That's a low reward compared to what they had in the past. I remember them having Rare, Epic and Champion wild cards in the same bucket. At least give us a Champ one, Soldammit!
I think this prompt is too complicated. There should be more people posting ideas by this point :/ Anyways, I came up with a newer one which is hopefully less broken.
Prompt is pretty simple, i thought about making a submission, but i don't really care about battlegrounds.
It's simple, but hard to come up with interesting ideas for it.
I'm the one who suggested it, btw, so it was self-criticism, mostly 😂
Not sure how much is "This is too complicated!" and how much is "Ygh, I need to make the same card twice!", since hearthcards resets the maker once the card is created.
This is where you come to talk about your cards. You post it, and people give you feedback on it, if it's balanced, that kinda stuff. You're supposed to come here before submitting.
Yeah, it's dumb. They should let you play as many spells as you want, and, if there's isn't enough physical space on the screen, have the stack scroll to the right, while showing only half the icon of the most recent spell that's visible, so you know there's more than 8 spells there.
Got quite a few ideas for this comp, the last of which I'll also use for the regular competition. Linkblade pointed out that the first version of Arcane Evolution would leave you without Spell Damage minions, so I made another one.
Feedback on this page:
Show Spoiler
CursedParrot: The idea is good, but sadly Priest/Rogue isn't a Scholomance combo. Either use a custom expansion set, or limit it to one of the classes.
R: Card looks interesting, but if you change it's flavour, I might wait for that version to come out.
BloodMefist: This is really crazy in Demon Warlock. Any sort of board clear can be negated with it. I'm not sure Iike it.
AnAngryBadger: I'd say it counts, and the effect is pretty interesting. The problem is going to be stitching together 2 Zombeasts, lol. I assume this adds the card to your hand?
DavnanKillder: Treant'r Treat (I think there's a typo in there) is pretty interesting, not sure about the balance. I'd make it cost 3 and restore 5 Heatlh. I don't like Impersonator.
Wailor: Horrifying Scream is too strong, especially with [Hearthstone Card (Radiant Elemntal) Not Found] (which I think was still standard when Witchwood launched). Chromie is probaly my favourite, but I see no reason for her to be a 5 mana 5/5. It's Alive! has the same problems as AnAgryBadger's card, except yours has the potential to summon a really powerful beast.
Mechs are really weak right now in BG, so I decided to give 'em a boost. I'm also thinking of using the regular version in the Halloween competition.
Feedback:
Show Spoiler
Hordaki: Garrison Commander. I could see Blizz printing your version, but it's probably more likely they just bring the Commander to BGs.
CursedParrot: 'Round' is pretty much exclusive to BGs, the word you're looking for is 'turn'. Look at Cobalt Scalebane. The card is fine in constructed, but I can see it being really broken in BGs. Maybe make it Tier 5.
Wailor: Radiant First Mate looks cool, but the idea of Piratedin makes me shake in me boots. Shirvallah's Disciple is better, but I'd make it cost 5 for the regular version. Funny enough, the latter would also copy Magnetics.
linkblade91: LOVE IT! Give Freeze Shaman some support!
Demonxz95: I like it. Really nice support for pretty much every comp except Menagerie in BGs, and card is fine in Constructed.
This would've been so much better if it restored equal to the spell's cost (maybe change the character to someone other than Chromie). It's also a bit expensive.
At least now there's a good chance to not see it.
Don't Feed the Animals has the same problem the Pally Gagetzan handbuffs had: You run out of resources. Card won't be good.
Petting Zoo will see play. Two secrets make this already far above the curve. In Wild, will definitely see play in Spell Hunter.
Meanwhile, in Wild, those 2 might enable a Big Deathrattle Hunter that runs an early spell package to summon minions, and uses this to end the game.
That's a low reward compared to what they had in the past. I remember them having Rare, Epic and Champion wild cards in the same bucket. At least give us a Champ one, Soldammit!
Congrats, MathU!
Murgur Murgurgle
"If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you can possibly imagine."
Love this article! The Runeterra universe reminds me of the WoW, with all those different characters and regions that have very interesting histories.
Not sure how much is "This is too complicated!" and how much is "Ygh, I need to make the same card twice!", since hearthcards resets the maker once the card is created.
"My grandfather's deck has no pathetic cards, Kaiba! But it does contain... A very lengthy novel..."
Yeah, the fact that they have both trims and backs makes them more customisable.
This is where you come to talk about your cards. You post it, and people give you feedback on it, if it's balanced, that kinda stuff. You're supposed to come here before submitting.
Yeah, it's dumb. They should let you play as many spells as you want, and, if there's isn't enough physical space on the screen, have the stack scroll to the right, while showing only half the icon of the most recent spell that's visible, so you know there's more than 8 spells there.
Got quite a few ideas for this comp, the last of which I'll also use for the regular competition. Linkblade pointed out that the first version of Arcane Evolution would leave you without Spell Damage minions, so I made another one.
Feedback on this page:
CursedParrot: The idea is good, but sadly Priest/Rogue isn't a Scholomance combo. Either use a custom expansion set, or limit it to one of the classes.
R: Card looks interesting, but if you change it's flavour, I might wait for that version to come out.
BloodMefist: This is really crazy in Demon Warlock. Any sort of board clear can be negated with it. I'm not sure Iike it.
AnAngryBadger: I'd say it counts, and the effect is pretty interesting. The problem is going to be stitching together 2 Zombeasts, lol. I assume this adds the card to your hand?
DavnanKillder: Treant'r Treat (I think there's a typo in there) is pretty interesting, not sure about the balance. I'd make it cost 3 and restore 5 Heatlh. I don't like Impersonator.
Wailor: Horrifying Scream is too strong, especially with [Hearthstone Card (Radiant Elemntal) Not Found] (which I think was still standard when Witchwood launched). Chromie is probaly my favourite, but I see no reason for her to be a 5 mana 5/5. It's Alive! has the same problems as AnAgryBadger's card, except yours has the potential to summon a really powerful beast.
Here's my idea:
Mechs are really weak right now in BG, so I decided to give 'em a boost. I'm also thinking of using the regular version in the Halloween competition.
Feedback:
Hordaki: Garrison Commander. I could see Blizz printing your version, but it's probably more likely they just bring the Commander to BGs.
CursedParrot: 'Round' is pretty much exclusive to BGs, the word you're looking for is 'turn'. Look at Cobalt Scalebane. The card is fine in constructed, but I can see it being really broken in BGs. Maybe make it Tier 5.
Wailor: Radiant First Mate looks cool, but the idea of Piratedin makes me shake in me boots. Shirvallah's Disciple is better, but I'd make it cost 5 for the regular version. Funny enough, the latter would also copy Magnetics.
linkblade91: LOVE IT! Give Freeze Shaman some support!
Demonxz95: I like it. Really nice support for pretty much every comp except Menagerie in BGs, and card is fine in Constructed.
He's Dick Y'Shaastardly.
Add Mecha'thun and make it a triple.
Good luck to the finalists
This would've been so much better if it restored equal to the spell's cost (maybe change the character to someone other than Chromie). It's also a bit expensive.
This is going to be the best mode in the game, and whoever disagrees can eat Big FAT NARDS!
New idea:
The text should probably say "If the spell..."