
I have only one thing to criticize: I don't like the third option. It's a very cool effect, but I think the power level should be toned down a bit by forcing the player to discard one of the two cards. That way, it's still better than most current discard effects, but it's still a little risky to play them.
Wailor
I very much prefer Gunslinger, it's the most flavorful keyword I've seen so far. If you add a last little bit of polish, you're gonna be my favorite for this week's competition :-) linkblade already pointed out that the Paladin card wouldn't qualify and I have some small flavor issues with the Warrior card. A shotgun typically deals smaller shrapnel AOE damage which doesn't fit the current statline and effect very well. Might easily be solved by changing the name.
Demonxz95
I'm a little torn here. While I really like the flexibility your keyword adds by the scaling effects, it's still pretty close to what sidequests do already. A drawback of the scaling effects is that your cards are packed with numbers which doesn't look very nice to me when you see them side by side. Might be better if you see them among other cards of the class without this keyword, but that's unfortunately not the way we'll see them when we vote. Finally, I would go with the initial three and skip the Priest card because it's too close to Priest's Galakrond for my taste.
On another note, thanks for your feedback! I'm a little surprised "Stamina" caused confusion. The way it's meant to work is that the effect triggers when the minion with the keyword survives (x) turns, so when The Prismatic Disc survives 2 turns, it gains Spell Damage +2 for example. How do you think could I word the tooltip to make this more clear?
They do, it's the 6th bug from the bottom of the list with the fixed issues.
Edit: Although the wording leaves room for interpretation. Maybe we'll keep them and only people who unlock the cards in the future won't benefit any longer.
And that's the beauty of it. I love the chaos you've created here!
Feedback!
Amazing card, 5 stars from me!
But for Yogg's sake check the timeline in the initial post, you can only submit until Wednesday!
I have yet to properly wrap my head around what we're supposed to do here / what would make for a cool card text, but I generally love special competitions so thumbs up for hosting this!
I'm sorry I couldn't find the time to provide feedback this week. I'll try to do better in our next competition. Thanks to everybody who gave advice on my idea!
Devs confirmed this as well:
https://twitter.com/bonanzaaGP/status/1640734731703664640?t=jx3AHXiQkuxxrleUNxyaNg&s=19
Different opinions are totally fine. Going out of your way to post them on a dedicated fan page might cause some irritation though.
Congrats! That's a special moment for sure, glad you got to experience it.
Not that I play Standard, but what's Machine Gun Hunter? Could you please share your list?
I love that feeling of really having earned a win. Just came up against a Renathal Blood Death Knight with a golden Hero Power tray, I was playing Unholy/Blood Even Death Knight. Veeeery tough matchup. They have tons of life gain and board control, im basically relying on handbuff. Unless... Unless I draw my Hematurges early and outvalue them by coining out Alexandros Mograine on 6 and playing a second copy on 7. The second stage astalor on 9 sealed the deal. One of the rare times my opponent's "Well played" emote felt sincere. Thank you, stranger!
Congrats to Wailor!
Real life is going really rough these days, that's why I've been absent for the last two weeks. New keyword competitions are kinda my favorites though so I'll try to find the time to participate this week. Here's a first idea I came up with when Overheal was revealed. The art is a placeholder for now.
This might be an unpopular opinion, but I think the new expansion is very interesting from a card design perspective. The flavor is through the roof, I really love it - but the effects of the cards are giga meh. Take this with a grain of salt because I'm a Wild player, but I have yet to see something I really want to try day 1 . It feels like all we get is Mana cheat and that's it. I'm disappointed, but there are still quite a few reveals to go so maybe this was only a slow start leading up to an amazing Finale.
Congrats, Wassculaire!
Kindly Grandmother?
What a cool riddle!
I love it, especially the Cobraptor is amazing!
That's correct! Your next :-)
Yes it is!
Fun addition to Wild Menagerie Warrior which has gotten quite some support over the last year (Mistake and Hookfist-3000 being the most recent examples). It's probably still too fair to be considered meta relevant, but if you get out a Ringmaster's Baton early, things can get spicy.
Feedback time!
On another note, thanks for your feedback! I'm a little surprised "Stamina" caused confusion. The way it's meant to work is that the effect triggers when the minion with the keyword survives (x) turns, so when The Prismatic Disc survives 2 turns, it gains Spell Damage +2 for example. How do you think could I word the tooltip to make this more clear?